This morning I identified two additional newspaper endorsements, one of them for Obama, the other for Romney. That makes the total count 39 newspapers and magazines that have endorsed Barack Obama for president, 44 45 that have endorsed Mitt Romney.
Update
Thanks to Icepick for finding the endorsement of Romney by the Detroit News, a self-described “conservative paper”. I have been unable to determine who, if anyone, the News endorsed in 2008.
Something that’s important to keep in mind is that in 2008 495 newspapers and other publications endorsed Obama while 215 endorsed McCain, more than 2 to 1. The crossovers, i.e. switches in party endorsement relative to the previous election cycle, was 6 to 1 in favor of Obama. This will be a very different election.
I thought it was just my imagination, that the Left Blogosphere had become distressingly dull and dry. Apparently not:
But with another critical election two weeks away, politicians, political operatives, and even the bloggers themselves say the Netroots are a whisper of what they were only four years ago, a dial-up modem in a high-speed world, and that the brigade of laptop-wielding revolutionaries who stormed the convention castle four years ago have all but disappeared as a force within the Democratic Party.
I am a centrist and a moderate. I don’t identify either with the Right or the Left. Indeed, my eyes start to glaze over when I read the words “the Right” or “the Left”. And I vastly prefer a tempered, controlled level of discourse. I think such control promotes discourse where vitriol discourages it.
I do find it sad that the Left Blogosphere has fallen from its heights. I’m even sadder than there’s so little interaction between the two biggest corners of the American political blogosphere. Echo chambers are maddening whatever they’re echoing.
In my view there are a number of reasons for this that go unmentioned in the cited post, a collection of remembrances and interviews. I think these things are interrelated.
First, both political parties are dominated by technocrats and professional organizers. They have been, are, and always will be. Recent Harvard grad who hews to the party line, won’t pee on the carpet, and do what he’s told? Have or can raise money? Welcome, friend! Otherwise, fuggedaboutit. There isn’t much room for mavericks or, at least, mavericks without money.
And, as I’ve complained before, a lot of those in the Left Blogosphere really sound as though they’re angling for a job, presumably as a media consultant for a Democratic campaign or administration somewhere. There aren’t nearly as many of those jobs available as there are Left Blogosphere bloggers who want them.
Second, sadly, a lot of the Left Blogosphere bloggers of those olden days were sold a bill of goods. The people they put their support behind are narcissists who don’t give a darn about improving things, good or honest government, or much of anything else except getting elected to office and raising money to get elected to office.
They shouldn’t feel so all alone. The Right Blogosphere bloggers of today will be disappointed, too, because the people they put their support behind are narcissists who don’t give a darn about improving things, good or honest government, or much of anything else except getting elected to office and raising money to get elected to office.
Third, a lot of the discontent that was out there was just plain anti-Bush. No Bush, no urgency. Yes, there are a few True Believers out there. Glenn Greenwald comes to mind. I doff my figurative hat to him. I don’t really have a hat head.
The big journalism story of the day isn’t the endorsements in the presidential election that continue to come in but this editorial by Rick Green of the Des Moines Register. In assessing whom the Register would endorse for president the editors asked both the president and Gov. Romney to meet face to face with them. Gov. Romney did; the president made time for a phone conversation. The prerequisite the president made for the conversation was that the conversation be off the record. Here are some of Mr. Green’s comments on the conversation and the terms:
Romney appeared before our board Oct. 9. We literally met in a barn on a family farm owned by Jeff Koch, just west of Van Meter.
We had a wide-ranging conversation in a little under an hour of access. He squeezed us in just before a campaign stop that spotlighted his agriculture policies. With the exception of one final question (“Why have you earned the Des Moines Register’s endorsement?â€) his camp said the interview could not be videotaped, which has become our typical practice with politicians meeting our editorial board. But the audio was digitally recorded and posted on DesMoinesRegister.com.
We repeatedly –- and politely — have asked Obama 2012 campaign officials in Iowa and Chicago for the same access to the president. I believe it earned serious consideration. But despite at least 28 campaign stops and 11 days in our state, we never could convince his team to carve out a few moments for our editorial board –- in our office, on the trail or even in a barn somewhere in Iowa.
Which takes me back to Monday afternoon’s call from the White House, inviting us to chat with President Obama this morning.
It was a “personal call†to the Register’s publisher and editor, we were told. The specifics of the conversation could not be shared because it was off-the-record.
Of course, we immediately lobbied his campaign staff in Des Moines for a formal, on-the-record call. We were told it was not their decision; it came from the White House. We requested that the White House be asked to reverse course so whatever the president shared with us could be reviewed by voters and our readers.
No reason was given for the unusual condition of keeping it private.
We relented and took the call. How could we not? It’s the leader of the free world on line one.
and
Our expectation is that the answer to one of the most important questions the Register ever can ask a politician –- “Why should you be our president?†–- deserves to be shared with voters.
It’s unfortunate that did not happen today.
I think there are a number of tacks that could be taken on this. For example, who the heck is the Des Moines Register? Or who cares about newspapers any more? However, I’m also reminded of Greener’s Law: never argue with a man who buys ink by the barrel.
I think that the re-election campaign, for whatever reason, bungled this and may be mismanaging other communications with newspaper editorial staffs. Iowa is not in the bag. As of the most recent polls it is a toss-up—tied dead even. Des Moines is the state capital and, consequently, the Register probably has more influence than most cities of a quarter million people.
As of today I’ve identified 38 newspapers and magazines that have endorsed Barack Obama for president, 43 that have endorsed Mitt Romney. The Casper Star-Tribune has endorsed Mitt Romney for president:
Obama has failed. And voters shouldn’t reward failure with another term in office.
Instead, Republican Mitt Romney offers a viable alternative to Obama.
Romney is not only the right fit for America, he’s also a pretty good choice for Wyoming.
The Star-Tribune endorsed Barack Obama in 2008. The difficult to excerpt editorial goes on to suggest that Obama’s energy policy is bad for Wyoming while Romney’s would be better.
Some will tell you there isn’t a war on coal. They will argue it’s just a lot of rhetoric intended to hurt Obama. Those who make such foolish statements certainly don’t live here in the coalfields of southern West Virginia and Southwest Virginia. If they did, they would see first-hand all of the coal miners and their families who are unemployed and hurting, and the others who don’t know if they will be working from one day to the next. They would hear from the 200 Norfolk Southern Corp. employees who were furloughed just last week due to decreased coal traffic. They would see the impact the closure of coal-fired power plants are having on small communities like Glen Lynn, Va. They would realize the impact this war on coal will have on our future electric bills.
Yes, the war on coal is real. It’s very real. And it has to be stopped.
Republican Mitt Romney is the man who will end this war. He has embraced coal, natural gas and our other naturally abundant fossil fuels. He advocates a common-sense national energy policy that will put millions of Americans back to work. An energy policy that includes coal, oil, natural gas and — yes — even green energy sources.
The Daily Telegraph endorsed Barack Obama in 2008.
Can someone please explain something to me? Recently, I heard the president touting the growth in U. S. exports, saying exports were on track to double as he had promised. What in the world is he talking about?
If he’s talking about growth since the trough (which took place in 2009), it’s so modest a goal as hardly to be a goal at all. If he’s talking about growth relative to the peak (which took place in 2007), we’re not remotely close to doubling that.
If he’s talking about real growth in exports, that’s been flat for decades.
When he first mentioned this goal several years ago, I remarked on it. The U. S. exports an enormous amount already. Doubling that in real terms is a tall order. For that to occur other countries would need much higher incomes than, in fact, they have. Our balance of trade problems aren’t because we don’t export enough; they’re because we import too much.
As you may recall I’ve been puzzled by the president’s reluctance to lay out his plans for a second term. In that light I was amused by columnist E. J. Dionne’s column last week in which he proposed his own agenda for a second Obama term capped with a somewhat contradictory assertion that a custodial presidency, guaranteeing the accomplishments of the first term, was really good enough.
Mickey Kaus noticed that column, too, and even more he noticed that the column implicitly contradicts a previous Dionne column:
Oh wait. I’m sorry. That was written last month when it looked like Obama had some chance of winning big and defeating the entire â€GOP congressional apparatus.†Now that he doesn’t, winning big turns out not to matter so much! In a fortuitous development, it seems that, on second thought, Obama can not only govern but pursue an ambitious second term agenda even if Republicans continue to control the House–at least he can on five big issues (immigration, energy, education, infrastructure and campaign finance).
Our confusion can now be laid to rest. The Obama re-election campaign has produced a booklet outlining the president’s plans for a second term. If I find an online version, I’ll link to it but here’s a summary:
The new booklet—a glossy, 20-page publication with several policy sections—makes no mention of Mr. Romney or any of his ideas. In some cases, such as health care, it explains what Mr. Obama has already done and details what he won’t do, such as privatize Social Security. Other sections highlight his promises for a second term, though the promises are somewhat limited. For instance, his education section includes his goal of cutting the growth of tuition by half over the next 10 years, though the federal government’s power to achieve that is uncertain.
The new, 60-second TV ad is narrated by Mr. Obama. In it, he says the nation has added five million jobs, seen exports and home values rise, and brought soldiers home from wars abroad.
“Here’s my plan for the next four years,” the president then says. “Making education and training a national priority, building on our manufacturing boom, boosting American-made energy, reducing the deficits responsibly by cutting where we can, and asking the wealthy to pay a little more. And ending the war in Afghanistan.”
“Cutting the growth of tuition by half” seems like a very modest goal to me. Over the last ten years tuition costs have more than doubled. They’ve grown about four times as fast as prices, generally (CPI-U). Is cutting the rate of increase to twice that of CPI-U an adequate goal?
What effect will “cutting where we can” and increasing the rate paid by the top 1% of income have on the deficit? Practically nothing, according to the CBO.
For me the most enlightening part of the plan is that it’s pretty clear that the president is doubling down on structural problems, that Americans just don’t have the training and education needed for the jobs that are available, as the main problem facing the U. S. economy. You can believe that a shortfall in demand is the main problem facing our economy or you can believe that the president has the right prescription. You can’t believe in both.
As of today I’ve identified 35 newspapers and magazines that have endorsed Barack Obama for president, 37 that have endorsed Mitt Romney. The Sentinel and Enterprise of Fitchburg, Massachusetts has endorsed Mitt Romney for president:
Romney knows how to run a business and a government. If elected, he would enter the White House with a level of private- and public-sector expertise unseen in modern times.
He’s got a track record of buying failing companies and turning them around. Democrats have demonized Romney for the wealth he’s amassed working in the same capitalistic system they do and for making difficult CEO decisions expected of strong, prudent leaders. Yet who among the Democrats wouldn’t take Romney on their team if his political affiliation were different?
As governor of Massachusetts (2003-07), Romney reversed a downward economic trend and wiped out a $1.5 billion budget deficit through spending cuts and fee increases. He didn’t raise taxes. He also championed investments in the state’s public schools, and the results were stunning: No. 1 national and international rankings on student achievement tests.
Romney didn’t do it alone. Even today he gives credit to the 87 percent of Democrats in the state Legislature who collaborated with a Republican administration to solve difficult problems. It was a bipartisanship that Bay Staters came to believe in and expect. The capstone was controversial — Massachusetts’ first-in-the-nation universal health care law — and it was approved because it fit the state’s unique needs to guarantee access to quality medical services for its 6.3 million citizens.
The editorial goes on to analyze Obama’s very weak case for re-election. This is a meatier editorial than most and worth reading. The Sentinel and Enterprise endorsed Obama in 2008.
By my reckoning the publications that have changed from endorsing Obama to endorsing Romney outnumbers the publications that endorsed McCain in 2008 but endorse Obama now by 11-6.
As is my custom I did not watch the last debate between the presidential candidates last night. The consensus seems to be that the president won:
Thanks to an aggressive performance and a couple of zingers, a plurality of debate watchers questioned in a national survey say that the president won his final faceoff with Republican nominee Mitt Romney.
But a CNN/ORC International poll conducted right after Monday night’s faceoff here at Lynn University in south Florida also indicates that the debate may be a draw when it comes to whether it will affect the choice of voters who watched the showdown, and Romney held his own with the president on the commander-in-chief test.
And according to the survey, unlike previous debates, there was a big gender gap, with women responding much more favorably to Obama’s performance and men giving a small advantage to Romney.
Partisans of each side are claiming that their preferred candidate trounced his opponent. The president’s fans are making much of this exchange:
President Obama told Mitt Romney that he was out of touch on his criticism of the current military structure, at the foreign policy debate.
“But I think Gov. Romney maybe hasn’t spent enough time looking at how our military works,” said Obama. “You mention the Navy, and how we have fewer ships than 1916. We also have fewer horses and bayonets, because the nature of our military has changed. We have aircraft carriers; we have ships that go underwater; nuclear submarines.”
Mitt Romney needed to pass the usual tests for Republican presidential candidates in his debate Monday night with President Obama.
There was the Ford test (alternatively known as the Palin/Cain/Perry test): Would Mr. Romney say something so obviously misinformed, so manifestly silly, so revealingly ignorant as to disqualify him from serious consideration as a prospective commander-in-chief? He said nothing of the sort.
There was the Goldwater test (unfairly named, but reputations are stubborn things): Did Mr. Romney make pronouncements so belligerent as to make ordinary people fear for their children’s safety—or at least provide David Axelrod a chance to make it seem as if he did? He did not, though that won’t stop Mr. Axelrod from trying.
And there was the Bush test (not unfairly named but mistakenly understood to mean ideology when it ought to be about consistency): Would Mr. Romney find a deft way to define his foreign policy as something other than a retread of the 43rd president—but also as something defensible, distinctive, and (not least) identifiably Republican?
On this score, Mr. Romney succeeded, too, if only in a manner coyly calculated to raise the hackles of every conservative who has harbored doubts all along about the Massachusetts governor.
I think that the president may have out-smarted himself in the wisecrack that’s being quoted. If he’d said “crossbows and arbalests” he might have been on to something but the reality is that the Army buys thousands more bayonets, mostly M9s, every year and horses have proven very useful lately in Afghanistan so I strongly suspect we’ve been buying more of them too. Ships as a category aren’t obsolete, either. Do we need to buy more of them? The Navy has said “yes” but the president has disagreed with that. That’s due to a difference in strategic views rather than being out of touch.
I honestly don’t see how the president’s supporters can make the argument with a straight face that Mitt Romney isn’t sufficiently experienced in foreign policy to be president. You could reasonably argue that Barack Obama wasn’t sufficiently prepared in 2008 but that presidents get all of the experience they need in OJT, implying that Mitt Romney has all of the experience he needs as well. You might argue that Barack Obama learned everything he needed to know as a child in Indonesia which IMO doesn’t meet the laugh test. You can’t reasonably argue Romney doesn’t have enough experience.
Using the method I’ve suggested before of listening to the debate with the sound off the description I’ve been reading of the president’s performance as “condescending and small” comes across pretty strongly, particularly in the president’s closing remarks. Fortunately for the president by that time most people had probably changed the channel anyway.
Consider the graph of the last 30 days of the RCP average of polls. Obama has gone from four full points ahead to being slightly behind.
The overnight polls haven’t come in yet but as of this moment it looks to me as though Mitt Romney accomplished what he needed to in the debates while the president staunched the bleeding from the wounds he inflicted on himself in the first debate. As Bret Stephens, cited above, put it Romney is a “perfectly plausible president”. I don’t believe the president succeeded in painting Romney as stupid, frightening, or a clone of George W. Bush. If anything, on foreign policy he’s a clone of Barack Obama. For me that’s distressing but most of the country doesn’t see it that way.
Update
The overnight tracking polls are starting to come in and the RCP average of polls has risen to nearly a one point advantage for Romney over Obama. The Gallup poll of likely voters, the most significant metric until the election itself, shows that 51% of likely voters now plan to vote for Romney. That fully supports the point I made above: Romney did what he needed to do and the president, while he may be encouraging his most faithful supporters with quips and putdowns, didn’t.
Also, quite a few people are making the observation that I did—that the president outsmarted himself with the wisecrack about bayonets and horses that his faithful followers like so much. See here, for example.
I haven’t been able to quantify it as well as I’d like but I do know that the Army has been buying about 5,000 bayonets a year, a lot of them from the Ottawa Knife Company as it has for nearly the last century.
With The New Yorker’s endorsement of Obama and several additional Romney endorsements, my reckoning of the total is 34 endorsements of Obama, 33 endorsements of Romney. None of the new endorsements I’ve found constituted a reversal so I don’t plan to link to them or excerpt them.