It’s Internet Traffic

A commenter to a post recently complained that LLM AI had induced a sharp increase in data center construction. The chart above puts the increase in data centers into historical context. The expansion of data-center capacity clearly predates the widespread adoption of LLMs. LLM AI may have accelerated that expansion, but it did not initiate it. It does illustrate increases, particularly since 2010, in utilization of the Internet. The iPhone was introduced in 2007.

In other words the demand for new data centers is a continuation of a process that has been going on for some time.

13 comments… add one
  • Zachriel Link

    Dave Schuler: LLM AI may have accelerated that expansion, but it did not initiate it.

    Data-centers != Internet traffic.

    You send an 83 character message to Deep Thought, “What is the answer to the ultimate question of life, the universe, and everything?” After seven and a half million years of calculation, it sends back two characters, “42”. Not much in terms of internet traffic. But quite a lot of computation.

  • No, data centers are all of the factors listed in my graph. They are data, websites, LLM AI, streaming video, and online shopping. They aren’t just transmission.

  • Zachriel Link

    Dave Schuler: No, data centers are all of the factors listed in my graph.

    Per the graph: “The data center line is a facility count (Synergy Research), a construction-activity proxy, not traffic volume.” New data-centers are much larger than older data-centers. Total capacity is doubling about every four years, with the newest gigascale campuses measured in gigawatts. Note that your graph is logarithmic. That by itself tells the story.

  • Exactly. Don’t want new data centers? Put down your smartphones. Stop streaming video.

    From your example in the modern era compute and other web services are products of data centers. Not merely data transmission. You’re trying to separate things that are interconnected.

  • Zachriel Link

    Dave Schuler: From your example in the modern era compute and other web services are products of data centers.

    Sure, but AI is a magnitude larger and quite likely soon to be two magnitudes larger. Things that are manageable at one scale may not be at another scale, especially when the scaling is very rapid.

    AI >> Search (traditional)

    Look at the log scale in your own graph. What shows as a linear trend is exponential growth.

  • Drew Link

    “Don’t want new data centers? Put down your smartphones. Stop streaming video…………………………. Not merely data transmission. You’re trying to separate things that are interconnected.”

    While Zach flails about, for some unknown reason, Dave plants a hammer on the nails head. Propaganda goes only so far. Explain to people what they are really opposing and it will end right now. Dems just perceive a poll driven election issue. Dishonest fucks, as always.

    For the umpteenth time, neither electricity nor water concerns will hold up to scrutiny or time; only media dishonesty will perpetuate it. The issue will be eminent domain. Fair treatment of those displaced, and NIMBY vs latency. And the sweet nectar of property taxes……..

    And to a recent post, “steamrolling” is just juvenile thinking. I’m here in GA. #3 in datacenters. They are incentivizing data centers, not getting steam rolled.

  • Zachriel Link

    Drew: And to a recent post, “steamrolling” is just juvenile thinking.

    Maybe you’re from a different world. But on Earth, just putting up a residential development can be fraught with backroom deals, real estate speculation and political shenanigans. With AI, you’re looking at potentially trillions of dollars over the next few years. If you don’t think that might be an issue, you might try visiting planet Earth. Nice place in a lot of ways.

    As for power, about 10% is projected to be consumed by AI by 2030.

    The problems can be addressed, but that requires first recognizing the problems.

  • steve Link

    I am not sure what the left side of your graph means but having done a bit of reading on thei recently its pretty clear that the term data center is not well defined and it encompasses facilities that are pretty different. The new hyperscaler centers are much larger and use much more in resources than older centers. Anyway, using different definitions as was apparently done at this link below you get very different numbers showing that the number of hypersclae centers went from about 400 in 2017 to 1100 in 2024. That is a large increase and the number of centers being planned (in the pipeline) is increasing.

    I think it’s fine if some places want to give companies tax breaks. I think it’s dishonest to then claim that places should want to have centers because it will increase tax revenue. It remains unclear to me why it makes you a NIMBY if you dont want to help finance something you dont want to begin with.

    https://www.fierce-network.com/cloud/picture-data-center-boom-charts

    Steve

  • Drew Link

    Nice try, Zach.

    I’m from the real world, not your childish fantasies. Governments are recruiting data centers. And factories, and Amazon distributors………,

    It’s called economic growth.

    Next thing I know people like you will be telling me global warming will kill us all by 1990, Covid requires government overlords, and now, AI is going to dismember our children in a programming error.

    Grow up. The world adapts. Your philosophical views end up in the toilet.

  • Zachriel Link

    Drew: Next thing I know people like you will be telling me global warming will kill us all by 1990, Covid requires government overlords, and now, AI is going to dismember our children in a programming error.

    We don’t hold those positions, so those are strawman arguments, fallacies of diversion. Ignoring the points raised is a fallacy of irrelevance. As suggested, start with ordinary development. Your position appears to be that ordinary development never entails any issues of corruption whatsoever. Your reply is that pointing this out means being against development, which is a false dichotomy, a fallacy of presumption.

    When money is at stake, corruption often follows. The more money involved, the more pressure there is to cut corners, dumping problems on others. Accountability is the key to minimizing the issues associated with development. Rust never sleeps.

  • steve Link

    In Drew’s world Enron never happened. Only the government can be corrupt, incompetent or do stupid things.

    Steve

  • TastyBits Link

    The bigger question should be, “what is going on, really?”

    We have CEOs claiming they are developing technology that will end human civilization, and they must get it done as quickly as possible. Either they do not know what a collapsed civilization actually looks like, or they are psychopaths, or a combination.

    In a collapsed civilization, the laws are made by the strongest, and the strongest take what they want. I have seen Sam Altman, and any wealth he has left would be taken, quickly.

    AI data centers are qualitatively different than simple cloud data centers, but again, “what is going on, really?”

    We must build AI data centers as fast as possible, or we will lose the race to destroy civilization to China. Really, is Chinese civilization destrustruction worse than American civilization destruction? We outsourced everything else to China. Why not our own destruction? Cheap Chinese civilization destruction should be good for US consumers.

    Of course, the politicians will save us. Since they are as AI illiterate as the public, we must get the experts involved, and the experts are the same psychopaths that are building the civilization destroying technology. Now, we have psychopathic politicians in addition to the psychopathic CEOs.

    Then, we have investors pouring as much money as they can into a technology that will end human civilization and the entire society that makes their wealth retention possible. So, we can add psychopathic investors to the list.

    Nothing adds up.

  • TastyBits Link

    My bullshit meter is off the chart.

    For the past 30 to 40 years, the same people who had no problem with shipping our manufacturing capacity and technology to China are now telling us we cannot let China beat us in the AI race.

    I have no doubt that China can build and run cheaper data centers, and Chinese AI is cheaper than US AI. Suddenly, exporting production and importing finished goods is bad. Why the sudden change?

    Why is an American driving an imported Chinese vehicle better than a Chinese AI driving a domestic American vehicle? It does not make any sense?

    I expect to be chastised, but I suspect the reason is financial. The ten years being predicted is not the point civilization collapses but the point the financial structure collapses.

    Between government debt and private debt, the failure point is quickly approaching. It may be more or less than 10 years, but we are in the waning days of exotic financial engineering – government and private.

    Data centers and AI technology are the last remaining assets to be leveraged, and they represent the lifeboat these folks are trying to use to save their wealth and/or power. This is reason for the urgency.

    They are not predicting some Star Trek utopia. They are predicting the eminent collapse of human civilization, and the technology to accomplish it must be completed as quickly as possible. Nobody wants to “pump the brakes”. They want to put up guardrails and floor it.

    When we are not being terrorized with imminent destruction, we are assured AI will make life better by making things cheaper. One scheme to replace lost income is for the government to skim off this windfall and redistribute it as UBI.

    This makes no sense. The UBI required would need to be equal to the price of the goods it was used to buy. This would mean producers using AI would see 0% ROI, and even a simpleton like me can see that is a bad deal. At this point, financial engineering would result in hyper-hyperinflation.

    AI did not create the financial collapse event horizon. It just quickened the arrival. All the same bad actors are shoveling the same bullshit. Some of them are aware they are shoveling, but most are just spooked by the herd leaders. I suspect that some of the pushback has a similar origin. People have been screwed over by these scumbags, and their bullshit detectors are in the red.

    The community’s complaints may not be justified, but when all the usual suspects are telling you, “nothing to see here, move along”, it is best to be wary.

    I expect a lecture and informed that I am incoherent, but could somebody explain how this works. Use simple words.

    (I do not mean that AI automates tasks and replaces some workers. I mean how does AI end human civilization? Bonus Question: How Sammy intend to keep his wealth after the end?)

Leave a Comment