The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

The Logic of “Breakout Capability”

I want to solicit from my audience (or, possibly, audient) an explanation of the strategic significance of “breakout capability”. The CIA defines it:

Knowledge, infrastructure, and materiel, which usually lie beneath the threshold of suspicion, but which can be rapidly adapted or reorganized to allow for weaponization processes to be undertaken. Such capabilities require pre-disposed resources and often employ dual-use technology, equipment, or knowledge.

I understand the words but I don’t understand its strategic significance. For one thing has any country anywhere demonstrably sought “breakout capability” without subsequently going on to develop nuclear weapons? I can’t think of any.

This isn’t the 1940s. An ICBM can go from Nebraska to Tehran in just about a half hour and I presume the journey from Siberia or Xinjiang would be even shorter. So, taking the Iranians as our example, breakout capability wouldn’t deter us from doing anything we actually intended to do. The only candidate I can think of for such deterrence is Israel.

I’ve asked this question elsewhere without ever receiving an adequate answer.

28 comments

“Subject to the Jurisdiction Thereof”

The United States really is a remarkable country. There’s a lot of debate going on right now over just what the words “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” mean. That’s the part of the Fourteen Amendment to the Constitution granting what is referred to as “birthright citizenship”. Section 1 is the relevant portion of the amendment:

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

Under the common law it was assumed that all persons born within the realm had natural loyalty to the sovereign. In England that was the monarch. Here it was the country, as embodied in the system of declarations, laws, and agreements that constitute why G. K. Chesterton called us “a country founded on a creed”.

Until the Fourteenth Amendment was enacted and ratified in the wake of the American Civil War, citizenship was regulated and determined by the states. You were a citizen of a state and by virtue of that citizenship a citizen of the United States. As commerce from other countries to the United States became cheaper and easier, states increasingly tightened their regulations but the two principles on which states based their citizenship statutes were residence and allegiance. Not all states had citizenship laws and in those states the common law prevailed.

The Fourteenth Amendment was enacted to ensure that former slaves would be citizens of their states. Subsequent to the Fourteenth Amendment the law was that either you inherited your citizenship by virtue of your father having been a citizen or you became naturalized. Those were the alternatives. Then in 1898 a chap named Wong Kim Ark, who had been born in San Francisco in 1871 of Chinese parents, was denied re-admission to the United States after a trip abroad on the grounds that he wasn’t a citizen because his father wasn’t a citizen and he couldn’t become naturalized because immigrants from China were prohibited by law from being naturalized. He sued; the case went to the Supreme Court as United States v. Wong Kim Ark; the Court found in his favor 6-2. Since then nearly all children born in the United States are automatically citizens.

The question is being raised again by opponents of birthright citizenship in its present form. They may have a point. At the least it is not absurd. In most countries transients are not deemed to be “under the jurisdiction” of the countries they’re visiting for purposes of birthright citizenship for their children and it’s certainly not the case under the common law. Considering someone who entered the U. S. illegally, has repeatedly broken U. S. laws, e.g. filing and paying taxes, driving only with valid drivers’ licenses, etc., and voted in foreign elections as being under the jurisdiction of the United States seems a stretch to me. It all depends on whether you think that “under the jurisdiction thereof” and “physically in the country” mean the same thing.

For those who think that changing our present law would require a constitutional amendment, think again. The law as it is now was created by judges and it can be uncreated by them. Additionally, it’s possible that an act of Congress could reverse United States v. Wong Kim Ark.

29 comments

Which Law? (Again)

I’ve been saying all along that the laws that were likely to get Hillary Clinton into trouble were less likely to be the Espionage Act or the Intelligence Identities Protection Act or any of our other laws respecting government security (despite the petition from former intelligence officers that Sec. Clinton’s security clearance be suspended) but the Federal Records Act and the Freedom of Information Act. At least one of the judges involved in the case seems to agree with me:

A federal judge has added fresh fuel to the incendiary controversy over Hillary Clinton’s email, asserting during a hearing Thursday that she violated government policy by storing official messages on a private server when she worked as secretary of state.

“We wouldn’t be here today if this employee had followed government policy,” said U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan, apparently referring to Clinton, during a hearing on one of the many Freedom of Information Act lawsuits seeking access to her records as secretary of state.

Sullivan’s said Clinton’s actions had complicated the State Department’s ability to respond to requests for records on various topics. He also ordered the State Department to contact the FBI to determine whether the private server Clinton used, which Clinton turned over to that law enforcement agency earlier this month, contains official records possibly responsive to the FOIA suit.

After Justice Department lawyer Peter Wechsler argued that the open records law normally doesn’t allow for searches of government officials’ private accounts, the judge said he viewed it as an unusual situation because “there was a violation of government policy.”

Long-time jurist Emmet Sullivan has received appointments both from Republican and Democratic presidents including Bill Clinton. IMO he’s nopartisan operative, just a conscientious judge although I’m sure there will be complaints from partisans that the only possible motive for treating the case seriously is partisan, a charge I consider specious.

I’m honestly surprised that no one seems to be making a “fruit of the tree” argument relative to the emails on Sec. Clinton’s private server. It seems to me that since some of the emails were clearly work-related there’s a case to be made along those lines. Should Sec. Clinton’s staff or lawyers be making the determination as to which of the emails on that server are work-related and which aren’t?

18 comments

Things to Come

The story in the feature above is about recent research that suggests that U. S. companies with owners who are from countries in which cheating on your taxes is commonplace are more likely to cheat on their taxes than U. S. companies with owners who are from countries in which cheating is less common. I honestly don’t know how anyone can be surprised or distressed by that. As I’ve said any number of times before people bring their cultural and political assumptions with them when they come here. It’s true for investment as well as for corporate corruption.

The next time you hear someone touting immigration of people likely to start businesses as a strategy for boosting our economy keep in mind that the immigrants we get are more likely to come from Haiti or Venezuela (among the most corrupt countries in the world) than they are from Sweden or Denmark (among the least corrupt).

2 comments

You Never Hear the One That Gets You

There’s quite a bit of chatter about the economic problems in China. First a stock market crash, then the clear panic of the authorities over the crash followed by measures of mixed efficacy in propping the stock market up, and finally substantial damage to a major port as a result of an explosion. Keep in mind an attitude common in China: if something happens it’s either because the government made it happen or allowed it to happen.

My take: if we’re hearing about it, a serious economic downturn has already taken place in China. I always discount the official Chinese reports of economic growth by a percentage point or two.

0 comments

California Wolves

For the first time in decades California now has a small population of wolves:

California has its first wolf pack since the state’s gray wolf population went extinct in 1924.

State and federal authorities announced Thursday that a remote camera captured photos earlier this month of two adults and five pups in southeastern Siskiyou County.

They were named the Shasta pack for nearby Mount Shasta.

The pack was discovered four years after the famous Oregon wandering wolf OR-7 first reached Northern California.

As should have been expected ranchers are already complaining about possible predation.

Unmentioned in the article are some of the possible reasons that moved the newcomers to move to California. I suspect population pressures wherever they came from accompanied by a lack of game, even the small game wolves primarily rely on, due to drought.

It may be unnecessarily grim of me but I can’t help but wonder how soon these few wolves will be hunted out of existence in their new home.

3 comments

Touching the Right Bases

Mort Zuckerman touches the right bases in his plaint on the state of the U. S. economy namely:

  • The recovery has been and remains lackluster.
  • There will be another recession eventually, it will be sooner rather than later, and we aren’t well-equipped to deal with it.
  • The White House does not show any particular sense of urgency or even interest in the problem.
  • Those seeking the presidency from both parties don’t have much in the way of answers, either.

To which I’d add:

  • Even if you rely on the late recession having been a “balance sheet recession” it doesn’t make things any brighter. We haven’t deleveraged as much as we needed to in order to recover, neither party has proposed any policies that would have changed that, the policies they have proposed assumed it was an ordinary cyclic recession, and just because it was a balance sheet recession doesn’t preclude a cyclic recession being right around the corner.
  • Just as the Chinese require about a 7% growth rater to avoid social unrest, we assume about 4% growth. Failing to realize that is producing all sorts of problems, especially for retirees—slow growth is one of the reasons for the pension panic and the incipient collapse of state and local governments, e.g. Chicago and Illinois.
  • Mr. Zuckerman hasn’t proposed much in the way of solutions, either.

A persistent topic here at The Glittering Eye has been the structural changes we need to make. I’ve proposed dozens of them over the years. In the case of each and every one somebody’s ox will be gored which is why we are struggling like a fish on a gaff to avoid making them.

4 comments

Now, That’s What I’m Talking About

What if we could extract carbon from the air and use the extracted carbon to make carbon nanofibers or even diamonds and do it inexpensively? Some researchers at George Washing University say that we can:

A new method for taking carbon dioxide directly from the air and converting it to oxygen and nanoscale fibers made of carbon could lead to an inexpensive way to make a valuable building material—and may even serve as a weapon against climate change.

Carbon fibers are increasingly being used as a structural material by industries like aerospace and automotive, which value its strength and light weight. The useful attributes of carbon fibers, which also include electrical conductivity, are enhanced at the nanoscale, says Stuart Licht, a professor of chemistry at George Washington University. The problem is that it’s very expensive to make carbon fibers, much less nanofibers. Licht says his group’s newly demonstrated technology, which both captures the carbon dioxide from the air and employs an electrochemical process to convert it to carbon nanofibers and oxygen, is more efficient and potentially a lot cheaper than existing methods.

But it’s more than just a simpler, less expensive way of making a high value product. It’s also a “means of storing and sequestering carbon dioxide in a useful manner, a stable manner, and in a compact manner,” says Licht. He points out that if the process is powered by renewable energy, the result is a net removal of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. In a recent demonstration, his group used a unique concentrated solar power system, which makes use of infrared sunlight as well as visible light to generate the large amount of heat needed to run the desired reaction.

That’s exactly the sort of solution I’ve been talking about. Start looking around for applications for carbon nanofibers.

Lithium is not all that uncommon. It can be produced from seawater. You produce lithium carbonate by an interaction of lithium peroxide and carbon dioxide. Lithium peroxide can be made from the interaction of lithium metal with water.

12 comments

Farewell, Charcuterie!

For most of the last decade I’ve been saying that the EU’s agricultural policy needed a major overhaul and it’s beginning to look as though my predictions are coming true:

Unless France reforms agriculture in depth, farmers, meat purchasers and analysts say that some sectors — notably breeders — are set to go the way of coal mining, and disappear.

“The entire breeding sector, from pork to beef to milk producers, faces a huge competitiveness challenge,” Pascal Viné, the general delegate of the Coop de France group of agricultural firms, told POLITICO. “We’ve reached a point where we can no longer play for time and hope that prices will pick up.”

The latest crisis is partly explained by European Union economic sanctions on Russia, a huge export market for EU meat that has largely been shut off to farmers. Unable to sell to the east, farmers have flooded the European market with cheap meat products to drain supply.

While French industrial purchasers normally agree to absorb a set volume of local production at controlled prices agreed during roundtables, this time some of them balked over the huge difference between the cost of French meat and products from Germany or Spain — around 30 euro cents per kilo.

Let’s start by noting that when you get right down to it the purpose of the European Union is to provide agricultural subsidies to French farmers and subsidized export markets for German manufacturers. The purpose of the euro, on the other hand, is as a credible attack vehicle on the dollar.

There was never any way that French agricultural subsidies would ever survive an increasingly efficient German agricultural sector let alone the admission of Romania, a country about the size of France much of it devoted to agriculture.

0 comments