Personal Enrichment, Public Service, and Private Philanthropy

The editors of the Wall Street Journal underscore a point I’ve been making pretty much since I began posting on this blog:

The Band memo reveals exactly what critics of the Clintons have long said: They make little distinction between the private and public aspects of their lives, between the pursuit of personal enrichment, the operation of a nonprofit, and participation in U.S. politics.

Mr. Band writes that he and his colleague Justin Cooper “have, for the past ten years, served as the primary contact and point of management for President Clinton’s activities—which span from political activity (e.g., campaigning on behalf of candidates for elected office), to business activity (e.g., providing advisory services to business entities with which he has a consulting arrangement), to Foundation activity.”

This excerpt and all the potential conflicts it describes, plus Chelsea’s warning about business “hustling” at foundation events, would seem more than ample cause to trigger an IRS audit of the foundation. For that matter, why aren’t the IRS and prosecutors already on the case? Any normal foundation has to keep records to show it is separating its nonprofit activity from any for-profit business.

Mr. Band’s memo confirms that donors were not seeking merely to help the sick and the poor. He explains that the Clinton Foundation had “engaged an array of fundraising consultants” over the past decade but “these engagements have not resulted in significant new dollars for the Foundation.” In other words, it wasn’t working as a conventional charity.

Mr. Band then explains how he and his Teneo partner Declan Kelly had to carry the fundraising load, and did so by packaging foundation solicitations with other services such as a meeting with Bill Clinton, $450,000 speeches or strategic advice. Many of the donations, from U.S. companies like Coca-Cola and Dow Chemical and foreign firms like UBS and Barclays, occurred while Hillary Clinton was Secretary of State.

Why exactly were donors writing checks? The Band memo makes clear that donations untied to additional Clinton or Teneo services weren’t all that appealing to potential supporters. This is significant, because the large grant-making foundations in the U.S. are almost entirely run by Clinton voters. So you know they weren’t turned off by the brand name. They’d contribute more if they thought they were also buying goodwill and influence with a current Secretary of State and a potential future President.

which is that elected officials inevitably come to conflate their own personal benefit with the public good. It isn’t unique to the Clintons; in fact the Clintons aren’t particularly distinguished in it other than by scale. It isn’t limited to one political party. I think it’s a human characteristic.

And it’s corrupt. In some cases it’s amazing that any public business is conducted at all. That’s certainly the case in Illinois where public business is not in fact being conducted but public money continues to flow to the law firms, etc. of elected officials.

The solutions are to keep elected officials on much shorter leashes, to give them greater scrutiny, and limit their terms of office.

11 comments

Fighting Words

In a race for the North Carolina legislature heated campaigning went beyond an exchange of words. The Bladen Journal reports:

According to witnesses, Republican District 46 candidate Brenden Jones and Democratic candidate Tim Benton were exchanging words Saturday afternoon at the main entrance to the festival near U.S. 242.

“Some flyers have evidently been circulating saying Mr. Benton was involved in (a white supremacy group), and he was accusing Mr. Jones of being responsible for the flyers,” said eyewitness Woody Hester. “Mr. Jones told him he wasn’t responsible for the flyers and there wasn’t anything he could do about it, and he suggested they continue the conversation across the street away from the crowd.

“Mr. Benton kept nudging him with his shoulder the whole time they were walking across, and then he just stepped back and little and coldcocked him,” he said.

“To beat all, he (Benton) left a little child in a stroller to walk across the street, and if Mr. Jones’ (companion) hadn’t caught her, the child would have rolled into the street,” Hester added.

I’m surprised there isn’t a lot more of this sort of thing. As Chesterton said, it is terrible to contemplate how few politicians are hanged.

More care should be taken with all of the reckless name-calling. There are such things as “fighting words” which justify a physical response and “racist” might just be one of them.

There is such a thing as principled disagreement and if we’re self-editing for fear of being called a racist, misogynist, etc. that too is a form of bigotry. Inferring bigotry from disagreement is fallacious and may even spill over to bigotry of its own. When every disagreement is bigotry nothing is and it distracts from identifying actual bigotry.

3 comments

The Quotable Eye

Recently, I’ve caught local news media quoting me at length without attribution. I’m not offended or upset by it and I haven’t complained about it. Actually, I think it’s funny.

What I think is happening is that they’re Googling for things, The Glittering Eye comes up, and they’re lifting paragraphs straight from my blog into their copy. Coming up with material day after day after day ain’t easy. I’ve been writing 2,000 words or more per day, seven days a week, 365 days a year for some time. That puts me up there with Dumas and way ahead of Hemingway, both of whom produced something every day as part of their daily routines. David Brooks, Nicholas Kristof, and George Will only need to produce 800 words a week.

I know I don’t do it right by social media standards. If I were to do it right, I would need to publish something on an hourly basis 24 hours a day. That would be too limiting.

Pretty obviously, plagiarism ain’t what it used to be. It does make you look differently at the media conglomerates’ pursuit of intellectual property violators. It’s as I’ve been saying for some time patent, copyright, etc. law isn’t there to protect the little guy from the big guy. It’s to give Goliath an edge over that upstart David.

0 comments

The Peculiar Silence

At War on the Rocks Richard Sokolsky and Jeremy Shapiro outline U. S. support for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia:

During the span of the Bush and Obama administrations, total U.S. arms sales to Saudi Arabia increased by nearly 97 percent. The U.S. has offered $115 billion in arms sales to Saudi Arabia during the Obama administration. Over the last three years alone — since the start of negotiations with Iran on its nuclear program — America has sold nearly $36 billion in arms to Saudi Arabia. These sales are certainly in the commercial interests of the United States and the American firms that manufacture the weapons. They create jobs, generate corporate profits, and improve the U.S. balance of trade.

But whether the massive sale of American arms to the Saudis serves U.S. geopolitical interests is a much more debatable proposition. U.S. military assistance to Saudi Arabia is a mere tool of American policy toward the Kingdom, not an end in itself. As such, it should serve broader objectives in the relationship. It should influence the Saudi government to make decisions that support American interests and priorities in the relationship and in the region more broadly.

There is a truly peculiar silence about our support for the KSA. The rulers of Saudi Arabia are certainly no better than the Assad regime and in many ways much worse. Mysteriously, we support the Saudi regime and oppose the Assad regime. In the Saudis’ war against Yemen 10,000 people, many of them civilians, have died and nearly a million have been displaced. And our fingerprints are all over the conflict from destabilizing Yemen to supporting the Saudis.

9 comments

NIGYSOB

I have the sinking feeling that over the course of the next four years we’re going to be subjected to the world’s largest and highest-stakes games of Now I’ve Got You, You Son of a Bitch.

1 comment

Probability Zero

I think that we can safely assign a probability of zero to John Kass’s suggestion in his Chicago Tribune column. Referring to Hillary Clinton and the reopening of the FBI’s investigation of her he writes:

What if she is elected? Think of a nation suffering a bad economy and continuing chaos in the Middle East, and now also facing a criminal investigation of a president. Add to that congressional investigations and a public vision of Clinton as a Nixonian figure wandering the halls, wringing her hands.

The best thing would be for Democrats to ask her to step down now. It would be the most responsible thing to do, if the nation were more important to them than power. And the American news media — fairly or not firmly identified in the public mind as Mrs. Clinton’s political action committee — should begin demanding it.

American politics isn’t responsible, prudent, or fair and the time to do that was in the primaries. Now for good or ill the Democrats are stuck with her. I think they’ll see it as good.

I do agree with him on one particular:

I’ve always figured that, as secretary of state, Clinton kept her home-brew email server — from which foreign intelligence agencies could hack top secret information — so she could shield the influence peddling that helped make the Clintons several fortunes.

The Clintons weren’t skilled merchants. They weren’t traders or manufacturers. The Clintons never produced anything tangible. They had no science, patents or devices to make them millions upon millions of dollars.

All they had to sell, really, was influence. And they used our federal government to leverage it.

There are other explanations but they require so many assumptions, the implications of which are even worse and less likely, that it would be amazing to me if most people even Sec. Clinton’s supporters believed anything else.

9 comments

Different Worlds

I think that Harvard scholar Danielle Allen has lurched uncontrollably on to a point I’ve been making here at The Glittering Eye for the last decade in her recent Washington Post op-ed. Most people are no longer literate; the way they obtain new information is primarily visual. However, I think she’s wrong in attributing political discord to that:

My hypothesis is that, as of summer 2015, the conversations in TV and radio land were barely visible within text-based journalism. Some of those conversations involved sustained criticism of the cultural authority of newspapers and universities. That criticism targeted the professional norms of these sectors, which now include a widespread commitment to gender and racial equality as well as to social equality in relation to sexual identity. That TV and radio land conversation also stirs up great attraction for towering figures of that landscape — Trump, for instance.

In launching his campaign, TV-titan Trump routinely exhibited disdain for the professional norms of newspapers and universities that require respectful language. He got away with it. A sizable number of Americans answered his call.

In the primary, his campaign tried to deploy the idea that he was puncturing a spiral of silence. They made widespread use of posters and signs claiming that Trump spoke for a “silent majority.” But those who answered Trump’s call throughout the primary were neither silent nor a majority. In the primaries, he crossed over the threshold to victory by means of a plurality, not a majority. And his supporters do participate in a big, public conversation — whether through Fox News or on talk radio or by passing pieces of the Drudge Report and Breitbart through social media.

In this campaign, we haven’t seen a silent majority suddenly awoken. Instead, we’ve seen a coming-of-age of a vocal minority that was nearly invisible to another vocal minority, the community of readers of traditional text-based journalism, a community dominated by the professional classes. Over the past nine months, these two minorities have been battling for the country’s soul.

While I agree that those who obtain information from the written word live in a different world from those who don’t, I don’t think that those are the worlds that are clashing. I think that two different primarily visual worlds, occupying the same landscape but viewing the events that occur completely differently and rarely intersecting, are colliding and the small remaining literate world has just now realized that the social and political landscapes are very different from what they thought they were.

Since coming back into the corporate world after decades in my own, cozy little company, one of the things that has been impressed on me is how few people are functionally literate. Being literate doesn’t just mean you can read the words in an email or on a page. It means you obtain information from reading. The differences between the literate world and the visual one aren’t superficial. They’re basic, as I’ve discussed at length. See my “Visualcy” subject for more. Communicators in an oral society tend to be additive, agonistic, redundant and repetitive, empathetic, and situational. Communicators in a literate society tend to be subordinative, analytic, objective, and abstract. My thesis is that a visual society more closely resembles an oral one than it does a literate one.

In today’s world we have virtual communities that rarely interact. When these societies are forced together, that they are both agonistic, empathetic, and situational makes an enormous difference. The interactions are unsettling and that’s what we’re seeing now.

3 comments

Crowd-Sourcing

I have a question, based on my general impression that there’s a lot of exaggeration these days. At what presidential political rallies has there been mass violence and by whom has it been perpetrated?

I don’t mean a single instance of someone slapping someone or punching them in the nose. I mean groups of people turning cars over, setting them on fire, or lobbing rocks at police. Stuff like that.

I don’t think there’s been much of it. Just list every instance you can think of.

7 comments

Grasping the Nettle

I found this article by Kelefa Sanneh at the New Yorker on immigration interesting. Right from the outset it starts tackling tough issues:

What, exactly, are our obligations to people in other countries who would like to come to this one? The argument over Syrian refugees is a good example of how our political conversation tends to sidestep this thorny issue. Ironically, strong opposition from Republicans made it easier for President Obama to avoid explaining how he had determined that ten thousand, not more, was the proper quota for Syrian refugees. Were there security concerns that prevented the U.S. from admitting, say, a hundred thousand? How many Syrian refugees—an estimated five million have fled the country’s civil war—would be too many? Obama didn’t have to entertain questions like these, airily insisting that “refugees can make us stronger,” and claiming, not implausibly, that some of his political opponents seemed to be deficient in “common humanity.”

If there is such an obligation, which countries bear it and why? Japan, for example, accepted fewer than 30 asylum-seekers in 2015 and fewer than 200 to date in 2016.

My own view is that there’s a distinction between virtue and obligation. It would be virtuous to accept genuine asylum-seekers but we are not obligated to do so. I’d be more comfortable if more of the refugees were being settled in Marin County, California, Westchester County, New York, and Fairfield County, Connecticut than in suburban Omaha or Indianapolis.

Our experience in accepting refugees from the Middle East and North Africa has not been particularly felicitous. Somali refugees have had unemployment rates north of 25% for decades and constitute a very large proportion of the Americans who’ve joined DAESH. And we shouldn’t forget that an astonishing proportion of the total number of Chechen refugees in the United States either perpetrated or were complicity in the Boston Marathon bombings, despite their having by all accounts very little to complain about in their treatment here.

Is it possible that there isn’t actually much of an analogy between Ashkenazic Jewish refugees 70 years ago and Middle Eastern refugees today?

10 comments

Controlling the Cities Isn’t Enough

I would have it was obvious. The reason the House of Representatives has a Republican majority is that the Democrats’ strength is in the cities and that runs afoul of the deliberately designed structure of the Constitution. That’s the gist of Jason Willick’s post at The American Interest.

That’s not a result of chicanery and it’s not unfair. It’s the rules of the game. If you don’t like the rules, change them. Or change your appeal.

The Democratic Party wasn’t always ultra-urban. For nearly 50 years of the 20th century Democrats controlled the House under the same rules as prevail today. But Democrats had much greater rural, small town, and suburban strength then than they do now.

But under the present rules and with the present Democratic Party strategy Republicans will maintain strength in the House if not outright control. Which is one of the reasons the Republicans won’t go the way of the Whigs whatever the outcome of the 2016 presidential election.

2 comments