Lest We Forget

I would be remiss were I not to mention that this is the 16th anniversary of the attacks on New York and Washington. I’ve already said everything I care to on the subject but I’ll update this post with links to any memorable reflections I stumble across today.

Update

I promised to update if I found something memorable and I think this is. According to the Tribunist the pilots who scrambled on 9/11 were ordered to take down Flight 93, regardless of whether they had missiles or live ammunition:

On September 11, 2001, Lt. Heather “Lucky” Penney in an F-16 at Andrews Air Force Base. She had her orders. She was to take down down United Airlines Flight 93. The hijacked plane was headed toward Washington DC. Three other planes had hit targets in New York and Washington, and Flight 93 was destined to become the fourth.

Penney was the second combat pilot in the air that morning. The idea of shooting down a civilian aircraft, even a hijacked one, was troublesome enough–but Penney had no missiles or live ammunition. All she had were her orders and her plane. She was going to take the plane down the hard way.

“We wouldn’t be shooting it down. We’d be ramming the aircraft,” Penney said of the surreal moment. “I would essentially be a kamikaze pilot.”

0 comments

Pesto!

One of the very nicest things about late summer is harvesting the basil I’ve been growing through the summer to make pesto. Last night I harvested one plant and used it to make one batch of pesto. I’ll harvest more in the coming days, consume some, and freeze the rest.

My experience has been that how good pesto is depends greatly on the quality of the ingredients used in its preparation. This year in addition to my own fresh basil, harvested moments before processing, I used fresh garlic, good olive oil, good pine nuts, and good Parmesan cheese, grated just minutes before I added it to my pesto. My wife pronounced it our best ever.

0 comments

Ideas, Identities, and the Way Ahead

I both agree and disagree with Jedediah Purdy’s essay at Politico on the transition of the United States from Chesterton’s “country founded on a creed” to one in which warring racial, ethnic, and religious groups vie for power:

We all know the lived experience of the new American tribalism, both the outward-facing kind—us, the United States, versus them, the rest of the world or at least our chosen foes—and the inward-facing kind—the bubble neighborhoods, the fractured media, the rush of blood upon seeing bumper stickers for the other candidate. We know the sense that there is not even a common premise of fact in an argument over a new police shooting or the latest Trump tweet. There is a sense that maybe there is no way out of these foxholes, that this clash of tribes rules out even an imperfect common understanding or a partial overlap of common principles that might breed progress. At a bubble-neighborhood musical event recently, I stepped aside for a well-groomed, younger middle-aged guy whose shirt said, “I’VE BEEN TO THE FUTURE. WE WON.” At first, I kind of liked it. Then I wondered, what did WE do to them? What would they have done to us, if they had won instead? And who drew the lines?

I agree that it has happened and that saddens me. I disagree with his wholesale exoneration of the Obama Administration and with his prescription:

Solidarity is one idea that might help begin coming to terms with these conflicts. Trump used the word in his inaugural address—surprisingly, the first time a president had done so. In his mouth, it had a nationalist meaning, but historically speaking, it is a word for robust democracy—from the Polish workers’ movement of the same name that helped bring down the Soviet-backed communist state in the 1980s to the social democratic governments of Europe that built, for a few decades after World War II, the most egalitarian societies the modern world has seen. It evokes being in a shared struggle, lending a hand, understanding that people can flourish only with support from one another.

Coming together does not mean embracing Trump’s “many sides” framing. Some American inheritances, such as nostalgia for the Confederacy’s racist social order, are flatly incompatible with real solidarity, and must be fully repudiated. And like other values, such as liberty and equality, solidarity inevitably has left-leaning and right-leaning inflections that might seem at odds—more emphasis on public higher education, on the one hand, and respect for and identification with law enforcement on the other, for instance. But institutions such as unions, public schools and religious communities still connect people with very different partisan outlooks. The fight over repealing Obamacare, with its unexpected surge of rural conservatives recognizing their communities’ reliance on Medicaid, is a reminder that when institutions really do tie people together and serve their essential needs, those institutions are harder to shred by vilifying them or identifying them with the other tribe.

I see no room for solidarity other than in a totalitarian double plus good duck speak sort of way. Solidarity as long as you adhere rigidly to today’s orthodoxy which is certain to change tomorrow?

I don’t see the kind of loyalty to any of the institutions he names that existed a half century ago. Identity politics has killed it.

0 comments

Where’s the Growth?

The topic du jour, spurred, no doubt by the discussions of the federal budget and debt ceiling, is federal debt. Here’s Phil Gramm’s and Michael Solon’s sally at the Wall Street Journal:

Growth deniers are declaring that America’s economy has lost its ability to grow at 3% above inflation. If that’s the case, maybe we should go back to where we lost 3% growth and retrace our steps until we find it. For only with 3% or higher growth does America experience measurable progress in poverty reduction, strong job creation and income growth. If 3% growth is irretrievably lost, so is the American Dream.

Did America actually experience 3% real growth to start with? Yes. In the postwar era, the U.S. averaged 3.4% annual growth from 1948 through 2008. We averaged 3% growth for half of the George W. Bush presidency (2003-06). From 2009-12, the Obama administration, the Congressional Budget Office and the Federal Reserve all thought they saw 3% growth just around the corner. If the possibility of 3% growth is gone forever, it hasn’t been gone very long.

America enjoyed 3% growth for so long it’s practically become our national birthright. Census data show that real economic growth averaged 3.7% from 1890-1948. British economist Angus Maddison estimates that the U.S. averaged 4.2% real growth from 1820-89. Based on all available data, America has enjoyed an average real growth rate of more than 3% since the founding of the nation, despite the Civil War, two world wars, the Great Depression and at least 32 recessions and financial panics. If 3% growth has now slipped from our grasp, we certainly had it for a long time before we lost it.

So poor was our economic performance during the Obama presidency, with its 1.47% economic growth, that now many Americans believe 3% growth is gone forever. The CBO has slashed its 10-year growth forecast to a measly 1.8% per year. If we never see 3% growth again, our grandchildren may point to 2009 and say, “That was when the American economy ran out of gas.”

Not to be left behind, in his regular Washington Post column Robert Samuelson, too, complains about the debt:

A new study by Paul N. Van de Water of the left-leaning Center on Budget and Policy Priorities makes this clear. On the one hand, government gets bigger. In 2016, federal spending totaled 20.9 percent of gross domestic product (GDP), our economy. By 2035, this will be 23.5 percent of GDP, Van de Water projects. That 2.6-percentage-point gain may seem tiny. It isn’t. It equals almost $500 billion in today’s dollars. (Remember: The U.S. economy has a $19 trillion GDP; one percentage point is $190 billion.)

At the same time, much of government is projected to shrink. The simple answer is that the increases for the elderly overshadow the losses for everyone else. Look at the table below. It measures the major categories of federal spending as a share of GDP in 2016 and Van de Water’s estimates for 2035. (Using the share of GDP eliminates the effect of inflation between the two years.)

The elderly enjoy big gains in Social Security, Medicare and “other health spending.” Meanwhile, defense spending drifts toward its lowest level since 1940. Other domestic programs (the FBI, the national parks, regulation) could face crippling defunding. The same holds true for “other entitlements” (food stamps, unemployment insurance).

Note also that, despite the cuts and a large tax increase, there remains a big 2035 deficit running into the hundreds of billions.

Here’s the table to which Mr. Samuelson refers:

To put that into perspective, present state, federal, and local government spending already exceeds what it was at the height of World War II as a percentage of GDP and there’s no end in sight.

That’s not a painless increase. Deadweight loss results in less economic growth than would otherwise be the case as does financing the deficit via debt.

Trimming the federal budget would require ending foreign adventurism and cutting defense spending correspondingly, making the commonsense reforms to Social Security Retirement Income suggested in Mr. Samuelson’s column, and slowing and/or reversing the growth in healthcare spending. Increasing median wages by curbing immigration of low wage workers and creating a tighter labor market would help, too, as would depending less on consumer spending and imports, incentivizing business investment, and more exports. As long as the party of small government that won’t cut government faces it off against the party of big government but, sadly, not of good government, the prospects are bleak.

5 comments

Not Letting a Good Crisis Go To Waste

Wasting no time, the editors of the Wall Street Journal have put in their oar for open borders:

Even before the hurricanes, construction firms around the U.S. reported trouble finding enough workers. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported 225,000 construction job openings in June, up 30% in the last year and 125% since 2012. According to a survey this month by the Associated General Contractors of America, 86% of firms nationwide anticipate hiring workers in the next year.

The worker shortage is especially acute in fast-growing metro areas in the South such as Atlanta, Houston and Miami. In Texas, 69% of contractors said they struggled to fill positions. About 60% of contractors in the South are having trouble finding carpenters and concrete workers while half need more day laborers.

Older construction workers have left the workforce since the last housing boom. About a third moved to higher-paying industries such as energy and manufacturing. Fewer young men are pursuing the trades or a vocational education, and some can’t pass a drug test.

Big Labor and the restrictionist right say employers simply need to increase wages. But in Texas 57% of contractors reported increasing base pay while a quarter offered bonuses—and they’re still struggling to recruit workers. Between 2013 and 2016, the base pay for a day laborer increased 30% in Houston. Carpenters there earn about $25 an hour, 55% more than three years ago. Large contractors with government contracts can perhaps pay more. But small firms then get out-competed for workers.

Let’s put that in a little perspective. Real wages in construction in the United States are lower than they were 45 years ago:

That decline was mostly due to workers imported from abroad, almost entirely illegally. Do I need to produce evidence that wages in big banks have continued to increase right through the Great Recession despite their having created it? Over time one becomes accustomed to an ever-growing stream of workers who can be paid below what used to be the ordinary expected wage. It’s a great business model as long as the stream continues.

And let’s not talk about the secondary effects. The depressing of wages more generally. The higher spending for roads, schools, sewers, healthcare and so on than would otherwise have been the case.

Meanwhile, the black youth unemployment rate in Houston hovers at around 20%. Sounds like there are plenty of workers available to me.

8 comments

Frankly Speaking

In his op-ed at the Washington Post advocating additional sanctions against North Korea, Josh Rogin says there’s still pressure to be applied on North Korea:

Once the Trump administration acknowledges that China and Russia have done all they intend to, the United States can go much further unilaterally, or with allies, to finally test whether drastic sanctions, combined with tough diplomacy, can move Kim from his defiant position.

“The amount of pressure North Korea has been put under economically is still far short of what we applied to Iran or even Iraq,” a senior administration official said. “There is a long way to go before North Korea is going to feel the pressure they would need to feel to change their calculus.”

but what he means is that we need to start pressuring China:

The Trump administration has dabbled in imposing sanctions on Chinese entities that help enable the Kim regime’s illicit activities, but it has yet to cross the line into any area that might put delicate U.S.-China coordination at risk. Royce urged Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and Defense Secretary Jim Mattis to put such measures into action during a briefing last week.

His committee also wrote a letter to the administration listing large Chinese entities ripe for sanctions, including the Chinese Agricultural Bank and the China Merchant Bank.

“We have not had the resolve to put these sanctions on those major institutions,” said Royce. “It’s time to go to maximum pressure.”

There are risks in confronting large Chinese banks, which are essentially arms of the Chinese government. Former top Treasury Department official Adam Szubin testified to the Senate Banking Committee last week that imposing sanctions on the banks could harm the Chinese economy and have unintended consequences for the U.S. economy.

In the op-ed he doesn’t mention a single additional sanction against North Korea that doesn’t involve China. That’s not saying that it couldn’t or shouldn’t be done. It is saying that it won’t be done.

You can hear the arguments already. We don’t want to start a trade war. My company will lose money. It will cost jobs. The Chinese won’t risk millions of North Koreans streaming across their borders should the Kim regime fall. And so on.

Part of the art of accomplishing objectives is establishing priorities and subpriorities. If everything is equally important, nothing is important. If, as I expect, once North Korea has the ability to use nuclear weapons against us, our allies, or our interests, it will or, worse, it will sell their technology to others who will, avoiding nuclear war would seem to me to be a higher priority than keeping Apple’s stock price high.

2 comments

Always Look for the Bright Side

Larry Dignan, editor in chief of ZDNet, sees a silver lining in the Equifax data breach: the company can serve as an object lesson in how not to handle a data breach. Here are his conclusions:

Add it up and Equifax looks like a company with the following:

  • A massive database with personal information that’s not protected well.
  • Little technology knowhow.
  • A need for more regulation — since it has more valuable data on consumers than Facebook or Google.
  • Class action lawsuits on the horizon.

IMO Equifax is enormously fortunate that the weather has filled the airwaves for the last week. The company’s data breach, the malfeasance that may have followed it, the company’s response to it, and, above all, the broader implications of a breach of so much data of such sensitivity on so many people would have been big news by now.

One additional word. The “data breach checker” the company has apparently implemented is the looniest thing I’ve ever heard of. There is no conceivable way I would ever give out the last six digits of my Social Security number over a wifi connection which is the way most people connect to the Internet these days. I or any other knowledgeable person can deduce somebody’s whole Social Security number in seconds if given the last six digits.

7 comments

Saturday Dinner

I don’t recall whether I’ve shared this before but my wife and I have a regular Saturday night ritual. Saturday night is steak night. Every Saturday we have approximately the same dinner: steak, baked potato, and a vegetable dish or salad (occasionally both). We split a small steak, no more than about 4 oz. for each of us, split a baked potato, and I usually prepare some sort of vegetable dish.

Last night’s vegetable dish was green beans and cherry tomatoes. I started by blanching about a half pound of fresh green beans for four minutes, then drained them. I then sauteed about twenty fresh cherry tomatoes in olive oil and garlic until the cherry tomatoes just started to brown and added the green beans, continuing to saute them for about two minutes, then turning the heat off and covering the pan until I was ready to serve. That’s it. It’s simple, delicious, and very pretty, the green beans still bright and the cherry tomatoes adding color.

That and a glass of wine makes for a darned nice dinner.

14 comments

Spot the Neocolonialist

At American Conservative Daniel Larison reacts to the same op-ed by Bernard-Henri Lévy about which I posted the other day:

The chief danger of establishing a new Kurdish state is that it would be violently opposed by at least three of its new neighbors, and the people of Iraqi Kurdistan would be the ones to suffer as a result. This is why the case in favor of doing this is so exceptionally weak. Proponents of a new Kurdish state never take seriously any of the obvious problems and obstacles, but just wave them away or treat them as unimportant. BHL does much the same, and lamely accuses critics of being neo-colonialists because they are opposed to redrawing the boundaries of Iraq once again.

I’m glad to see someone other than me expressing at least a little skepticism about the prospects for an independent Kurdistan. Maybe I’m naive but I’m skeptical about the likelihood of liberal democracy anywhere the heads of the two major political parties are the hereditary chieftains of its largest tribes.

6 comments

We Can’t Negotiate With North Korea

At Bloomberg View Leonid Bershidsky explains why negotiating with North Korea is impossible:

Mansky’s negotiations were with rather senior officials in the North Korean propaganda machine but perhaps things can go better if the supreme leader himself is involved in talks? Mansky doesn’t think so. “Paradoxically,” he says, “the man at the top doesn’t make decisions, either, because he’s dependent on the dictatorship he has created.” As Mansky tells it, the Kim dictatorship must maintain the cult that was created to sustain it, absurd rules and all; it’s a two-way street of mutual reinforcement. The Communist regime under which Mansky and I both grew up sort of worked like that, too — but North Korea has created a “perfect, flawless” version of the game,

[…]

Mansky looked for signs of the trademark late Soviet irony, the doublethink that allowed our parents, and for some time also us, to survive in an absurd system. He didn’t find any. That left him convinced that the indoctrination of North Koreans was absolute. While they realized the regime’s propaganda was fake, their belief in the necessity of that fakery was absolute.

It’s been tried. It didn’t work. It can’t work. Read the whole thing.

The only real prospect for dealing with North Korea short of risking a nuclear World War III resides in changing China’s incentives to the degree that they’re willing to shut North Korea’s nuclear weapons development program down. That will take determination of a sort that we haven’t shown in decades.

5 comments