I have severely conflicted feelings about Nicholas Kristof’s most recent column, a lament for a classmate who, according to Mr. Kristof, did not realize his own potential:
Alan Krueger, a Princeton economist, has noted that in the United States, parents’ incomes correlate to their adult children’s incomes roughly as heights do. “The chance of a person who was born to a family in the bottom 10 percent of the income distribution rising to the top 10 percent as an adult is about the same as the chance that a dad who is 5 feet 6 inches tall having a son who grows up to be over 6 feet 1 inch tall,†Krueger observed in a speech. “It happens, but not often.â€
I’ve been reflecting on this because of a friend in my hometown, Yamhill, Ore. Rick Goff was smart, talented and hard working, but he faced an uphill struggle from birth; I wrote about him last year as an example of the aphorism that “talent is universal, but opportunity is not.â€
I want the United States to be a “land of opportunity”. What policies would accomplish that? Does it even mean the same thing as it did in 1850? In 1950? Are the metrics Mr. Kristof cites even relevant? For example, the countries that have considerable “intergenerational income elasticity” are (in order of more elasticity) Japan, Germany, New Zealand, Sweden, Australia, Canada, Finland, Norway, and Denmark. The countries with very little elasticity (in increasing order) Switzerland, the United States, Argentina, Italy, United Kingdom, Chile, Brazil, China, and Peru. Are we more like Finland, a small country in which 90%+ of the people are ethnic Finns, cultural Lutherans, and speak Finnish, an obscure language spoken by only a handful of people outside of Finland, or are we more like the United Kingdom, a country with whom we share a language, historic, cultural, and economic ties? Should we be more like Finland? Can we be more like Finland? In Canada what are your prospects if you are Francophone rather than being Anglophone?
I also note that all of the countries being held up as paragons of intergenerational income elasticity have much more exacting immigration laws than we do and they enforce their laws. Does that make a difference. Has the intergenerational income elasticity in the United States increased or decreased since 1965?
I’m also suspicious of this passage in Mr. Kristof’s column:
Rick, who thought he was one-eighth American Indian, pretty much raised himself, along with his brother and two sisters. His mom died when he was 5, and his dad — “a professional drunk,†Rick once told me — abandoned the family. A grandmother presided, and the kids hunted and fished to put food on the table.
Does it matter what he thought? If Mr. Kristof is trying to blame Mr. Goff’s problems on racial animus? That seems far-fetched to me. The conclusion I draw is that opportunities can be limited in rural areas and Mr. Kristof is the exception there rather than the rule.
Just for the record both of my paternal grandparents were alcoholics, my paternal grandfather died at 46 and my paternal grandmother at 61. By all accounts she was extremely difficult to live with. I met her twice when I was very young. My maternal grandparents were both in vaudeville and practically destitute. My family income in real terms is orders of magnitude above theirs and so are the family incomes of all of my siblings. There’s something more than chance going on here.
In closing I’d like to ask Mr. Kristof a question. Judging by what you’ve written in your columns over the years the policies that you favor have been the dominant policy strain in the U. S. for the last 70 years. Is there more or less opportunity in the United States today than when you were a kid?