More On Those Canoes

There’s an interesting article at Slate about differing patterns of inmigration and outmigration among American cities. For example:

There are two types of cities in America. In some of them, the people moving in are better educated and make more money than the people moving out. In others, the opposite is true.

In the former category, we have, of course, San Francisco, where over the past 12 years the median in-migrant has earned $12,640 a year more than the median out-migrant did before he or she left. New York, Los Angeles, and Miami are also metro areas where new arrivals make, at the median, more than $5,000 more than their outgoing counterparts. There is something intuitive about this: People are liable to move away when things aren’t going well, and arrive because they’ve gotten a great job.

But it’s paired with a number of other trends that together indicate a widespread sorting occurring between metro areas where housing is expensive and wages are high and ones where they are not. San Francisco, New York City, Los Angeles, San Diego, Washington, D.C., Seattle, and Chicago are the cities in which in-migrants are the most likely to be more highly educated than people leaving town. New residents in these cities also tend to be younger. Their households have more earners (roommates, potentially, or working partners) and are more likely to rent than own.

but

Other U.S. cities show a different pattern. In Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati, and Pittsburgh, for example, people leaving tend to be earning more money than people arriving. They also tend to be better educated. This also sounds appealing, in a way, if you think of the city as an input-output machine of upward mobility. But these aren’t 19th-century immigrant metropolises. In practice, this data more likely represents a stream of ambitious and qualified people heading elsewhere.

Of the cities in that first category Chicago is the only one showing net outmigration or, “one of these things is not like the others”. It will be interesting to see how Chicago Democrats reconcile the city’s increasing gentrification and the large numbers of homicides on the South and West sides with their advance press as being the “party of the little guy”.

Also, I don’t think that urbanists should count their chickens before they’re hatched. The new residents being younger might be an advantage today but it is simply not true that they can depended on to stay in place forever. As their life circumstances change, they, like previous generations, are likely to move.

2 comments

Don’t Get Cocky, Kid

At Politico Jeff Greenfield warns Democrats against “magical thinking”:

Some of the most damaging blows to Democratic hopes this year are friendly fire.

The most recent—and most harmful—came from John Paul Stevens, the retired Supreme Court Justice, who wrote an op-ed piece for the New York Times in which he called for an outright repeal of the Second Amendment. Stevens, who wrote a powerful dissent in District of Columbia v. Heller, the case that established an individual right to bear arms under the Constitution, wrote in the Times: “Overturning that decision via a constitutional amendment to get rid of the Second Amendment would be simple and would do more to weaken the N.R.A.’s ability to stymie legislative debate and block constructive gun control legislation than any other available option. … It would eliminate the only legal rule that protects sellers of firearms in the United States—unlike every other market in the world.”

It is hard to overstate just how off-kilter Stevens’ argument is. In the first place, repealing the Second Amendment is “simple” in the same way that ending submarine warfare by heating the oceans to the boiling point is “simple.” There may be an alternate universe where there are 191 House members, 67 senators and 38 state legislatures ready to vote for the amendment’s repeal, but back here on Planet Earth? Not so much. (The only proposal less likely to succeed is the idea of depriving smaller states of the same clout in the Senate as the bigger ones. Why? Because Article V of the Constitution specifically says that “no state, without its consent, shall be deprived of its equal suffrage in the Senate” and that this rule cannot be amended.)

He goes on to remark on how obsession with Russian collusion, trysts with porn stars, and all of the other cable news staples can undermine the Democrats’ fortunes in November. Democrats have a number advantages, e.g. the tendency to for the party that doesn’t control the White House to gain seats in midterms, but they have disadvantages, too, including the large number of “safe” seats, offset somewhat by the large number of incumbents who have decided to spend more time with their families.

My advice continues to be run good candidates who are suited for the districts they want to serve, choose judiciously in nationalizing the election, and don’t act crazy.

11 comments

Can China Deliver?

I’m not really sure whether Martin Feldstein, writing in an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal believes that promises of change in their trade policies are enough or whether he thinks that China is actually willing to deliver on those promises:

The most important issue is the demand that U.S. companies transfer their technology to Chinese counterparts as a condition of doing business in China. American businesses that want to produce or sell in China are often required to enter into a joint venture with a Chinese firm that then has access to U.S. technology. Chinese companies then use that technology to expand their own production and sales at home and to displace American firms in the rest of the world. The result is a loss of income to the American businesses.

The Chinese government acknowledges that WTO rules forbid making the transfer of technology a condition for access to a nation’s economy. But it argues that the practice is “voluntary” because American firms aren’t forced to do business in China—their other option is to stay out of the country. American companies and officials say it’s a form of extortion because U.S. firms should have access to the Chinese market, as they do to markets in Europe and elsewhere, without losing their intellectual property.

Although the Chinese practice violates WTO rules, it is difficult to bring a successful technology-transfer case because American companies fear retaliation by Beijing if they complain openly or provide detailed evidence that the U.S. government can use in pursuing such a case. Even so, the U.S. government began an investigation in August 2017, as called for by WTO rules, and concluded last month that China does violate the rule that market access may not be conditioned on technology transfer. The U.S. then imposed tariffs and other penalties.

This is not the first accusation that China has taken intellectual property from American companies. The U.S. previously complained that Beijing was using sophisticated cyber tools to invade the computer systems of U.S. manufacturers, extract valuable technology, and transfer it to Chinese companies. The Chinese government denied it.

That’s not the only thing that the Chinese authorities agreed to in return for joining the World Trade Organization. They agreed to make the Chinese banking sector more transparent, open it up to foreign competition, and achieve a certain percentage of foreign ownership of Chinese banks. They have never lived up to any of those commitments.

Frankly, I’m skeptical that the Chinese government can live to up its commitments or, at the very least, that it’s willing to. China does not have a robust system of civil law. An American company can’t really sue a Chinese company for infringement. It would take an enormous commitment of resources either to change their system, something I can’t imagine their doing, or enforce its commitments in the absence of a robust system of civil law. A leopard does not change its spots.

6 comments

Interesting Times

There’s an informative piece on the infighting at the New York Times by Joe Pompeo at Vanity Fair. I think it’s indicative of the end of journalism as we’ve known it which was at least aspirationally impartial even if its impartiality was honored more in the breach than the observance. I think what we’ll see is increased partisan cheerleading masquerading as impartiality until our news media more closely resemble the situation that prevails in the UK where there’s a Labour daily and a Tory daily.

Contrary to what you might believe, the issue is not the editorial page. It’s the news pages.

7 comments

The Death of Democracy

If Lilliana Mason’s findings as reported in The Intercept are correct, I see no way that republican government can survive:

Her paper, “Ideologues Without Issues: the Polarizing Consequences of Ideological Identities,” published in late March by Public Opinion Quarterly, uses 2016 data from Survey Sampling International and American National Election Studies to study how and why Americans are politically polarized.

She used measures that identify both where people stand on issues and how they identify their political clan. For issues, she took six major ones from the survey: “immigration, the Affordable Care Act, abortion, same-sex marriage, gun control, and the relative importance of reducing the deficit or unemployment.” Additionally, she used their measurements of social identity on a range from liberal to conservative.

She then sought to correlate these answers with questions where respondents answered whether they would prefer to live next door to, marry, be friends with, or spend social time with someone who differs from them politically.

She found that the political identity people adopt was far more predictive of their preferences for social interaction.

For instance, “moving from the least identified to the most identified with an ideological label increases preference for marrying inside the ideological group by 30 percentage points.” In other words, if you are a committed liberal, you’re much more likely to want to live next to other committed liberals. But if you just disagree strongly with them about a specific issue like abortion, not so much.

She writes, “The effect of issue-based ideology is less than half the size of identity-based ideology in each element of social distance. … These are sizable and significant effects, robust to controls for issue-based ideology, and they demonstrate that Americans are dividing themselves socially on the basis of whether they call themselves liberal or conservative, independent of their actual policy differences.”

In honesty I don’t think she is. I think that politicians views exhibit the behavior she has identified:

The loose connections some voters have with policy preferences has become apparent in recent years. Donald Trump managed to flip a party from support of free trade to opposition to it by merely taking the opposite side of the issue. Democrats, meanwhile, mocked Mitt Romney in 2012 for calling Russia the greatest geopolitical adversary of the United States, but now have flipped and see Russia as exactly that. Regarding health care, the structure of the Affordable Care Act was initially devised by the conservative Heritage Foundation and implemented in Massachusetts as “Romneycare.” Once it became Obamacare, the Republican team leaders deemed it bad, and thus it became bad.

but that there continues to be an American consensus that is not, in fact, represented by either political party. That’s borne out by any number of opinion polls and the fact that party affiliation in either party has declined over time.

So, for example, most Americans favor reduced immigration but support some sort of legal clemency for “DREAMers”. That’s in diametric opposition to both political parties which want increased immigration without any sort of official program for the “DREAMers” (the Democrats want the situation to be addressed illegally by fiat while the Republicans don’t want it to be addressed at all).

What we see now is that a narrowing sliver of each party controls their respective parties while most people are disgusted with both parties.

13 comments

Blame the Guy Behind the Tree

Jason L. Riley, ever the one to be the dog in the manger, writes in his Wall Street Journal column:

Racial gaps that were steadily narrowing in the 1940s, ’50s and ’60s would expand in the 1970s, ’80s and ’90s, which suggests that the disparities that continue today aren’t being driven by racism, notwithstanding claims to the contrary from liberals and their allies in the media. It also suggests that attitudes toward marriage, education, work and the rule of law play a much larger role than the left wants to acknowledge. More marches won’t address out-of-wedlock childbearing. More sit-ins won’t lower black crime rates or narrow the school achievement gap.

Even electing and appointing more black officials, which has been a major priority for civil-rights leaders over the past half-century, can’t compensate for these cultural deficiencies. Black mayors, police chiefs and school superintendents have been commonplace since the 1970s, including in major cities with large black populations. Racially gerrymandered voting districts have ensured the election of blacks to Congress. Even the election of a black president—twice—failed to close the divide in many key measures. Black-white differences in poverty, homeownership and incomes all grew wider under President Obama.

Discussion of antisocial behavior in poor black communities, let alone the possibility that it plays a significant role in racial inequality, has become another casualty of the post-’60s era. King and other black leaders at the time spoke openly about the need for more-responsible behavior in poor black communities. After remarking on disproportionately high inner-city crime rates, King told a black congregation in St. Louis that “we’ve got to do something about our moral standards.” He added: “We know that there are many things wrong in the white world, but there are many things wrong in the black world too. We can’t keep on blaming the white man. There are things we must do for ourselves.”

I think he discounts racism as a factor in holding the advancement of American blacks too quickly. I think it’s racism that caused the quotas and set-asides that were supposed to help American blacks result in giving preferences to African and Caribbean blacks. All that the presumably well-intentioned could see was the color their skins.

I also have no explanation other than racism to account for how limited the power of blacks is in the Democratic caucus. If blacks held power in proportion to black voters’ importance for Democrats there would be many more black Congressional representatives and more of the leadership would be blacks as well.

Paternalism is possibly the most virulent form of racism.

1 comment

Spring Is Here

At The Week Matthew Walther remarks about the growth in Trump’s popular approval:

It’s not surprising that after little more than a year in office many people who voted for a president still support him. But it’s also surprising that a president who has been the object of more negative reporting than any in our history still enjoys something like the same middling base of support he had before taking office. Unless it’s the negative reporting that is the problem, which I suspect is very largely the case. You can only ask adults to participate in the fiction that a retweet of a wrestling GIF is a credible threat of violence against some nerd reporters at a cable station or delight in what you hope will be the failure of American trade policy before they decide to tune you out. Very largely this had already happened by Inauguration Day, but now the work of MSNBC and The New York Times and PolitiFact is complete. Millions of Americans do not know the difference between what is true and what is false and have decided that they do not much care either.

He proposes that journalists alter course from the relentless attacks on Trump and take a different tack:

If Trump argues against free trade, consider the issue on its merits. The idea that liberalizing the production and distribution of goods and services across national borders will automatically enrich everyone — instead of just the already wealthy in rich and poor countries alike — has had its critics on the left and the right for centuries; even President Obama was skeptical of NAFTA during his first Senate campaign and as late as the 2008 election he was telling audiences that it should be renegotiated. When Trump criticizes Amazon for its monopolistic practices, don’t turn it into a tedious finger-wagging exercise in fact-checking (and if you work for a newspaper owned by its founder and CEO, maybe avoid saying anything if you don’t have to); subject the company to the same scrutinty you would reserve for any other giant corporation that treats America’s cities as its fiefdoms and her people as its grateful serfs.

which you might recognize as the approach I’ve been taking here, which some have characterized as “sticking your head in the sand”.

I would say rather that Trump has a floor of approval of around 38% and a ceiling right around where he is now—42%. IMO that’s enough to shield him from impeachment by Republicans but not enough to inoculate him against a continuing onslaught of attacks.

I wouldn’t hold my breath waiting for the journalistic profession to reform itself. They think what they’re doing is working. Look at MSNBC’s ratings!

6 comments

The Intellectual Center of Gravity

In a piece at Bloomberg View Tyler Cowen makes several intriguing observations. First, that New York is now intellectually and politically irrelevant:

My biggest takeaway from the get-together was that today’s America has two fundamental and really quite different cultural and intellectual centers: Washington and its environs, and the Bay Area (including Silicon Valley, San Francisco and, if I may cheat a little, Seattle).

and second that the tech corridor running from San Jose through Seattle is doomed:

To date, these two new cultural and intellectual centers have proceeded on largely separate tracks, each with its own strengths and weaknesses, ignoring each other as much as possible. For the most part, it has been a good bargain, giving the nation the advantage of two distinct ways of thinking, without them stepping on each other’s toes too much.

But that won’t be the case going forward. The law-making and regulatory state will expand to cover more of tech, and tech has scaled so effectively that its products — such as autonomous cars or the possible ability to influence elections — are running into more legal and political issues.

I hope that neither observation is correct.

I would draw a different conclusion than he and it’s one that I have proposed several times here: what is subsidized prosper; what isn’t subsidized languishes. Silicon Valley rests on a foundation of defense contracts and it has been built, brick by brick, with subsidies including patents, government grants, and exemptions from tax and/or regulation.

0 comments

Observations on Immigration

More or less at random:

  1. The American Colossus is not, in fact, part of the U. S. Constitution. It’s aspirational not binding.
  2. Today’s immigrants, eligible or not, receive many more benefits than they would have received in 1883. Conditions have really changed in 135 years.
  3. My ancestors came here legally. They weren’t “poor and huddled masses”. They were mostly fleeing their debts. Within less than a generation they spoke English exclusively including at home.
  4. Very few migrants from Central America to the United States are refugees. They cease being refugees when they leave Mexico and become economic migrants.
  5. The unemployment rate for black youth on the South Side of Chicago is over 80%. I’m more concerned about them than I am about economic migrants.
9 comments

What Should Our Trade Policy Be?

In many ways identifying the correct trade policy for the United States is more difficult than nailing down a good immigration policy. For the last 40 years we’ve been highly focused on negotiating multi-lateral trade agreements, advertised as “free trade” but which really benefit service businesses, media and pharmaceutical companies, and retail at the expense of mining and manufacturing.

I’m in favor of free trade and think we should have it with any country willing to open their own trade up to us completely. Since genuinely free trade would require us to abandon all sorts of policies on which well-to-do people depend for their incomes, I predict that would receive almost no support.

I don’t think that businesses owned by foreign governments should be allowed to do business in the United States. I don’t think that we should import goods from those businesses at all. I think that our general policy on trade should be oriented towards reciprocity rather than on imagined free trade. We should abandon our myriad of subsidies and we should impose tariffs on imports from other countries to the degree that they subsidize those export goods. If countries impose quotas on what they’ll import from us, we should impose corresponding quotas.

I’m also tempted to think that we should impose tariffs on goods from other countries in the amount of what those countries would have spent if they had the same safety, environmental, and labor regulations we do.

What should our trade policy be?

13 comments