State of the Union, 2018

At my wife’s insistence we watched the 2018 State of the Union message last night. It had the usual recitations of accomplishments. There was also the wish list we’ve become accustomed to hearing. Is it my imagination or were there more than the typical number of call-outs?

I don’t care for President Trump’s prosody or diction, e.g. stacking modifiers “very”, “beautiful”, but I thought it was okay as these messages go. Neither a hit nor a flop.

If you were looking for division, you found it and I’m confident the opinion pages will be full of emotional condemnations of the president’s divisive SOTU. If you were looking for unity, you found that, too. What’s the opposite of a “dog whistle”? Deafness that only the hyper-focused recognize? I’m also quite confident that Mr. Trump’s supporters will proclaim it the best SOTU ever.

I think that highlights that the gap between our differing views is real, not just posturing, and will be hard if not impossible to bridge. The 50%+1 style of governance isn’t working and won’t be improved by changing who’s in charge.

I don’t think the Democrats did themselves much good last night by maintaining their sullen, taciturn demeanor. They may have thought it was resolute but I thought it was churlish. As me auld mither used to say it’s not the man it’s the cloth.

Update

The editors’ of the New York Times response was more balanced than I expected. After reciting a list of the benign things that have happened in the last year, they follow up with their complaints:

Despite promising a $1 trillion infrastructure plan a year ago, a phantom plan whose price tag he raised to $1.5 trillion on Tuesday, he has yet to do anything to fix rusting bridges and faltering rail lines. His tax plan will undermine local efforts to make improvements around the country. He has yet to take serious action to end the opioid crisis. (“We have to do something about it,” he said Tuesday night, rather pathetically.) He has rubbed raw the nation’s wounds of bigotry and sexism. Without study or discernment, he has stripped away regulations meant to restrain climate change and to protect consumers. He seems utterly indifferent to improving an education system that is the foundation of the global competitiveness he insists he cares so much about. He’s deepened America’s commitment to Afghanistan with no exit strategy, and he’s raised tensions in the Middle East to no clear end. By gratuitously alienating allies and upending trade deals, he has eased the way for China’s hegemony.

I haven’t bothered to reproduce the many hyperlinks in the quote above. There are a dozen of them. They do bring up one question to my mind—are good intentions enough?

he has stripped away regulations meant to restrain climate change and to protect consumers.

Their study and discernment doesn’t seem to have reached as far as measuring the actual net effects of the regulations. We need to start reckoning the value of policies against what has happened rather than against what their proponents wanted to happen.

E. J. Dionne’s column was about what I would have expected. Here’s an example of the divisiveness he complains about:

“All Americans deserve accountability and respect. And that’s what we are giving to our wonderful heroes our veterans,” Trump said. “So tonight, I call on Congress to empower every Cabinet secretary with the authority to reward good workers and to remove federal employees who undermine the public trust or fail the American people.”

This sounded like an attack on the entire civil service system. It sounded like a demand by Trump that he and those who work for him have the right to fire federal employees whenever he or they feel like it. Perhaps this idea will come with safeguards, perhaps not. Trump didn’t say.

I guess I’m tone deaf. It didn’t sound like that to me. It sounded like a call for long overdue civil service reform. Is that inherently divisive?

Dana Milbank’s reaction was even sharper:

When he said “we proudly stand for the national anthem” — a reference to black NFL players who have protested by taking a knee — there was a lusty roar from the GOP side and wan looks from Democrats. Trump applauded the cheering Republicans.

which I found to be weak tea. This is more to the point:

He drew Democrats’ heckling by alleging that “a single immigrant can bring in virtually unlimited numbers of distant relatives.” Trump, in the context of immigrant violence, even tried to make off with the “dreamer” label applied to young undocumented immigrants brought to the United States as children. He said his duty is to “defend Americans, to protect their safety. . . . Because Americans are dreamers too.” By implication: The “dreamers” are not American.

quoting what will undoubtedly be seen as the most memorable line in the speech. Is that divisive or a case of where you stand depends on where you sit?

The editors of the Washington Post cited divisiveness as well:

HAVE A president’s words ever rung more hollow? In his first State of the Union address Tuesday night, President Trump spoke of “what kind of nation we are going to be. All of us, together, as one team, one people and one American family.” Yet Mr. Trump could not avoid, even for an hour, lacing his address with divisive references to hot-button issues and graceless attacks on his predecessors: to “disastrous Obamacare,” “the mistakes of past administrations,” “the era of economic surrender” and more.

The editors of the Wall Street Journal strike a note closer to what I heard:

Democrats want to legalize the young adult Dreamer immigrants, spend money on roads and bridges, and give ex-cons a second chance at a better life. More dangerously for the economy, more Democrats than Republicans share Mr. Trump’s protectionist views on trade, which we were glad to see him play down on Tuesday night.

Mr. Trump’s immigration message was a mix of rhetorical edginess with policy compromise. He spent far too much time flogging immigration as an issue of crime rather than highlighting the many contributions that newcomers make. He also included a gratuitous gibe that “Americans are Dreamers too,” which will insult more people than it persuades. This rhetoric may have been intended to placate supporters who are nervous about Mr. Trump’s willingness to negotiate with Democrats, but he missed a chance to seem more big-hearted.

On the other hand, Mr. Trump’s legislative offer last week is a bid for compromise between left and right that includes a path to citizenship for 1.8 million Dreamers who were brought to the U.S. as children. That’s far more than the 700,000 or so that applied for work permits under Barack Obama’s illegal order—and far more than GOP restrictionists want.

Did the Democrats already signal their response? If compromise is betrayal and you won’t accept anything you want unless you get everything you want, it’s the end of republican government.

16 comments

Another “Best Movies” List

I found this list of 50 best movies at 24/7 Wall Street very interesting. There must be something to their methodology since it does select quite a few of the best movies.

However, I think they’re missing something. Shouldn’t the list of “best movies” tend to stabilize over time? Shouldn’t the only movies that enter the list over time be new movies? I don’t think their methodology is robust in that sense. I think there are some movies in their list that no one will watch in 10 years and others that aren’t on the list that people will still be watching in 50 years.

2 comments

What Should the Policy Be?

I suspect that I agree with the position articulated by Noah Smith in his piece at Bloomberg View, critiquing the idea that we can “bring back manufacturing jobs”, more than this post might suggest. Rather than take on his points one by one I’ll put my thoughts into a series of questions about policy. When I present a dichotomy, assume we can only select one (I know it’s more complicated than that).

  • Should the objective of policy be to maximize the number of low wage jobs? That’s what the Germans call “the American model”.
  • Should we subsidize consumption or employment? Right now we impose steep taxes on employment, suggesting that we want less of it.
  • Should we subsidize immigration? Failing to enforce our own laws is a form of subsidy. We’re doing that with respect to legal and illegal immigration.
  • Why do we subsidize the creation of intellectual property? Hypothetically, a residual can be attached to any good or service.
  • Why do we subsidize imports? It might not be obvious but we subsidize imports in dozens of ways including requiring different things from domestic and foreign suppliers.

These all boil down to a much bigger question: what kind of America do we want?

I think the policy objectives should be to maximize the number of high wage jobs, to stop subsidizing consumption and increase the subsidies to employment, that we should not subsidize immigration, that we should cut the subsidies for the creation of intellectual property, and that we should not subsidize imports. I want a much more egalitarian United States in which more people are employed in creative, highly compensated work.

To achieve my goals we’d need to reduce subsidies on some things and increase the subsidies on others.

7 comments

The Meaning of Life

I strongly suggest that you read this frequently distressing article at The New Yorker recounting a young Oakland woman’s journey from more-or-less good health through insufficiently attentive care to being pronounced dead to maintaining something just a bit more than vegetative life and the effect of that journey on her family. The article raises all sorts of difficult questions, not the least being are the girl’s parents correct? Did the color of her skin influence the care she received? Does her parents’ conviction that’s the case influence the care they want provided?

Not the least disturbing question and unquestionably the thorniest: who pays?

9 comments

Free Trade False Flags

I disagree with this remark of George Friedman’s in his recent criticism the post-recession recovery:

Across European and American society, economic classes that were traditionally linked to left or center parties have shifted their allegiance. One major reason has been that the parties they have traditionally supported were advocates of free trade.

IMO there are practically no advocates of free trade, either here in the United States or anywhere else and certainly none in positions of power. What there are are people who say they support free trade but actually are just pushing their national or personal benefit under the pretext of free trade.

When the United States blocks a major trade agreement on the grounds that the agreement doesn’t do enough to protect American intellectual property rights, that’s not free trade. That’s pursuit of national interest. Or political donor interest. That’s trying to dictate the terms of managed trade.

That’s what I think that practically all countries do. They look our for their national interests or for the interests of some of their citizens.

What has actually happened since the Great Recession is that, partially because the global trade picture has changed, partially because domestic political landscapes have changed, the various countries that have pushed for these managed trade agreements see their interests differently than they did.

0 comments

China’s Hierarchy of Values

I think there’s something missing from James Holmes’s post at The National Interest on China’s strategy and tactics and the South China Sea and that’s the notion of a hierarchy of values. He writes:

The ornerier the better when you’re playing the part of Screwtape. So it’s with a whiff of fire and brimstone that I take issue with my friend Gordon Chang, who maintains that “China Wants Confrontation in the South China Sea.” Hence Beijing’s decision to disclose that USS Hopper executed a freedom-of-navigation cruise last week while Washington initially remained silent about it. Gordon regards Chinese bombast as proof that Chinese Communist Party (CCP) leaders are spoiling for a fight of some sort, rather than as yet more proof that bombast is encoded in Communist China’s political DNA.

Keyword: wants. It’s the job of all strategic leaders to prepare for confrontation. To do otherwise courts disaster should confrontation come. But few sane leaders crave strife.

Let’s start reasoning from premises. The first thing that should be considered is Clausewitz’s formulation: war is politics by other means. The second is that politics is important in every country—democratic, authoritarian, or somewhere in between. The third is that China’s leaders want to stay in power.

Now to some observations. The Chinese want China to assume its rightful place in the world whatever that might mean. And the Chinese leaders think that economics and foreign policy are zero-sum games. One side wins; the other loses.

The implication of that is that for China to assume its rightful place in the world the United States must be diminished.

Now let’s weave those all together. The Chinese leaders may not want war but they may choose it if they believe it will advance China’s place in the world, if it will diminish the United States, or if they believe it’s necessary for them to retain hold of the reins. IMO all of those are more important in their hierarchy of values than maintaining the status quo or avoiding war.

0 comments

The Monster That Devoured Washington

The enumerated powers of the federal government include defense, minting money, regulating commerce between the states and with foreign countries, and enforcing the laws. Fifty years ago the largest single budget category was defense and most federal disbursements were for things within those enumerated powers. You will search in vain for “health care” among the enumerated powers except under the catch-all category of “general welfare”. Now health care is the federal government’s largest single budget item as this article at the American Spectator observes:

A half-century ago, defense accounted for 45 percent of federal outlays at $405 billion. Medicare and health, combining for $45 billion, constituted five percent of the budget. Granted, the budget disparity occurred at the peak of the Vietnam War. But a review of federal budgets during non-war postwar years generally shows defense dwarfing health-related expenses.

The entity eating up the largest portion of the federal budget remains the well-fed Department of Health and Human Services, which devours roughly $1.1 trillion. Social Security ($1 trillion), Defense and the Veterans Administration ($900 billion), and the catchall category “everything else” ($1 trillion) each account for a smaller piece of the federal pie.

I don’t think that “general welfare” means what you probably think it means. I think that general welfare is to be distinguished from particular welfare. If Americans were living longer and were becoming healthier it would be arguable that all of that health care spending was justified. But those are not the case and, consequently, I don’t believe it is, at least not by the federal government.

Politicians are absolutely uninterested in controlling health care spending. There’s nothing in it for them. Too many people get angry when the treatment they want isn’t being paid for by someone else and that “someone else” is most commonly the federal government.

If you could put an absolute lid on how much the federal government could borrow, it would force politicians to become interested but you can’t. That would require a constitutional amendment, something else which politicians are absolutely uninterested in.

I don’t know how to solve this problem but I do know that it is a problem. I don’t think there’s any way to resolve it as long as the same companies, organizations, and individuals decide what care should be provided, decide when and how it should be provided, and decide how much it’s worth and the people receiving the care aren’t interested in how much it costs.

I also know that borrowing to pay operating expenses is a very bad idea but that’s what we’re doing. Most of the borrowing in the years ahead will be to pay for health care. Even if we cut our military spending to zero it still wouldn’t cover the difference.

4 comments

Torn

I’m severely torn about whether to listen to the State of the Union message tonight or not. On the one hand I don’t like listening to Trump. I didn’t watch his television program. I thought he was obnoxious and unamusing then and I think he’s obnoxious and unamusing now.

On the other hand it’s news and who knows? He might say something interesting.

8 comments

Sauce for the Goose

This story at the Los Angeles Times about illegal immigration from the United States into Canada caught my eye:

Worried that anti-immigrant rhetoric and decisions from the Trump administration could drive more people across its border, the Canadian government is trying to nip that in the bud.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau dispatched Rodriguez to California.

The whip for the majority Liberal Party in Parliament, Rodriguez arrived in the U.S. a few days after President Trump announced his decision to end temporary protected status of an estimated 200,000 Salvadorans in the country.

His message was not that different from immigration hardliners in the U.S. But it was delivered with a nicer Canadian soft sell.

Rodriguez was a young boy when he arrived in Canada as a political refugee from Argentina. He said he can empathize with those looking north.

He said that Canada is “an open country” and a nation of immigrants. But, he stressed, immigrating to the country needs to be done legally.

1 comment

What’s Missing from the U. S. Economy

At Bloomberg View Mark Whitehouse jumps on my bandwagon:

The latest data on the U.S. economy underscore one of the greatest challenges facing the administration of President Donald Trump: getting businesses to invest like they used to. For all the progress that’s been made, there’s still a long way to go.

Last week’s report on U.S. gross domestic product suggested that the economy ended 2017 with good momentum. Although the overall annualized, inflation-adjusted growth rate was a slower-than-expected 2.6 percent in the three months through December, the details were encouraging. In particular, businesses boosted investment in the equipment, buildings and know-how needed to support future growth. Nonresidential fixed investment increased sharply for the fourth quarter in a row, putting it up 6.3 percent from a year earlier.

[…]

Growth rates alone, though, don’t tell the whole story. Equipment deteriorates and technologies become obsolete. So it’s also important to understand whether the level of investment is enough to both offset this depreciation and expand the capital base.

[…]

It’s not the prettiest picture. In the last quarter of 2017, net private business investment was $492 billion, or 2.5 percent of GDP. That’s a big improvement from the darkest days of the last recession, when it went negative for the first time on record, but still not much more than it was at the low points of several earlier recessions.

Business investment has been phlegmatic since the 90s. You can’t blame a lack of consumer spending for the change. 25 years ago and before businesses invested a lot more with lower consumer spending.

There are several possible explanations. Businesses may be investing—just not in the United States. Managers’ expectations may be unrealistic. They may have lost their appetites for risk.

But Mr. White house is right. The test of the tax cuts as economic policy will be businesses’ propensity to invest. I had wanted a somewhat more targeted tax cut for just that reason.

0 comments