You Can Go to Hell, I’m Going to Indiana

Yet another Illinois company is pulling up stakes and moving to Indiana. Hoist Liftruck, a manufacturer of forklifts, is moving from Bedford Park across the border to East Chicago:

The growing company needed more space for its manufacturing operations, and when it found a suitable building in East Chicago, it decided to make the leap. It was an easy decision, because Indiana offers a better business climate than Illinois and Hoist will save “many millions of dollars a year” by moving, said Marty Flaska, president and CEO of the company.

“The environment isn’t friendly for what I do” in Illinois, Flaska said.

In East Chicago, he said, Hoist will save $1 million annually on workers’ compensation-related costs, a significant sum for the firm. Workers’ compensation lawyers in Cook County right now are bringing three to four illegitimate claims against the firm a month, costing it money, according to Flaska.

Indiana also offers lower taxes for the company and less-expensive housing for his employees, he said. Hoist employs welders, assemblers, material handlers and other production workers. Hoist’s lifts are used by big manufacturers, like automakers.

Incentives played a critical role in the company’s decision to leave Illinois. Hoist will be able to lay claim on a big package of tax credits as it ramps up operations in East Chicago. By 2022, the company plans to employ around 500 people there.

The Indiana Economic Development Corporation has offered the company close to $8.3 million in tax credits, according to a statement. The city of East Chicago and economic development agencies in Lake County, Ind., are also chipping in subsidies.

If memory serves, Hoist was a client of mine 25, 30 years ago. I never did anything for them directly but one of my guys did. I haven’t heard from them in decades.

At some point Illinois is going to need to decide what kind of state it’s going to be. It can’t go on losing companies to Indiana, Wisconsin, and Iowa forever.

7 comments

The Way the Canoes Are Heading

More bad news for Illinois. As should have been anticipated, Heinz is starting to lay off its Chicagoland staff:

Kraft Heinz on Wednesday laid off 700 workers at Kraft’s corporate headquarters in north suburban Northfield, part of a cost-cutting plan that will slash the combined company’s head count in the U.S. and Canada by 2,500 jobs.

Employees affected by the cuts, which have been expected for months, will get “generous” severance benefits that last at least six months and outplacement services, said Michael Mullen, Kraft Heinz’s senior vice president of corporate and government affairs. The cuts took effect immediately.

Many of the remaining workers will be commuting to downtown Chicago:

H.J. Heinz completed its purchase of Kraft Foods Group in July, forming Kraft Heinz, now the third-largest food and beverage company in the U.S. and the fifth-largest worldwide.

A few weeks later, Kraft Heinz announced it would move one of its headquarters, which encompasses some 700,000 square feet in north suburban Northfield, to less than a quarter of that amount of space in downtown Chicago. Kraft’s lease at Aon Center, which starts Jan. 1, is for 170,000 square feet over five floors.

Sadly, that won’t do much for the city other than adding another thousand people to the morning commute. Chicago doesn’t have a city earnings tax and doesn’t have the power to impose one. While the Kraft Heinz workers may be working in Chicago, they’ll undoubtedly still live on the North Shore and do their shopping there.

And, of course, there isn’t much joy in Pittsburgh, either:

Heinz, which is based in Pittsburgh, cut more than 7,000 jobs — about 20 percent of the workforce — in the 18 months after it was acquired in 2013 by Berkshire Hathaway and private-equity firm 3G Capital.

Other snack companies cutting costs include Mondelez, which was created in 2012 when Kraft split into two public companies. The maker of Mini Chips Ahoy and Oreo cookies said last month that it will cut half of its 1,200 jobs at a bakery on Chicago’s Southwest Side over the next year, as it moves some of its production to a plant in Mexico.

That’s mnore economic growth for Mexico so at least that’s something. Creative destruction. We could use a little creative construction to go along with it right about now.

5 comments

The Second Shoe Drops on the Yuan

There has been continued fallout from China’s surprise devaluation of the yuan yesterday:

Concerns China’s economy is faltering torpedoed stocks around the world for a second day and fueled demand for the safety of gold and Treasuries.
American equities attempted a comeback in afternoon trading, as the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index trimmed its decline to 0.5 percent as of 1:25 p.m., paring a 1.5 percent slide. The rebound came too late for European stocks, which plunged 2.7 percent for the biggest one-day rout since October. China’s yuan led a slide in Asian currencies, and emerging-market shares plunged.

The dollar retreated, while Treasuries got a boost as investors speculated that the yuan’s devaluation will slow inflation globally. That led to bets that the Federal Reserve may delay raising interest rates, while a weaker U.S. currency boosted the appeal of some commodities.
“China is a big growth driver around the world, so there’s a certain risk to global growth,” said Otto Waser, chief investment officer at R&A Research & Asset Management AG in Zurich. “If the world economy turns out to be weaker, the Fed will keep an eye on the dollar.”
The S&P 500’s drop sent it careening through its 200-day moving average, a level that has halted previous selloffs this year. The gauge’s comeback has stalled at that mark.
The U.S. financial-services industry was among the worst-performing sectors as U.S. government debt rallied. Bank shares had surged in recent months amid expectations that a Federal Reserve rate increase will expand lending margins and boost profits.

The exchange rate for the yuan is now right about where it was when they removed the peg 15 years ago and started letting the yuan fluctuate within a range they found desireable.

I know that the Chinese are complaining about exports falling off but if that’s the case I want to know who the heck has stopped buying. It ain’t us

1 comment

‘Splain Me, Please

I am frankly puzzled by Robert Solow’s op-ed on why wages aren’t keeping up. In the op-ed he doesn’t mention globalization, immigration, or the reality that the mechanism by which labor unions raise wages is by limiting entry, i.e. restricting the number of workers.

Don’t those omissions produce a, shall we say, skewed view of the subject he’s addressing?

Can someone explain this to me?

6 comments

Making Choices

Writing at Inside Sources, Aparna Mathur comes at the decision to raise the minimum wage from another tack:

The movement for a $15 minimum wage in cities such as New York, Seattle and Los Angeles has many economists and policymakers worried. Supporters of a minimum wage hike have typically favored modest hikes in the minimum wage under the assumption that modest hikes could result in no more than modest job losses. A small negative impact on employment could be acceptable so long as it resulted in a large hike in earnings for other workers. But let’s step back and ask what we mean by “modest” job losses? Last year, the Congressional Budget Office modeled an increase in the federal minimum wage from $7.25 to $10.10 and found that nearly 500,000 jobs could be eliminated as a result. A loss of 500,000 jobs is not trivial, but would these losses be acceptable if nearly 16.5 million workers experienced wage gains? This is the quintessential trade-off associated with minimum wage hikes: a lost job for some and a higher wage for others. From my perspective, this trade-off is not only unacceptable, but also one that policymakers need not make.

She continues by pointing to the Earned Income Tax Credit as another way of boosting the incomes of low wage workers which won’t have the adverse effect of throwing the people you’re presumably trying to help out of work.

One of the complications is that workers earning the minimum wage are not a monolithic group. According to Pew Research almost two-thirds are part-time workers, whether by default or by design is not mentioned, and more than 50% are under the age of 24. Just about half are white women. A quarter self-identify as something other than white. The overwhelming preponderance work in fast food or retail.

It seems to me that in order to come up with an effective policy you’ve got to decide which group you’re trying to help. A policy tailored to help white college kids probably won’t do much for full-time Hispanic workers over the age of 25 who are trying to support a family and send money back to Mama in Mexico. And policies designed for either of those groups probably won’t do anything for black teenagers.

Of course, if the objective of the policy is to signal your concern for people earning a low income without actually requiring you to have any concern for those people, full speed ahead with upping the minimum wage!

3 comments

Devaluation of the Yuan

In a move that took many by surprise the Chinese authorities devalued the yuan relative to the dollar by a sharp 2%, characterizing it a “market adjustment”. That explanation is problematic for a number of reasons. China’s economy may be slowing but its exports aren’t. The U. S. trade deficit with China is running at record levels. What’s happening in China isn’t the slowing of exports but the collapse of a credit bubble caused by its own mismanagement.

Here’s the analysis of the editors of the Wall Street Journal:

China effectively devalued the yuan by 1.9% on Tuesday, with the possibility of more to come under a new system of daily fixes. There are three main ways to interpret Beijing’s motivation.

First, China believes the yuan is overvalued compared to the currencies of its trading partners, and the central bank is committed to liberalize controls and allow market forces to play a larger role in day-to-day trading. This is the optimistic reading.

Second, China is a victim of the U.S. Federal Reserve’s quantitative easing, which flooded the world with cheap dollar liquidity and now is poised to spark crises in emerging markets as it raises interest rates. This would mean China is trying to delink from the rising dollar more than it is trying to devalue the yuan.

Or third, Beijing has joined a wave of beggar-thy-neighbor devaluations sweeping the region. This would be the worst news for Chinese and global growth.

Jim Cramer think it’s panic:

Did the entire market come down with a case of amnesia, and forget all about when the miners, industrials and biotechs roared on Monday? Judging by the action on the averages on Tuesday, Jim Cramer suspects that could be the case.

“Last night I tried to be skeptical, if not downright critical, about the rally, suggesting it could easily be repealed as the week went on. I didn’t know it would be repealed immediately,” the “Mad Money” host said.

That’s because Cramer was not expecting that investors would be dealing with a Chinese currency devaluation, which makes China’s goods cheaper to export and U.S. goods more expensive to sell there.

The devaluation shocked Cramer so much that he decided to review what happened, so that investors can be prepared for what is next.

First, China is totally desperate. It is clear to Cramer that the Chinese Communist government is trying to put everyone to work while also trying to stop widespread corruption in business and politics. It tried to fix the issue by exports, but then Europe fell apart. Then it tried infrastructure, but now it seems as if everything it needed has been built.

while Howard Gold observes that the move illustrates why China isn’t “ready for primetime”:

The crash and the government’s stealth nationalization of stock trading`exposed China’s equity markets as government-owned-and-operated casinos driven by reckless, ignorant individual investors just waiting to be fleeced.

MSCI has postponed including China A-shares in its China and broader emerging markets index, largely for technical reasons. Vanguard, which tracks emerging-market indexes provided by MSCI competitor FTSE Russell, is plowing ahead.

Speculation MSCI would add A-shares to its indexes helped fuel the melt-up in Chinese shares, and the meltdown may have been partly triggered by its surprise decision not to, for now.

Sebastien Lieblich, MSCI’s executive director of research who spoke to me from Geneva, wouldn’t comment on that. But he said the delay was caused primarily by feedback from MSCI’s large institutional investor clients on regulatory roadblocks in the Chinese markets.

On reflection I think the Chinese have been planning this move for a long time. Since the start of the year they’ve been on a Treasuries selling spree. Getting the best price they could while they still can. For the last couple of months they’ve been buying enormous amounts of oil. Now that their tanks are full they’re ready to devalue the yuan against the dollar, presumably hoping that once again the U. S. consumer would restore their economy’s fortunes.

Not only do I not think it will not work this time I strongly suspect it will provoke a reaction. The U. S. economy is edging towards recession. Expect some screaming from the EU and Brazil.

15 comments

The Early Returns

Following the wave of cities including Chicago raising their minimum wages, some to $15 per hour, the returns are starting to come in and they’re very much as predicted. Seattle, the first mover, is seeing some results:

As the notion of a $15 minimum wage spreads and gains popularity, some new data of possible relevance out of Seattle via the American Enterprise Institute:

In June of last year, the Seattle city council passed a $15 minimum wage law to be phased in over time, with the first increase to $11 an hour starting on April 1, 2015. What effect will the eventual 58% increase in labor costs have on small businesses, including area restaurants? It’s too soon to tell for sure, but there is already some evidence that the recent minimum wage hike to $11 an hour, along with the pending increase of an additional $4 an hour by 2017 for some businesses, has started having a negative effect on restaurant jobs in the Seattle area. The chart above shows that the Emerald City MSA started experiencing a decline in restaurant employment around the first of the year (when the state minimum wage increased to $9.47 per hour, the highest state minimum wage in the country), and the 1,300 job loss between January and June is the largest decline over that period since 2009 during the Great Recession (data here). The loss of 1,000 restaurant jobs in May following the minimum wage increase in April was the largest one month job decline since a 1,300 drop in January 2009, again during the Great Recession. In contrast to the January-June loss of restaurant jobs in the Seattle area: a) restaurant employment nationally increased by 130,700 jobs (and by 1.2%) during that same period (data here), b) overall employment in the Seattle MSA increased 1.2% and by 21,800 jobs (data here) and c)non-Seattle MSA restaurant employment in Washington increased 3.2% and by 2,800 jobs (data here).

I reported back in March about restaurateur fears of the hike and looming further hikes in Seattle, then about some counterdata noting that, well, permits for new restaurants hadn’t seemed to slow down.

The loss of potential jobs to specific individuals on the margin need not show up in overall macro data about total employment post minimum wage. Still, the data AEI presented provides still further suggestive empirical evidence that the laws of supply and demand that underlie the entire logic of the science of economics might not disappear when it comes to labor, just because people think it would be cooler if lower wage people got paid more, as long as it isn’t at their clear and direct expense.

Fast food companies are behaving much as would be expected as well. I reported earlier how McDonalds has decided to get rid of most of its company-owned stores, thereby dodging the bullet of paying the higher wages it promised to pay to its minimum wage employees. Its franchise fees come out of the gross rather than the net. They’re indifferent to whether their franchisees can make a profit while paying the higher wages that are being mandated. At least they’re indifferent now. We’ll see what happens next quarter or next year.

Now Wendy’s has chimed in:

Last week the Wendy’s Company did a public service on its second-quarter earnings call by explaining how mandated wage hikes will lead to fewer jobs for the low-skill workers that progressives claim to be helping.

First, CFO Todd Penegor talked about the pressure to pay higher wages and said that “we continue to look at initiatives and how we work to offset any impacts of future wage inflation through technology initiatives, whether that’s customer self-order kiosks, whether that’s automating more in the back of the house in the restaurant. And you’ll see a lot more coming on that front later this year from us.”

So the company will now use machines to do jobs that used to be done by people who have become too expensive to employ. We keep hearing that these minimum-wage laws benefit restaurant workers. But since many will no longer be working in restaurants at all, the reasonable conclusion is that the activist campaigns to raise the minimum wage are mainly intended to benefit the unions that back them.

The beauty of the minimum wage as a mechanism for demonstrating your philanthropy is that it enables compassionate upper middle income city dwellers to feel good about themselves without leaving the comfort of their armchairs or shouldering higher taxes. That it might actually harm the people they purport to want to help is a mere detail.

You cannot outmaneuver supply and demand or profit and loss. A frequent topic in this blog is how to increase the wages of the lowest income earners without throwing them out of work but I advocate recognizing the ineluctable power of supply and demand rather than ignoring it. What is need among non-skilled and semi-skilled workers is a tighter labor market or, alternatively, wage subsidies.

But wage subsidies cost money and for cities that would mean higher taxes. Chicago can’t afford to pay the commitments it’s already made let alone make more. Much better to enact a higher city minimum wage and throw a few thousand more poor people out of work. At least the mayor and the City Council can feel good about the benignity of their intentions.

0 comments

The Last Step

Robert Samuelson points out, quite correctly, that President Obama’s plan to deal with cliamte change doesn’t do much about the problem:

Let’s assume, for simplicity’s sake, that the plan works perfectly. It achieves its goal of reducing carbon emissions from power plants in 2030 by 32 percent from a base year of 2005. Other problems fade. Court challenges to the regulations are rejected. The expansion of solar and wind generation does not lead to less reliable electricity supplies. Greater efficiencies and cheap natural gas avoid sizable consumer rate increases.

Even under these favorable assumptions, Obama’s plan won’t immediately depress global temperatures, which — if the logic of climate change holds — will be higher in 2030 than today.

A refresher course in global warming explains why. What counts are the amounts of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. It’s these concentrations that are said to trap heat and raise temperatures. The concentrations have gone from roughly 280 parts per million (ppm) of carbon dioxide in preindustrial times, around 1800, to about 315 ppm in 1960 to 400 ppm now. As long as concentrations increase, so does the potential for more warming.

Obama’s plan doesn’t reduce these concentrations. It just cuts — but does not eliminate — the annual emissions into the atmosphere. These emissions raise concentration levels, which are now growing by about 2 ppm per year, says Princeton climate scientist Michael Oppenheimer. True, Obama’s plan might slow this a tad. However, the larger point is that ongoing power plant emissions, though diminished, would continue to boost concentration levels.

to which I presume the president and/or supporters of his plan would retort that it’s just a first step. And that highlights the problem that I have with the president’s approach not just on this issue but on healthcare reform, diplomacy, and just about everything else he’s tackled during his term of office. His plans are invariably just first steps in what would undoubtedly prove to be a lengthy process and yet he lays no groundwork for such a lengthy process.

He has made no alliances, cultivated no friendships in the Congress, done no favors, rolled no logs, produced no movement, groomed no successors. The Democratic Party is weaker now than when he took office. Additionally, his high-handed and imperious approach to politics makes it easy to oppose him. That was brought into bold relief in his remarks last week on the agreement he’s negotiated with Iran. In each case his first step might just as well have been his last step.

Policy is hard. If it weren’t anybody could do it. It is chess and the only game the present incumbent appears to know is slapjack. Whoever the next president may be I hope that he or she has more appetite for the political process than has been evident during President Obama’s term of office.

12 comments

It’s the Democrats’ Move

The editors of Crain’s Chicago Business exhort the Democrat-dominated legislature to take action on the state’s budget:

Here’s the Illinois Democrats’ guide to negotiation and compromise:

1. Pass a state budget with more spending than revenue and refuse to own up to its real costs.
2. Label the Republican governor an extremist for pointing out the obvious disconnect.
3. Hold breath until other (poor) people turn blue. Then blame the governor.

Illinois is well into its second month without a full state budget, continuing its shameful tradition of political incompetence and arrogance. Important bills, such as one that provides some temporary relief for Chicago’s shaky pension finances, have been bottled up, apparently out of personal pique. Not only is it embarrassing, but this failure of legislators to do the most basic part of their jobs soon may have real impact on the low-income and special-needs populations that Democrats profess to be fighting for.

Voters might begin to get the idea that the populations that the Democrats in the state legislature are “fighting for” are all either officeholders or their donors.

The Democrats don’t need the governor’s permission to act. They seek it from pure political cowardice and calculation. So far the governor hasn’t risen to the bait.

However, the governor himself isn’t pure as the driven snow:

Rauner has made plenty of rookie mistakes during his first months in office. Unfortunately, he’s not above some rather juvenile name-callingE, and some of his demands to limit collective bargaining sound more punitive than productive. But this former private-equity executive has plenty of experience at cutting a deal. He has signaled over and over again that he’s prepared to compromise with Democrats, including raising taxes, a move that’s unlikely to endear him to his Republican base. But he understandably wants some things in return, including changes in the workers’ comp system and prevailing wage rules for government projects, and a vote on a term-limits proposal.

Even if the governor gets everything he’s asked for it still will only be the first step in what would presumably be the lengthy process of getting Illinois back on the right course and, frankly, as Lord Keynes put it, in the long run we’re all dead. I’d like to see the big picture. I’d like the governor to flesh out his plan a bit. Does he have one?

3 comments

The Life of Pi

Last night I watched The Life of Pi. It’s a beautifully made picture, visually stunning, and in one respect it surprised me, a respect that I don’t think one would take away from the trailers.

It’s the most deeply religious movie I’ve seen in decades. It’s not religious in the sentimental devotional way of the biblical epics of the 50s or 60s or of the “Christian” movies of today but in a much more basis way. Whether you’re religious or not I think you’ll enjoy it.

I won’t say much more about it. I’ll only ask you a question. Which story do you prefer?

5 comments