The Godfather of Trade

In an article in Maclean’s that some will find impenetrably counter-intuitive, Raoul Leering explains why Trump’s tariffs may be his making an offer to our trading partners that they cannot refuse:

Trade partners such as Canada, Mexico, but also China, depend much more on American demand for their products than the other way around. U.S. demand for Mexican and Chinese products contributes respectively twenty and five times as much to their GDP as their demand for U.S. products adds to U.S. GDP. Also, Canada has much more to lose in a bilateral trade war with the U.S. than the Americans.

China seems to blow up Trump’s strategy to blackmail U.S. trade partners into granting the U.S. more favourable conditions of trade so he can avoid a real trade war but get something done at the same time. The Chinese have drawn up their own list of products to incur tariffs in retaliation to the US$50bn tax that Trump will levy on Chinese goods as punishment for alleged theft of intellectual property and limits on foreign investments.

But, it is no coincidence that the Chinese have not yet set the date when these new tariffs will become effective. This means they still see room for extending the current negotiations. Given the relatively large dependency of the Chinese economy on American demand, it is likely that China will, in the end, cut its losses and be willing to give Trump something.

That Trump might be canny enough to pull off such a ploy would, presumably, shatter the worldview of some. That this article has been published in a Canadian periodical is probably not an accident. I honestly don’t care whether the tariffs are outrageous, dangerous, a blunder, wily, what you’d expect with a dollar that’s the global reserve currency, or whatever. I want to know what the U. S. economy and society will look like if we run a permanent trade deficit of a half trillion dollars that rises with GDP, whether that’s somewhere we want to go, and, if not, what we should do about it.

7 comments

The Mystery of the Marked Books

Here’s a fun story. It’s about how a librarian in Dundee, Scotland learned the code behind the many books that had been marked in her library. It’s from Atlas Obscura.

4 comments

Most Spoken Languages

I got 8 of the 10 most spoken languages in the world correct. I’m not surprised I didn’t get the other two. I knew in general what they were but not specifically what they were.

7 comments

Rising to the Challenge

For what may be the first time I am in complete agreement with Fareed Zakaria’s column in the Washington Post on the challenge posed by China’s mercantilist trade policy to the United States’s economy and people:

Many of the Trump administration’s economic documents have been laughably sketchy and amateurish. But the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative’s report to Congress on China’s compliance with global trading rules is an exception worth reading. In measured prose and great detail, it lays out the many ways that China has failed to enact promised economic reforms and backtracked on others, and uses formal and informal means to block foreign firms from competing in China’s market. It points out correctly that in recent years, the Chinese government has increased its intervention in the economy, particularly taking aim at foreign companies. All of this directly contradicts Beijing’s commitments when it joined the World Trade Organization in 2001.

Whether one accepts the trade representative’s conclusion that “the United States erred in supporting China’s entry into the WTO,” it is clear that the expectation that China would continue to liberalize its markets after its entry has proved to be mistaken.

China’s policies are worse than that. They are a threat to any rules-based system of international governance. They manifestly will not conform to the rules voluntarily and they are too big and powerful to be compelled to.

We can’t change China’s behavior but we can change our own and imposing a broad regime of tariffs on goods made in China is the beginning of that process. If you oppose such tariffs, I think you have an obligation to explain how the United States can maintain a robust and egalitarian economy and society solely on the basis of retail, banking, and health care because that’s the direction in which we are headed. I don’t believe we can; I think we need a much more diverse economy than that.

8 comments

Poisoning Politics

In an op-ed in the Washington Post William Galston handily sums up why populist movements are gaining force both here in the United States and in Europe:

The immigration issue is poisoning democratic politics, and not just in the United States. Purging this poison means resisting the urge to demonize the critics of current policies and instead searching for common ground that promotes the common good. While prejudice and hatred cannot be tolerated, liberals and progressives need to pay more attention to grievances — such as fears about economic and cultural displacement, the rule of law and loss of sovereignty — that should not be dismissed as pure bigotry.

Believing that you have a right to your own culture and that immigrants have an affirmative responsibility to adopt the cultures of their new home countries is not bigotry but painting it as such is. Emma Lazarus believed that immigrants had an affirmative responsibility to adopt the dress, customs, and language of their new homes, for goodness sake.

Societies have carrying capacities for being able to handle numbers of new immigrants peaceably and without undue disruption. We have very nearly reached ours.

Don’t be confused. The real poison in our politics is the wish by the powerful to replace their workforces or voters with more tractable and grateful ones.

0 comments

What Is Albright Warning Us About?

In an op-ed in the New York Times Madeleine Albright warns us that fascism is on the rise:

Today, we are in a new era, testing whether the democratic banner can remain aloft amid terrorism, sectarian conflicts, vulnerable borders, rogue social media and the cynical schemes of ambitious men. The answer is not self-evident. We may be encouraged that most people in most countries still want to live freely and in peace, but there is no ignoring the storm clouds that have gathered. In fact, fascism — and the tendencies that lead toward fascism — pose a more serious threat now than at any time since the end of World War II.

Warning signs include the relentless grab for more authority by governing parties in Hungary, the Philippines, Poland and Turkey — all United States allies. The raw anger that feeds fascism is evident across the Atlantic in the growth of nativist movements opposed to the idea of a united Europe, including in Germany, where the right-wing Alternative für Deutschland has emerged as the principal opposition party. The danger of despotism is on display in the Russia of Vladimir Putin — invader of Ukraine, meddler in foreign democracies, accused political assassin, brazen liar and proud son of the K.G.B. Putin has just been re-elected to a new six-year term, while in Venezuela, Nicolás Maduro, a ruthless ideologue, is poised to triumph in sham balloting next month. In China, Xi Jinping has persuaded a docile National People’s Congress to lift the constitutional limit on his tenure in power.

including in the United States:

At one time or another, Trump has attacked the judiciary, ridiculed the media, defended torture, condoned police brutality, urged supporters to rough up hecklers and — jokingly or not — equated mere policy disagreements with treason. He tried to undermine faith in America’s electoral process through a bogus advisory commission on voter integrity. He routinely vilifies federal law enforcement institutions. He libels immigrants and the countries from which they come. His words are so often at odds with the truth that they can appear ignorant, yet are in fact calculated to exacerbate religious, social and racial divisions. Overseas, rather than stand up to bullies, Mr. Trump appears to like bullies, and they are delighted to have him represent the American brand. If one were to draft a script chronicling fascism’s resurrection, the abdication of America’s moral leadership would make a credible first scene.

I’ve tried but I can’t figure out what she’s warning us about. IMO fascism including in the U. S. peaked in the 1960s but has been with us constantly since the end of World War II. Saddam Hussein’s Iraq and Assad, père et fils, exemplies it in Syria. They are both examples of Arab fascism. Mao in particular is an example from China; Putin rather obviously pursues Russian fascism. In other words it has never gone away.

Here’s the dictionary definition:

a political philosophy, movement, or regime (such as that of the Fascisti) that exalts nation and often race above the individual and that stands for a centralized autocratic government headed by a dictatorial leader, severe economic and social regimentation, and forcible suppression of opposition.

Every president of my lifetime has pursued increased presidential power; that alone is not a mark of fascism. Barack Obama attacked the judiciary, chafed at even the slightest criticism of him in the media, and quietly defended torturers. More of his diktats were struck down by unanimous decisions of the Supreme Court than any other president. I list these not to suggest that Barack Obama was a fascist but to point out that the pursuit of power and dislike of criticism are not sufficient evidence to support a case of rising fascism.

What’s missing from Trump’s approach to being president which would warrant concerns about U. S. fascism are severe economic and social regimentation and forcible suppression of opposition. I see few if any signs of either.

What I do see signs of is too great a willingness to label your political opponents fascists. Let’s leave the label for actual cases lest it come to mean merely “people we don’t like”.

7 comments

Deciding What’s Important

Last month Atlantic hired Kevin Williamson, a fiery former National Review writer, what passes these days for a conservative these days. I didn’t considerate it worthy of comment. I just wasn’t interested.

Yesterday Atlantic fired him, apparently for repeating ideas he’d put forward frequently in the past. Is that more interesting and why?

I think it may be. That Mr. Williamson has ideas outside the political mainstream and a harsh way of expressing them should have been no surprise to Atlantic’s editors. Due diligence would have revealed that quite readily. That they are unable to stand up to pressure from others whose views may too be outside the political mainstream but in another direction sounds noteworthy to me, especially for a publication that considers itself a “thought leader”.

I’m not particularly exercised about it either way. I mention it only because it may be a bellwether of political discourse in the U. S. today.

4 comments

Wrong-Headed

If I gave an award for the most naive article I read in a day, week, month, or year this one at RealClearDefense by Rathna K. Muralidharan, encouraging investment in infrastructure in Africa:

Washington should develop and modify programs to support FDI by American companies in Africa to build out infrastructure. These developments can be leveraged by U.S. federal organizations when carrying out security and aid missions. They would also benefit local communities trying to grow and expand their economies.

would have to be considered a strong contender.

I have no doubt that African countries need better infrastructure but that’s isn’t their gravest problem. Their most serious problems are corruption and bad government which go hand in hand. There isn’t enough money in the whole world to build useable infrastructure in Africa as long as every dollar that’s, er, invested goes to line somebody’s pocket.

12 comments

Nothing Succeeds Like Success

If the “Washington Consensus” had more successes, it would have a lot more credibility. Actually, any successes would be welcome. Consider this observation from Michael Gordon at RealClearWorld:

Most Middle Eastern and North African countries need financial assistance, massive infrastructure financing, or humanitarian aid, and the IMF has four active programs in Arab countries totaling billions of dollars. Far from making recourse to the IMF only during times of severe economic crisis, Arab capitals’ relationships with the IMF have evolved to near perpetual dependency. Jordan has had eight IMF programs since 1989, often with one program beginning as another concludes.[i] Egypt in November 2016 negotiated its fifth IMF program — a $12 billion facility. It is hard to imagine these countries freeing themselves from this cycle.

After decades of IMF financing, commitments to reform, and billions of dollars, what have these countries to show? Social indicators such as unemployment, poverty, and income inequality actually worsened in the majority of states that accepted IMF intervention through the 1980s and 1990s — even in those states that “religiously” followed IMF prescriptions.

Three years before Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak was ousted, the World Bank’s Doing Business report ranked Egypt as the world’s top economic reformer.[iii] Yet behind all the growth and capital inflows, average Egyptians saw little benefit from the economic reforms praised by outside observers and investors. Just across the Gulf of Aqaba, Jordan’s economy has fared little better: The official unemployment rate stands at 18 percent.[iv] A third of Jordan’s population lives below the poverty line, and after years of fiscal consolidation, the country’s debt-to-GDP ratio sits precariously at 95 percent.[v]

Years of “reform” have arguably not made these countries or their societies more resilient, and in fact might have contributed to an undermining of social safety nets. In fairness, many of the region’s social programs have long been fiscally unsustainable, but all Arab countries have had implicit social contracts since their independence whereby the state provided a baseline of social welfare, with benefits including health care, education, subsidized food and energy, and often a government job.

It’s hardly a wonder that more and more autocrats are looking to China for inspiration (and money) rather than Washington. There are so many differences between China and the MENA countries it’s hard to see how China can be a model. And as the natural resources on which so many of them depend dwindle China won’t find them nearly as interesting.

1 comment

Where Are the Circling Wagons?

Complaining about Big Business and “the rich” is a staple of American political discourse but politicians lambasting individual companies or rich individuals is much rarer. At Atlantic Ronald Brownstein compares Trump’s complaints about Amazon with Kennedy’s feud with U. S. Steel:

When Trump assailed Amazon and its founder, Jeff Bezos, taking “the stock price down by publicly singling out a company and its leader… relentlessly, and without a specific public-policy purpose, there is no precedent for that,” she said.

As Koehn noted, the closest comparison is probably the spring 1962 confrontation between John F. Kennedy and Roger Blough, the chairman of U.S. Steel. Blough infuriated Kennedy by announcing he would raise steel prices more than was recommended by Washington’s informal wage-and-price guidelines at the time. That announcement came immediately after the administration had pressured the United Steelworkers union to accept a leaner-than-usual contract.

Kennedy responded with a fierce public counterattack—which included a Justice Department investigation into alleged price fixing and threats to shift Defense Department steel procurement to companies that hadn’t raised prices. Within days Blough capitulated, reversing the increase.

He goes on to speculate on why the Chamber of Commerce hasn’t rallied ’round Amazon the way it did around U. S. Steel 65 years ago.

I think that one of the answers is that Amazon is actually two (or more) companies in one. It’s an IT services company that dominates its market and is making a lot of money conjoined with a retailer that’s losing a little money and the two in combination are practically the textbook definition of a company illegally using monopoly power. That’s not a good way to make a lot of friends.

5 comments