Representative—Except in the House and Senate

I think there’s actually a kernel of truth in what Symone Sanders says here, reported by RealClearPolitics:

Symone Sanders, former spokeswoman for the Bernie Sanders presidential campaign, appeared on CNN Wednesday afternoon to weigh in on the future of the DNC and the Democratic party. Sanders dismissed the idea of Howard Dean returning as DNC chairman commenting, “we don’t need white people leading the Democratic party right now.”

“Howard Dean is also on record maligning young people and millennials. Telling those Bernie folks they just need to get in line and maligning Bernie Sanders. And that is not what we need,” Sanders said about the former party chairman.

“In my opinion we don’t need white people leading the Democratic party right now,” Sanders said. “The Democratic party is diverse, and it should be reflected as so in leadership and throughout the staff, at the highest levels. From the vice chairs to the secretaries all the way down to the people working in the offices at the DNC.”

The voting base of the Democratic Party is just about half black. About a quarter of Democratic members of the House are black and only one senator. If the party’s diversity is to be anything but a cynical charade, there should be more black members of the House and at least ten Senate Democrats should be black.

4 comments

Perspectives on Medicaid

The editors of Bloomberg leap to the defense of Medicaid:

Whatever the problems with other parts of Obamacare (chiefly, rising premiums in the state insurance exchanges), Medicaid expansion has worked. Rolling it back now would hurt state budgets, the health-care industry and, most of all, the newly insured.

To place the issue in a little perspective here are the ten states with the largest Medicaid enrollments, what percentage of the state’s population that represents (based on Census Bureau figures), and I’ve color-coded the states not participating in the Affordable Care Act’s expansion of Medicaid:

State Medicaid/CHIP Enrollment Percentage of total state population
California 11,843,081 31%
New York 6,412,390 33%
Texas 4,730,940 18%
Florida 3,644,673 19%
Illinois 3,114,000 24%
Ohio 3,003,170 26%
Pennsylvania 2,854,944 22%
Michigan 2,273,867 23%
North Carolina 2,004,486 20%
Washington 1,781,499 26%

To refresh your memory, Medicaid is a shared federal-state program with federal payment rates depending on the state’s per capita income, i.e. wealthier states pay more.

BTW, that calculation of which states are “givers” and which “takers”, i.e. the ROI of the states based on federal taxes paid in the state vs. federal monies received? Most calculations that I’ve seen don’t include SSRI, DI, Medicaid, or Medicare. If you find a source that calculates state “dependency” that includes SSRI, DI, Medicaid, and Medicare, and other federal spending, tell me about it and I’ll crank that into my table.

11 comments

The Insurgency

While I think that the characterization of the Trump campaign as a start-up is interesting, I don’t think it really explains what we’ve witnessed. Trump’s campaign is an insurgency. That was pointed out as early as February of this year by John Robb:

Trump is trouncing the competition. He’s doing so well that the prediction systems give him a 81% chance of winning the nomination — despite the opposition of the entire Republican establishment.

What’s most surprising to many pundits and analysts is that Trump has done this without presenting all of the detail plans, voluminous position papers, etc. that we’ve come to expect over the last couple of decades.

He has simply refused to play by those rules, and he’s not paid a price for it.

Trump is able to pull this off because he’s not running a political campaign. Instead, he’s running an insurgency.

We are presently in the third phase of that insurgency. The first phase of the insurgency was waged against the other presidential candidates in the Republican Party. Then attention was turned to defeating Hillary Clinton.

This insurgency is presently in its third phase and that’s directed against the major media outlets, the civil bureaucracy, and other entrenched power structures, mostly in Washington, DC. In each phase Trump has successfully insinuated himself into his opponents’ OODA loop. If you’re looking for consistency in Trump’s policies, start there. Don’t expect what he’s said at the various stages of his insurgency to be internally consistent. He’s said whatever’s been necessary to get into his opponents’ heads.

You can see the Trump insurgency as dark and sinister, as completely ego-driven, or take it at face value. I’m skeptical that Mr. Trump’s strategies can be applied to actual governance but who knows? It’s hard to deny that it’s Fourth Generation Warfare as applied to politics.

6 comments

Unicorns

A “unicorn” is a start-up valued at over $1 billion. This Forbes article by Steven Bertoni made me wonder. Is Donald Trump the political equivalent of a unicorn?

2 comments

Applying Chekhov’s Gun to Op-Eds

The Russian playwright and short story writer characterized his rule of parsimony in drama like this:

Remove everything that has no relevance to the story. If you say in the first chapter that there is a rifle hanging on the wall, in the second or third chapter it absolutely must go off. If it’s not going to be fired, it shouldn’t be hanging there.

Why isn’t there such a rule governing opinion writing? The title of Gus Van Horn’s RealClearMarkets piece is “In Defense of a Strong U.S. Patent System”. Nowhere in the piece were there any hints of what he thought a strong patent system would look like.

I can tell you what my idea of a good patent system indeed any system of intellectual property would be. It would have the following characteristics:

  • Patents would be of short duration.
  • They would not be extendable including by the Congress.
  • They would be rigorously enforceable without regard to the patent-holder’s ability to pay.

I once heard Dean Kamen speak. His advice to would-be inventors was don’t invent anything big or important until you’re rich enough to defend it from big companies. They’ll infringe your patent at will and have the legal firepower to withstand attacks from upstarts.

0 comments

A Cabal of Its Enemies

In his Washington Post post Ed Rogers offers more of that advice to Democrats I mentioned yesterday:

I would tell the Democrats to keep Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) as their House minority leader. More of the same from her would be great. And if they really want to exile someone, I would say they should get rid of the able, media-savvy Donna Brazile as head of the Democratic National Committee and elect another member of congress, a la Debbie Wasserman Schultz, to serve as a part-time, conflicted chairman. I would order them to elect a real leftist, such as uhh . . . Rep. Keith Ellison (D-Minn.), who was a Bernie Sanders supporter and who has been associated with both the Council on American-Islamic Relations and Louis Farrakhan.

That’s the analog of the view that the more right-wing members of the Republican Party have held for some time with stronger arithmetic support, that is, if the party just nominates candidates that are far enough right, they’ll be elected in landslides. I don’t think it has dawned on them yet that Donald Trump is the living refutation of that.

Robert Conquest’s Laws of Politics seem to apply:

1. Everyone is conservative about what he knows best.
2. Any organization not explicitly right-wing sooner or later becomes left-wing.
3. The simplest way to explain the behavior of any bureaucratic organization is to assume that it is controlled by a cabal of its enemies.

particularly #3. That also probably explains why self-described independents now outnumber either Republicans or Democrats. Why, when Nancy Pelosi became House Speaker half of all Americans thought of themselves as Democrats.

2 comments

The Fifth Branch of Government?

The editors of the Washington Post concur with President-Elect Trump’s tentative decision not to continue the Justice Department investigations of Hillary Clinton:

The nation ought to be relieved that President-elect Donald Trump has decided not to press his campaign pledge to criminally investigate rival Hillary Clinton for her handling of email while secretary of state and for the activities of the Clinton Foundation. A drawn-out probe, fueled by Mr. Trump from the White House, would invariably become a political circus, take on the overtones of vendetta and deepen the wounds of the election.

but they’re on shakier ground here:

The law enforcement system and the U.S. attorneys who investigate and prosecute federal crimes are supposed to be independent, free from interference by the White House or anyone else.

Here’s what the U. S. Constitution has to say on the subject:

The executive power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America.

That’s it. No specific executive branch officers are named in the Constitution; they serve at the pleasure of the president.

The Department of Justice characterizes the authority of the U. S. attorneys like this:

In the exercise of their prosecutorial discretion, United States Attorneys construe and implement the policy of the Department of Justice. Their professional abilities and the need for their impartiality in administering justice directly affect the public’s perception of federal law enforcement.

In the Act of August 2, 1861 (Ch. 37, 12 Stat. 185) the Attorney General gained supervisory authority over U. S. attorneys. Their offices were created at the same time as that of Attorney General was. The president has plenary power over them.

There’s nothing there about independence from control by the Attorney General or the president. We have an independent judiciary. We do not have a law enforcement branch of government independent of the executive any more than Chicago’s police department is free of mayoral control. Any more than generals in the Army are independent of presidential control; any more than the diplomats in the State Department are independent of executive control; any more than the people who work for the Treasury Department are.

U. S. attorneys are employees of the Department of Justice. Like other employees of the DoJ, they, too, serve at the pleasure of the president except as regulated by the Civil Service Act. While not interfering with their work may be a custom (I see little evidence even of a custom), the president may fire them, direct them to act, or direct them to cease action. If there are laws restricting the president’s control of executive branch departments, they are likely unconstitutional and could readily be challenged in the courts.

Doing so might be politically imprudent but it is well within the power of the presidency.

2 comments

Firing Back

At RealClearWorld David Benson writes about the implications of a trade war between China and the U. S.:

If Beijing attempts to accommodate American demands, it risks domestic unrest as its economy contracts. If China refuses to accommodate changes, then it risks a punitive American response, potentially producing a trade war it cannot afford. China cannot even threaten to cut off production access in the long term, as Washington could simply return to the TPP to fill that need.

The United States, for its part, is similarly positioned. Domestic pressure demands adjustment of the Sino-American trade relationship, but any attempts to put direct pressure on China risk blowing up that relationship, destabilizing China and imposing significant costs on the American consumer. Importantly, no change in global trade is guaranteed to return American manufacturing jobs, either.

Consider the following tabulation of WTO claims over the last ten years:

Against Number filed
China 32
United States 28
European Union 21
Brazil 2
Argentina 7
Morocco 1
Russian Federation 6
Thailand 4
Indonesia 8
Republic of Korea 3
Colombia 3
South Africa 3
India 6
Ukraine 3
Canada 3
Pakistan 1
Australia 6
Peru 1
Turkey 1
Moldova 1
Dominican Republic 4
Armenia 1
Philippines 1
Chile 1

Many of these claims are actually counter-claims. The United States files a complaint against China; China files a counter-complaint against the United States.

If you were to weight the claims by GDP, some obvious offenders emerge (Argentina, Indonesia, Russia) but something else does, too. There’s already a trade war between the United States and China. We just aren’t fighting our side very effectively.

As has been oddly the case with our real, live, shootin’ wars, the complaint about trade wars mostly come when we try to win.

0 comments

One Campaign at a Time

Once again I find myself in agreement with The Nation’s Katrina vanden Heuvel. From her column in the Washington Post:

For years, many progressives — including me — have called for taking our movement to the states. Yet Democrats have prioritized maintaining control of the presidency while giving short shrift to state-level infrastructure. Meanwhile, Republicans have invested heavily in winning state legislative and gubernatorial races, which has allowed them to advance conservative policies across the country and seize control of congressional redistricting. Heading into 2017, there are 68 legislative chambers under Republican control, 34 Republican governors and a record 29 Republican state attorneys general. It’s painfully clear which party’s strategy has been more effective.

It must be said that’s no task for someone who only wants to work for ten months every four years. It’s a daily grind, month after month, year after year and will require something that most progressives seem to find anathema: compromise.

You can’t just rely on a phone and a pen to effect your programs for you. You’ve got to compromise. You must persuade. You must deliver.

4 comments

One Good Sentence

The balance of David Brooks’s column in the New York Times is just a preamble to the single sentence highlighted below:

Those of us in the opinion class have been complaining that Trump voters are post-truth, that they don’t have a respect for expertise. Well, the experts created a school system that doesn’t produce skilled graduates. The experts designed Obamacare exchanges that are failing. Maybe those of us in the professional class need to win back some credibility the old-fashioned way, with effective reform.

Just saying “give us a free hand and we’ll fix everything”, the usual retort, isn’t nearly good enough. And it’s what every tyrant has said since the dawn of time.

Accomplishing that will require listening. Is the “professional class” up to it? Why listen when you already know it all?

9 comments