The American Religion

I’ve suddenly realized what I disliked so vehemently about the NYT article I linked to yesterday. It’s that it nodded approvingly at this characterization of progressives and conservatives:

The linguist George Lakoff suggests that the political right conceives of society as a family ruled by a strict father, whereas the left thinks of it as a family guided by a nurturant parent.

It’s not just the clumsy circumlocution. I think that statements reflects an utter lack of understanding of the United States and what makes us tick. It’s confusing us with Britain or France or Germany.

Families are based on kinship ties, either ties of blood or ties of formal adoption. Being American isn’t based on kinship. It’s more like a religion, as G. K. Chesterton understood a century ago: America is the only nation founded on a creed. Rejecting that creed is like rejecting the creed of a religion. If you reject it, you’re not trying to make the religion better. You’re trying to start a different religion.

22 comments

Endorsement Dump

As of this morning by my reckoning 40 publications have endorsed the re-election of Barack Obama, 49 have endorsed Mitt Romney for president. Two major circulation dailies made their endorsements yesterday: the Washington Post and the New York Post. Although the WP endorsed Obama in 2008 while the New York Post endorsed McCain, I’ve linked and excerpted both of their editorials below in recognition of their circulation and, at least in the case of the Washington Post, presumed influence.

Of Chicago’s two important dailies, the Sun-Times has decided no longer to make political endorsements and the Tribune endorsed Barack Obama’s election in 2008. I expect it to do so again but that’s not a foregone conclusion and I’m eagerly awaiting its endorsement.

The reason that I’m putting so much energy into tracking newspaper endorsements is twofold. Newspapers perform two differing functions. On the one hand they provide a barometer based on ears to the ground on opinion among their readership and on the other they attempt to educate and inform their readership. Both of those functions are useful in evaluating presidential candidates and the status of their candidacies.

Based on newspaper endorsements alone I think it’s very clear that the election this cycle is very, very different from that of 2008. I continue to think that the advantage lies with the incumbent but that the election will be extremely close.

The president’s re-election campaign must be worried. As I’ve said before I don’t pay much attention to the polls until the middle of October. We’re past the middle of October and the polls are not going in the president’s direction. As of today the RCP average of polls shows Mitt Romney leading by almost a full point and an increasing number of polls are reflecting a significant 50% in Romney’s favor. The campaign isn’t acting worried. Its reaction seems to me to be something between panic and disbelief.

9 comments

Newspaper Endorsements: Washington Post

The Washington Post has endorsed Barack Obama for president:

So voters are left with the centerpiece of Mr. Romney’s campaign: promised tax cuts that would blow a much bigger hole in the federal budget while worsening economic inequality. His claims that he could avoid those negative effects, which defy math and which he refuses to back up with actual proposals, are more insulting than reassuring.

By contrast, the president understands the urgency of the problems as well as anyone in the country and is committed to solving them in a balanced way. In a second term, working with an opposition that we hope would be chastened by the failure of its scorched-earth campaign against him, he is far more likely than his opponent to succeed. That makes Mr. Obama by far the superior choice.

The Post occupies an interesting position in American journalism. On the one hand it is the reliable weathervane for The Common Wisdom in Washington, DC. As such it is a national newspaper. On the other hand it’s the major local newspaper for Washington, DC and adjoining areas. I’m not sure which voice is speaking in this editorial. The president’s accomplishments probably look a lot more impressive from DC which did not ever experience the recession than they do in Chicago whose economy is, at best, in the doldrums, possibly even declining.

I suspect that the editors of the Post believe that Obama will win. That’s probably the view from Washington.

8 comments

Newspaper Endorsements: New York Post

The New York Post has endorsed Mitt Romney for president:

In contrast, the smoke now hanging over the Middle East testifies to Obama’s inability to get the job done.

Any job.

Because, in the end, the fundamental problem is the president’s core philosophy.

He believes in equality of outcome, not equality of opportunity — and that is not how America is supposed to work.

America is not working right now.

Forward?

For four more years?

We think not.

The Post’s editorial is a litany rather than an essay, difficult to excerpt, and, frankly, I did not find it particularly interesting reading. Perhaps that’s because I’m already aware of the president’s failings as I suspect the Post’s readers are as well.

0 comments

Crystal Ball: Republicans Will Hold House

The Crystal Ball is projecting that Republicans will maintain control of the House of Representatives after Nov. 7. Following a race-by-race analysis, here’s the bottom line:

Democrats need a big wave to capture the House: If Democrats were to win all the races that at least lean to them and ALL the leans Republican seats, they would have 220 House seats, or two more than a bare majority. Democrats nearly sweeping all the leans Republican seats is possible, but not plausible, especially with no lift from the generic ballot — or, it appears, from the top of the ticket. There will be plenty of drama in individual House races across the country, and there are a range of potential outcomes. But we believe that Democratic control of the House is no longer one of them.

That would leave the following prospective outcomes:

  • Divided government—Obama is re-elected, Democrats retain control of Senate, Republicans retain control of House.
  • Divided government—Obama is re-elected, Republicans control House and Senate.
  • Divided government—Romney elected, Democrats retain control of Senate, Republicans retain control of House.
  • Republican rule—Romney elected, Republicans take control of Senate, Republicans retain control of House.

The Crystal Ball’s status report on the Senate elections is here. Basically, it’s a toss-up.

0 comments

There Are Very Few Red States. There Are Very Few Blue States

When (If) you read this NYT article on why some states are “red” and some states are “blue”:

But why do ideology and geography cluster so predictably? Why, if you know a person’s position on gay marriage, can you predict that he or she will want to increase the military budget and decrease the tax rate, and is more likely to hail from Wyoming or Georgia than from Minnesota or Vermont? To be sure, some of these affinities may spring from coalitions of convenience. Economic libertarians and Christian evangelicals, united by their common enemy, are strange bedfellows in today’s Republican party, just as the two Georges — the archconservative Wallace and the uberliberal McGovern — found themselves in the same Democratic Party in 1972.

I think there are a couple of things you should keep in mind.

First, even the bluest states are not uniformly blue. The idea of a Blue North and a Red South is erroneous. Take the county by county 2008 presidential election results for New York for example. Simple analyses like those used by the author of the NYT article just don’t stand up to scrutiny. The same is true of Illinois, Pennsylvania, Ohio, and many, many other states.

Neither are red states really red. See Mississippi. That’s easily explained by demographics but I don’t need to belabor the point.

There is an element of truth in it, however. I don’t think that you can explain today’s voting patterns by the Church of England/Nonconformist split of the 17th and 18th centuries. But you don’t have to look back that far. When people come to the United States they bring their ideas about social organization and politics with them. This is territory I’ve covered before. The Irish brought their ideas of proper governance, based on the systems that prevailed in Irish villages, and refurbished them for New York and Chicago. Scandinavians brought their ideas of what constituted a just society from Scandinavia of the 19th century to the Upper Midwest. And so on.

There are other, pragmatic, bread-and-butter reasons, too. That’s fodder for another post.

8 comments

Another Question

Will the enormous amount of television advertising the election cycle, on track to exceed 2008’s by 25%, make it more or less likely that people will turn out to vote? Or won’t it make any difference?

1 comment

Exporting the Negative Externalities

I sincerely wish I had as many answers as I do questions. Here’s the question that’s bedeviling me today.

The U. S. used to be the world’s largest producer of rare earth metals, used in all kinds of high tech electronics and metallurgy. The reason that China is now the world’s largest producer of rare earth metals isn’t because they have them and we don’t. The rare earths are actually extremely common. We cagily don’t publish reports of our known reserves but they’re believed to be very large.

It also probably isn’t due to wages. Rare earth production isn’t enormously labor intensive. Most of the effort is in the processing. And that’s the reason our production has declined, too.

Processing rare earth metals into usable form has lots of nasty environmental effects. We’ve put environmental regulations into effect that makes it much less cost-effective to produce them here.

But now we’re getting to my question. A law prohibiting something or a regulation that prohibits something is just another way of saying that, as a society, we think that something is wrong. We think it shouldn’t be done. Importing our rare earth metals from China does not improve the environment or preserve people’s health one iota. It just moves where the harm happens from here to China. Indeed, I believe that lax enforcement of the environmental laws they have in China and their inadequate system of civil law mean that importing these things from China (or just letting the Chinese produce them so they can use them and we can buy the consumer products—let’s not get picayune) is actually worse than producing them here.

So here’s my question. What’s the moral defense of letting the Chinese pollute their environment and harm their people? I understand that it’s expedient. Out of sight, out of mind. I wonder about the moral issues.

Perhaps one could argue that in China there are mitigating circumstances. Aren’t there places in the U. S. where there are mitigating circumstances, too? How do you evaluate that, quantify it? Arguing along those lines seems to me to be getting into the territory of the unadministrable.

Shouldn’t we be imposing Pigouvian duties on imports of things that we don’t produce here because we’ve decided that doing so is too noxious?

11 comments

The Ground Game

The other day I was looking at the 2008 election returns for Illinois. It occurred to me that 450,000 fewer Obama voters in Cook County, 450,000 fewer Obama voters downstate, and 450,000 more Romney voters statewide than there were McCain voters in 2008 is the difference between Illinois being carried by Obama and being carried by Romney. Considering that 2012 2008 had recordbreaking turnout, that’s absolutely possible.

The “ground game” is important. It’s important in Illinois.

I have yet to see a single sign for either Obama or Romney in my neighborhood, even in the windows and on the lawns of people I know to be very politically involved. I’ve seen a handful of signs in Cook County. For Obama, natch. But nothing like what I was seeing in 2008.

I don’t think that betting on a low turnout among Romney voters is a winning strategy for the Obama campaign.

Also: frequent commenter Icepick reports on the signs of the times in his neck of the woods in Florida.

3 comments

Training Is the Key?

I have made no secret of my skepticism of the idea that the reason that the number of unemployed, underemployed, and discouraged workers is so high is that the workers who are available don’t have the education, training, and skills necessary for the jobs that available. That structural explanation for unemployment is, however, the view embraced by Democrats and Republicans, by Obama and Romney.

This morning in the Washington Post reporter Amy Goldstein looks at the explanation more closely and finds it leaves much to be desired:

The idea of teaching new skills to laid-off workers is a rare economic policy on which the two major political parties agree, eager as they are to offer a salve for unemployment. During the first presidential debate this month in Denver, Obama praised the “great work” that community colleges are doing “to train people for jobs that exist right now.” The GOP nominee, Mitt Romney, said federal money must help workers “get in the training they need for jobs that will really help them.”

This unlikely bipartisan agreement fits with an abiding cultural belief, since America’s founding, in the United States as the land of personal reinvention. And it keeps faith with a deep-etched understanding that education is the key to upward mobility.

But does retraining actually work?

[…]

In the end, I found certain successes. But most of what I discovered was sobering. The transition from a factory culture to college life to a new career turns out to be far more complicated than the political rhetoric hints at. Students arrive grieving lost jobs and shattered lives, panicky to regain their old wages however they can, rusty at writing and math, often having no idea even how to turn on a computer. Two-thirds do not graduate. And with or without a degree, new work at good pay has proved elusive for many.

What I found, in other words, suggests that even if the U.S. economy is gradually reviving, the bruises to individual workers and individual communities can be deeper than what job training alone can readily heal.

It also fails to account for the newly-minted nurse, medical technician, IT specialist, or engineer who’s unable to find a job because in addition to the skills prospective employers demand years of experience. It fails to account for older workers with plenty of experience but who are overtrained for anything other than the jobs they had but no longer exist. And it fails to account for the nearly 50% of young people living in major urban areas who can’t be induced to graduate from high school on time let alone go on for additional training.

I’ve already made one proposal: a central clearing house where those seeking to bring workers into the country on H1-B or L1 visas can be matched with workers who have the skills and experience they demand and are already here. We could establish apprenticeship programs in which the pay of certain new hires is subsidized until they have the experience their jobs require.

However, the sad reality is that we simply need to be creating more jobs here. I don’t believe that the shortfall in job creation here is due to a lack of consumption here. I think it’s due to a lack of consumption elsewhere, particularly in those countries that are illegally maintaining enormous dollar reserves. Smaller dollar reserves and more consumption in China, Japan, Germany, Switzerland, Russia, and Brazil will mean more jobs here. Relaxing some of the many barriers to job creation here might be a nice idea, too.

We shouldn’t be waiting for the crisis to hit before putting programs into place. As Ms. Goldstein suggests, once the crisis has struck it may already be too late for far too many people.

51 comments