Working Dogs

More dog days stuff. Check out this story of real working dogs.

Here at Camp Schuler we believe that dogs are happier when they have jobs. The joy that dogs bring to the work they were born to do is something you’ve got to see to understand.

Maybe that doesn’t just apply to dogs.

3 comments

U. S. Government Needs to Start Getting a Clue Fast

Do you remember that exploit of the federal government? Not the breach of security at the Office of Personnel Management but the the breach before that where Russian hackers made off with the personal information of people using the IRS’s website? Well, as it turns out the extent of the breach was understated by an order of magnitude:

WASHINGTON—The Internal Revenue Service said identity thieves’ penetration of one of its computer databases was much more extensive than previously reported, with more than 300,000 taxpayer accounts potentially affected and more than 600,000 breaches attempted.

The IRS reported in May that cyber crooks used stolen Social Security numbers and other data acquired elsewhere to try to gain unauthorized access to prior-year tax return information for about 225,000 U.S. households. That included about 114,000 successful attempts and 111,000 unsuccessful ones.

On Monday, the agency said its review showed that an additional 390,000 taxpayers were potentially affected. That includes about 220,000 additional households “where there were instances of possible or potential access” to prior-year return data, the IRS said in a statement. It also includes about 170,000 additional instances of “suspected attempts that failed to clear the authentication processes,” it added.

I don’t know about you but I find this story very distressing. We need to start taking cybersecurity much, much more seriously. If the federal government is incapable of dealing with the threat itself, start issuing letters of marque.

The world is really much different than it used to be. The effort against cybercriminals can’t operate in government time.

I’m also amazed this story isn’t getting more attention. An enormous number of people are at risk. And people wonder why I don’t file my taxes or do my banking online.

6 comments

Losing the Middle East

For the last few days there’s been a blogospheric food fight, sparked by South Carolina Sen. (and Republican presidential aspirant) Lindsey Graham’s complaint that President Obama was responsible for “losing Iraq”, a judgment in which as noted by Tom Maguire, the New York Times concurred. John Hinderaker piled on. As was to be expected John Amato denied it. I have a vague recollection of some of the president’s defenders making the same argument that Noam Chomsky did about “losing China” (the original country to which the appellation was applied more than a half century ago): it wasn’t ours to lose.

Now, honestly, none of that interests me. What does interest me is a little quote from Gen. David Petraeus that Tom Maguire dredged out of an interview conducted with him in March. Here it is:

Where I think a broader comment is perhaps warranted has to do with the way we came to think about Iraq and, to a certain extent, the broader region over the last few years. There was certainly a sense in Washington that Iraq should be put in our rearview mirror, that whatever happened here was somewhat peripheral to our national security and that we could afford to redirect our attention to more important challenges. Much of this sentiment was very understandable given the enormous cost of our efforts in Iraq and the endless frustrations that our endeavor here encountered.

In retrospect, a similar attitude existed with respect to the civil war in Syria — again, a sense that developments in Syria constituted a horrible tragedy to be sure, but a tragedy at the outset, at least, that did not seem to pose a threat to our national security.

But in hindsight, few, I suspect, would contend that our approach was what it might — or should — have been. In fact, if there is one lesson that I hope we’ve learned from the past few years, it is that there is a linkage between the internal conditions of countries in the Middle East and our own vital security interests.

The emphasis is mine and it is there that my questions arise. If the internal affairs of other countries, whether in the Middle East or elsewhere, are also our internal affairs which would give us the right to intervene in them, how is that to be distinguished from colonialism? Doesn’t the same argument apply to Russia’s intervening in Ukraine? Or in Syria?

I don’t think there is such a distinction.

I, on the other hand, would prefer to consider our relationship with the Middle East in terms of mitigating risks rather than “vital security interests”. How do we mitigate the risks posed to us by unstable, malignant, or even outright antithetical governments in the Middle East? I can think of a half dozen different ways, none of which involve going to war with them or overthrowing their governments.

10 comments

The Dog Days of Summer, 2015

We have reached the end of the dog days of summer, that time of year around the conjunction of Sirius, the “dog star”, with the sun and what better way to commemorate them than with the story of a real dog?

The dog in question’s picture is at the top of this post. That’s Ziva, the newest member of our pack. Ziva is 6 years old, Nola’s half sister and Kara’s aunt. We picked her up on Saturday and brought her home. She’s a very sweet, gentle dog and is already quite attached to Nola and Kara.

She’s still a bit confused about this tremendous change in her life but I think she’s settling in nicely. My wife and I are committed to seeing to it that she has the happiest, healthiest, most fulfilling life we can give her.

That’s a commitment I don’t know that other dog owners feel as keenly as we do. We don’t think it’s enough that we own the dog. We believe in taking a dog into our home we are making a commitment to that dog not only to feed her and care for her but for her life. We want her to have a worthwhile life that means something and will do our best to make that happen.

5 comments

I Doubt That Obama Is Anti-Semitic

Normally, the kerfuffle over Republican presidential nomination aspirant Dr. Ben Carson suggesting that President Obama is anti-Semitic:

Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson says he believes some of President Barack Obama’s actions are anti-semitic.

“I think anything is anti-Semitic if it’s against the survival of a state that is surrounded by enemies and by people who want to destroy them and to sort of ignore that and to act like everything is normal there and that these people are paranoid is anti-Semitic,” Carson said on “Fox News Sunday.”

Carson did not specifically mention the Iran nuclear agreement, but said during a recent visit to Israel he could not find a single person who “didn’t think this administration has turned its back on Israel.”

wouldn’t interest me and I’d just ignore it. However, since it ties in with themes I’ve mentioned here before, I thought I might comment on it. Presumably, the logic goes something like this. The Iranians are determined to build a nuclear weapon. The president’s Iran deal leaves Iran on the path to building a nuclear weapon, either covertly now or, after the deal’s expiration date, in fifteen years time. Iranian possession of a nuclear weapon is a threat to the existence of the state of Israel whether now or in the future. Threatening the existence of the state of Israel is synonymous with anti-Semiticism. Consequently, President Obama is anti-Semitic.

I doubt that President Obama shares any of those assumptions. I don’t think that he believes that the Iranians are determined to develop nuclear weapons, that Iran’s thirst for nuclear weapons won’t be moderated with the passage of fifteen years, or that allowing a persistent threat to the state of Israel is ipso facto anti-Semitic. I have no idea what his views on the state of Israel are or whether he believes that Iranian possession of a nuclear weapon is an existential threat to Israel. I suspect that he is sincere in the claim that he has made any number of times that the deal that has been negotiated leaves Israel safer than it would be without it.

I think that the president makes the same error in dealing with the Israelis that he does in dealing with the Republicans (does that mean he is “making common cause” with the Iranians?): he dismisses the Israelis’ concerns as illegitimate and frivolous rather than taking them seriously. Disagreement with him about the Iranian deal is not provably wrong any more than it is necessarily emblematic of reflexive partisan opposition to the president’s policy positions.

It is possible for intelligent people to have different assumptions, different preferences, different appetites for risk, and it should be possible for them to disagree without being accused of bad faith. Let’s curb the accusations of anti-Semiticism and of purely partisan motives. They’re not persuasive; they’re barriers to persuasion.

9 comments

What Law?

Hillary Clinton’s supporters have been vehement in claiming the complete innocence of Sec. Clinton in the matter of her covert private email server, further claiming that the entire matter is a non-scandal and purely political contrivance. What law has she broken? Former attorney general and long-time judge Michael Mukasey answers the question in a Wall Street Journal op-ed:

It is a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment for not more than a year to keep “documents or materials containing classified information . . . at an unauthorized location.” Note that it is the information that is protected; the issue doesn’t turn on whether the document or materials bear a classified marking. This is the statute under which David Petraeus—former Army general and Central Intelligence Agency director—was prosecuted for keeping classified information at home. Mrs. Clinton’s holding of classified information on a personal server was a violation of that law. So is transferring that information on a thumb drive to David Kendall, her lawyer.

Moving up the scale, the law relating to public records generally makes it a felony for anyone having custody of a “record or other thing” that is “deposited with . . . a public officer” to “remove” or “destroy” it, with a maximum penalty of three years. Emails are records, and the secretary of state is a public officer and by statute their custodian.

The Espionage Act defines as a felony, punishable by up to 10 years, the grossly negligent loss or destruction of “information relating to the national defense.” Note that at least one of the emails from the small random sample taken by the inspector general for the intelligence community contained signals intelligence and was classified top secret.

To be sure, this particular email was turned over, but on paper rather than in its original electronic form, without the metadata that went with it. If other emails of like sensitivity are among the 30,000 Mrs. Clinton erased, that is yet more problematic. The server is now in the hands of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, whose forensic skills in recovering data in situations like this are unexcelled.

The highest step in this ascending scale of criminal penalties—20 years maximum—is reached by anyone who destroys “any record, document or tangible object with intent to impede, obstruct or influence the proper administration of any matter within the jurisdiction of any department or agency of the United States . . . or in relation to or contemplation of any such matter.”

So, for example, if Mrs. Clinton caused to be wiped out emails that might have been anticipated to be of interest to a congressional committee, such conduct would come within the sweep of the statute. That, by the way, is the obstruction-of-justice statute, as revised by the Sarbanes-Oxley law, passed by Congress in 2002 while Mrs. Clinton served as a senator, and for which she voted.

In the event that the investigation actually becomes a criminal prosecution to be sure Sec. Clinton is entitled to the presumption of innocence. Such a presumption does not pertain to political judgments and IMO in that area only the most stubborn supporter could leap to her defense. Far from being a contrivance of her political enemies this entire matter is what is called in baseball an “unforced error” which should, at the very least, bring the Secretary’s judgment into question.

11 comments

The Hotel California Budget

George Will kvetches about long-obsolete budget items that somehow never end:

Federal funding went to whaling museums in three states from which whalers went to sea (Massachusetts, Alaska and Hawaii) and in Mississippi, which was not a home of whalers but is the home of Sen. Thad Cochran (R), an Appropriations Committee titan. The whaling program, which cost about $9 million in its last year, was administered by the Education Department. It objected to doing this, which is one reason the funding ended: Government changed because part of it was annoyed. Also, a congressman publicized the subsidy.

The $9 million was a piddling smidgen of a fraction of the federal budget, as is the $5 million wool and mohair subsidy. It was smuggled into the 1954 National Wool Act, which was supposed to stimulate wool production, lest we run short when next we need 12 million uniforms for a two-front world war. Mohair had nothing to do with this supposed military necessity, but mohair producers wanted a seat on the gravy train.

There are thousands of such budget items. They check in but they never check out for the reasons Mr. Will outlines.

However, I don’t think that Mr. Will recognizes a tenth of government at all levels’ problems in this regard. It isn’t only budget items. Regulations are rarely ever revisited let alone removed. No bureaucrat was ever criticized for leaving his predecessors’ diktats intact. Regulations are piled on top of one another like Ossa on Pelion.

And that goes for the way in which governments run their affairs as well. When new reporting is required it never goes away. Decades after some nameless department head demanded such-and-such a report from his underlings, civil servants continue to faithfully fill out the paperwork. The next department head will make his or her own pet report part of the routine. It’s no wonder that public employees feel overworked.

Sadly, other than a vigilant and ruthless legislature, something we’ve lacked for most of our history, there are no appealing solutions to the problem. Prior to the Civil Service Code, every new administration swept in with a completely new staff, from department heads to janitors, all political appointees. That swept away the chaff but it also swept away the wheat.

In theory we’ve professionalized government. In practice we’ve frozen the spending, regulations, organizational structures, and approaches of the past in place like a fly in amber.

11 comments

After the Bath

Yesterday my wife sent me this picture of our Australian Shepherd, Smidge, with the caption “Just for the record, I may be clean but I don’t like it.”

0 comments

Noah Smith on the Chinese Devaluation

Over at Bloomberg I see that Noah Smith agrees with me that the idea that the Chinese devalued their currency to prepare it for internationalization is daffy:

The big question is: “Why is this happening?” There are three major theories. The first is that China is responding to an economic slowdown by depreciating its currency in order to stimulate exports. The second is that China is responding to market pressures, which are pushing the yuan lower due to the aforementioned downturn. The third is that China’s government is simply preparing the country’s currency for internationalization, in accordance with the recommendations of the International Monetary Fund.

Let’s start with the third theory, which — I’m sorry to say — makes no sense at all.

Basically, he questions the timing.

To me, the “internationalization” explanation seems to fit with a general tendency of commentators — both Western and Chinese — to portray the Chinese government as all-knowing, wise and in firm control of the economy. As my Bloomberg View colleague Justin Fox recently wrote, this probably isn’t the case.

He also dismisses the “market pressures” theory, for the same reasons I have:

If the yuan is overvalued, then markets want to sell it, and the government is merely giving them the opportunity to do so, in order to avoid a more dramatic downward revaluation later on. That would seem to fit with stories of increased capital flight from China. If people really do think the yuan is overvalued and the economy is about to slow dramatically, it would be a reason to pull money out of the country (though doing so is difficult because of capital controls).

But few are willing to claim that the yuan is overvalued. For more than a decade, the conventional wisdom has been that China keeps its currency pegged artificially low in order to stimulate exports — a policy generally known as mercantilism. If that is the case, then China’s devaluation is simply more of the same — an attempt to ward off recession by making the currency even more undervalued.

As he says, either way it’s not a good sign for the Chinese economy.

I remain skeptical that devaluing the yuan will draw the American consumer out of hibernation. For one thing the American consumer isn’t in hibernation and household debt is rising, sadly without the deleveraging that I’m being told is necessary to restore the economy to good health.

2 comments

He’s Not Encouraging Me

Charles Lane muses over whether we’re reaching one of those highly fragmented moments in American history:

If anything’s constant in American political life, it’s the stable two-party system, jostled occasionally by third-party presidential challengers such as Ross Perot in 1992 and 1996 or Theodore Roosevelt in 1912.

Yet, more rarely, at times of extreme political flux, this society has broken up into four parties.

In 1948, the first post-World War II presidential election year, Republicans ran against three Democratic party factions: Harry Truman’s pro-New Deal, anti-Communist majority wing (which won in November), a Southern-based segregationist offshoot led by Strom Thurmond, and pro-Communist bolters headed by former vice president Henry Wallace. The latter two polled more than 1.1 million votes each out of 48 million cast; Thurmond got 39 electoral votes.

In 1860, as the country and its political parties came apart over slavery, the Republicans, northern and southern Democrats and a residual Whig body called the Constitutional Unionists fielded candidates for the White House. All four captured electoral votes; Abe Lincoln’s victory gave way to the Civil War.

If he’s trying to cheer me up, he’s not succeeding. Within a year or so of each of those “four party moments” we were at war.

1 comment