To the Marshal Foches of “Anti-Trumpism”

In his latest column at the New York Times David Brooks lurches uncontrollably to the conclusions I reached in November 2016:

We have persuaded no one. Trump’s approval rating is around 40 percent, which is basically unchanged from where it’s been all along.

We have not hindered him. Trump has more power than he did a year ago, not less. With more mainstream figures like H. R. McMaster, Rex Tillerson and Gary Cohn gone, the administration is growing more nationalist, not less.

We have not dislodged him. For all the hype, the Mueller investigation looks less and less likely to fundamentally alter the course of the administration.

We have not contained him. Trump’s takeover of the Republican Party is complete. Eighty-nine percent of Republicans now have a positive impression of the man. According to an NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll, 59 percent of Republicans consider themselves more a supporter of Trump than of the Republican Party.

as he acknowledges one of the viewpoint’s gravest flaws:

Part of the problem is that anti-Trumpism has a tendency to be insufferably condescending. For example, my colleague Thomas B. Edsall beautifully summarized the recent academic analyses of what personality traits supposedly determine Trump support.

Trump opponents, the academics say, are open-minded and value independence and novelty. Trump supporters, they continue, are closed-minded, change-averse and desperate for security.

This analysis strikes me as psychologically wrong (every human being requires both a secure base and an open field — we can’t be divided into opposing camps), journalistically wrong (Trump supporters voted for the man precisely because they wanted transformational change) and an epic attempt to offend 40 percent of our fellow citizens by reducing them to psychological inferiors.

What I think that Mr. Brooks is missing is the implication of our being reduced to tribalism. We have realized George Santayana’s definition of fanaticism. Let me offer another of Dr. Santayana’s famous remarks for reflection:

Progress, far from consisting in change, depends on retentiveness. When change is absolute there remains no being to improve and no direction is set for possible improvement: and when experience is not retained, as among savages, infancy is perpetual. Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.

Categorical rejection of 40% of the people is not a formula for republican government. You may get your way temporarily but any victory will be shortlived.

Imagining an unrealizable future is not one bit better than trying to recover an imaginary past. The same things are true in politics as in war. Amateurs talk about tactics. Professionals study logistics.

22 comments

What To Do About Facebook

In an op-ed in the New York Times academic Zeynep Tufekci wonders why the Congress wants to interview Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg at all, suggesting instead that the members of Congress do the unthinkable and actually enact legislation:

What would a genuine legislative remedy look like? First, personalized data collection would be allowed only through opt-in mechanisms that were clear, concise and transparent. There would be no more endless pages of legalese that nobody reads or can easily understand. The same would be true of any individualized targeting of users by companies or political campaigns — it should be clear, transparent and truly consensual.

Second, people would have access, if requested, to all the data a company has collected on them — including all forms of computational inference (how the company uses your data to make guesses about your tastes and preferences, your personal and medical history, your political allegiances and so forth).

Third, the use of any data collected would be limited to specifically enumerated purposes, for a designed period of time — and then would expire. The current model of harvesting all data, with virtually no limit on how it is used and for how long, must stop.

Fourth, the aggregate use of data should be regulated. Merely saying that individuals own their data isn’t enough: Companies can and will persuade people to part with their data in ways that may seem to make sense at the individual level but that work at the aggregate level to create public harms. For example, collecting health information from individuals in return for a small compensation might seem beneficial to both parties — but a company that holds health information on a billion people can end up posing a threat to individuals in ways they could not have foreseen.

While I think those measures would be a good start, I don’t think they go nearly far enough. In answer to the retort that such restrictions would destroy Facebook, I’d answer so what? Nobody has a right to a business model and particularly not to a business model of selling something you don’t own.

And, the preferences of anarcho-capitalists notwithstanding, there are some things you just cannot contract to do or, at least, for which binding contracts cannot be written. Sale of the data gathered about your online behavior might well be one of them.

However, let me assuage Dr. Tufekci’s concerns. The reason that Congress will be browbeating Mark Zuckerberg is not as a prelude to doing something about Facebook’s bad behavior but as an alternative to action. They will appear to be tough while actually being marshmallows.

3 comments

Please Wait…

I continue to be content to let the Mueller investigation work its way through.

8 comments

No Bids

I’ve mentioned it before but 10-20 RFPs for the State of Illinois come across my desk just about every day. By far the greatest number of these are not receiving responses: the vendors are no-bidding at an enormous rate. The reason for it is obvious: Illinois is a deadbeat. People need to get paid for their work.

At some point it’s going to become darned hard for the state to keep operating. This stuff is going to have implications for years or even decades to come.

2 comments

Who Checks the Checkers?

RealClearPolitics has leapt into the breach and is launching a review of fact checkers:

The RealClearPolitics Fact Check Review is an initiative to explore how the flagship fact-checking organizations operate in practice (as opposed to their self-reported descriptions), from their claim and verification sourcing to their topical focus to just what constitutes a “fact.” To answer these questions, we’ve created a centralized searchable database, updated weekly, that codifies key characteristics of all fact checks bearing on issues of civic and public concern published by six highly prominent fact-checking organizations: Factcheck.org, New York Times, Politifact, Snopes, Washington Post, and Weekly Standard. These fact checkers were selected due to their influence in the fact-checking landscape and the reliance of major internet platforms like Facebook on their decisions.

Each week we’ll review every fact check published the previous week on those six sites and compile a list of those that bear on civic and public concern, given their importance to the functioning of democracy. In practice, we define “civic and public concern” as any topic that relates to politics or American civil life. Issues involving past or present public officeholders or topics of national or international discussion are included under this heading, while run-of-the-mill urban legends are not. A fact check about how many votes a particular U.S. senator has missed would be included, but a fact check about reports of UFOs landing in Area 51 this week would not.

On the one hand that’s something that’s long overdue but on the other journalism covering journalism is beginning to sound like a low ebb to me.

3 comments

More Figleafs

Sophistry is always in generous supply but today we seem to have a bumper crop of it. I can only conclude that’s a result of the prosaic observation that if you subsidize something you get more of it. Robert Samuelson’s Washington Post contribution to the strategic sophistry supply is:

To those paying attention, the recent strikes for higher teachers’ pay in West Virginia and Oklahoma are a harbinger of things to come. You can attribute the strikes to the stinginess of the states’ political leaders. After all, average annual teachers’ salaries in these states ranked, respectively, 49th-lowest (Oklahoma at $45,276) and 48th-lowest (West Virginia, $45,622) in 2016, reports the National Education Association. But that’s the superficial explanation. The deeper cause is that teachers — and schools — are competing with the elderly for scarce funds.

Once again that is a half truth. A more complete truth is that present government workers are competing with retired government workers for funds. That’s an inevitable problem when the growth assumptions required to maintain the solvency of public employee pension funds are 7% or even 8% and actual growth is more like 2%.

The sad truth is that we are about 20 years late in reforming government pension plans.

Meanwhile, I think that the states that pay the lowest wages to teachers need to adjust themselves to the reality that they’ll need to pay more. Paying starting teachers the median wage might be a good start.

4 comments

The Coming Storm

I agree with the statements of a group of distinguished former chief advisors to Democratic presidents from their op-ed in the Washington Post:

A group of distinguished economists from the Hoover Institution, a public-policy think tank at Stanford University, identifies a serious problem. The federal budget deficit is on track to exceed $1 trillion next year and get worse over time. Eventually, ever-rising debt and deficits will cause interest rates to rise, and the portion of tax revenue needed to service the growing debt will take an increasing toll on the ability of government to provide for its citizens and to respond to recessions and emergencies.

None of that is in dispute. But the Hoover economists then go wrong by arguing that entitlements are the sole cause of the problem, while the budget-busting tax bill that was passed last year is described as a “good first step.”

Entitlement programs support older Americans and those with low incomes or disabilities. Program costs are growing largely because of the aging of the population. This demographic problem is faced by almost all advanced economies and cannot be solved by a vague call to cut “entitlements” — terminology that dehumanizes the value of these programs to millions of Americans.

[…]

Just as entitlements are not the primary cause of the recent jump in the deficit, they also should not be the sole solution. It is important to use the right wording: The main entitlement programs are Social Security, Medicare, veterans benefits and Medicaid. These widely popular programs are indeed large and projected to grow as a share of the economy, not because of increased generosity of benefits but because of the aging of the population and the increase in economywide health costs.

about the red ink as far as the eye can see in the federal budget. Up to a point.

This statement:

not because of increased generosity of benefits but because of the aging of the population and the increase in economywide health costs

is a figleaf. Social Security retirement income benefits have increased at a rate at or below the rate of inflation for years. We have known about the increase in the number of recipients that is now occurring for seventy years and done nothing about it.

The reasons for our increasing debt are growth inadequate to match our desire to spend and health care spending full stop. Not an aging population. Not too low a tax rate. There is no level of taxation that will fill in the gap created by health care spending that grows at a multiple of non-health care economic growth and incomes year after year.

I wish such a distinguished panel had weighed in with their formula for increasing economic growth beyond its present inadequate level. I would be particularly interested in how they see growth increasing solely on the basis of retail and health care. The Republicans have expressed their opinion in the form of legislation. Time will tell whether they’re right.

8 comments

Dirty Tricks Squad

One of the Chicago Sun-Times’s frontpage stories today is about the Chicago Public Schools’s fraudulent program to ensure that it passed cleanliness audits:

When parents, teachers or students have complained in recent years about dirty classrooms and lunchrooms, Chicago Public Schools officials have pointed to high “pass” rates found in audits by an independent firm that monitors the work of private companies overseeing the cleaning.

But following Chicago Sun-Times reports revealing that CPS staffers found filthy conditions at 91 of 125 schools they examined, janitors now tell the newspaper that supervisors cheated to pass those cleanliness audits.

Janitors at two Chicago schools say their bosses alerted them whenever the auditing company would be coming — sometimes several days ahead — and also tipped them about where to clean.

That allowed them to focus on areas they knew the auditors would check — and skip other parts of the schools that wouldn’t face inspection, the school janitors say.

Also, extra help would be provided in the form of “floater” custodians and additional cleaning supplies, they say.

This story is:

  1. An example of typical Chicago corruption.
  2. An example of public employees’ union dirty tricks (CPS’s janitorial services were privatized in 2014).
  3. Battlespace preparation for the next mayoral election.
  4. A “dog bites man” story.
  5. All of the above.
  6. Other.
1 comment

Is World War I Forgotten?

At Guardian David Smith wonders why World War I is forgotten in the United States:

t redefined women’s rights, race relations, civil liberties and America’s role in the world. It caused twice as many American deaths as the Vietnam war. But there is no national memorial to it in Washington DC and, on Thursday, its centenary will pass with little fanfare.

On 6 April 1917, America declared war on Germany and charged into the first world war. After nearly three years of reluctance, its hand was forced by the sinking of neutral US ships by German submarines, and by Britain’s interception of the so-called Zimmerman telegram revealing a German plot to persuade Mexico to wage war on the US.

America mustered more than 4.7 million service members with astonishing speed and suffered 53,402 battle deaths and 63,114 other deaths in service, many from Spanish flu. America’s involvement was crucial to the Germans’ defeat in 1918, profoundly shaping what came to be known as “the American century”. Yet in contrast to the extensive centenary commemorations in Britain three years ago – a memorial at the Tower of London featured 888,246 red poppies to represent each soldier who died – this has for many Americans become a forgotten war.

You probably don’t know that the U. S. had an expeditionary force in Russia following the First World War, that German-Americans were treated worse during the war than Japanese-Americans were treated during World War II, or about the Black Tom explosion when German saboteurs detonated explosives being sent to Britain and France by the notionally neutral United States.

I think there are a number of reasons. Americans despise history. You can hardly find a Briton whose great-grandfather or great-great-uncle didn’t die in the war. Most of us don’t have ancestors or even collateral family members who fought in the war. I also think that many Americans deep down recognize that we should never have entered World War I.

14 comments

Not a Liberal Democrat

I have now read two articles, one at Vox.com and one at Time, that promote the same view I have—that Saudi Arabia’s heir apparent is no liberal democrat and no friend of ours or, indeed, of a benign, peaceful world. I expect that will become increasingly apparent in the fullness of time and these two are just the first of many.

A few minor and, ultimately, meaningless gestures in liberalizing the Kingdom’s repressive policies don’t make up for prosecuting a needless war against Yemen or KSA’s continuing financing of imams all over the world who preach their reactionary form of Islam and in many cases violent jihad.

If a charm offensive and letting women drive is all it takes to get good press in the U. S., they’re a pretty small price to pay. I’d rather see some real, material policy changes.

The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s problems weren’t caused by Iran and they won’t be solved by turning the clock back to 1979. It has serious economic and social problems and they won’t be solved so easily.

0 comments