The Ordo of Coronation of Xi

Ryan Hass muses at Brookings about the meeting between Chinese President for Life Xi and North Korea’s Dear Respected:

Based on the extensive Chinese media coverage after the visit—as well as the overwhelmingly positive read-out in China’s official media—Chinese leaders appear to want to signal to a domestic and international audience that: 1) Beijing and Pyongyang each see it as in their interests to repair relations, 2) Beijing is determined to play a decisive role in any diplomatic process for dealing with the Korean Peninsula, and 3) Xi is the elder statesman in his relationship with Kim. Beijing seems to be trying to dispel any speculation that Trump and Kim could reach a grand bargain on their own about the future of the Korean Peninsula. The visit also served as a fresh reminder that Xi is unencumbered by emotion or sentimentality. In shaping China’s approach toward North Korea, Xi will not be swayed by charm or personal chemistry with Trump, nor will he be blinded by any personal feelings toward Kim.

I wonder that more Western commenters haven’t recognized the meeting for what it was: a vassal went to kiss the ring of his newly-crowned monarch.

Maybe something good will come of the incipient meetings between Kim Jong Un and Donald Trump. I’m holding to my own view, expressed here frequently. We shouldn’t be negotiating with North Korea at all over North Korea’s abandoning its nuclear and missile development programs. We should be negotiating with China.

One way of assessing whether my hypothesis is correct or not would be to see if a parade of foreign leaders, Asian, Western, and other, go to meet with President Xi over the next few weeks.

6 comments

An Embarrassment of Riches

At Slate Fred Kaplan considers who made the worst decision of the Iraq war? Read it and weep. There are so many bad decisions and bad decision-makers to choose from. I would start all the way back in 1990:

  • Expelling Saddam Hussein from Kuwait
  • Allowing him to remain in power
  • Installing troops in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
  • Maintaining the no-fly zone in Iraq
  • Invading Iraq in 2003.
  • De-Ba’athification
  • Disbanding the Iraqi military
  • Allowing the Iraqis to write their own constitution rather than imposing one on them
  • Withdrawing our troops from Iraq in 2011

and it doesn’t really stop there. And the decision-makers! They include all of the last four (five?) presidents and their advisors.

These bad decisions are like dominos. Each leads to the next. The only way to win is not to play.

If we had made decisions other than those we had made, we would be facing an entirely different set of problems than we do now. Would we better or worse off? I don’t know but thousand of Americans who are now dead would still be alive and we would have spent trillions less. Plus millions of Iraqis who have left Iraq would still be there. The dominos are still toppling…

6 comments

Return of the Mythical Philosopher-King

At RealClearPolicy Dennis Bullock asks why should we let the political parties draw the maps of legislative districts?

Neutral redistricting would render real benefits for the American people. The House would be more likely to function as intended, with representatives advocating for local interests and compromising when there is no consensus on issues of great national importance. Legislators’ incentives would be quite different: constituencies would be more mixed and partisan appeals less useful in campaigns; extreme ideas would lose much of their cachet because they wouldn’t be likely to win many elections; pragmatism would regain potency because constituencies would not be promised the moon; and legislative compromise would again become necessary for members to win reelection.

There’s a simple answer to the question: because there is no alternative. Whether the district boundaries are drawn by legislators, redistricting committees, judges, or algorithms, they will be political and will reflect the preferences, prejudices, and goals of their authors.

There still are no dispassionate, wise philosopher-kings. Whoever draws the boundaries will have political views and those views will inform how the boundaries are drawn. If drawing the boundaries of districts is consigned to algorithms (agree on the rules for an algorithm: I dare you), the boundaries drawn will reflect the assumptions and preferences of its designers and those will be political, too. If you really want to make our system fairer and more democratic, make the districts smaller. And for goodness sake reduce the stakes. Limit the reach of government.

1 comment

What Credibility?

I think that in his latest Washington Post column Fareed Zakaria drastically overstates U. S. credibility:

America has built up its credibility and political capital over the past century. The Trump administration is raiding that trust fund for short-term political advantage, in ways that will permanently deplete it.

Let me provide just a few examples so you get the idea of what I mean.

  • 70 year stalemate on the Korean peninsula. Increase or decrease U. S. credibility?
  • Losing the Vietnam war. Increase or decrease U. S. credibility?
  • Iran’s holding Americans hostage after the Iranian revolution. Increase or decrease U. S. credibility?
  • Expanding NATO after pledging not to. Increase or decrease U. S. credibility?
  • Overthrowing Qaddaffi after he gave up his nuclear weapons development program. Increase or decrease U. S. credibility?

and that’s just off the top of my head. We have very little credibility on the international stage. We have the power of the American economy and U. S. military might and the Powers-That-Be are working fulltime to undermine those.

11 comments

How to Do Cybersecurity

While I’m glad that Tad Mcgalliard is highlighting the cybersecurity of state and local governments in his op-ed in the New York Times, I don’t believe that if everything he proposes is adopted it will change much:

First, local leaders must create a culture of cybersecurity that imagines worst-case scenarios and explores a range of solutions to mitigate threats to the ecosystem of local government technology. This should involve prioritizing funding for cybersecurity, establishing stronger cybersecurity policies and training employees in cybersecurity protocols. Success will require collaboration with local elected officials, internet-technology and cybersecurity staff members, department managers and end users.

Cybersecurity is more than just the I.T. department’s problem. It must now also be a top priority along the entire chain of elected and appointed officials in and around local governments. Preventing and mitigating the effects of future attacks will require intergovernmental cooperation, because localities work together across state lines and collaborate with the federal government on crucial tasks like running elections, managing transportation and sharing intelligence.

In my view the federal, state, and local governments are peculiarly ill-suited to deal with cybersecurity. Here are some of the things that must happen to make government computers and networks secure.

We must change how budgeting is done, particularly with respect to government computers. The complete lifecycle must be taken into account. Cybersecurity should be considered in ordinary maintenance. It costs as much as it costs. If you can’t afford to be secure, you can’t afford to computerize.

We must reform the civil service. Present civil service regulations mean that there are no consequences for failure to put appropriate policies into place and no consequences for failing to adhere to the policies. Yes, private companies experience security breaches, too. I guarantee you that the Boeing employee who caused the recent security breach there will experience consequences.

Some substitute for the profit motive must be found that are applicable to governments to incentivize process improvement. Good intentions are not enough. As Napoleon observed, the two great motivators are the fear of loss and the hope of gain.

0 comments

The Stopped Clock

The problem with radicalism is that you attribute everything to whatever you’re radicalized with respect to. If you’re radicalized with respect to race, there’s a great temptation to attribute every setback to racial bigotry.

Sometimes you’re right and that reinforces your conviction.

0 comments

Number of Speakers and Language Complexity

English and Mandarin have a number of features in common. Both have simple grammars. Both have large numbers of native speakers. As it turns out those two things are related. From the Cornell Chronicle:

Languages have an intriguing paradox. Languages with lots of speakers, such as English and Mandarin, have large vocabularies with relatively simple grammar. Yet the opposite is also true: Languages with fewer speakers have fewer words but complex grammars.

Why does the size of a population of speakers have opposite effects on vocabulary and grammar?

Through computer simulations, a Cornell cognitive scientist and his colleagues have shown that ease of learning may explain the paradox. Their work suggests that language, and other aspects of culture, may become simpler as our world becomes more interconnected.

They have another feature in common: both are difficult to learn to read and write well but for different reasons. Mandarin’s orthography is difficult while English’s spelling is difficult.

The complexity of English spelling is easy to explain. English is highly syncretistic—it adopts words readily and (again like Mandarin) has a large number of homonyms. English dealt with that by having the variants spelled differently, signalling the words’ origins. Mandarin used different ideographs.

4 comments

Not Dead Yet

An article in the New York Times reports some interesting findings about the 2016 elections:

The Pew Research Center and the Center for American Progress have produced methodologically sophisticated surveys of the electorate that sharply contradict 2016 exit polls.

Perhaps most significant, a March 20 Pew Research Center public opinion survey found that 33 percent of Democratic voters and Democratic leaners are whites without college degrees. That’s substantially larger than the 26 percent of Democrats who are whites with college degrees — the group that many analysts had come to believe was the dominant constituency in the party.

According to Pew, this noncollege white 33 percent makes up a larger bloc of the party’s voters than the 28 percent made up of racial and ethnic minorities without degrees. It is also larger than the 12 percent of Democratic voters made up of racial and ethnic minorities with college degrees.

In sum, Pew’s more precise survey methods reveal that when Democrats are broken down by education, race and ethnicity, the white working class is the largest bloc of Democratic voters and substantially larger than the bloc of white college-educated Democratic voters.

or, in other words, the rich and well-to-do whites who run the Democratic Party have gotten ahead of themselves. In some future election it might be true that they can neglect or even belittle white working class voters, ignoring their interests, but today they do so at their peril. At least if they want to win elections.

0 comments

Sad News

I just learned that an acquaintance of mine was murdered last week in River North. Wrong place, wrong time. They think he might have been stabbed to death by a homeless person.

It’s all very sad.

3 comments

What’s Chicago’s Balance of Trade?

I was mostly amused by Karl Rove’s imagined meeting among the countries whose imports from the U. S. exceed their exports in the Wall Street Journal:

I recently received a dossier concerning an emergency meeting by some of America’s trading partners at the Illuminati headquarters in Venice. The document came to me by sources and methods of intelligence I’m not at liberty to share. But for the record, Fusion GPS and its agents played no role in procuring or preparing this dossier.

What united the 138 nations gathered in Venice? Each country imports more from the U.S. than it exports. Together they formed the international advisory group known as Countries Shafted by Bad Trade Deals with the U.S., or Cosbatdus. They were meeting to discuss how to respond to President Trump’s protectionist actions.

A representative from Hong Kong, which has the largest trade deficit with the U.S., led the meeting. His vice chairmen—from the United Kingdom, United Arab Emirates and Belgium, other large-deficit nations—assisted. The agenda and recommendations were prepared by the Cosbatdus executive committee. It consists of Australia, Chile, Egypt, Ethiopia, Honduras, Iceland, Mongolia, Morocco, the Netherlands and Vatican City—with all of which the U.S. has a trade surplus.

but I was brought up short there. The total exports, not net exports but exports mind you, of goods and services by the United States is around $2.3 trillion and imports are around $2.9 trillion. Exports are increasing but imports are increasing faster. I question the veracity of both of those figures for reasons I’ve explained before but that’s another subject. The total trade deficit was around $600 billion and $375 billion of that was with China alone.

Is Hong Kong part of China or not? Our total exports to Hong Kong are about $40 billion. If you subtract from our trade deficit with China, China still constitutes more than half of our total trade deficit. Germany and Japan account for another $130 billion in deficit.

Forget the teeny tiny amount of trade the U. S. has with Vatican City or Iceland. If you add up the entirety of our exports to the bottom two-thirds of those 138 countries, it probably doesn’t amount to .5% of our GDP.

But let’s not reckon our trade deficit by city. That way lies madness. We need policies for fixing our problems with the biggest offenders—China, Germany, and Japan.

0 comments