The editors of the Economist have a number of good remarks in their recent piece, the thesis of which is that the Democrats need some better ideas. So, for example:
Perhaps worse, considering the defining place it occupies in American debate, the Democrats failed to think critically about the issue that divides conservatives and progressives most, the role of government. Endlessly pushing publicly-funded solutions that Americans find unsatisfactory has made them the party of bad government.
and
“There’s still a feeling that if we just redistribute wealth, everything will be all right,†says Senator Mark Warner of Virginia.
Actually, I think there’s a chance it would help. However, I don’t think that redistributing wealth from the ultra-rich to the merely rich is nearly as benign as its exponents may claim and redistributing wealth among the members of the upper middle class does next to nothing. There is so much that needs to be done that doesn’t require the redistribution of income we might consider those things for a change. It tends to persuade one that redistribution is the end rather than the means to an end.
Or this:
The new ideas on offer mostly involved swelling the size of a government which the Republicans’ latest tax cut has made even more unaffordable than it was.
Here’s some food for thought:
Here are three reasons why fresh thinking is needed on the centre-left. First, moderate Democrats need better arguments to explain why the all-government solutions preached by Mr Sanders are not merely unaffordable but bad. There is otherwise a risk they will mistake seething anti-Trump resistance with a desire for Mr Sanders’s similarly fervent pitch.
Second, even if the Democrats could reclaim power with a divisive Sandernista agenda, they could not implement it. The reality is that neither party can bring big change without some support from the other. Hence, Barack Obama’s executive record has been easily shredded by the Republicans, and they now struggle to pass laws.
The third, overarching, reason is that the contempt voters feel for both parties is grounded in those failures. To mitigate their disdain will above all require much better government. The Democrats trying out presidential pitches all seem to want that: their shortcomings are not to be compared to Mr Trump’s cynicism and greed. Yet they are some way from suggesting the requisite turnaround in Washington is a realistic prospect.
In my view a key problem is that Democrats have conflated repeating the same ideas they’ve been flogging for the better part of the last century for new ideas. A key example is the $15 minimum wage. It’s obvious that too high a minimum wage just doesn’t take into account the economic differences among different parts of the country. Less obvious is that its run-on effects might overwhelm its intended effects. If a $15 minimum wage in Seattle increases homelessness, is it really having the intended effect?
My view continues to be that we don’t need less government or more government, higher taxes or lower taxes, but different government and different taxes. The national debate needs to be less like a football game. No matter how long you play the distance between the yardlines remains the same.