Be Careful What You Wish For

The latest slender reed on which Democrats and anti-Trumpers are relying in their year-long effort to impeach President Trump is that he has obstructed justice. In the New York Times David Leonhardt makes his case. It depends on nine points, relying heavily on imputed motive.

Impeachment is rare in the United States so it’s hard to generalize but I think that, should the Democrats win control of the House, they would be prudent in not using that as the linchpin of their case against Mr. Trump. Previous cases have not relied on imputed corrupt motives in the president’s exercising his otherwise legal powers. Such a precedent could go a long way towards making the country ungovernable if not fomenting an actual civil war.

Ken Starr’s notion of “lying to the people” as grounds for impeachment is even worse. If such a notion were to catch on it would make politics as we know it impossible.

3 comments

Three Tribes

I found this observation from Arnold Kling interesting:

Arnold Kling stopped by to talk with me on The Bill Walton Show about his book, The Three Languages of Politics. His view is that “politically aware Americans seem to split into three tribes, and those tribes use the skills of cooperation not to work with each other, but instead to mobilize against each other.”

They’ve sorted themselves into “three tribal coalitions—progressive, conservative, and libertarian. Progressives assert a moral superiority over conservatives and libertarians. Conservatives assert a moral superiority over libertarians and progressives. And libertarians assert a moral superiority over progressives and conservatives.” Not exactly a recipe for comity.

“Progressives, conservatives, and libertarians are like tribes speaking different languages. The language that resonates with one tribe does not connect with the others. As a result, political discussions do not lead to agreement. Instead, most political commentary serves to increase polarization,” he explains.

Conservative language values civilization. What preserves law and order? What preserves the virtues of western civilization?

The progressive language focuses on the relationship between oppressor and oppressed. It takes the side of the oppressed, and looks for ways to limit the power of the oppressor, while increasing the power of the oppressed.

Libertarian language frames political realities around the individual. What increases the ability of the individual to live the life they want to live? They measure everything on a scale of coercion. If I’m not coercing you, you shouldn’t coerce me, not even with laws.

and distressing. I think he’s kidding himself if he believes the language gap can be bridged.

What’s missing from all of this is any reliance on experience or evidence. Once you’ve retreated from the empirical world into the ideological one, it’s darned hard to make your way back.

0 comments

There Aren’t Any Voters Capable of Objective Thought

At Commentary Noah Rothman expresses confusion about the tactics Democrats have employed lately:

By insisting that $1,000 constitute “crumbs” and giving citizenship to nearly 2 million illegal residents is racist, Democrats are flirting with utter incoherence. These claims might enliven their base, but they risk turning off every other sentient voter capable of an objective thought. Moreover, unreasonable polemics have a habit of activating the opposing side’s partisans at a time when reliable Republican voters have been staying away from the polls. The risks of the Democratic Party’s present course seem to outweigh the rewards.

I think it’s easy enough to understand. The Democrats in the Congress are out of touch with ordinary Americans. The majority of Congressmen are millionaires. Most are among the top 1% of income earners. They also think that no one is persuadable. From that point of view the electorate is composed of people who will only vote Democratic, people who will only vote Republican, and people who are lying when they say they’re non-partisan or independents.

Finally, they think that demographics will ultimately prevail and give them a permanent majority. They may be right but elections are not won in the long run. In the short run they’ll raise as much money from their few very well-heeled but extreme donors and try to energize the most extreme factions in the base.

1 comment

That Hammer Guy

in 1953 the best-selling fictional detective character was Mickey Spillane’s Mike Hammer. Mickey Spillane’s books were more lurid in practically every way than their contemporaries. Naturally, the Mutual Broadcasting Company wanted to get in on the Mike Hammer craze so it produced a short-lived radio program, That Hammer Guy. In its short run Mike Hammer was voiced by two different actors, Larry Haines and Ted de Corsia. Both actors did a lot of character work on radio and television in the 50s and 60s.

I just finished listening to all of the circulating programs. There aren’t many of them. They’re well-written and well-acted. They aren’t Mike Hammer but you couldn’t very well broadcast the real Mike Hammer stories over the public airwaves in 1953, could you? Most aficionados prefer Ted de Corsia’s voicing and he does have a certain gritty charm but I liked Larry Haines better. He sounds remarkably like William Conrad. I wish there were more programs still extant. I don’t think it’s quite as good as Pat Novak…For Hire or the best episodes of Johnny Diamond or Richard Diamond but it’s not bad.

I’m starting to run out of radio dramas that aren’t anthologies, kiddie programs, or too pulpy. I tried listening to the New Adventures of Nero Wolfe but found it unlistenable. Rogues Gallery, the radio program Dick Powell starred in before Richard Diamond, was almost as bad. On the plus side it’s the only radio program I know of that features the main character’s subconscious as a separate character. I’m not sure where I’ll turn next. I may be forced to start listening to Suspense or Escape.

2 comments

She Was Real

You learn something new every day. Gidget was a real person. She was a little Jewish girl with émigré parents in Southern California in the 1950s, her writer father turned her story and her 50s surfer lingo into a book, the book was made into a movie (starring Sandra Dee), the movie was made into a TV series (with Sally Field), and she’s still alive. Her story is here.

0 comments

Best British Films

Yesterday evening I stumbled across the British Film Institute’s list of 100 Best British Films. I was delighted to see that my all-time favorite movie, Hitchcock’s The 39 Steps, is #4 on the list. Hitchcock only has two films on the list, The 39 Steps and the delightful 1938 film The Lady Vanishes but I attribute that to all of his movies from 1940 on being considered American movies.

The director with the most films on the list is David Lean with six (seven if you include In Which We Serve)but another of my favorite directors, Michael Powell, is in second place with five including the movie that basically destroyed his career—1960’s Peeping Tom. It’s odd that two movies so similar and produced right around the same time should have such different effects. Hitchcock’s Psycho bolstered Hitchcock’s career; Peeping Tom very nearly ruined Powell’s.

John Schlesinger has four on the list; Andrew Mackendrick and Tony Richardson each three;

To my eye the list is quite different from the AFI’s list of 100 Best American movies. For one thing is has lots more genre movies. And one Carry On picture! Maybe the Brits aren’t as pretentious as we are.

3 comments

The Case Against Preventive War With North Korea

I don’t generally build my cases without citing and quoting the pieces that motivated my doing so but in this case I’ll make an exception. Why has Kim Jong Un executed high-ranking military officers including his uncle with anti-aircraft guns? I think there are multiple reasons:

  1. Because he can.
  2. Because he saw them as threats.
  3. As a dramatic show of strength and power.
  4. To encourage the others.

just to name a few reasons. In other words, it’s extreme and cruel but not irrational.

As the next plank in my case, preventive war is always immoral. When an attack is imminent and you engage in a spoiling attack, that’s preemptive war and moral. When an enemy might attack some time in the future and you attack to preclude that possibility it’s preventive war. When you wage war against someone who attacked you but isn’t attacking you and it’s 15 years after the attack, it’s revenge and possibly justifiable. When you wage war against someone who knows a guy who knows a guy who attacked you and in all likelihood was in elementary school when the original attack took place, I’m not sure what it is. Loopy?

Finally, I think that the Kim regime needs an enemy and the South Koreans just don’t fit the bill. It’s demanding extraordinary sacrifices of the North Korean people. You don’t get sacrifices of that order without a big, dramatic enemy. Hating your cousin isn’t good enough. That’s why although I think the Kim regime is rational and, Lord knows, we’ve given it every reason in the world to fear and hate us, I don’t believe it’s deterrable and I don’t think there’s anything we could do that would make it abandon its war against us, still in progress. We could withdraw all of our forces from Asia and Asia-adjacent all the way back to Hawaii and we’d still be the enormously powerful, dramatic potential enemy that the Kim regime needs.

Now back to the piece that inspired me. In an interview by Tobin Harshaw of retired Air Force General Merrill McPeak at Bloomberg View, Gen. McPeak says:

Look, we would be much safer as a country if the world contained zero nuclear weapons. They do not enhance our security. We have very superior conventional warfighting capabilities, so we’d be much better off if nobody had nuclear weapons. Now, we’re not going to get there — not least because Israel won’t give up its weapons, and if even one country insists on keeping them, then we can’t achieve a nuclear-free world.

So our problem is, what steps do we take to keep ourselves safe in a proliferating world? We’ve already made a huge mistake by not insisting that India and Pakistan stop their programs. We have been lucky so far with Iran because Barack Obama was smart enough to give us a 10-year breathing period, which Donald Trump seems for some reason anxious to give away.

But here we have a case with North Korea that appears to me to represent more or less the classic case of when we should intervene pre-emptively. We have military forces precisely for a case like this, where someone who is unpredictable, maybe crazy, who executes his uncle with an anti-aircraft gun, and we have no reason to think that he’s not fully capable of doing what he says he’s going to do. He says he’s got a red button — it may be smaller than Trump’s, but he’s got a red button, and we shouldn’t allow that position to continue.

I think that’s irresponsible. Not only is it putting an immoral course of action on the table, it’s counter-productive and antithetical to our interests. A preventive attack against North Korea would inevitably draw China and possibly Russia into direct armed conflict with us. They couldn’t afford not to engage us. It is not too much to say that it’s courting the end of life on earth.

My view, articulated here many times before, is that perfect security is impossible. We should just hold our water, despite provocative actions short of actual war on North Korea’s part. Actually, I wish North Korea were doing a lot more nuclear tests. North Korea is not China or Russia. It can’t afford to build an indefinite number of nuclear weapons. The more tests they do the more it impoverishes themselves and the more it hastens a reaction against the regime. If North Korea is so foolish as to attack us, I think we should respond with all of the force at our disposal and, honestly, I think the Chinese and Russians would understand for the simple reason that’s what they’d do in similar circumstances.

But engaging in saber-rattling, setting deadlines, or loose talk of preventive attacks should just be off the table. They do more harm than good.

2 comments

We’re #1!

And the worst state to live in according to its own residents is…Illinois! Here’s a report from the Daily Mail:

If you live in Illinois, Connecticut or Rhode Island, the chances are you know someone who is not happy. Not happy at all.

Around a quarter of the population living in these regions have described them each as the ‘worst possible state to live in’, according to a Gallup survey.

The map data doesn’t explain the nature of the residents’ grievances.

However, classic socio-economic indicators would clearly be relevant – including work-life balance, healthcare, crime levels, education, housing, income and the environment.

While 21-25 per cent of people ranked these three states as the ‘worst’, Louisiana and Mississippi also featured prominently – with 17-20 per cent describing the two southern states as the worst.

The reasons for the levels of dissatisfaction are not entirely obvious. In Connecticut and Illinois governmental financial mismanagement is clearly a factor. The three least happy states were all carried by Clinton but the happiest states are nearly evenly divided between having been carried by Trump and having been carried by Clinton.

As a group the happiest states (Utah, Colorado, Wyoming, Texas, North Dakota, Minnesota, Iowa, Wisconsin, New Hampshire, Maine) to my eye are also the least diverse. Make of that what you will.

I can only speculate that if you’re bombarded on a daily basis by complaints about how awful things are, many from the media but also from your neighbors, it can be demoralizing.

5 comments

The Simple Truth

There’s a post by Daniel C. Lynch at the blog of Stanford University Press which presents what might for some be a counter-intuitive argument—China’s precipitous rise is over.

The Rise of China is over.

Note, by the way, that in saying the rise of China is over, I am not saying that China is on the verge of a collapse—I am not even certain what a collapse would look like. There are many people outside of China, portentously predicting a collapse, who evidently have in mind something like the disintegration of the Soviet Union—which, given the multiethnic, empire-like nature of the PRC, one could never rule out completely. But after poring over interviews, books, “internal circulation only” (neibu) policy analyses, and open source journals concerning what Chinese elites think the future holds, I found no suggestion that anyone of influence in the PRC expects a collapse—they do however, express anxiety over an impending “leveling off”.

Read the whole thing. His hypothesis is hardly surprising. It even has a name: “the middle income trap”. It’s a commonplace in developing countries, meteoric rise up to a certain point and then much, much slower growth.

I think that China will continue to be a very powerful country and it will continue to grow. It won’t threaten the United States which I presume will be a disappointment to some in Washington who are longing to fight a “near peer” war with a technologically advanced enemy.

0 comments

Radical Reform

If his piece at The Week Ryan Cooper wantgs basic reform of the federal government. He wants to:

  1. Get rid of the Senate filibuster.
  2. Radically change the way House members are elected.
  3. Neuter the Senate.
  4. Elect the president from the House.
  5. Throw the entire Constitution in the garbage.

Over the two and a quarter centuries of the existence of the United States the federal government has transmogrified from an institution that maintained a military, negotiated with foreign governments, printed money, and took care of a handful of other tasks into one with a primary responsibility of redistributing income. Of the $3.9 trillion disbursed by the federal government, about half a trillion was spent on defense, a quarter trillion on interest on the debt, and most of the balance was transfer payments, mostly Social Security which goes to retirees and those on disability and Medicare and Medicaid which goes to health care providers.

The assumptions on which Mr. Cooper’s proposal rests are that there are pressing matters on which there is an urgent need for action, there is a consensus on what that action should be, and that the main factor preventing action is the structure of the federal government. I think that all of those assumptions are false. The illusion of urgency is an artifact, there is grave disagreement on how the matters before the federal government should be addressed, not just between Republicans and Democrats but between elected officials and the voting public, and the primary impediments to action are cowardice on the part of the Congress and that lack of consensus.

An even more activist government will not result in a more courageous Congress, it won’t force the legislators to do their jobs, and it won’t foster greater consensus but will only aggravate the problems we have. I have an even more radical proposal: go back to the structure of government as originally envisioned. Under that structure

  1. The federal government’s primary responsibilities are the military and foreign affairs.
  2. Most other activities of government are the responsibilities of the states.
  3. The federal government should only intervene in the internal activities of the states when they’re in violation of the Constitution or of grave national concern. Slavery was such a national concern. The racism of Jim Crow that resulted in, for example, the Civil Rights Act of 1965, was another such national concern. Providing housing in downtown Chicago is not such a concern.

In such a context it makes sense for it to be difficult to get things done.

I think that Mr. Cooper should consider. The primary effecta of a centralized, efficient federal government with a consensus among legislators has been 25 years of war and an enormous increase in the concentration of wealth. How efficient does he want the federal government to become?

2 comments