More Pablum from the Post

Similarly, the editors of the Washington Post want to go farther than outlawing conversions from semi-automatic to automatic:

When House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) was asked if the bill banning bump stocks might be a slippery slope toward other gun restrictions, she answered, “I certainly hope so.” To which we say, amen.

They also talk obliquely about banning “assault weapons”, presumably aware that there is no coherent definition of what constitutes an “assault weapon”. Show some spine and initiative. If there are specific weapons or characteristics of weapons they believe should be made illegal, spell them out. Delineate them. That would enable me to evaluate the prudence, effectiveness, and enforceability of the law so I could decide whether to agree with them or disagree.

10 comments

What Are “Real” Gun Control Laws?

The editors of the New York Times call for “real” gun control laws:

After the slaughter in Las Vegas, Republican leaders in Washington tried to stifle the public’s demands for action with the same technique they’ve deployed after mass shootings in the past: offering up pious exhortations not to “politicize” a tragedy by debating gun controls that might, you know, prevent such mass killings from happening again.

without ever delineating what “real” gun control laws would be. Do they want a full repeal of the Second Amendment? Do they want a modification of the Second Amendment to prohibit private ownership of firearms, presumably accompanied by compulsory buybacks?

It may be that my view of law is drastically different from that of the editors. I believe in laws that are narrowly tailored to accomplish achievable goals and enforceable rather than in laws that provide law enforcement and prosecutors the discretion to indict just about anybody for just about anything. I think that making “bump stocks” and other after-market adaptations that turn semi-automatic weapons into fully automatic weapons illegal would be sensible. It’s unclear to me what measures would prevent “mass killings from happening again”.

The people of the United States already have a vast number of firearms, it is not a tiny island, and experience tells us that prohibition laws, whether against alcohol, gambling, prostitution, or drugs, while they may reduce the incidence of the behaviors they’re attempting to affect, do not prevent them. There are already laws on the books making it illegal for convicted felons to own firearms; they do not prevent them from doing so.

Of the three largest mass murders in American history only one, the recent Las Vegas shootings, used firearms. Shall we also prohibit air travel and fertilizer?

Note that I am not advocating doing nothing. I am advocating limiting what you call for to what’s effective, what you are willing to enforce, and what you are able to enact.

4 comments

Markets Have Supply and Demand

At the Wall Street Journal Scott Atlas proposes some measures that might decrease the cost of healthcare:

Republicans have now failed twice to repeal and replace ObamaCare. But their whole focus has been wrong. The debate centered, like ObamaCare, on the number of people with health insurance. A more direct path to broadening access would be to reduce the cost of care. This means creating market conditions long proven to bring down prices while improving quality—empowering consumers to seek value, increasing the supply of care, and stimulating competition.

First, equip consumers to consider prices. Critics always claim this is unrealistic: Are you supposed to shop around from the back of the ambulance? But emergency care represents only 6% of health expenditures. For privately insured adults under 65, almost 60% of spending is on elective outpatient care. Likewise, nearly 60% of Medicaid money goes to outpatient care. For the top 1% of spenders—a group responsible for more than a quarter of all health expenditures—a full 45% is outpatient. Giving consumers an incentive to consider price when seeking such care would make a huge difference.

ObamaCare moved in the opposite direction, shielding consumers from having to care about prices. Its broad coverage requirements and misguided subsidies encouraged bloated insurance policies, furthering the misguided idea that the purpose of coverage is to minimize out-of-pocket costs. When the insurer picks up nearly the entire tab, patients have little reason to consider costs, and doctors don’t need to compete on price.

Effective reform would put patients in charge of their own spending, while giving them a way to gain from paying less. The first step is to broaden the availability of high-deductible insurance plans with fewer mandated coverage requirements. ObamaCare went in the wrong direction. Its regulations—including required “essential benefits”—raised prices on these plans and limited their availability.

My analysis of data from the Employer Health Benefits Annual Survey shows that premiums on high-deductible policies rose between two and five times as fast as other types of coverage. It would also help to repeal ObamaCare’s 3-to-1 age rating, the rule that insurers can charge the oldest customers only three times what they charge the youngest ones. This alone raised premiums for young people by 19% to 35% in 2014, according to an estimate for America’s Health Insurance Plans.

A second tool for motivating patients to consider price is large, liberalized health savings accounts. These tax-sheltered accounts are generally used to pay for the noncatastrophic expenses that form the bulk of medical care. Better than tax deductions, HSAs introduce something unique—an incentive to save.

When people have savings to protect in HSAs, the cost of care drops without harmful effects on health. A study two years ago that analyzed data from 2003-07 showed that the spending of patients with HSAs and high-deductible plans decreased by 15% a year. If even half of Americans with employer-sponsored insurance enrolled in this kind of coverage, U.S. health expenditures would fall by an estimated $57 billion a year, according to a 2012 study in Health Affairs.

HSAs should be available to all Americans, including seniors on Medicare. Given that seniors use the most health care, motivating them to seek value is crucial to driving prices lower. Life expectancy from age 65 has increased by 25% since 1972, meaning Americans need to save for decades of future health care. Raising maximum HSA contributions, now $3,400 a year for an individual, to at least match the limit on individual retirement accounts of $5,500 a year, is one important step. When a person with an HSA dies, the funds should be allowed to roll over tax-free to surviving family members. HSA payments should also be permitted for the expenses of the account holder’s elderly parents.

The information that patients require to assess value must be made radically more visible. A 2014 study on magnetic resonance imaging showed that price-transparency programs reduced costs by 18.7%. The most compelling motivation for doctors and hospitals to post rates would be knowing that they are competing for price-conscious patients empowered with control of their own money.

Second, work strategically to increase the supply of medical services to stimulate competition. In large part, this means deregulation. Lawmakers should remove outmoded scope-of-practice limits on qualified nurse practitioners and physician assistants. That would enable them to staff private clinics that would provide cheaper primary care, including vaccinations, blood-pressure checks, and common prescriptions. In a 2011 review, 88% of visits to retail clinics involved simple care, which was provided 30% to 40% cheaper than at a physician’s office, while keeping patients highly satisfied.

Medical credentialing should be simplified, and the licensing boards should institute reciprocal (national) licensing for doctors to help telemedicine proliferate across state lines. Medical school graduation numbers have stagnated for almost 40 years. Some projections suggest a shortage of 124,000 doctors by 2025, with almost two-thirds being specialists. Yet medical societies artificially restrict competition by imposing protectionist residency limits that raise prices and harm consumers.

Archaic barriers to medical technology also impede competition and raise prices. Although originally intended to restrain “health care facility costs,” certificate-of-need requirements, which require health-care providers to get permission from the state to add medical technology like MRI scanners, are an example of bureaucratic overregulation. Despite unintended consequences, they are still in place in 34 states, Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia.

Third, introduce the right incentives into the tax code. Today employees aren’t taxed on the value of their health benefits—and there is no limit to that exclusion. This creates harmful, counterproductive incentives. It encourages higher demand for care and minimizes concerns about cost.

Similarly, ObamaCare’s premium subsidies and the tax credits proposed by Republicans artificially prop up high insurance premiums for bloated coverage that minimizes out-of-pocket payments. This prevents patients from caring about the bill, which reduces the incentives for doctors and hospitals to compete on price. If health-care deductions are maintained, the tax code should cap them and limit eligibility to HSA contributions and catastrophic premiums.

In other countries, governments hold down costs mainly by limiting access to care, drugs and technology. The results are long waits and worse medical outcomes, particularly for the poor and middle class, who are unable to circumvent those single-payer systems. If Republicans want to avoid going down that road, they need to educate the public on the benefits of a different approach: leveraging incentives and deregulation to reduce prices so that quality health care is affordable for all Americans.

I agree with a lot of that particularly eliminating CONs, changing scope of practice regulations, and tax changes affecting health are. I would concentrate on the income part of that equation rather than the deduction part. Employer contributions to health are insurance should be taxable as income.

However, since so much of health care spending is in fact provide-induced, I wonder how much that would really reduce costs even if implemented in toto. Something else that might be tried is lowering the reimbursement rates for Medicare. That would be dreadfully unpopular so I’m sure it would hardly be whispered about let alone implemented.

All of these things point to why I’m skeptical that any measure that’s presently on the table will actually lower the cost of health care.

17 comments

Commonsense

I don’t have a lot to say about the massacre in Las Vegas. My heart goes out to the survivors and their families as well as the families of those who were murdered.

Details are still emerging and I still don’t know enough to say much else. I have no objections to commonsense restrictions on firearms and it would seem to me that banning the sort of conversions from semi- to full automatic that this guy apparently used fall into that category as well as being a law that might actually have reduced the carnage had it been in place.

All too frequently these days proposals take a form something like this. “If you put an extreme version of such and such in place and enforce it with 100% effectiveness, it will have a minor effect on whatever it is you’re trying to do.” To my eye banning conversions to full automatic fire does not fall itnto that category.

18 comments

And What About the Mayor of San Juan?

I’m not sure which is more likely. That the mayor of San Juan, Puerto Rico will be increasingly considered an “American hero”, as claimed by Mike Lupica in the New York Daily News or that mainland Democrats will quickly start backing away from her.

9 comments

Independence Votes

I don’t have a great deal to say about the two votes on independence that have taken place lately. The first was by the Iraqi Kurds, a majority of whom voted for independence from Iraq. The second was by Catalonians in which an overwhelming majority of a minority of Catalonian voters voted for independence from Spain.

All I have is questions. Can Iraq tolerate a Kurdish state? Will it allow the Kurds to retain Kirkuk? Will Turkey? Will Iran? Or Syria? Can a landlocked Kurdistan completely surrounded by enemies, practically guaranteed a permanent state of war and unrecognized by any major power survive?

Does Catalonia actually have a history separate from Spain? Is it a country or a linguistic community? Will Spain tolerate an independent Catalonia? Will it be recognized by the European Union? By other countries?

What is a country? What is the unit of measure of national sovereignty? The county? The city? The block? The household? The individual? How is that going to work?

Are there any instances of of people being given a country? Or do peoples take their countries?

6 comments

Give War a Chance

Australian Crispin Rovere articulates the case that war with North Korea is inevitable at RealClearDefense:

This piece focuses on the reasons why deterrence is destined for failure and war on the peninsula is increasingly inevitable. A future piece will discuss the ethics of embarking on second Korean war (and those of advocating it).

There’s one argument that goes unmentioned in his piece. Apparently, the Chinese are convinced that North Korea is so fragile that the only future remotely acceptable to them is maintenance of the teetering status quo. Any step on their part sufficient to stop the Kim regime in its headlong rush to nuclear annihilation will lead to the collapse of the regime accompanied by a stream of refugees, the North being absorbed into the South, or both.

My own view is that the only way to avoid a genuinely catastrophic war for all parties is through strategic patience in the hope that either the Chinese will see the folly of their own position or the North Koreans will make a move that the Chinese will recognize demands an answer from the United States. I see few signs that we are prudent enough to take that course.

2 comments

My Mom’s House


Not long ago I showed you pictures of the house where I grew up. When I was ten we moved to a very different suburban neighborhood, to a house that they had built. That’s it at the top of the post. Offhand I would say that’s the way it looked about five years after we moved in. When we moved in there was no lawn, the yard hadn’t been graded, and there were dozens of large fallen trees stacked every which way.

How different was it? The new neighborhood was an upper middle class neighborhood, nearly all of the houses brand new, the families prosperous. Most of the men living there were professionals, business owners, or corporate executives. The old neighborhood was very blue collar, old, rundown houses, all sorts of illegal activities going on (prostitution, gambling, drug dealing). My dad stuck out like a sore thumb.

If you think that I must’ve experience culture shock, you’re right. I loved the new house but I never really adjusted to living there or in the new neighborhood. My siblings think of the new house as their childhood home but for me the old house will always be my childhood home.

0 comments

‘Allo ‘Allo!

Lately my wife and I have been watching ‘Allo ‘Allo! streaming on Netflix. It’s an 80s BBC sitcom which ran for a remarkable nine series, a spoof of the conventions of movies about World War II. It’s actually a lampoon of Secret War, a 70s BBC war drama. It was created and written Jeremy Lloyd and David Croft, the same team responsible for Are You Being Served? and Dad’s Army.

Like Are You Being Served? it’s very broad comedy based proudly on stereotypes. It you are offended at stereotypes, you’ll hate ‘Allo ‘Allo!.

Each of the major characters has a catchphrase. For René, owner of a cafe in a small French town and the main character of the series, it’s “You may be wondering…”, followed by a synopsis of how he got into whatever fix he’s in. For Michelle, the head of the Resistance (the Resistance is entirely composed of attractive young women wearing trenchcoats and berets), it’s “Listen very closely;I shall say this only once” which becomes hilarious as the series progresses.

It has one interesting and useful convention. Broad stage accents are used to indicate that a character is speaking in one language or another. Most of the characters speak with a stage French accent to indicate they’re speaking French, the Germans speak with an exaggerated stage German accent, the British flyers with Bertie Wooster-style English accents, the Italian captain with a stage Italian accent, and so on. When Michelle, who normally speaks with a stage French accent, speaks to the English flyers and they can’t understand her she switches to their stage upperclass English accent. The device is used to humorous effect in the case of Officer Crabtree, a British spy disguised as a French policeman, who speaks with a stage French accent, bizarrely mispronouncing words (“Good moaning”), indicating that he speaks broken French.

We’re in Series 6 now. I hope they get around to lampooning Americans.

‘Allo ‘Allo! is possibly the daffiest sitcom I’ve ever watched and I find it a welcome relief from the events of the day. Be aware that it is occasionally coarse, bawdy, and employs stereotypes.

2 comments

Coming to Grips With a Problem

Student demands at colleges are nothing new. My dad gained a certain amount of notoriety 80 years ago with an editorial in his college newspaper demanding that co-eds be allowed to smoke on campus. However, a set of demands by a black student organization at Cornell University has made the news. For background see this article at the Cornell Sun.

The specific demand that has garnered the most attention and certainly caught my notice was this:

The Black student population at Cornell disproportionately represents international or first-generation African or Caribbean students. While these students have a right to flourish at Cornell, there is a lack of investment in Black students whose families were affected directly by the African Holocaust in America. Cornell must work to actively support students whose families have been impacted for generations by white supremacy and American fascism.

When you strip away the jargon and boilerplate, there’s a serious issue there, one that I wish received more attention.

We have a social problem in the United States and it’s only partially about race. There are grave problems among black Americans who are the descendants of slaves, a group of black Americans the sociologist Charles Moskos dubbed “Afro-Americans” . The problems include lack of economic opportunity, the collapse of the family, the street gangs that have led to Chicago’s homicide rate, and a host of others. Sub-Saharan Africans in the United States don’t experience those problems and Caribbean blacks experience them to a reduced degree.

In the 1960s, 70s, and 80s a series of measures were put in place that were at least notionally intended to address those problems. Perversely, they have been used to confer advantages on sub-Saharan Africans and Caribbean blacks.

It’s not new. It’s been going on for the last 30 years. That’s deseg’s dirty secret. Preferences and set-asides have gone disproportionately to sub-Saharan Africans and Caribbean blacks rather than to the African Americans, the descendants of American slaves, they were intended to help.

While I look with favor on points that have been made by some about groups as opposed to individuals and the inherent problems in trying to solve the problems of groups, nonetheless it still remains the case that Afro-Americans have special problems, if we wish to be one society rather than two as a society we need to do something about them, and some other means will need to be found to address them.

13 comments