What About Equifax?

In his New York Times column Farhad Manjoo fumes over the Equifax data breach:

If a bank lost everyone’s money, regulators might try to shut down the bank. If an accounting firm kept shoddy books, its licenses to practice accounting could be revoked. (See how Texas pulled Arthur Andersen’s license after the Enron debacle.)

So if a data-storage credit agency loses pretty much everyone’s data, why should it be allowed to store anyone’s data any longer?

Here’s one troubling reason: Because even after one of the gravest breaches in history, no one is really in a position to stop Equifax from continuing to do business as usual. And the problem is bigger than Equifax: We really have no good way, in public policy, to exact some existential punishment on companies that fail to safeguard our data. There will be hacks — and afterward, there will be more.

There’s a simple, practical solution to that conundrum: let the courts decide. All that needs to happen to solve the problem is for Equifax to be held responsible for the costs, direct and indirect, of the data that it held’s becoming public and the problem along with the company will go away.

Holding vast amounts of private and sensitive data is a business model. When the profitability of the business model depended on inadequate controls as seems to be the case, why should the federal government act or not act to prop up that model? If the functions that Equifax performed are so vital to the functioning of our society as seems to be claims, perhaps we should not depend on a private company to perform them?

As to the executives who are alleged to have sold large blocks of their stock in Equifax prior to the announcement, the question will become what did they know and when did they know it? If they knew about the breach in anticipation of selling their stock, they should be indicted for insider trading and, if found guilty, subject to the maximum penalty—20 years in prison and a $5 million dollar fine. That will open the floodgates for what promises to be the largest class action suit in history.

We need to come to the understanding that size itself can be a problem. A company that is too large to be allowed to fail is too large to be allowed to exist.

9 comments

Silicon Valley Follows Conquest’s First Law

At Bloomberg View Megan McArdle remarks on the politics of Silicon Valley:

Silicon Valley titans, suggests Farhad Manjoo of the New York Times, are really quite liberal. But there is one major exception to their liberalism: They aren’t very fond of regulation. Especially, one might add, regulation aimed at the tech industry.

This supposition is based on a single paper that is still under peer review. But I suspect that Manjoo was willing to write about it because it fits his anecdotal impression of these people, counterexamples like Peter Thiel notwithstanding. It certainly fits with mine.

If so, they’re certainly obeying the First Law of Politics, attributed to Robert Conquest: “Everyone is conservative about what he knows best”.

It’s not too surprising that the techies of Silicon Valley would be as sanguine as they are about government intervention. Most of the intervention they’ve experienced to date has explicitly been on their behalf, expressly intended to create a space in which their business models would flourish. Now they very much want to pull up the ladder to ensure that they, too, aren’t disrupted.

4 comments

Is the Voynich Manuscript a Renaissance Gynecologist’s Notebook?

The “Voynich Manuscript” is a 15th century manuscript discovered in 1912. It’s full of cryptic handwriting and mysterious symbols and drawings and has attracted interest for more than a century. Now one researcher may have discovered what it’s actually about. From Ars Technica:

Since its discovery in 1969, the 15th century Voynich Manuscript has been a mystery and a cult phenomenon. Full of handwriting in an unknown language or code, the book is heavily illustrated with weird pictures of alien plants, naked women, strange objects, and zodiac symbols. Now, history researcher and television writer Nicholas Gibbs appears to have cracked the code, discovering that the book is actually a guide to women’s health that’s mostly plagiarized from other guides of the era.

Gibbs writes in the Times Literary Supplement that he was commissioned by a television network to analyze the Voynich Manuscript three years ago. Because the manuscript has been entirely digitized by Yale’s Beinecke Library, he could see tiny details in each page and pore over them at his leisure. His experience with medieval Latin and familiarity with ancient medical guides allowed him to uncover the first clues.

Read the whole thing. Mr. Gibbs’s theory makes pretty good sense.

2 comments

Ever Gone a Week Without a Rationalization?

HealthCareDive considers a recent survey of physicians that found that they believed that 20% of care is unnecessary. Here’s the quick summary:

  • A survey of 2,106 U.S. physicians found that, on average, they believe 20.6% of medical care is unnecessary, including 22% of prescriptions, 24.9% of tests and 11.1% of procedures.
  • An overwhelming majority (84.7%) attributed overtreatment to fear of malpractice, according to the study in Plos One. Other oft-cited reasons were patient pressure (59%) and difficulty accessing medical records (38.2%).
  • More than seven in 10 respondents said there is a chance profit encourages overtreatment, and most believed less fee-for-service reimbursement would reduce overutilization.

Maybe it’s time to start asking the ancient question about our system: cui bono? Who benefits? Hint: if you perform an analysis of our system based on marginal costs and marginal benefits, the primary beneficiaries of our system are not patients.

6 comments

Fear of a Black Hat

I wish a lot more Americans were thinking about this. At War Is Boring Maj. Danny Sjursen questions the established orthodoxy in considering what we’re doing in the Middle East:

The United States is in many ways little more than an air force, military trainer and weapons depot for assorted Sunni despots. Now, that’s not a point made too often — not in this context anyway — because it’s neither a comfortable thought for most Americans, nor a particularly convenient reality for establishment policymakers to broadcast, but it’s the truth.

Yes, we do fight ISIS, but it’s hardly that simple. Saudi Arabia, our main regional ally, may portray itself as the leader of a “moderate Sunni block” when it comes to both Iran and terrorism, but the reality is, at best, far grayer than that. The Saudis — with whom Pres. Donald Trump announced a $110-billion arms deal during the first stop on his inaugural foreign trip back in May — have spent the last few decades spreading their intolerant brand of Islam across the region. In the process, they’ve also supported Al Qaeda-linked groups in Syria.

Maybe you’re willing to argue that Al Qaeda spin-offs aren’t ISIS, but don’t forget who brought down those towers in New York. While Trump enjoyed a traditional sword dance with his Saudi hosts — no doubt gratifying his martial tastes — the air forces of the Saudis and their Gulf state allies were bombing Yemeni civilians into the grimmest of situations, including a massive famine and a spreading cholera epidemic amid the ruins of their impoverished country.

Our wars in the Middle East are illegal and immoral, they aren’t in our interests, and they certainly aren’t in the interests of the people of the Middle East. We continue them for domestic political reasons, because some people profit mightily from them, and inertia. We could accomplish our legitimate goals in the Middle East at a much lower cost by legal and moral means. It’s long past time for a change.

2 comments

Trending at the Watcher’s Council Site

Watcher of Weasels

The illogical hysteria behind claims about campus sexual assault

In speech, Betsy DeVos calls out Title IX failures.

Outrageous Leftist hypocrisy about Arpaio’s pardon and DACA

 The Bookworm Beat 9-8-17 — the illustrated edition and open thread

[VIDEO] English as she was spoke when Shakespeare wrote 

No The End of DACA Is Not Like the Round Up of Jewish Children During the Holocaust 

WoW! Forum: Should DACA Be Ended? 

A Modest Proposal Regarding Antifa*

A Humane And Fair Solution For DACA 

 Bill Whittle & D’Souza eviscerate Progressives for inciting hate and bigotry 

 Israeli nuclear opacity and oversight: yes or no? 

 What Kennedy Can Teach Trump on North Korean Crisis 

 Facilitators 

 Robert Spencer at David Horowitz Freedom Center Discusses War on Freedom of Speech 

 A Citizen’s Guide to Education Reform, With a Bandana 

 US LNG Shipments To Ukraine – Peace Through Fracking 

 Do We Have a Labor Shortage?

 Judge Jeanine Pirro: “Time to Go After ‘Mr. Holier-Than-Thou’ Jim Comey” 

0 comments

Exchange Watch

Assuming this actually transpires, I wonder what the reaction to it will be? CNBC reports:

Half of Virginia’s counties now are on track to have no health insurers offering Obamacare plans in 2018 after an insurer reversed a decision to sell individual health coverage in much of the state.

The pullback by Optima Health in Virginia ends a brief, two-week period in which every county in the United States was projected to have at least one Obamacare insurer next year.

And it reflects ongoing uncertainty among insurers about the stability of the individual health plan market in light of the factors including Trump administration’s hostility to Obamacare.

On Wednesday, big insurer Anthem, citing market volatility, said it would slash in half the number of counties in Kentucky where it will sell Obamacare plans in 2018.

Virginia’s Bureau of Insurance said 48 counties and 15 cities are now expected to be “bare” of Obamacare plans in 2018.

There are a total of 350,000 Virginians who currently have individual health plan coverage and who live in those bare areas, or have a plan provided by an insurer that will not longer offer coverage next year, according to Sentara Healthcare, the nonprofit health system parent of Optima Health.

Virginia is the most over-represented state in the Union. Most of our alleged Congressional representatives are actually residents of the State of Virginia. A disproportionate number of bureaucrats, lobbyists, pundits and journalists live there as well. Consequently, Virginia looms large in the scheme of things and I’m sure that the plight of the uninsured in the State of Virginia will receive substantial attention.

9 comments

Upstaging Yourself

At RealClearWorld Dylan Loh says that Chinese President Xi has been upstaged by events on the Korean peninsula:

The latest nuclear test was conducted just as Xi was busy hosting a BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) nations conference in Xiamen. This was supposed to be the latest feather in Xi’s cap, a chance to show off his diplomatic finesse after resolving the Doklam border dispute with India just before the summit. But then came the nuclear test, and the attention Xi dearly wanted immediately evaporated.

This act of upstaging is a serious matter. The importance of the BRICS summit should not be understated; this was the last major international event for Xi before the 19th National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party, China’s most important domestic political event, which kicks off on October 18.

Unlike the standard agenda of previous meetings, this year’s national congress is immensely personally important to Xi. He is trying to install allies in the Politburo Standing Committee, to push through wide-ranging social, economic and military reforms, and possibly aiming to stay on in some capacity beyond the normal 10-year term.

Let me explain that terminology a bit. Old-fashioned stages were “raked”, i.e. they slanted—higher in the area away from the audience than in the area nearest the audience. “Upstage” means “towards the back of the stage”. It was literally upstage. You “upstaged” another actor by forcing the actor to turn his or her back on the audience.

To whatever extent Xi and by extension China have been upstaged, they have upstaged themselves. China’s problem is that like Buridan’s ass, they are frozen into inaction by contradictory objectives. They shouldn’t feel too alone. The United States has the same problem.

1 comment

Thinking Like a European

Maybe I’m misreading Bernard-Henri Lévy’s op-ed in Foreign Policy on the upcoming Kurdish independence referendum but it seems to me that it expresses a peculiarly even bizarrely European pattern of thought:

The timidity of the international community in the face of the Sept. 25 referendum on an independent Kurdistan is a trifecta of shame, absurdity, and historic miscalculation.

We are talking about a people who have been deported, Arabized by force, gassed, and pushed into the mountains where, for a century, they have mounted an exemplary resistance to the tyranny their Baghdad masters successively imposed on them in defiance of geography and of the Kurds’ thousand years of history.

Theirs is a region that finally gained autonomy with the fall of Saddam Hussein — a region that, when the tsunami of the Islamic State crashed over Mesopotamia in 2014 and the Iraqi Army took flight, was the first to organize a counteroffensive. Since then, over a front 600 miles long, the Iraqi Kurds held off the barbarians and thus saved Kurdistan, Iraq, and our shared civilization.

And it is the Kurds again who, in the run-up to the battle of Mosul, went on the offensive on the Plains of Nineveh, opened the gates to the city, and, through their courage, enabled the coalition to strike at the heart of the Islamic State.

But now that the time has come to settle up, the United States remains stubbornly opposed to the referendum, urging the Kurds to put off their aspirations for independence to an indeterminate date in the future. Instead of thanking the Kurds, the world is telling them, with thinly veiled cynicism, “Sorry, Kurdish friends, you were so useful in confronting Islamic terror, but, uh, your timing is not so good. We don’t need you anymore, so why don’t you just go on home? Thanks, again — see you next time.”

Let’s cut if off there. In the history of the world can anyone think of an instance in which a people were given a country? I can’t. What I see is people seizing their countries by force.

The Kurds’ problem is that they’re divided among Turkey, Iraq, Syria, Iran, and Armenia and don’t have enough power in any one country to seize control from a country that isn’t interested in having a chunk of itself carved out.

Our European cousins imagine a world governed by a civil code and popular sovereignty. Might that world exist someday? Perhaps. It doesn’t exist now.

In the particular case of the Iraqi Kurds I strongly suspect that the Shi’ite majority in Iraq would welcome the Kurds’ departure and don’t let the door hit you as you go out as long as they didn’t intend to take Mosul or oil-rich Kirkuk with them.

In the pre-Saddam days the area of Iraq where the Kurds live was called the “Kurdish Autonomous Region”. That’s probably about as good as it gets and it’s what the Kurds—and the international community such as it is—should be striving for.

4 comments

Bigotry Rising

California Sen. Dianne Feinstein’s remarks in interrogating judicial nominee Amy Barret, reproduced below:

Why is it that so many of us on this side have this very uncomfortable feeling that — you know, dogma and law are two different things. And I think whatever a religion is, it has its own dogma. The law is totally different. And I think in your case, professor, when you read your speeches, the conclusion one draws is that the dogma lives loudly within you, and that’s of concern when you come to big issues that large numbers of people have fought for years in this country.

are clearly improper given the provision of Article VI, Section 3 of the Constitution—”…no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States”. A proper question might have been “Would your religious beliefs prevent you from providing fair, honest, and just opinions in accordance withe the laws of the United States?”

The “no religious Test” prohibition is only enforceable against the executive branch. Congressional immunity protects the members of Congress from prosecution.

I think Sen. Feinstein’s remarks are just the latest example of open bigotry being expressed in the increasingly Marcusist strain of thought that’s become fashionable lately. But it’s nothing new. I’ve been exposed to anti-Catholic bigotry incidentally since I was a child. But it does look as though either bigotry were increasing in this country or it may just be more openly expressed.

4 comments