Doing the Wrong Thing

I see that New York Times reporters are still jumping through their rear ends in what should be a futile attempt to avoid the obvious in the, as they put it, “winding” story of Sec. Clinton’s emails:

WASHINGTON — Earlier this summer, the inspector general of the nation’s intelligence agencies contacted the longtime lawyer for Hillary and Bill Clinton with a pointed question. Classified information had been found in a small sample of 30,000 messages from the former secretary of state’s private email account. The inspector general, I. Charles McCullough III, wanted to know from the lawyer, David E. Kendall, where copies of the message collection might still be stored.

Let’s stop right there. Here’s the definition of “sample”:

a small part or quantity intended to show what the whole is like. “investigations involved analyzing samples of handwriting”

The sample examined by the IG was small: 40 emails. 10% of them were found to contain classified material. If the sample was representative of the whole, not necessarily the case but possible, that would translate into 1,000 of the emails containing classified material. That is not small.

In the balance of the examination of the twists and turns in the story, they never hit on what’s obvious to anyone who’s not hopelessly biased: what Sec. Clinton did was wrong. She shouldn’t have done it. It was confessedly a breach of regulations which, if punished even at a nominal level, would result in huge fines and even jail time because of the magnitude of the breach. It was at the very best a grave lapse of judgment and at the worst a criminal conspiracy to hide wrongdoing.

The higher the office held by a public servant the higher the standard to which their behavior should be held, not lower. I’d say that about any Republican, Democrat, and even about someone I liked and with whom I agreed.

10 comments

Dealing With Illinois’s “Debt Bomb”

The editors of the Chicago Tribune call the Powers-That-Be here in the state of Illinois to take our fiscal problems seriously. I agree with their closing paragraph:

At some point — maybe now — Democratic leaders have to decide: Will we keep blocking reforms that would cut government costs? Or will we tell our union allies the truth? We can compromise to rescue failing governments. Or we can let them, and many union jobs, implode.

The question I think we have to ask is why is Mike Madigan, speaker of the Illinois House and the real power in the state, doing nothing? I think it’s because regardless of what he chooses to do, he loses. Like Marley’s Ghost, he wears the chains he forged in life. We’re all wearing them. He’s hoping somebody comes along who’ll share that burden with him and Gov. Rauner is refusing to play along.

0 comments

What I Think About the Iran Deal

I’ve been struggling to explain what I think about President Obama’s incipient deal with Iran and in those post I’ll try to do a better job at that. The quick summary of what I think about it is that Iran gets a great deal while the U. S. gets practically nothing if anything. I don’t think the deal is either a sign of the Apocalypse or a tremendous victory.

To understand why I think those things you’ve got to examine your assumptions. As I see it there are three practical possible assumptions:

  • Iran is building a nuclear weapon.
  • Iran isn’t building a nuclear weapon
  • Iran is seeking “breakout capability”, the ability to build a nuclear weapon over a period of months, but can be dissuaded from doing that

There are other prospective assumptions but I don’t think they have any strategic difference from those three. For example, you might think that Iran is working on achieving “breakout capability” and can’t be dissuaded from building a nuclear weapon once they’ve accomplished that. From a strategic standpoint that’s no different from Iran building a nuclear weapon, the first assumption.

The reason i characterize these as assumptions is that we honestly don’t have any incontrovertible proof for any of them. They are all reasonable interpretations of the known facts, just more or less likely.

Now let’s look at different courses of action in the light of those assumptions.

Assumption Course of action Outcome
Iran is building a nuclear weapon The president’s deal is a disaster. If you assume that Iran is building a nuclear weapon, that means they’re doing it covertly, they’ve bamboozled our intelligence apparatus, and undoubtedly will continue to do so. The deal does nothing to change that while allowing them more resources to do it with.
  Letting the sanctions remain in place even if they decay over time is not so bad. At least it keeps the pressure on the regime up.
  Letting the sanctions remain in place and taking action to bolster them. is even better. We do have some influence in the world, including over Germany, Russia, and China. We have lots of carrots and sticks at our disposal.
Iran is not building a nuclear weapon. The president’s deal We don’t get anything from the deal. The Iranians give up nothing and get sanctions relief. Sanctions relief for the Iranians is not a win for us because we have interests other than Iran’s nuclear development program.
  Letting the sanctions remain in place is not so bad. We gain a little time. We lose nothing.
  Letting the sanctions remain in place and taking action to bolster them would be even better because we lose nothing and gain even more time.
Iran is seeking “breakout capability” but can be dissuaded from building a bomb The president’s deal might contribute to the process of dissuading them.
  Letting the sanctions remain in place even if they decay over time might aggravate matters with the Iranians a little but probably not much.
  Letting the sanctions remain in place and taking action to bolster them would actually make things worse by giving the Iranians more motivation to build a bomb.

and that’s the calculus that leads me to my view. Do nothing. Leave the sanctions in place even if they decay over time, even if they decay pretty quickly. It minimizes downside risk.

The president’s plan looks best if you assume that the Iranians are seeking “breakout capability” but can be talked out of building a bomb. I think the evidence for that is extremely weak.

Note that I don’t include war with Iran as one of the possible courses of action. That’s consistent with the view I’ve expressed before: preventive war is immoral and illegal.

13 comments

Policies Matter

I have severely conflicted feelings about Nicholas Kristof’s most recent column, a lament for a classmate who, according to Mr. Kristof, did not realize his own potential:

Alan Krueger, a Princeton economist, has noted that in the United States, parents’ incomes correlate to their adult children’s incomes roughly as heights do. “The chance of a person who was born to a family in the bottom 10 percent of the income distribution rising to the top 10 percent as an adult is about the same as the chance that a dad who is 5 feet 6 inches tall having a son who grows up to be over 6 feet 1 inch tall,” Krueger observed in a speech. “It happens, but not often.”

I’ve been reflecting on this because of a friend in my hometown, Yamhill, Ore. Rick Goff was smart, talented and hard working, but he faced an uphill struggle from birth; I wrote about him last year as an example of the aphorism that “talent is universal, but opportunity is not.”

I want the United States to be a “land of opportunity”. What policies would accomplish that? Does it even mean the same thing as it did in 1850? In 1950? Are the metrics Mr. Kristof cites even relevant? For example, the countries that have considerable “intergenerational income elasticity” are (in order of more elasticity) Japan, Germany, New Zealand, Sweden, Australia, Canada, Finland, Norway, and Denmark. The countries with very little elasticity (in increasing order) Switzerland, the United States, Argentina, Italy, United Kingdom, Chile, Brazil, China, and Peru. Are we more like Finland, a small country in which 90%+ of the people are ethnic Finns, cultural Lutherans, and speak Finnish, an obscure language spoken by only a handful of people outside of Finland, or are we more like the United Kingdom, a country with whom we share a language, historic, cultural, and economic ties? Should we be more like Finland? Can we be more like Finland? In Canada what are your prospects if you are Francophone rather than being Anglophone?

I also note that all of the countries being held up as paragons of intergenerational income elasticity have much more exacting immigration laws than we do and they enforce their laws. Does that make a difference. Has the intergenerational income elasticity in the United States increased or decreased since 1965?

I’m also suspicious of this passage in Mr. Kristof’s column:

Rick, who thought he was one-eighth American Indian, pretty much raised himself, along with his brother and two sisters. His mom died when he was 5, and his dad — “a professional drunk,” Rick once told me — abandoned the family. A grandmother presided, and the kids hunted and fished to put food on the table.

Does it matter what he thought? If Mr. Kristof is trying to blame Mr. Goff’s problems on racial animus? That seems far-fetched to me. The conclusion I draw is that opportunities can be limited in rural areas and Mr. Kristof is the exception there rather than the rule.

Just for the record both of my paternal grandparents were alcoholics, my paternal grandfather died at 46 and my paternal grandmother at 61. By all accounts she was extremely difficult to live with. I met her twice when I was very young. My maternal grandparents were both in vaudeville and practically destitute. My family income in real terms is orders of magnitude above theirs and so are the family incomes of all of my siblings. There’s something more than chance going on here.

In closing I’d like to ask Mr. Kristof a question. Judging by what you’ve written in your columns over the years the policies that you favor have been the dominant policy strain in the U. S. for the last 70 years. Is there more or less opportunity in the United States today than when you were a kid?

16 comments

Counting Votes

The vote tally in the Senate is presently 54 Republicans, 44 Democrats, and 2 independents, both of whom caucus with the Democrats.

Let’s assume that the Republicans all vote against the Iran agreement. Both independents will vote “aye”. IMO there were several potential defections among the Republicans but the two most likely candidates for that, Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire and Mark Kirk of Illinois, both running for re-election in states that were carried by Obama in 2012, have made public statements that strongly suggest they will vote against the agreement.

Chuck Schumer has said he’ll vote against the agreement. That suggests 55 “nay” votes. Of the other Democratic senators running for re-election in 2016 I think that Bennett (Colorado) will vote for the agreement and Blumenthal (Connecticut) will vote against. That’s 56.

Several ranking House Democrats have already gone on the record as opposing the agreement.

That’s why the president’s truculent attitude about the agreement, so evident in his statement the other day, puzzles me. He can’t afford to lose too many votes in the Senate and getting up on his high horse and, if there are any Senate Democrats teetering, verbally abusing them might not be the best strategy for courting their favor.

My auld mither told me you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar. Apparently, President Obama’s mother did not do the same.

9 comments

It’s All the Fault of the English

True to their relentless demand for open borders everywhere, the editors of the Wall Street Journal blame the chaos at the port of Calais on the simple but probably futile desire of the English to remain English:

The EU has the right to secure borders and needs to invest far more in border protection, especially at sea. But an enforcement-only policy won’t work against hundreds of thousands of desperate migrants and wily traffickers. If Europe wants to channel the immigration flood, it will also have to broaden legal opportunities for orderly migration while loosening regulations that strangle employment opportunities for the poor, wherever they may be from. Immigration needn’t be a problem for societies that see human beings as opportunities, not burdens, and who prefer growth to redistribution in their economies.

In the final analysis if a country doesn’t have a right to say “no” to anybody, what right does it have to secure borders? It is impossible to will the end without also willing the means.

I have a much more likely candidate to blame for the chaos in Calais not to mention the thousands of refugees braving the Mediterranean to reach Italy and, ultimately, the prosperity of Germany and Northern Europe: American interventionism.

1 comment

Why We Lag in Reactor Design

There’s a good briefing from Cheryl Rofer at Physics Today on how the United States came to lag so far behind other countries in the design of nuclear reactors. The short version is that we chose the research approaches that had the most immediate military applications.

I still have hopes for small, modular nuclear reactors, especially those that use thorium for fuel. They have all sorts of advantages over our present reactor designs not the least of which is security. However, I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if the reactors of the future were designed in India. Necessity is the mother of invention after all.

0 comments

Emergent Strategies Require Grand Strategies

You might find James Holmes’s op-ed at Foreign Policy interesting. He opens his piece which advocates for a unitary straight line strategy in dealing with China by arguing that the U. S. suffers from the sheer multiplicity of strategies:

Me, I’d be slightly more circumspect about the state of China strategy in Washington. Call me a hairsplitter and a professor. But in reality, overabundance is the problem. President Barack Obama’s administration has more China strategies than it can shake a stick at, under the aegis of its pivot to Asia. They bear strange labels like “Air-Sea Battle,” “JAM-GC,” “offshore control,” and “archipelagic defense.” What the administration lacks is a settled strategy vis-à-vis the Asian titan.

which I believe reflects a misunderstanding of American culture and history as well as a misunderstanding of the nature of strategy. Throwing a grab bag of tactics into a hat doth not a strategy make. He goes on to advocate for a “sequential campaign”:

So let me add some sequentially minded principles for a winning strategy to those broached by Forbes. One: Set priorities among theaters, freeing up extra air and naval forces for deployment to the Far East. Self-discipline matching commitments with resources could convince China its sequential strategies will fall flat. Two: Enlist U.S. allies and partners to police their own neighborhoods, reducing the load on the U.S. hegemon. If, say, Europe took charge of the North Atlantic and Mediterranean, India oversaw the Indian Ocean, and Japan and South Korea set aside their differences to police Northeast Asia, new operational vistas would open up for American commanders.

Three: Devise operations that give the lie to the narrative Beijing has been spinning in recent years — namely that China is the rightful owner of Asian waters and skies, even those apportioned to its neighbors under the law of the sea. Use it or lose it should be Washington’s motto on freedom of the seas. In other words, any nautical freedom U.S. forces don’t exercise to its utmost is a freedom fated to vanish over time.

And Beijing’s island claims? Let’s ignore any claims to island outposts such as Scarborough Shoal or Mischief Reef, both deep within the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone. Chinese forces there are invaders — and are entitled to no legal standing beyond that customarily afforded invaders. Sail right by them early and often to make a point: Occupy these flyspecks if you must, but you have zero rights in adjacent waters or the skies overhead. Likewise, voyages should be charted to deny efforts to change the legal status of geographic features by “reclaiming” sand from the seafloor — in other words, by manufacturing artificial islands.

And four: Settle on a strategy for winning in wartime. Prevailing in peacetime strategic competition demands convincing observers you’d win in wartime. It’s tough to make a potential foe a believer in your capabilities and resolve if he thinks you’re strategically adrift. Strategic competition is a war of perceptions. To do better in that fight, let’s focus U.S. maritime strategy while making it more linear. Will doing so automatically deliver victory in this twilight struggle? Nope. But it’s a start. The more sequential Washington’s approach, the better.

I think that exhibits an ignorance of our society and history. We are a very large, diverse, historically egalitarian (at least aspirationally) country. Sequential strategies, especially in the modern day, require consensus that we have only rarely been able to muster or a hereditary aristocracy.

What we have had is an emergent strategy. As Chesterton pointed out a century ago in his book-length essay “What I Saw in America”, we are a country founded on a creed. That creed is presently being rocked by the forces of globalization, interests, and hypocrisy—our own failure to live up to our creed.

I don’t look forward to our abandoning that creed. To paraphrase what Chesterton wrote elsewhere when we abandon our national creed we will not believe in nothing. We will believe in anything and if you doubt it, look around you.

Meanwhile, I think that Mr. Holmes is thinking of some other country. The most we can hope for is a “cumulative campaign” and if he wants to find the force multipliers in that campaign he should look to our people, our culture, and our values—our “soft power” as Joseph Nye felicitously expressed it. China’s hard power, its military and economic force, attracts only the world’s worst dictators. It’s only by combining our own military and economic power with our soft power that we will arrive at a strategy for opposing China, to whatever degree that’s necessary.

0 comments

Why Did the Rate of Increase Slow?

Robert Samuelson muses over why the rate of increase in healthcare spending slowed for a few years only to start rising again:

“There’s a great debate about how much [of the slowdown] is due to the economy and how much is from health system changes,” says Drew Altman, head of the Kaiser Family Foundation, a health-care think tank. Altman figures that the weak economy was the main cause, explaining about 60 percent of the slowdown, as people “put off care that they [could].”

But when the economy recovers, the trend reverses. Not surprisingly, the CMS actuaries cite improving economic conditions as one factor fueling the rebound in health spending last year and in the future. Another factor in 2014 was an 8.4 million surge in Americans with health insurance, mostly reflecting the Affordable Care Act (ACA). People with insurance use more health services than people without.

Looking ahead, the CMS actuaries say that the aging population will boost spending as more people move into Medicare (up 19 million by 2024, or 37 percent) and Medicaid (also up 19 million, 33 percent). As people age, their health costs rise. Medicaid is hit both by an aging population — it covers nursing home care for the poor elderly and disabled — and liberalized eligibility requirements under the ACA.

Let’s clear up one misconception from the get-go. Healthcare spending never went down. Only its rate of increase went down.

That’s been part of the pattern of healthcare spending over the last half century. The rate at which spending increases goes in fits and starts but spending always increases and it continues to increase far faster than other spending.

You can’t appeal to market economics for explanations for all of this because healthcare does not operate under a market system.

0 comments

Poor Little Fellows

I think that George Will is being entirely too patronizing to Mexico:

Mexico is a casualty of a U.S. drug enforcement success. In the 1980s, the South Florida Task Force produced the “balloon effect” — squeeze a balloon in one spot, it bulges in another. The task force deflected sea-borne cocaine imports to Mexico. Hence today’s northward flow of drugs, southward flow of money and drenching flow of Mexican blood as the cartels war with one another and with Mexico’s federal, state and local governments.

Mexico is an independent country with the resources to deal with its own domestic problems. While the U. S. may aggravate Mexico’s problems, it doesn’t create them. It’s quite capable of creating its own problems and dealing with them as well.

We didn’t create narcotics gangs in Mexico. We aren’t forcing the Mexicans to use drugs at an accelerating rate. We are not responsible for every bad thing that happens everywhere in the world.

3 comments