At the Foundation for Economic Education Alston Ghafourifar presents some information which is obvious to anyone who’s actually studied the issue but I’m sure will be bitterly rejected by many. Automation is a net creator of jobs, as true today as in the 20th, 19th, and 18th centuries. The most compelling evidence he offers is from a recent study in the United Kingdom:
A Deloitte study of automation in the U.K. found that 800,000 low-skilled jobs were eliminated as the result of AI and other automation technologies. But get this: 3.5 million new jobs were created as well, and those jobs paid on average nearly $13,000 more per year than the ones that were lost.
Positive, worker-friendly outcomes like this illustrate a more complete range of possibilities for automation. Technology is changing the way we work – that’s not in dispute. These changes can improve people’s lives and lead to a more creative, intellectually engaged workforce. AI often means that employees can spend more time on complex tasks for which they are uniquely suited, like interacting with customers or brainstorming innovative new campaigns.
The other examples he cites, Panera whose experience I’ve written about in the past, and Marlin Steel, whose experience is characterized here:
Drew Greenblatt, CEO and owner of Marlin Steel, credits automation with not only providing a lifeline to the company but to its employees as well. “All of a sudden they’re super productive and it’s because we’ve given them the tools – it’s robotics and automation,†he said. “Thank God for robots. If it wasn’t for robots, these guys would be unemployed.â€
Leveraging robotics helped Marlin Steel land major clients by creating higher-quality products. The company’s success suggests yet another positive side effect of automation: the opportunity for companies to enter into higher-margin product lines. Staying competitive means always finding a new edge, a differentiator that inspires people to choose your company over the next.
are both anecdotal but also indicative. The experience of the last 300 years is that automation and efficiency actually produce more jobs than they destroy. That’s why, despite the large number of farming jobs that have been lost over the years, more people are gainfully and productively employed than at any time in human history.
Tellingly, there are no counterexamples over that period. While the people in nearly every country are living better than ever before, no country has experienced persistent massive unemployment due to automation.
That tells us that persistent technological unemployment is a risk to be mitigated rather than an issue. The graver concerns are the factors that are preventing new jobs from being created: governments taking too much money out of the private sector, excessive government regulation, barriers to trade particularly the one way autarkies favored by some of our major trading partners, and protections being given to favored occupations that are prime targets for automation.
What is true is that the sorts of jobs on offer will change. There aren’t nearly as many jobs plowing fields behind a team of mules or hauling loads by driving a team of draft horses as there used to be and I strongly suspect there are few who want to see those jobs return. There are millions more truckers than there ever were of those original teamsters and they’re paid a lot better.






