Is Fragility Obama’s Lasting Legacy?

In an article at Brookings Elaine Kamarck points out how brittle Barack Obama’s legacy is:

It becomes clearer every day that Barack Obama, a historic president, presided over a somewhat less than historic presidency. With only one major legislative achievement (Obamacare)—and a fragile one at that—the legacy of Obama’s presidency mainly rests on its tremendous symbolic importance and the fate of a patchwork of executive actions.

How much of that was due to fate and how much was due to Obama’s own shortcomings as a politician is up for debate and is a question that emerges from Princeton historian Julian Zelizer’s new edited volume, The Presidency of Barack Obama.

With contributions from seventeen historians, the book bills itself as “a first historical assessment” of the Obama presidency. The overwhelming consensus, Zelizer writes, is that Obama “turned out to be a very effective policymaker but not a tremendously successful party builder.” This “defining paradox of Obama’s presidency” comes up again and again: the historians, by and large, approve of Obama’s policies (although some find them too timid) while they lament his politics.

Government-by-presidential-edict is specifically Cass Sunstein’s contribution to American politics. He championed it before Obama’s presidency and again once Obama took office.

Our system was intentionally constructed to have a strong Congress and a weak presidency. Although ruling by executive order may provide a temporary solution to a problem, it’s only good until the next presidency or until exigent circumstances makes the president change his or her mind.

Don’t imagine that permanent single party rule will change that. There is no such thing as a permanent majority, not by a party and certainly not by a faction of a party.

These executive orders don’t work to the advantage of the American people and they don’t work to the advantage of the president. They allow the Congress to avoid doing what they were hired to do: make commitments. By avoiding commitments they avoid accountability and, consequently, blame.

I don’t know how this situation can be rectified—any solution requires the acquiescence of Congress and the incumbents like the status quo just fine.

3 comments

Unconcerned

I’m not particularly concerned that Paul Ryan will not be seeking re-election. I’m not particularly concerned that the lack of an incumbent may mean that his district is represented by a Democrat in the next Congress. It doesn’t particularly concern me that the Democrats may take the majority in the House or both the House and the Senate. It does concern me a little that Nancy Pelosi will probably become Speaker of a newly Democratic House. I thought she was a terrible Speaker but, then, I think that Ryan has been a pretty terrible Speaker, too.

What should concern Democrats is that the people who are happiest about Ryan’s announcement are those who are strongly pro-Trump. Also, don’t be surprised if the people who are most disappointed by a Democratic Congress are those in the Sanders wing of the party.

2 comments

Observation About Entertainers

In my opinion and based on years of observation going back to childhood, I think that people without manic phases are at a competitive disadvantage with people who do have such phases when it comes to the field of entertainment. Under the circumstances we shouldn’t be surprised that there are a lot of bipolar entertainers.

10 comments

End Game

At RealClearDefense Willis Krumholz asks two very good questions:

  • What is the scope of the Global War on Terror?
  • Why are we supporting Saudi Arabia’s war on Yemen?

I wish he had addressed the question posed in the title, “How Does the Global War on Terror End?​”, but those two are good question. I can only presume that the question of the title is rhetorical. It never ends. Or it ends when we end the conditions that make it possible. Or it ends when the radical Islamists win.

5 comments

The Cause of the Long-Term Deficit

Writing at Economics 21 Brian Riedl takes another stab at explaining why entitlements (and primarily Medicare) are the cause of our long-term budget deficit. Read it and make your own decision.

I’m still trying to find someone’s, anyone’s explanation of how health care spending can grow at a multiple of incomes without either a) forcing an unending series of tax increases, something that’s obviously politically impossible or b) requiring us to spend more than we take in.

5 comments

What Are Our Goals in Syria?

Blog posts come about in a number of different ways but in many cases they’re responses or reactions to a single sentence. At any rate that’s true of this post and the sentence is from a comment to Doug Mataconis’s post on our options in Syria which quoted Kevin Drum:

I don’t want to pretend that Obama’s approach to Syria was a model of foreign policy precision, but in the end he did the right thing: nothing.

That is untrue. Doing nothing would have been better than what the Obama Administration actually did. What they did was arm Al Qaeda, prolonging the Syrian civil war which resulted in more Syrians being killed than might otherwise have been the case. It also drew Russia and Iran farther in.

What are our objectives in Syria? Here are some possibilities:

  1. Remove Assad.
  2. Remove Assad’s regime.
  3. Impede or reduce Russia’s and Iran’s gaining of influence in the region.
  4. A liberal democratic government friendly to the U. S. in Syria.
  5. Stay out of it.

A decision tree would be a better approach to this but I don’t have the energy, time, or ambition to create one. Let’s start with #4. I suggest prayer. It would be at least as effective as what we actually did and have many advantages over what we actually did including costing less.

We could have realized objective #5 by actually doing nothing. We didn’t do that so, clearly, that wasn’t our objective or, at least, it wasn’t our sole objective.

The only way we could have accomplished #2 was by a full-fledged invasion-of-Iraq style campaign. If we had actually accomplished it, the outcome would have been a violent Islamist Sunni Arab regime replacing the Alawite regime and the subsequent genocide of Alawites. It would also have risked a direct great power confrontation and possible nuclear exchange. I genuinely hope that isn’t our objective.

Short of that campaign we might have accomplished #1 by helping the Syrian government to put down the civil war. At least we would have had a seat at the table which is more than we have now.

What we did accomplished the opposite of #3. Is there some politically possible way we could have accomplished it? I don’t see it. Somehow we never seem to learn. Don’t expect our military to accomplish something that can’t be accomplished at all.

7 comments

Facebook Fallout

When I was a child, I spake as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child: but when I became a man, I put away childish things.

Here’s Christine Emba’s take from the Washington Post on Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s testimony before Congress:

Facebook may tout itself as an idealistic operation, connecting humans across the globe for the greater good, but its business model is based on monetizing as much personal data as possible. In essence, the company has ushered in a new era of what is essentially personal surveillance for profit. Facebook may be making itself safer or more secure, but it hasn’t answered the question of whether we should continue to interact with it at all.

Mine is somewhat different. What I saw was tremendous immaturity, not just on Zuckerberg’s part but on the part of the Congressmen questioning him as well. I don’t think they’re alone.

Adulthood means taking responsibility. For your own conduct. For the results of your conduct. For paying your bills. For your support and your family’s. For your children. It used to be that you began taking responsibility when you were an adolescent, were an adult with adult responsibilities including marriage and children when you were 18, and by the time you were 25 were expected to be serious, grave, stable adults. No more.

Now adolescence is greatly prolonged, frequently into your 30s or even later, and that period is growing ever-longer. Some people never take responsibility.

Zuckerberg is a kid. He acts like a kid. He has the moral consciousness of a kid. And it’s not just him. Much of Trump’s behavior is most easily explained as the casual cruelty of adolescence as practiced by a 70 year old man.

And it’s not just us. The Europeans aren’t taking responsibility for their own defense—they’re relying on their Uncle Sugar. Or health care research, for that matter. Most of the world depends on American research, God help them. What passes for research here may be inadequate here but it’s miles beyond what’s being done in China, India, and nearly everywhere else.

I don’t know how we’ll survive as a country or, indeed, as a species without adults.

2 comments

Decreasing Returns in Research

A topic that shows up frequently in the comments here is a plea for more spending on research, sometimes framed as a lament, sometimes as a question. An article at Scientific American may provide an answer to the question. The reason we don’t spend more on research is that we’re getting decreasing returns:

The Session was inspired in part by research suggesting that scientific progress is stagnating. In “Are Ideas Getting Harder to Find?”, four economists claim that “a wide range of evidence from various industries, products, and firms show[s] that research effort is rising substantially while research productivity is declining sharply.” The economists are Nicholas Bloom, Charles Jones and Michael Webb of Stanford and John Van Reenen of MIT.

As an counter-intuitive example, they cite Moore’s Law, noting that the “number of researchers required today to achieve the famous doubling every two years of the density of computer chips is more than 18 times larger than the number required in the early 1970s.” The researchers found similar trends in research related to agriculture and medicine. More and more research on cancer and other illnesses has produced fewer and fewer lives saved.

As I’ve said before, we’ve picked the low-hanging fruit, indeed, we picked it a long time ago (the transistor is 70 years old). That doesn’t mean that there isn’t more to learn. It means that it will cost a lot more (note: the universe is not linear) and may not be worth it.

5 comments

Are We a Good Ally?

There’s an interesting discussion at The Cipher Brief over whether the U. S. is a good ally or not. IMO when you get outside the Anglosphere none of our notional allies has ever considered us a reliable ally.

0 comments

How To Tell the Birds from the Flowers

In an interesting essay at the Wall Street Journal Walter Russell Mead summarizes the present U. S. foreign policy situation:

Five distinct threats will compete for John Bolton’s attention as he settles into Henry Kissinger’s old digs: First, North Korea’s drive toward nuclear weapons that threaten the U.S. has reached a critical juncture. Second, China’s militarization of the South China Sea coincides with a crisis in U.S.-China trade relations. Third, Russia’s efforts to disrupt the Western alliance system and re-establish itself as a major power in the Middle East have progressed to the point that not even Donald Trump can ignore them. Fourth, Iran’s push to consolidate its gains in Syria and Lebanon has alarmed and provoked Israel and its once-hostile Arab neighbors. Fifth, Islamist terrorism continues to lurk in the shadows, threatening to emerge at any moment and force Western governments to respond.

As the White House considers these threats, its options are constrained. Seventeen years of indecisive war has left a polarized American public weary of global engagement. The midterm elections may yield a “blue wave” that forces the president into a defensive crouch to fend off investigations and perhaps even impeachment by a Democratic Congress. The press is deeply hostile to the Trump administration and unwilling to grant it the benefit of the doubt in foreign policy. Traditional alliances are strained: Europe and Asia worry that an “America First” administration is less valuable and reliable as a partner; Turkey, meanwhile, flirts with a revisionist confederation with Russia and Iran.

Compounding the challenge is that adversaries world-wide share an interest in keeping Uncle Sam off-balance. North Korea, China, Russia, Iran and the jihadists don’t operate on a single master plan, but this common interest leads to a kind of informal coordination. Crises may erupt at inconvenient times for the U.S. precisely because they are inconvenient times for the U.S.

I’m not sure those are actually our gravest foreign policy problems. I think that I would say that the most important issues are:

  • We’re waging too many wars of dubious national security value.
  • China’s persistent flouting of international rules.
  • Largescale migrations of populations from Central and South America, Africa, and Asia are producing social upheaval here, in Europe, and, increasingly, in Africa and South America.
  • The alliances we’ve sustained since the end of World War II are running out of gas. Turkey is no longer an ally. Is Germany our ally or our enemy? How about Israel?
  • The Middle East is entering a period of sharply declining economic fortunes.
  • We need to come to a modus vivendi with Russia.

I think that John Bolton is uniquely ill-suited to offer sound advice on those issues but maybe it’s just me.

2 comments