One Good Sentence

The balance of David Brooks’s column in the New York Times is just a preamble to the single sentence highlighted below:

Those of us in the opinion class have been complaining that Trump voters are post-truth, that they don’t have a respect for expertise. Well, the experts created a school system that doesn’t produce skilled graduates. The experts designed Obamacare exchanges that are failing. Maybe those of us in the professional class need to win back some credibility the old-fashioned way, with effective reform.

Just saying “give us a free hand and we’ll fix everything”, the usual retort, isn’t nearly good enough. And it’s what every tyrant has said since the dawn of time.

Accomplishing that will require listening. Is the “professional class” up to it? Why listen when you already know it all?

9 comments

The Problem With Accepting Refugees

I’ve been thinking about the U. S.’s accepting refugees and I’ve come up with an analogy that I think captures my thoughts.

If the residents of progressive strongholds like Scarsdale, New York, Dover, Mass., or San Rafael, California want to accept refugees, I won’t stand in their way. I think they should take as many refugees as they care to from wherever they care to accept them.

However, if the good burghers of those municipalities want to settle these refugees in Birdseye, Indiana or Bauxite, Arkansas or Bear Dance, Montana, I think the very least they can do is ask the residents’ of those villages permission. Having more votes isn’t nearly enough.

It’s like inviting guests out to dinner and then sticking the people at the next table with the check. That’s not philanthropy. It’s rude at the very least.

5 comments

Bureaucracy: Keep Doing Whatever You’ve Been Doing

I have a question about this story, reported in the Daily Express:

Michael Skråmo was handed more than £53,000 (50,000 Kroner) despite fleeing to war-torn Syria with his wife and four small children.

The 31-year-old regularly appeared in propaganda videos, posing alongside Kalashnikov assault rifles with his children.

Now going by the name of Abdul Samad al Swedi, the family are thought to have lived off Swedish state handouts of £627 (5,814 Kroner) a month.

It took more than a year for the country’s welfare agency, Försäkringskassan, to update their records and payments were made for at least eight months after they pledged their allegiance to the bloodthirsty regime.

Doesn’t that make Sweden a supporter of jihad?

You know, if you repeat that a couple thousand times, that’s about all that DAESH would need to stay afloat. About 6,000 Europeans are estimated to have joined DAESH.

0 comments

What Could Possibly Explain It?

The Economist wonders what could possibly explain the surge of nationalist feeling, not just in the United States but in much of the developed world?

It is troubling, then, how many countries are shifting from the universal, civic nationalism towards the blood-and-soil, ethnic sort. As positive patriotism warps into negative nationalism, solidarity is mutating into distrust of minorities, who are present in growing numbers (see chart 1). A benign love of one’s country—the spirit that impels Americans to salute the Stars and Stripes, Nigerians to cheer the Super Eagles and Britons to buy Duchess of Cambridge teacups—is being replaced by an urge to look on the world with mistrust.

Happily, they also provide an explanation in the form of the graph above. Another factor, not considered by The Economist, is that the new waves of immigrants may not feel the same pressures to adopt the language, customs, and manners of their new homes as immigrants did in the past. They may not even look at them as their homes. Skype and Facebook keep their connections to the Old Country firm and bright.

Some of the new immigrants, like Germany’s and Sweden’s new guests, may feel an affirmative obligation to transform their foster countries rather than be transformed by them.

From my perspective Sweden and Germany are late-comers. In 1960 4% of the American population was Hispanic. Today 16% is. That’s an enormous change over a relatively short period of time.

I don’t think we can or should turn back the clock. But I wouldn’t be surprised if the deplorables, Hispanics, and blacks link arms and say “this far and no farther”.

Let me put it this way. Right now our foreign born population comprises its highest percentage in nearly a century and possibly ever. Under the circumstances which do you think is most likely. We will accept (as a proportion of population)

  1. A lot fewer immigrants than we have over the last 30 years.
  2. Slightly fewer immigrants than we have over the last 30 years.
  3. About the same proportion of immigrants as we have over the last 30 years.
  4. Slightly more immigrants than we have over the last 30 years.
  5. A lot more immigrants than we have over the last 30 years.

I think the answer is B for demographic, social, and political reasons. I think that Germany’s answer is very likely to be E.

0 comments

Neo-Feudalism

Joel Kotkin has the core of an interesting idea at The Daily Beast:

In contrast to the old Democratic notions embraced by the likes of Harry Truman or the late California Governor Pat Brown, today’s progressives promote social control and the consolidation of a cognitively determined world order. Its promise amounts to forging a kind of high-tech middle ages in which the new aristocracy—techies, media grandees, financial moguls, academics, high-level bureaucrats—dominate while the middle class becomes increasingly serf-like.

What strategies would counter the would-be neo-feudal masters? Here are some proposals: make energy cheaper and more abundant, stop subsidizing the new aristocracy, require higher standards of proof to import so-called “knowledge workers”, break up monopolies, have the Justice Department go after their zoning restrictions as illegal segregation.

5 comments

The New Age

It was the best of times,
it was the worst of times,
it was the age of wisdom,
it was the age of foolishness,
it was the epoch of belief,
it was the epoch of incredulity,
it was the season of Light,
it was the season of Darkness,
it was the spring of hope,
it was the winter of despair,

we had everything before us, we had nothing before us, we were all going direct to Heaven, we were all going direct the other way— in short, the period was so far like the present period, that some of its noisiest authorities insisted on its being received, for good or for evil, in the superlative degree of comparison only.

0 comments

The Fourth Wall


The purpose of the “fourth wall” isn’t to protect the audience from the performers. It has two purposes. First, to create a special place where, as Coleridge put it, the willing suspension of disbelief may take place. Secondly, it protects the performers from the audience.

My advice: ixnay on the ambushesway. The stage is your safe space. Unless you want every performance to become a real-life re-enactment of the country western bar scene in The Blues Brothers. Maybe I ought to go after the chicken wire concession.

0 comments

The Latest Cottage Industry

The latest cottage industry seems to be giving advice to the Democrats. A recent example, A. B. Stoddard’s at RealClearPolitics, is to look elsewhere for leadership of the Democratic National Committee and Congress:

House Democrats are still leaning towards re-electing San Francisco liberal Rep. Nancy Pelosi, age 76, as their minority leader, while several key party leaders have thrown their weight behind Rep. Keith Ellison to lead the Democratic National Committee. Doing either would be a huge mistake.

I guess it depends on what the Democratic leadership wants to accomplish. If it’s ideological purity, stick with Pelosi and Ellison. Who cares if the Congressional leadership remembers when Roosevelt was president? Or if the head of the DNC was “involved with” an expressly racist organization? So long as they presently espouse the correct views.

The purposes of the DNC are to raise money, give voice to the corporate beliefs of the party, and recruit and support candidates for elective office. I think that electing more Democrats in 50 states would be a good objective but what do I know?

Sadly, it’s a lot easier to rule than to govern.

0 comments

Of Men and Mandates

I may be one of the few Americans who thinks that both Barack Obama and Donald Trump have mandates. And it’s the same mandate: change.

President Obama’s great mandate was to “save the economy”, i.e. stop the bleeding and restore the economy to robust health. The first was accomplished as much despite him as because of him while the second hasn’t been accomplished at all, as may be concluded from the continuing low rate of economic growth, the phlegmatic growth in employment, and the very low rate of labor force participation.

Unfortunately, he turned his attention from the economy to healthcare and the rest, as they say, is history. After healthcare he turned to re-election and then building a legacy, a legacy which now looks very likely to be completely erased by his successor.

Donald Trump has the clear mandates to kickstart the economy and get our border with Mexico under greater control. Whether either of those are within any president’s power to accomplish let alone his remains to be seen.

5 comments

What’s Their Economic Policy?

Everybody talks about it but no one does anything about it. Do our two major political parties actually have economic policies?

To the best of my ability to discern Democrats’ economic policy consists of

  • Infrastructure spending
  • Support for higher education

while Republicans’ economic policy consists of

  • Cuts in the personal income tax
  • Support for higher education
  • Repealing Dodd-Frank

It’s a bit early in the day but the early returns suggest that Donald Trump’s preferred economic policy consists of

  • Tax cuts
  • Infrastructure spending (which Democrats criticize as consisting of backdoor tax cuts).

Far from being revolutionary, to me that looks like splitting the baby.

Anyone who thinks that infrastructure spending will ipso facto spur the economy needs to go back and re-read what Keynes wrote and said. Nine years is more than enough time for structural changes in the economy to have taken place.

Since “the rich” pay most of the income tax which stands to reason since they have the majority of the income, any cut in the personal income tax is likely to be a “tax cut for the rich”. While I think that is likely to result in greater investment and economic growth somewhere, that somewhere won’t necessarily be in the United States. That’s the real meaning of a global economy. Governments in individual countries don’t have as much control over their domestic economies as they used to.

The idea that higher education is a useful economic policy is one of those things about which you don’t know whether to laugh or to cry. Under that peculiar version of supply side, Field of Dreams, cargo cult thinking, more educated people will naturally result in the creation of more jobs for people with higher education. It hasn’t worked out particularly well so far but who knows?

Its even greater deficiency is that it ignores the two-thirds of the people who won’t pursue higher education or won’t benefit from it if they pursue it. Oddly enough, those people are starting to notice that there’s no place for them in that brave new world. You can fool all of the people some of the time, etc.

4 comments