Among the Many Major Parts…

I turned eagerly to this explication at The Conversation on how the Congress could address the problems with the Affordable Care Act only to be confronted by this:

The first question is what exactly do they want to repeal or fix. The ACA seems to have evolved into a great political Rorschach test somewhat devoid of real content but relying on projection of underlying beliefs.

For Republicans, it is evidence of governmental overreach and excess expenditures, while Dems seem to think of it as the essence of collective action and shared responsibility for those less fortunate. As such, neither informs the specific directions we might take from here.

In reality, the ACA consists of four major parts:

  1. Expansion of Medicaid for low-income working poor, with mostly federal financing.
  2. Research on alternative ways to treat conditions to inform physician practice.
  3. Tests of innovative ways to organize and deliver health care for better value that can be quickly implemented across the system.
  4. The exchanges, for purchasing subsidized individual policies from private insurance companies.

That prompted me to think about the Monty Python sketch shown above. Among the many major part of the ACA…

By what stretch are the last two major components of the legislation? They certainly weren’t what the CBO thought were the legislation’s major components. It thought they were:

  1. The Medicaid expansion (initially the largest part)
  2. The exchanges (eventually the largest part)
  3. The individual mandate
  4. The employer mandate
  5. The tax on “Cadillac plans”
  6. The excise tax on medical devices

to which I would add the regulations imposed upon qualifying insurance plans and EMR. Methodologically, you shouldn’t intermingle unquantifiable objectives with quantifiable ones which is what the author of the post seems to be doing.

2 comments

The One in Which Schuler Votes

They say we shouldn’t take selfies of ourselves voting but I couldn’t resist.

0 comments

Analyzing Markets

It’s not exactly a state secret that markets can be analyzed. The “marketing universe”, the total pool of hypothetical customers for any given product, can be divided into the “early adopters”—those who will buy readily, those who, eventually, will buy, and those who will never buy. That’s true of everything whether you’re talking about soap or healthcare insurance, as the architects of the Affordable Care Act are learning. And it’s true of roof-top solar panels, as this Reuters article notes:

California for years has required utilities to purchase excess rooftop solar power, paying homeowners in credits that lower their utility bills. But this so-called “net-metering” mandate capped the number of people who qualified for the most attractive incentive. In June, the utility serving Scripps Ranch, Sempra Energy (SRE.N) unit San Diego Gas & Electric, was the first to reach its limit, and the state’s other large utilities are expected to reach theirs soon.

Scripps Ranch homeowners who put up panels now still will be able to sell power they don’t use to the utility at the same retail rates as those who got in before the cap. But they will have to pay $100 to $200 more per year in fees and charges to SDG&E. They also eventually will be shifted to new, time-of-use power rates, which could result in lower credits.

Installers say such changes will be meager compared to the thousands of dollars in savings over the life of a system. But customers seem skeptical. At the peak, installers were putting up 55 systems a month, on average, in Scripps Ranch. In July and August – typically good months – installations dropped to 15 and 36, respectively.

Residential solar connections were down 25 percent in the third quarter compared to a year earlier in the utility’s entire San Diego territory.

“The phones just aren’t ringing as much,” said Ian Lochore, director of residential sales at Baker Electric in nearby Escondido.

A less dramatic slowdown is playing out across California, which produces about 40 percent of the nation’s residential solar.

The sector saw slower growth in the first half of the year, and declines in the third quarter. Installations in Pacific Gas & Electric’s service territory in Northern and Central California fell 7 percent year-over-year, while in Southern California Edison’s territory they fell 4 percent.

One of the morals of this story is that if you’re seeing declines like this in the most favorable market in the country for your product you’re probably nearing market saturation. Once a market is saturated the only way to get new customers is to take them from somebody else, presumably by selling a better product.

The other moral is that the roof-top solar panel business is a creature of government policy and what the government hath given it can darn well taketh away. Relying on swift and prudent stewardship on the part of a government agency is living in another world.

9 comments

Web Services

Speaking of web services, consider the market share of the major web services providers. It depicts a classic oligopoly with the early mover, Amazon, holding 31% of the market, Microsoft, the next largest, 9%, IBM holding 7%, Google 4%, Salesforce 4%, and a “long tail” dragging behind.

The market for web services will continue to bubble for a while. Amazon may hold onto its largest share or it may not. It’s basically a zero sum game of perfect information. There is a solution and it probably won’t settle on a single dominant provider.

0 comments

An IPO in Search of a Business Model

I can’t help but laugh when I read analyses of Amazon and this one from Steven Russolillo at the Wall Street Journal is no exception:

Amazon.com Inc. boss Jeff Bezos is fond of saying “your margin is my opportunity.”

Traditional retailers who scoffed at him 19 years ago when Amazon went public aren’t any more. Shareholders who stuck with the company, on the other hand, are laughing all the way to the bank with a 2,400% gain in the past decade.

Yet, with the e-commerce giant set to report its sixth consecutive quarter in the black on Thursday, the source of more than half of its pretax operating earnings in its most recent report, is someone else’s opportunity.

Amazon Web Services, the cloud-computing unit, will be affected by the offsetting trends of rapid growth and brutal competition that has left much of the market commoditized. Competitors such as Alphabet Inc.’s Google, International Business Machines Corp. and Microsoft Corp. are no dowdy brick-and-mortar merchants. What’s more, AWS might fetch far less as a stand-alone company than what its profits have helped tack onto Amazon’s market value.

Investors therefore need to do more than see if Amazon misses or beats analyst consensus third-quarter estimates Thursday. They will look for signs that its core retail business can eventually be highly profitable.

Massive investment in Amazon’s warehouse and delivery infrastructure makes its position increasingly difficult to challenge. Newer endeavors into music, groceries and apparel are starting to pay off, too. Amazon is expected to top Macy’s Inc. next year as the biggest apparel seller in the U.S., according to Cowen & Co.

From this he concludes that Amazon should focus on retail.

The mistake he makes is in thinking that Amazon’s roots are in retail. They aren’t. They’re in finance.

19 years ago I said that Amazon was an IPO in search of a business model and nothing the company has done over the intervening period has done anything but confirm that. In Amazon Web Services it’s finally found something it can make money doing. If I’m not mistaken retail is still running at a slight loss for Amazon, something that has moved Matthew Yglesias to call Amazon a not-for-profit operating for the benefit of the American consumer.

The “unicorns” of the future won’t be able to follow Amazon’s lead. Today you actually need viable business models in order to succeed. The mid-1990s were a unique time and we shall not see their like again. And don’t be surprised if Amazon disappears as mysteriously as it arrived, still searching for a business model. It will have given its investors a wild ride.

0 comments

The Washington Consensus Has Flopped

I strongly disagree with Laura Ingraham’s conclusion in her piece at LifeZette but I think her argument is obviously correct. Rather than forcing you to read it, I’ll summarize it. A long list of measures that have been part of the “Washington consensus”, a list of things on which Democrats and Republicans have largely agreed, have not worked as expected. These include:

  • Managed trade agreements have not made most American workers better off or reduced problems caused by illegal immigration.
  • The WTO has not protected the United States against unfair practices on the part of our trading partners. Quite to the contrary it has provided a forum in which our trading partners could sue us.
  • A wealthier, more prosperous China has not tended towards liberal democracy and has become more aggressive.
  • Weakening Russia has not made it less aggressive.
  • The EU has not brought greater prosperity to most of its members. However, it has made Germany more prosperous.
  • Mass immigration has not produced greater prosperity or social comity.

and I would add that expanding NATO has not made us more secure but the opposite.

What conclusions should be drawn from all of this? I don’t think it’s that we should return to a “Fortress America”. I think it’s that we should recognize that the other countries of the world have interests, too, and should be expected to pursue them. And that there are no grand solutions. Slow, gradual, tedious work is necessary for just about everything, whether it’s negotiating good international agreements or producing peace and prosperity.

1 comment

Winners, Losers, and Managed Trade

At The Conversation Marina v. N. Whitman makes a proposal about mitigating the adverse effects of “free trade” agreements on those who are hurt by them—expand trade adjustment assistance:

The TPP, which was agreed to earlier this year by 12 Pacific Rim countries, is aimed at reducing tariffs but, much more significantly, it would remove other national barriers to finance and investment as well as trade in goods, services and digital transactions. Among these changes are harmonization of national regulations and protection of intellectual property.

That agreement, which still requires ratification by the Senate, is now on the rocks after the populist candidacies of Trump and Sanders seized on anti-trade sentiment and gave it a powerful voice.

While this won’t save the TPP, rethinking how we assist those hurt by free trade is important so that at a minimum – once the anti-globalization views now ascendant have attenuated and the U.S. budget can accommodate increases in discretionary programs – future agreements don’t leave so many workers feeling left behind. Tinkering isn’t enough.

It starts with crafting policies that encourage a more flexible labor force, while at the same time providing a safety net for those who have to do the flexing. The Danes have coined a word for such policies: “flexicurity.” Rather than trying to protect jobs toppled by economist Joseph Schumpeter’s “winds of creative destruction,” government policies should ease and speed the transition to new and sturdier ones.

So in terms of the TAA, a crucial change would be to make training and other programs for the reemployment of displaced workers more effective and wage insurance for those who have found new jobs but at significantly lower salaries than the old ones more generous, in both amounts and duration. It is also critical to extend such measures to all workers displaced by change – such automation and changes in consumers’ tastes – not just trade.

I have a related but alternative proposal. First, impose a Pigouvian tax on those who benefit most directly by these managed trade agreements. That will serve to limit the appetite of those who advocate poorly-constructed managed trade programs whose benefits are narrow and concentrated.

Second, give money directly to those hurt the most by these agreements. Give them to workers not companies. Don’t give them to educational institutions that produce retraining programs of dubious actual value. Let the workers do whatever they care to with them, whether it’s pursue retraining, starting a business, or just spending it.

Third, phase the subsidies out on a fixed calendar over time. A well-known process encourages people to adapt to circumstances rather than assuming the subsidies will last forever.

That wouldn’t be perfect but it would be better than what we’ve been doing.

2 comments

Analogy

Which of the following countries most closely resembles the U. S.?

  1. Canada
  2. Mexico
  3. United Kingdom
  4. Japan
  5. Germany
  6. France
  7. Russia
  8. Brazil
  9. India
  10. China
  11. Australia
  12. Other
  13. None. We’re sui generis

and why? I don’t think it’s Canada, UK, Japan, Germany, France, Russia, India, China, or Australia. Superficially, we’re like Canada or Australia. Large land area, mostly English speaking, economically strong. But Canada has a population 10% of ours and Australia is even less populous. And only about 15% of Canadians are of anything other than Western European descent and Australia is even more Anglo. So, not really very much like us at all.

11 comments

Soft Landing or Hard for China?

At Bloomberg Tyler Cowen summarizes China’s conundrum in a few paragraphs:

…might there be a chance that China can avoid an economic crackup altogether?

China has several factors going for it here, including increases in labor productivity, productivity-enhancing migration of labor to cities and technology transfers from abroad. A fourth set of factors, which have operated in the past but not so much now, are liberalizations and improvements in government policy. Even when Chinese businesses get into trouble, and might otherwise go bust or be forced to lay off workers, these broad rising tides often have come to the rescue.

So if you think China can reach the proverbial soft landing, your basic take should be that government-run fiscal policy will keep matters afloat long enough for underlying pro-growth forces to validate once more most of China’s struggling investments and debt burdens.

If you are more pessimistic, your core scenario might run like this: Most Chinese have not yet lived through a true economic crash, and policy makers seem to have an increasing focus on the short term and maintaining political power. Given that dynamic, each time China postpones a major recession it encourages more debt and a greater overextension of investment. That requires stronger underlying positive forces to come to the rescue each time, whereas productivity improvements and urbanization probably are slowing down, although Chinese data as usual do not yield definitive answers.

I’m more concerned about how the Chinese people and authorities will respond when the inevitable “crackup” happens. Will they accept it as just something else that must be endured? Will they blame each other? Or will they blame external enemies? China has an enormous capacity to create mischief and the Chinese authorities could potentially try to deflect blame from themselves and onto some external enemy, e.g. Japan, India, Russia, or us. Not a great time to be one of China’s neighbors.

1 comment

Who, Me?

I found the editors of the Wall Street Journal’s demand that Democrats be held responsible for the flaws in the Affordable Care Act astonishing in its naïveté:

At every stage of the ObamaCare saga, liberals said not to worry. Sure, the law was unpopular when Democrats rammed it through Congress on a partisan vote in 2009-10, but voters would learn to love it once the subsidies started rolling. That didn’t happen, and in 2014 President Obama tried to buck up Democrats by saying that “five years from now” people will look back on the law as “a monumental achievement.” Two years later it’s worse.

Nothing could shake the liberal faith in their supposed landmark: Not the Healthcare.gov website fiasco of 2013, or the millions of individual health plans that were cancelled despite President Obama’s promise about keeping them. The left kept the faith as the entitlement subtracted from economic growth, hurt incomes and killed jobs. MIT economist Jonathan Gruber called the critics stupid, and Mr. Obama denigrates anyone who disagrees with him as illegitimate or politically motivated.

Now reality is confirming what the critics predicted. ObamaCare’s regulatory mix—benefit mandates, requiring insurers to sell coverage to all comers, and narrow ratings bands that limit how much premiums can vary by health status—was tried by several states in the 1980s and ’90s. Every one saw the same results that are now unspooling nationally: high and rising costs, low and declining enrollment, and less insurer and provider competition.

because of its flawed understanding of the political process.

I don’t agree with the opponents of the PPACA who’ve claimed for years that the law was a stalking horse for a fully socialized healthcare system. If only that were the case! I also don’t agree with the supporters of the law who claim that the law was the best that could have been passed because of the “60th senator problem” for the same reason. That’s just not how our system works.

I think the PPACA is what you pour out when you toss all of the slogans about healthcare reform on which the progressive caucus of the Congress have agreed, e.g. “guaranteed issue”, “community rating”, into a blender, seasoned with a soupçon of political reality. Whether it could work or not was irrelevant.

Meanwhile, the great thing about being a U. S. senator is that you never need to take responsibility for anything. There are always 99 other senators plus the president to blame. And you don’t have all of that pesky constituent service to worry about, as they have in the House. Since everyone in the state is notionally your constituent, there’s always plausible deniability. All you really need to worry about are raising money for your re-election campaign and not getting caught.

4 comments