The Direction the Canoes Are Paddling

At City Journal Joel Kotkin and Wendell Cox notice something interesting:

The most recent Census population estimates revealed something that the mainstream media would prefer to ignore—the slowing population growth of big cities, including New York. The New York Times, for example, trumpeted Gotham’s historically high population yet failed to mention that the city’s growth is not only dramatically slowing but also, in the case of Brooklyn, declining for the first time since 2006. New York’s rate of growth, impressive earlier in this decade, now ranks among the nation’s lowest, mostly because of rising domestic outmigration. In 2017, nearly three times as many domestic migrants left the city as in 2011. This may be one reason why rents, which have soared for a decade, have begun to flatten, though they remain at a level many potential newcomers may still find difficult to afford.

New York’s population slowdown is hardly unique. Many of the largest U.S. metropolitan areas have seen domestic outmigration surge over the last few years. The highest-percentage declines were found in Los Angeles, Chicago, New York and, remarkably, tech-heavy San Jose, which ranked worst among 53 metropolitan areas with populations above 1 million. Last year, the San Francisco Bay Area’s seven metros experienced outmigration more than ten times higher than the annual average since 2010. This includes the “boomtown” San Francisco metropolitan area, which attracted domestic migrants from 2010 through 2015 but saw strong net outmigration last year. At 0.60 percent, San Francisco’s 2017 population growth was half its post-2010 average. In 2017, population growth in Los Angeles was among the lowest in the nation, and at 0.19 percent, down two-thirds from its annual average since 2010.

California, New York, and Illinois all have net domestic outmigration. California and New York continue to grow through immigration. IMO that can be accounted for by what’s on TV.

The medium-sized and small metro areas to which people are moving are full of deplorables. Will they become less deplorable?

1 comment

What If Democrats Retake the House?

At The Week David Faris makes several predictions of what would happen if Democrats were to retake the House of Representatives in 2018. Here they are in bullet form:

  • There will finally be real investigations into Trump’s scandals.
  • The Trump domestic legislative agenda would be dead.
  • Trump would still be able to transform the courts and start wars.
  • Democrats should do more than obstruct.

which I think are pretty fair as far as they go. Something depends on who the new Democratic majority would be. Would the new majority be able to resist impeaching Trump? I don’t think so. I think they’d have a rebellion in their caucus on their hands if they just tried to keep Trump as an issue without trying to remove him from office. Keep in mind that a “high crime or misdemeanor” is whatever the House says it is.

Would the House Democrats attempt to expand the PPACA, enact DACA into law, pass “comprehensive immigration reform” whatever that may be, pass gun control, or address any of the other issues they’ve whined about but done little about including the last time they held the House?

Don’t expect it. Republican or Democratic leadership, the House is mostly in the business of getting re-elected and they’ll do the least they can without losing the issues they run on or getting booted out of office.

1 comment

Why We’re So Lousy

I agree with Nathaniel Lewis that the U. S. has a host of problems. I disagree with his claim that increased spending would solve many of them. From his piece at Jacobin:

The US government has a spending problem. Given the country’s level of wealth, the government spends far too little — at least $1.6 trillion a year too little — on social welfare.

This exacerbates problems like poverty and inequality, and makes life a lot harder for a lot of people — from families with young children, to would-be college graduates, to the sick and elderly — than it should be. By leaving a large proportion of health care spending to the private sector, the United States has ended up with a health care system which does not even pass the basic test of universal coverage but is far more expensive than if one that was publicly funded were at stake.

The best way to show this is to compare US social welfare with similar countries around the world. As a starting point, I use the OECD’s social expenditure database, which defines social spending as “cash benefits, direct in-kind provision of goods and services, and tax breaks with social purposes. Benefits may be targeted at low-income households, the elderly, disabled, sick, unemployed, or young persons.”

Oddly, his own statistics might provide a clue to why we do what we do. Consider this graph:

Are we to believe that it is a coincidence that the U. S. is clustered with the rest of the English-speaking common law countries? Is it not more reasonable to conclude that there’s something about Canadian, British, American, and U. S. civil culture that leads to our having lower social spending related to total consumption than, say, France? Clearly, it has nothing to do with how our health care systems are organized: organizational and funding mechanisms for health care could hardly be more divergent than Canada, the United Kingdom, and the United States and yet there we are, all tightly clustered together.

I agree with this statement of his:

The best way to show this is to compare US social welfare with similar countries around the world.

Are we more like Canada or Luxembourg?

Let me provide another set of inconvenient truths. The United States doesn’t just spend more for its health care than any other country. It spends more for its military, more on education, and more per foot of public roads or bridges than any other OECD country. All of these are overwhelmingly dominated by government spending.

For most of the last two centuries France has promoted the notion of “Frenchness” as the core of civil society: common language, common mores, common culture. That has led to the active suppression of minorities there. But they do have a lot of public spending.

0 comments

What Should Our Immigration Policy Be?

What should our immigration policy be?

I’ve expressed my opinion about this many times. I think that we should greatly increase the number of work visas available to Mexicans, impose workplace-based enforcement of immigration law with serious penalties for failure to enforce, abandon family reunification and diversity as criteria for granting visas, enforce educational and tourist visas, tighten up greatly on the L-1 visa, and return the H1-B program to what it was supposed to be—a way of admitting more people who had skills unavailable in the domestic market. Over the years it has transmogrified into a way of bringing in relatively low level clerical and technical workers. Basically, it’s a fraud.

With respect to the beneficiaries of DACA, the Congress should establish some set of criteria and those criteria should be enforced rigorously. The parents of the “DREAMers” should not be included.

What do you think our policy should be?

7 comments

The Non-Existent Agency

At RealClearPolicy Andrew Wilform complains that the Congressional Budget Office is doing its job:

It is true that CBO and JCT have been guilty of using flawed assumptions in the past, as NTUF has pointed out. But the current system is such that they are effectively required to do so by Congress. Moderate reform can improve their ability to inform legislators and taxpayers about the impacts of legislation while encouraging the use of more realistic analysis.

As a first step, NTUF has created the Taxpayers Budget Office as a way of holding both the CBO and Congress accountable. The Taxpayers Budget Office aims to serve as a watchdog to provide more critical analysis at times when CBO does not provide the full picture. But lawmakers should also do their part by attempting to reform CBO to improve its methodology and make it more difficult for legislators to manipulate CBO processes.

The CBO is a creature of Congress and does its bidding. If the Congress tells CBO that such and such a provision will sunset, they’ve got to assume it will.

He longs for any agency that has never existed and cannot.

The real way to hold Congress accountable is for

  1. Bills to be limited to a single subject matter.
  2. Spending bills to include specific, explicit sources for what they’re spending, e.g. borrowing, a special tax, etc.
  3. Ditto for tax expenditures.

That can be accomplished the easy way, by Congress imposing rules on itself, or the hard way, by constitutional amendment. Neither will happen. The Congress has always been irresponsible and is now largely unaccountable and will remain so.

2 comments

Back to the Future

Dexter Filkins has a lengthy profile of Mohammed bin Salman, Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia, at The New Yorker. Mr. Filkins’s portrayal is somewhat less rosy than many of the portraits of MBS in the Western media but it doesn’t quite comport with my own views which can be summarized:

  • Anybody who arrests his cousins and puts them in detention in a hotel until they transfer their wealth to him isn’t a liberal democrat. It is, however, one way of getting the rich to “pay their fair share”. It’s not one that’s open to the U. S.
  • Ditto about waging a “wag the dog” war against Yemen.
  • There is no place for most of the Saudi population in a KSA remodeled along the lines of the UAE.
  • Don’t be misled by minor liberalizations. The farthest he will push the kingdom is to the middle of the 20th century which is none too far.

I think that he’s trying to weaken his opponents, religious or secular, and build a power base for himself. Be careful about thinking of him as a liberalizer.

Read the whole thing. It’s a good backgrounder.

3 comments

The Brightest Picture

At Bloomberg View Albert Hunt gives some unsolicited advice to Democrats:

Two top Democrats made dangerous blunders over the past few weeks that should serve as a warning for politicians opposing Donald Trump.

Former Vice President Joe Biden told college students that Trump’s comments and actions about women were so offensive that if they were in high school, “I’d take him behind the gym and beat the hell out of him.”

In India, Hillary Clinton suggested that her voters in 2016 were from “optimistic, diverse and dynamic” venues, while Trump appealed to voters who “didn’t like black people getting rights” and who “don’t like women getting jobs.”

There was a backlash: When you insult voters you may need someday, they probably aren’t going to vote for you; and when you mud-wrestle with pigs, the pigs enjoy it.

Biden, who immediately heard from friends and family, quickly realized the error of his impulsive threat and apologized. “I shouldn’t have said what I said,” he explained. “I don’t want to get down in the mosh pit with this guy.”

Other Democrats will be similarly tempted when insulted by something Trump has done or said, sometimes viciously.

Here’s a wacky idea. Avoid negative advertising entirely and ensure that the outside groups that support you do, too. Its main effect is to discourage voting.

I predict they won’t take the advice. The temptation is just too great and the force of habit is irresistible.

I’ll offer some advice I’m confident will also be ignored. It remains true that the candidate who paints the most optimistic picture of America, present and future, gets elected president. And if you exclude groups of voters from that picture, they won’t vote for you.

I’d also suggest that they run the candidates who are the best fit for the states and local areas in which they are running and leave ideology alone. They won’t take that advice either.

3 comments

Greatest Religious Epics

I’ve put in my own two cents about a lot of movie genres over the years but I don’t recall giving my opinion of the greatest religious epics so, in honor of Easter weekend, I’ll weigh in on them.

I think that “religious epic” is practically an oxymoron since most of the movies called religious epics are not religious and barely epics. The really great movies about religion, like Lilies of the Field aren’t epics at all.

However, from about 1930 to somewhere around 1970 lots of these movies were made. They made money in the theaters and, before television, cable, and streaming reruns they had a profitable second life being shown to church groups. Here’s a selection of some that I think are actually worth watching. My list is marred somewhat by my failure to view The Passion of the Christ. I haven’t been able to steel myself to watch it. Should I?

King of Kings (1927)

Cecil B. DeMille’s dramatization of the story of Jesus, at the time the most expensive movie in Hollywood history, is both beautiful and reverent, a rarity in the genre. It remains worth watching nearly a century later.

Ben Hur: a Tale of the Christ (1925)

There have now been three versions of Gen. Lew Wallace’s 1880 novel but the first silent version is by far the best. If you watch it keep in mind that every effect is practical.

Quo Vadis (1951)

Quo Vadis was the first of MGM’s spectacular Italian-produced Technicolor religious epics. It also features an incredibly gorgeous cast and good acting, provided by a largely British cast. I also think that Marcus’s faith is much like our own. Unlike Peter he hasn’t seen Jesus and unlike Lygia he remains unconvinced by the religion stuff but he does believe in something—Lygia.

The Robe

This movie, in a sense 20th Century Fox’s response to Quo Vadis and explicitly a reaction to 3D, was the first movie released in CinemaScope and it has a stereophonic score. Like Quo Vadis it’s redeemed by good acting by its largely British cast. It received the Academy Award for Best Picture and was tremendously profitable.

An amusing footnote: the movie’s poster features the wrong Jean. Jean Peters was originally cast as the female lead but was replaced by Jean Simmons. Jean Peters is depicted on the poster.

I liked The Last Temptation of Christ, too. I had read the novel and like it even more.

0 comments

Declaring Intellectual Bankruptcy

In a piece at New York Magazine Andrew Sullivan remarks on the same David Reich op-ed I did last week:

In some ways, this is just a replay of the broader liberal-conservative argument. Leftists tend to believe that all inequality is created; liberals tend to believe we can constantly improve the world in every generation, forever perfecting our societies. Rightists believe that human nature is utterly unchanging; conservatives tend to see the world as less plastic than liberals, and attempts to remake it wholesale dangerous and often counterproductive. I think of myself as moderately conservative. It’s both undeniable to me that much human progress has occurred, especially on race, gender, and sexual orientation; and yet I’m suspicious of the idea that our core nature can be remade or denied. I completely respect the role of liberals in countering this. It’s their role. I think the genius of the West lies in having all these strands in our politics competing with one another.

and

I know this is a touchy, fraught, difficult subject. I completely understand the reluctance to discuss it, and the hideous history of similar ideas in the past. But when people seeking the truth are immediately targeted for abuse and stigma, it matters. When genetics are in a golden age, when neuroscience is maturing as a discipline, and when the truth about these things will emerge soon enough, it matters that we establish a liberalism that is immune to such genetic revelations, that can strive for equality of opportunity, and can affirm the moral and civic equality of every human being on the planet. Liberalism has never promised equality of outcomes, merely equality of rights. It’s a procedural political philosophy rooted in means, not a substantive one justified by achieving certain ends.

That liberalism is integral to our future as a free society — and it should not falsely be made contingent on something that can be empirically disproven. It must allow for the truth of genetics to be embraced, while drawing the firmest of lines against any moral or political abuse of it. When that classical liberalism is tarred as inherently racist because it cannot guarantee equality of outcomes, and when scientific research is under attack for revealing the fuller truth about our world, we are in deep trouble. Because we are robbing liberalism of the knowledge and the moderation it will soon desperately need to defend itself.

I think he’s beating a very nearly literally dead horse. The ideas that have informed American politics since the end of World War II are just about played out and what have replaced them have little intellectual support.

Liberals are now over 80 or deceased. Those who used to be called conservatives and are now called paleocons are mostly in their 70s or dead. Bernie Sanders’s politics really isn’t much like that of Hubert Humphrey or Walter Mondale at all. Donald Trump no more resembles William F. Buckley than I do the Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer lion. Somewhat less so, actually.

There is no progressive equivalent of Walter Lippmann or Pat Moynihan any more than there is a modern conservative equivalent of William F. Buckley or Milton Friedman. Bill Kristol does not have the intellectual heft his father did.

What has replaced debate in our public discourse are quips, one-liners, memes, tropes, and jibes.

20 comments

The Thing With Feathers

Also from Brookings, I thought you might be interested in the remarks about a study of young people in Peru that found that hope has a beneficial effect on life outcomes:

We found remarkably high levels of resilience and education aspirations among our survey population. Eighty-eight percent of our young adults aspire to completing college or post-college education. In addition, most of the respondents in this high aspirations category had experienced one or more negative shocks in the past. Respondents in the high aspirations categories are also far less likely to partake in risky behaviors, such as smoking or having unsafe sex. This provides additional evidence suggesting that individuals with high aspirations and/or hope for the future are more likely to invest in those futures as well as to avoid behaviors that are likely to jeopardize their futures.

Is it just barely possible that the lack of hope is one of the factors behind the mutual massacre happening on the South and West sides of Chicago and in a number of other American cities?

Fortunately, our young people have no need of hope. They have firearms instead.

8 comments