What Happens in Venezuela?

The year-on-year inflation rate in Venezuela is anticipated to be around 2,300% in 2018. Shortages of basic staples are worsening. Its oil industry, responsible for nearly all foreign exchange, is collapsing. The opposition is boycotting the upcoming presidential election.

What happens in Venezuela? How long will the Maduro government be able to hold out? What’s the end game there? How will it affect Venezuela’s neighbors?

2 comments

The Paving Material

Sometimes I don’t know whether to laugh or to cry. This story in the Sun-Times exemplifies everything that’s wrong with Chicago, its Mayor Rahm Emanuel, and the Chicago Democratic Party:

A housing-assistance program that Mayor Rahm Emanuel set up two years ago to help people with “low to moderate incomes” buy homes has frequently ended up financing pricey homes in expensive neighborhoods, a Chicago Sun-Times investigation has found.

So far, 218 households have received a total of more than $1.6 million under the program run by the Chicago Infrastructure Trust, the not-for-profit that Emanuel created to finance public improvement projects.

The median value of a house in the city of Chicago is around $230,000. An astonishing number of the houses purchased under the program were bought for considerably more, in some cases a multiple of the median value:

• The program’s largest grant — $25,020 — went to a single man who owns a T-shirt company to help him buy a $500,000 bungalow one block from Wrigley Field.

• Another single businessman got a $16,490 grant to help him buy a $340,000 “garden” condo in Lincoln Park.

• A Chicago cop got $21,137 toward the cost of a new, $445,000 home on the Northwest Side.

• Another police officer got $13,353 toward a $340,000 home on the Northwest Side. He got the grant one day after he sold a nearby home for $277,000.

• A $6,480 grant went to a couple who appear to work for one of the mortgage companies that approve loans and grants for many of the home-buyers in the mayor’s housing-aid program. They used the money to buy a $187,000 home on the Far South Side.

Perhaps it’s just my defective hearing but when I hear cases like that it makes me wonder if the proceeds of the program aren’t going to benefit the politically connected rather than “those of low to moderate incomes”. To qualify for the program requires a household income of $131,000 per year or less. $131,000 is in the top decile of household incomes in Chicago. There’s nothing low or moderate about it.

1 comment

The Changing White Majority

It’s gratifying for me to see someone pointing out what I’ve been remarking on for years. The demise of the U. S.’s white majority is greatly exaggerated. Here’s a snippet of a Washington Post op-ed by USC scholars Dowell Myers and Morris Levy:

It was 2000 when the Census Bureau first projected an end to the white majority of the population in 2059. Four years later, it revised that date to 2050. Then in 2008, it told the public that the passing of the white majority would occur in 2042. At this abrupt rate of change, some anxious whites might see displacement as an imminent threat.

In fact, the Census Bureau projects no fewer than six futures for the white population based on various definitions of whiteness. The most touted set of projections adopts the most exclusive definition, restricting the white population to those who self-identify as white and also no other race or ethnicity. Under this definition, whites are indeed in numerical decline.

But this doesn’t reflect the increasingly fluid and inclusive way that many Americans now regard racial and ethnic backgrounds. Mixed-race parentage is growing more common, and a rapidly growing number of people choose more than one racial or ethnic category to describe themselves on the census.

For example, Meghan Markle — American actress and new member of the British royal family — has a white father and black mother, so she identifies as someone from both races. Under the older, exclusive definition of race — resembling the historical “one-drop” rule — Markle and her children can never be classified as white. Same goes for the offspring of Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Tex.) and former Florida Republican governor Jeb Bush.

Under a more expansive definition that counts as white anyone who so identifies (even if they also identify with another race or ethnicity), the white population is not declining; it’s flourishing. The Census Bureau’s inclusive projections show a white population in excess of 70 percent of the total for the foreseeable future.

By the standards of the 1830s the U. S. stopped having a white majority a century ago. I would not have been considered white by virtue of my Irish ancestry; my wife would not have been considered white by virtue of her Irish and Arbëreshë (Albanese) ancestry. And yet, somehow, today our whiteness is only occasionally questioned and that only because we’re Catholics.

My closest blood relatives other than my siblings and their children are my mother’s first cousins, Hispanic by virtue of their Mexican mother. I have never thought of them as anything other than white. Indeed, the number of Hispanics who consider themselves white will probably be alarming to those who favor a “majority minority” America.

There are two groups clinging bitterly to the “one drop” rule: the political far right and the political far left. Their rationales may be different but both seek to divide us rather than unite us.

3 comments

Hubbard’s Naïveté

What astonished me in the interview with Glenn Hubbard in the Wall Street Journal was how naïve he is. Take this passage, for example:

China, for example, “is not following the rule of law in intellectual-property protection. I don’t think there’s any question about that.” But he says there are ways to “get at that multilaterally, that don’t involve this kind of bilateral trade-bashing that the president has done.”

That’s naïve on all sorts of counts. First, there is no way for us to “get at that multilaterally”. What the Chinese are doing is working for them. We have no practical way of imposing our will on China.

But worse China does not have a robust system of civil law. There’s no way for a U. S. individual or company to seek redress through the courts there. They’ve got to take whatever the Chinese dish out and like it. That a company might agree to transfer their intellectual property to their Chinese partner in exchange for access to the Chinese market might help the company a bit. I doubt it will. But it does nothing for the rest of the United States. The U. S. is bearing the cost of development and the Chinese are reaping the benefits.

But I think that this is about right:

He invokes the Scottish Enlightenment, whose thinkers were “all very inclusive in their definition of what success is. It wasn’t just average measures of output. It was broad inclusion and prosperity.” The point is that modern economists need to talk in these terms, too. “One reason we lost some of the policy arguments in recent years—arguments that we shouldn’t have lost—is because we pointed out that policy X or Y would raise GDP on average by some amount,” Mr. Hubbard says. “It wasn’t that we were wrong, necessarily, but ‘average’ isn’t terribly useful.”

How much do we really care if Jeff Bezos gains another trillion of net worth while income and wealth for the median family doesn’t change at all? That’s where I think that Mr. Hubbard and economists have a major problem. In conditions of great income inequality it is quite possible for GDP to decrease but for median income to increase or at least remain the same.

As I’ve said before our present situation is not just of the haves and have-nots but of the protected and the unprotected. The protected, naturally enough, argue vehemently for continuing their gravy train.

1 comment

In a Grocery Store

Me to the checkout clerk: “A blessed Ramadan to you.”

The clerk, breaking into the most beatific smile imaginable: “I fasted today!”

1 comment

The Party of Ideas?

The editors of the Economist have a number of good remarks in their recent piece, the thesis of which is that the Democrats need some better ideas. So, for example:

Perhaps worse, considering the defining place it occupies in American debate, the Democrats failed to think critically about the issue that divides conservatives and progressives most, the role of government. Endlessly pushing publicly-funded solutions that Americans find unsatisfactory has made them the party of bad government.

and

“There’s still a feeling that if we just redistribute wealth, everything will be all right,” says Senator Mark Warner of Virginia.

Actually, I think there’s a chance it would help. However, I don’t think that redistributing wealth from the ultra-rich to the merely rich is nearly as benign as its exponents may claim and redistributing wealth among the members of the upper middle class does next to nothing. There is so much that needs to be done that doesn’t require the redistribution of income we might consider those things for a change. It tends to persuade one that redistribution is the end rather than the means to an end.

Or this:

The new ideas on offer mostly involved swelling the size of a government which the Republicans’ latest tax cut has made even more unaffordable than it was.

Here’s some food for thought:

Here are three reasons why fresh thinking is needed on the centre-left. First, moderate Democrats need better arguments to explain why the all-government solutions preached by Mr Sanders are not merely unaffordable but bad. There is otherwise a risk they will mistake seething anti-Trump resistance with a desire for Mr Sanders’s similarly fervent pitch.

Second, even if the Democrats could reclaim power with a divisive Sandernista agenda, they could not implement it. The reality is that neither party can bring big change without some support from the other. Hence, Barack Obama’s executive record has been easily shredded by the Republicans, and they now struggle to pass laws.

The third, overarching, reason is that the contempt voters feel for both parties is grounded in those failures. To mitigate their disdain will above all require much better government. The Democrats trying out presidential pitches all seem to want that: their shortcomings are not to be compared to Mr Trump’s cynicism and greed. Yet they are some way from suggesting the requisite turnaround in Washington is a realistic prospect.

In my view a key problem is that Democrats have conflated repeating the same ideas they’ve been flogging for the better part of the last century for new ideas. A key example is the $15 minimum wage. It’s obvious that too high a minimum wage just doesn’t take into account the economic differences among different parts of the country. Less obvious is that its run-on effects might overwhelm its intended effects. If a $15 minimum wage in Seattle increases homelessness, is it really having the intended effect?

My view continues to be that we don’t need less government or more government, higher taxes or lower taxes, but different government and different taxes. The national debate needs to be less like a football game. No matter how long you play the distance between the yardlines remains the same.

10 comments

Disclaimer

Among the hazards of growing up in a town that at least used to be somewhat French in its views is a tendency towards republicanism. Having such views I have less than no interest in the goings-on of British royalty. I have less than no interest in the upcoming wedding of Prince Henry of Wales to his American girlfriend. I will do my best to avoid watching the wedding.

That view is not shared in our household. My wife plans to watch the wedding.

1 comment

Uneasy Lies the Head

This must be my Jared Bernstein week. Today he has a really good op-ed at the Washington Post on dollar’s status as the preferred international currency of exchange:

The privileges of the reserve issuer have been twofold. First, they allowed us to run large, persistent trade deficits. This is partly a function of international accounting: When other nations buy dollars, our capital account (capital inflows from abroad) goes up, and our current account (trade deficit) goes down (it gets more negative). In fact, since the mid-1970s, countries have lent us whatever we need to consume more than we produce, meaning we have run trade deficits every year. (For the most recent quarter, the trade deficit was over $600 billion, or 3 percent of GDP.)

Of course, if you’re thinking that four decades of trade deficits are a mixed blessing/privilege, I’m with you, but more on that in a moment.

Second, being the premier reserve issuer means that other countries are happy to buy your debt — corporate, public and private. Moreover, assets in the reserve currency carry an inherent premium in international finance, which means we don’t have to pay creditors as much for their loans as we otherwise would, i.e., the reserve issuer has lower interest rates.

But both privileges carry costs. Inward capital flows strengthen the dollar, which makes our exports more expensive and our imports cheaper. As international trade expert Joe Gagnon wrote a few years ago, other countries “send capital abroad to push down the values of their currencies in order to boost exports and economic growth. Official purchases of foreign exchange reserves and other foreign assets — mainly U.S. dollars — have exploded since 2000 to unprecedented levels as a share of global GDP.”

Notice how this ties in with my earlier post today. People whose livelihoods depended on making things and weren’t protected lost their livelihoods. Those who were protected, mostly those who performed services, have flourished.

Here’s another important passage:

In other words, this is no morality tale of profligate Americans compared to thrifty Chinese or Germans. If trade-surplus countries suppress their own consumption and use their excess savings to accumulate dollars, trade-deficit countries must absorb those excess savings to finance their excess consumption or investment. The dollar’s reserve status is a key factor behind these dynamics.

That applies equally to the trade deficits among the states that make up the United States. New Yorkers complaining about Mississippians receiving more per capita from the federal purse have the wrong end of the stick. It’s the price they pay for their own high incomes and the states being on the same currency. The surpluses and the deficits have to balance out.

2 comments

Coming to Terms

Sheesh. How many of the people who insist that we come to terms with the past refuse to come to terms with the present?

5 comments

Mud-Wrestling

On the anniversary of the Mueller investigation, does anyone care to summarize its results to date? I think it’s kind of like the old wisecrack about mud-wrestling with a pig—you get dirty and the pig likes it. Will its most lasting impact be to reduce confidence in government?

As has been the case since its beginning, I’m content to let it run its course. I also think that everything it finds that’s prosecutable should be prosecuted regardless of whose ox gets gored.

3 comments