What’s Their Solution?

The editors of the Washington Post articulate the threat and risks of a cyberattack on the power grid well enough but they fall far short in proposing no solution. I’ll remedy the deficit.

Resiliency comes from high levels of maintenance, strict adherence to standards, decentralization, and redundancy. Private operators won’t implement and provide those on their own. They add costs, provide them with few benefits, and, frankly, the operators bear few risks. It’s their customers who bear the risks. I suggest applying two words to change that calculus: strict liability.

The reflex of the federal bureaucracy and those who see it as the solution to every problem is a top-down solution. As should be obvious from the experience with computing and networks over the last 30 years, a bottom-up solution will be more effective.

4 comments

The Way We Were

In his column at the Washington Post Michael Gerson proposes what he characterizes as a “compromise” on a legislative approach to the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrival ukase:

There is little question that the president can prioritize immigration enforcement in a variety of ways — say, to focus on deporting convicted felons rather than dreamers. This is the manner in which the law was generally enforced before DACA, and in which it could still be enforced without DACA.

At some point, however, the systematic organization of this discretion into a new legal status, bringing a series of public benefits, becomes the equivalent of legislating. And the courts might focus particular scrutiny on forms of executive action that Congress could have legislated but didn’t. Given the more conservative composition of the Supreme Court, it is likely that DACA would have been struck down.

Whatever the merits of the constitutional case on DACA, the dreamers should now be protected by law. For the past few decades, Congress has pliantly surrendered a number of roles — particularly on social policy and national security — to the courts and the president. A shortage of institutional ambition is a problem that America’s founders did not even contemplate. This is an opportunity for Congress to reclaim its proper constitutional role.

This is also a debate — given that few Republicans actually want to deport the dreamers, and most Democrats seem to prioritize their welfare — on which compromise is particularly ripe. The obvious deal: stronger border enforcement (though not the surpassingly silly wall) for a new version of DACA.

A key problem is that significant numbers of members on both sides of the aisle will see that as capitulation rather than compromise. For any compromise to be possible there needs to be a majority in the House and a supermajority in the Senate who believe that it is conscientiously possible to forge a compromise.

I don’t see it.

You would also need a majority in the House and a supermajority in the Senate who are willing to forego what they see as the additional leverage conjoined with protective coverage that coupling a legislative resolution to the status of young illegal immigrants to much broader piece of legislation whether “comprehensive immigration reform” or some other omnibus legislation would provide. That seems similarly unlikely.

We have abandoned the lubricants that used to make our form of government possible including consensus, moderation, compromise, logrolling, and earmarked spending. The foreseeable consequence is that it has become difficult or impossible to do anything. I am not optimistic.

1 comment

Send Good Thoughts. And Money

I don’t have much to say this morning. I was up all night in excruciating pain. Just something that happens every once in a while.

It sounds like Puerto Rico is in rough shape and Florida is expecting the worst. Send your prayers their way. Or your thoughts. And send money—much better than sending stuff. I usually give through Catholic Charities. If you earmark a contribution for specific disaster relief, they commit to devoting 100% of your contribution to relief for that disaster. I’ve known people who’ve volunteered or worked for Catholic Charities and IMO they’re credible.

20 comments

Don’t Make It a Problem

I agree with Dean Obeidallah’s point at The Daily Beast that Democrats don’t have an antifa problem. That’s exactly why Democrats should be very careful not to make it into their problem.

There have been editorials in mainstream newspapers in praise of antifa and some Democrats have attempted to make a distinction between antifa and its use of violence. Those are good ways to make it into your problem. Better to denounce it as Nancy Pelosi has done.

9 comments

Three Scenarios (Plus a Fourth)

In the Sydney Morning Herald former Australian Prime Minister and present president of the Asia Society Policy Institute, a think tank specializing in Asia-Pacific issues, explores three scenarios that might unfold in the “North Korea crisis”:

So what are the possible scenarios? One, that the US, as China would wish, informally accepts North Korea becoming part of the global nuclear weapons club, and that the North develops its own sets of rules, procedures and nuclear doctrine that enables it to behave “responsibly” as a nuclear weapons state.

Two, a US unilateral military strike to destroy or to retard the North Korean nuclear capability. The conclusion in Beijing is that Washington would never risk the consequences for South Korea, Japan and the future of their alliances with both in such a way. This is also the view held by many others in the wider region and around the world.

I’m less optimistic. Perhaps I’ve been in America too long. As a colleague reminded me recently, war has its own logic. To which I would add, crises have their own logic. The best approach is to avoid crises in the first place

Scenario three is diplomacy. But a potential diplomatic solution to this crisis does not appear to be going well so far.

He neglects to mention the possibility of an aggressive act by North Korea, whether directed against the U. S., South Korea, blackmail, etc. If such an act is impossible, there is no crisis and we should stop acting as though it were. If it is possible, why not consider its implications?

I’m afraid Mr. Rudd’s article is another exercise in wishful thinking posing as analysis.

6 comments

The Incubators

There’s a fun article at Forbes in which astrophysicist Ethan Siegel reminds us that stars of the incubators of elements other than helium. There’s a lot more fusion going on in stars than the nuclear fusion of hydrogen in helium.

1 comment

The Risk of Miscalculation

If you want to read something cheery, this article at Financial Times on the risk of miscalculation by one or more of the parties in the “North Korean crisis” by Gideon Rachman should do the trick:

The risk that Mr Kim is miscalculating, by potentially provoking an American attack, is raised by the unpredictability of Mr Trump. He has vowed that North Korea will not be allowed to develop nuclear weapons that can threaten the US. He has also repeatedly suggested that he is prepared to stage a pre-emptive military strike, at one point threatening Mr Kim with “fire and fury”. But the US president’s efforts to use brinkmanship to force North Korea to back down are undermined by doubts about the credibility of his threats. Steve Bannon, formerly the president’s chief strategist, has stated that the US cannot attack North Korea because of the risk of massive retaliation against South Korea that could kill millions.

Mr Trump’s reaction to the latest and most powerful North Korean nuclear test has increased the dangerous confusion about US policy. Rather than stressing American unity with South Korea, the president chose to criticise Seoul for its “appeasement” of Pyongyang. This, combined with the news that Mr Trump is actively considering scrapping the US-South Korea Free Trade Agreement, risks encouraging North Korea to believe its nuclear provocations are working, by splitting the alliance between Seoul and Washington.

The president has also damaged US credibility, at a crucial moment, by tweeting that America is considering “stopping all trade with any country doing business with North Korea”. Read literally, this would involve ending trade between the US and China, the two largest economies in the world; an action that would throw the global economy into chaos. Mr Trump’s threat underlines his naivety about both trade and international relations. It also suggests the president remains buffeted by competing instincts, with his instinctive protectionism potentially overriding his desire to combat the North Korean nuclear threat.

The confusing signals from the White House increase the dangers of miscalculation, not just in Pyongyang, but in Seoul, Beijing and Tokyo. With the North Korean threat mounting, the normal reaction for South Korea would be to move in lockstep with its American protector. But if the government of Moon Jae-in concludes the biggest danger is not that North Korea will attack but that Mr Trump will stage a pre-emptive strike, then the South’s incentives change. At that point, it might become rational to break publicly with Washington.

The Chinese government faces a similarly complex set of calculations. Mr Trump has repeatedly tried to persuade Beijing to exert more economic pressure on North Korea, threatening that the US will take unilateral military action if China fails to force Mr Kim into line. China has sought to placate Mr Trump by toughening sanctions on Pyongyang. But the Chinese also have to consider how Mr Kim might react if he is forced into a corner. The risk that the North Korean leader will use nuclear weapons first will surely rise if he is faced with the prospect of the collapse of his own regime — and his own certain death.

I don’t really have a great deal to add other than to point out failing to act decisively in the event of an attack by North Korea on the U. S., its interests, or its allies would be a miscalculation as well.

0 comments

The New Opiate

At Politico Alan Abramowitz and Steven Webster point out, correctly in my view, the role of what they call “negative partisanship”:

Over the past few decades, American politics has become like a bitter sports rivalry, in which the parties hang together mainly out of sheer hatred of the other team, rather than a shared sense of purpose. Republicans might not love the president, but they absolutely loathe his Democratic adversaries. And it’s also true of Democrats, who might be consumed by their internal feuds over foreign policy and the proper role of government were it not for Trump. Negative partisanship explains nearly everything in American politics today—from why Trump’s base is unlikely to abandon him even if, as he once said, he were to shoot someone on Fifth Avenue, to why it was so easy for vulnerable red-state Democrats to resist defecting on the health care bill.

Consider, for instance, that while Trump’s approval ratings have lately been in the mid- to upper 30s, he has maintained support of the overwhelming majority of Republican voters—around 80 percent in Gallup’s tracking poll. And that’s what matters to him and to most Republican members of Congress. The president understands that as long as that Republican base remains loyal to him, he is unlikely to face a serious challenge from GOP members of the House and Senate. He also knows that the surest way to keep the support of his base is by attacking Democrats, especially the two most prominent leaders of the Democratic Party—Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama. What looks like an unhealthy Twitter obsession over “Crooked Hillary” and her emails is more likely a team-building exercise—a shrewd effort to keep his party focused on their shared enemy: Democrats. And so far, it’s working for him.

This hostile and confrontational style of politics is a by-product of the growth in negative partisanship within the American electorate. Our research has shown that since the 1980s, supporters of both major parties, including independents who just lean toward one party or the other, have grown to dislike the opposing party and its elected leaders more than they like their own party and its elected leaders. And judging from opinion polls, that trend reached a new high in 2016—an election dominated by negative feelings toward both major-party candidates.

Lest you be confused the increase in “negative partisanship” is a fine example of misdirection. Politicians who not only make a lot of promises but fail to deliver results but actively work against the interests of their supporters and constituents, avoid being booted out of their jobs by the latch that the two major political parties have on the electoral process and by directing the ire of voters against the horrors of the other party rather than against them. They then proceed to use their safe seats to ensure job continuity and to enrich themselves, their families, and their friends.

I know of no better example of those warned about in the New Testament:

Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep’s
clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.

than today’s political leadership.

Politics has become the new opiate of the people.

1 comment

Blame Congress

The Economist points out a study that found an interesting but little commented-on aspect of the Affordable Care Act:

Hospitals in districts where a Republican congressman supported the Medicare Modernisation Act were five times more likely to receive a waiver than those in ones where a Republican lawmaker voted against. Those hospitals spent 25% more than they otherwise would have in the seven years after the law, according to the researchers. Between 2005 and 2010 the 29 hospitals that received the most lucrative waivers spent an average of $1.25bn more than if they had not received one.

Some of the windfall went on equipment and staff. The average hospital to benefit from a waiver increased its number of nurses by 16% per year from 2006 to 2010. But the splurge seems not to have improved care. No changes were registered as a result in the mortality rate for patients admitted to hospitals with a heart attack, or in the time taken to discharge those who survive one—two standard measures of quality.

Chief executives fared well, though. The average bump in bosses’ pay in the sample of hospitals benefiting most from the waiver was 81% over the same period, equating to a pay rise of about $428,000 per year above that received by bosses of similar hospitals with no waiver. Politicians benefited indirectly. Legislators with hospitals granted waivers in their district saw a 22% overall increase in campaign contributions after the act. Donations from individuals in the health industry in their state increased by 65%.

In other words in explaining the high cost of health care in the United States, your investigation should start and end with Congress. It didn’t start in 2013 or even in 2010. It began more than a half century ago when the Congress began using health care as a political lever.

Don’t expect the Congress to remedy the situation now or ever. More than anything else they want to keep their jobs.

0 comments

Summary of the Korea Situation

At RealClearPolitics Charles Lipson, whose blog Zip Dialog is in my select blogroll at right, ably summarizes the “North Korea crisis”:

We have entered the most dangerous moment in world politics since the 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis.

The nightmare is only getting worse, thanks to North Korea’s increasingly rapid development of nuclear weapons, the missiles to deliver them, and the regime’s chilling threats to use them against the U.S., Japan, and South Korea.

There’s only one paragraph in his assessment that I found controversial:

Since deterrence is almost certain to work, the real question is “Is ‘near certainty’ good enough?” If there is a 10 percent chance Seattle and Los Angeles could be destroyed in some future conflict with North Korea, should we wage preventive war now? What if the chance is 5 percent? 1 percent? No one has any idea what the odds are. No one. But we do know that preventive war now will kill tens of thousands, possibly many more, and we know the last preventive war ended badly.

I think, quite to the contrary, that deterrence is almost certain not to work in North Korea’s case because of the country’s unique political and cultural circumstances and that, absent a willingness in the United States to impose sanctions on China, North Korea’s primary sponsor and abettor in its nuclear weapons development, our alternatives are limited to preventive war or what President Obama referred to as “strategic patience”.

Preventive war is always immoral for reasons along the lines that Mr. Lipson lists and is certainly illegal. I choose patience.

Sadly, I also think that Mr. Lipson gravely underestimates the likely death toll of war with North Korea. It is far more likely to number in the millions than tens of thousands and our political leaders and media pundits are doing an awful job of preparing us for the likely outcome.

6 comments