The Real Bolsheviks Were Like That, Too

I found Gary Rosen’s Washington Post op-ed contrasting the Democratic Socialists of America with the historical Bolsheviks sadly amusing. Here’s a snippet:

The Democratic Party is not in the grip of a “Bolshevik revolution,” as House Majority Leader Steve Scalise (R-Louisiana) claimed from the stage of the GOP’s midterm convention last week in Dallas. Nor is it true, as President Donald Trump declared, that “it’s going to be a communist country” if the Democrats win in November. House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-Louisiana) was a bit closer to the mark when he said, “Next year the communists will be in Congress.”

What’s fair to say is that a handful of this fall’s Democratic candidates, many of whom will no doubt win seats in Congress, are proud members of the Democratic Socialists of America, which revels in Marxist rhetoric and whose ranks include a not-insignificant minority of self-identified communists. This ideological insurgency is a gift in a big red bow for Republicans, who need to overcome Trump’s abysmal approval ratings, and a political nightmare for floundering Democrats. The fact of the DSA’s radicalism cannot be disputed.

The real question is how seriously to take it. I tend to think not very.

Clearly, he has not spent enough time with Lenin’s April Theses. In April 1917 the Bolsheviks were a minority, their program seemed wildly unrealistic to many contemporaries, and Lenin himself prescribed patient persuasion rather than an immediate seizure of power. Six months later they took power.

That does not make the DSA the Bolsheviks, nor is the United States of 2026 remotely comparable to Russia in 1917. But it does expose the weakness in Rosen’s argument. He is comparing today’s DSA with the Bolsheviks as they appeared after they had seized power. The relevant comparison would be with the Bolsheviks when they were still a relatively small radical movement that many contemporaries regarded as doctrinaire, unrealistic, and unlikely to govern.

The lesson of the Bolsheviks isn’t that every collection of starry-eyed radicals eventually becomes a dictatorship. Obviously it doesn’t. It is that being starry-eyed, naive, numerically small, or even faintly ridiculous is not evidence that a radical political movement should be taken unseriously. Political circumstances change.

And Russia was hardly the only country in the twentieth century in which a radical movement changed character rapidly as it acquired political power.

As additional counter-evidence, I would submit that bona fide Democratic analysts Ruy Teixeira and John Halpin take the possibility of an ideological capture of the Democratic Party considerably more seriously than Rosen does. Their concern is not that the DSA is about to storm the Capitol and establish a dictatorship of the proletariat. It is that a relatively small but highly motivated ideological faction can exert influence over a much larger political party out of proportion to its numbers. Cf. Ruy’s most recent post.

That strikes me as the question Rosen should be addressing.

7 comments… add one
  • steve Link

    This happens every election. Remember the claim that the Democrats were going to promote sharia law everywhere? remember the claim that they were defunding the police everywhere when it in about a dozen or fewer cities and was immediately reversed?

    Steve

  • Drew Link

    “…remember the claim that they were defunding the police everywhere when it in about a dozen or fewer cities and was immediately reversed?”

    Why yes I do. And the Atlanta mayor did just that. Now running away from her defund position as she runs for governor. Dave can speak to Chicago. LA. Baltimore. Portland. Seattle. Death cities. Washington DC. Oh, wait! A completely different approach.

    Deny it all if you want, Steve. You are lying. And people are dying. All for partisan gain.

  • steve Link

    Nope. I went through the police budgets of our 100 largest cities as did many other people. But let’s use the Republican claim. Jim Jordan claimed 21 cities cut police spending by $1 billon. However, multiple sources went over his list and what they was those 21 represented were budget proposals, not actual budgets. Only 70 of those budgets passed intact. In several cases the cuts were removed entirely and in others they were reduced and the following year they were all, except for Seattle I believe, increased.

    Atlanta? “One year ago this month, protests filled the city’s streets daily after the police killings of George Floyd in Minneapolis and, less than three weeks later, Rayshard Brooks in Atlanta. Pushing for changes to Atlanta’s police budget, over a thousand residents sent comments into the City Council — so many that the recordings had to be played over two days.

    Facing a June 30 deadline to pass the budget, the City Council discussed temporarily withholding $73 million of the Atlanta Police Department’s budget while the city considered changes to the way it polices. The effort failed on an 8-7 vote.”

    Homicides went up everywhere, not just in cities with Dem mayors. They also decreased everywhere, including cities with Dem mayors.

    https://www.ajc.com/news/atlanta-news/atlanta-almost-withheld-73m-in-police-funding-last-year-whats-changed-since-then/FEZOTN3G7NFCDFAMAI5BBBTVYY/

    Steve

  • steve Link

    Grrr. Meant 7 instead of 70.

    Steve

  • TastyBits Link

    @steve
    Sorry. The left owns the “Defund the Police” movement. Claiming that it did not exist because it failed proves that the supporters were incompetent. It was an intentional choice. Among the left, “Reform the Police” may not have been as popular, but it would have garnered more support from the right.

    The left dropped a turd, and now, they want to pass it off as an imaginary grilled cheese sandwich. I know a shit sandwich when I smell it.

  • steve Link

    I think several people here support the idea that actions rather than words reveal what people believe. So if so few cities actually cut funding, and all but one IIRC reversed it the next year, I think that reveals it wasn’t the preference of many of the (Democratic) politicians of those cities. In national voting pro-police politicians were elected.

    it remains a popular idea because of a couple of reasons. First, the right wing media keeps talking about it. They portray it as something that happened in a majority of cities and not a small minority that quickly reversed. The second major reason was that crime increased after the few cities did this. Of course the increase was nearly universal, seen in nearly all of the other cities that didnt defund. By the same token crime also decreased everywhere once covid was over.

    However, I will agree that the “defund the police” thing was horrible messaging. As you said it should have been reform (and modernize) the police. The dems probably do deserve some losses for not tamping that down sooner. In my mind it’s similar to the black lives matter thing. They should have made it black lives matter too. That implies all of the other lives already mattered and they wanted equal treatment. Instead they lost a lot of ground arguing with people about why their preferred group mattered. Like most of these “movements” (occupy wall street, tea party, maga0 it all gets taken over by the grifters anyway so maybe it doesnt matter.

    Steve

  • TastyBits Link

    @steve
    Again, sorry. This smelly steamer belongs to the left.

    The slogan was not “Defund the Police (until it proves a failure)” or “Defund the Police (if we can get enough council votes)” or some other exotic variation.

    Be Loud and Proud.

    (I am kinda surprised you let @Drew get off by calling Trump’s $5,000 bribe “red meat”.)

Leave a Comment