Automation’s Creative Destruction

At the Foundation for Economic Education Alston Ghafourifar presents some information which is obvious to anyone who’s actually studied the issue but I’m sure will be bitterly rejected by many. Automation is a net creator of jobs, as true today as in the 20th, 19th, and 18th centuries. The most compelling evidence he offers is from a recent study in the United Kingdom:

A Deloitte study of automation in the U.K. found that 800,000 low-skilled jobs were eliminated as the result of AI and other automation technologies. But get this: 3.5 million new jobs were created as well, and those jobs paid on average nearly $13,000 more per year than the ones that were lost.

Positive, worker-friendly outcomes like this illustrate a more complete range of possibilities for automation. Technology is changing the way we work – that’s not in dispute. These changes can improve people’s lives and lead to a more creative, intellectually engaged workforce. AI often means that employees can spend more time on complex tasks for which they are uniquely suited, like interacting with customers or brainstorming innovative new campaigns.

The other examples he cites, Panera whose experience I’ve written about in the past, and Marlin Steel, whose experience is characterized here:

Drew Greenblatt, CEO and owner of Marlin Steel, credits automation with not only providing a lifeline to the company but to its employees as well. “All of a sudden they’re super productive and it’s because we’ve given them the tools – it’s robotics and automation,” he said. “Thank God for robots. If it wasn’t for robots, these guys would be unemployed.”

Leveraging robotics helped Marlin Steel land major clients by creating higher-quality products. The company’s success suggests yet another positive side effect of automation: the opportunity for companies to enter into higher-margin product lines. Staying competitive means always finding a new edge, a differentiator that inspires people to choose your company over the next.

are both anecdotal but also indicative. The experience of the last 300 years is that automation and efficiency actually produce more jobs than they destroy. That’s why, despite the large number of farming jobs that have been lost over the years, more people are gainfully and productively employed than at any time in human history.

Tellingly, there are no counterexamples over that period. While the people in nearly every country are living better than ever before, no country has experienced persistent massive unemployment due to automation.

That tells us that persistent technological unemployment is a risk to be mitigated rather than an issue. The graver concerns are the factors that are preventing new jobs from being created: governments taking too much money out of the private sector, excessive government regulation, barriers to trade particularly the one way autarkies favored by some of our major trading partners, and protections being given to favored occupations that are prime targets for automation.

What is true is that the sorts of jobs on offer will change. There aren’t nearly as many jobs plowing fields behind a team of mules or hauling loads by driving a team of draft horses as there used to be and I strongly suspect there are few who want to see those jobs return. There are millions more truckers than there ever were of those original teamsters and they’re paid a lot better.

13 comments

Time for Biometric ID

I agree with at least one component of Daniel Castro’s remarks at RealClearPolicy on the data breach at Equifax. It’s time, long past time actually, to abandon the Social Security number system:

We should replace the outdated, paper-based system of Social Security numbers with a secure identity system built for the digital era. To accomplish this, Congress must significantly expand the National Strategy for Trusted Identities in Cyberspace, an initiative led by the Department of Commerce to create secure electronic IDs that can be used both commercially and in government.

These electronic IDs would allow individuals to prove their identities (or attributes about their identities) securely to other systems — a complete replacement of the 80-year-old SSN for the digital era. Individuals could use these electronic IDs for a variety of purposes, from applying for credit and signing legal documents to verifying they are over the age of 21 when ordering wine online. The State Department, which already has systems and processes in place to verify the identity of individuals who apply for passports, could issue these electronic IDs. The IDs themselves could be either physical or digital artifacts, such as a smartcard or digital certificate installed in a mobile app.

The Social Security number system was devised when in all likelihood the system was administered with ledger cards. There was a ledger card for each individual enrolled in the system. In all likelihood each transaction was handwritten in—IIRC the ledger card machine which could imprint ledger cards wasn’t available until 1958.

There were far, far fewer of them, too. I believe the entire cache of old Social Security ledger cards are sitting around somewhere in 500 boxes.

Some form of biometric ID should be adopted. Not only would that make the system more secure it would make fraud a lot more expensive if not impossible.

Most OECD countries other than the Anglosphere countries, Denmark, and Norway have national ID cards, many of them are compulsory, and an increasing number are biometric IDs. It’s an idea whose time came a long time ago.

Update

About 35 years ago I advised a client not to use Social Security numbers as the primary ID for individuals in their computer systems on the grounds that it was insecure and likely to be banned. That’s exactly what has happened in many states but I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if there were still a lot of systems out there which use SSNs as primary IDs.

2 comments

Not Taking Security Seriously

Charles Lipson makes a good point with respect to Equifax’s data breach: why did neither the company’s Chief Security Officer nor its Chief Information Officer had any background in security, information, or computer science:

At first, I thought this LinkedIn profile for Susan Mauldin, Equifax’s chief security officer, was a joke.

It’s not.

The joke is on us.

Do you think the Chief Information Officer has a stronger background?

Nope. BA in Russian, an MBA, and then some work in a bank.

There are several obvious conclusions that may be taken from this. The first is that Equifax clearly didn’t take security seriously. Frankly, I’m skeptical that it will do so even with recent developments. I guess I should be philosophical about it. The company probably won’t exist in five years.

The other conclusion is that “technocracy” doesn’t mean what you think it means. In theory it means “rule by experts”. What does it mean in practice? My read is that both of these managers were Rolodex hires.

4 comments

What’s Happening in China?

I’m not sure of what to make of this report about China’s economy from Global Security Review:

Over two million Chinese workers have been laid off in recent months due to “over capacity.” Companies have been shut down as employers either sold their businesses or simply disappeared. These layoffs have increased the numbers of unemployed youth in urban areas, increasing the risk of social unrest.

Chinese President Xi Jinping has suggested sending China’s increasingly debt-prone youth to work in the country, in a “Second Cultural Revolution.” Few have taken the offer despite employment opportunities in farming, food processing, and rural tourism.

Let’s put that into some perspective. Two million sounds like a lot but the total number of employed persons in China is around three-quarters of a billion. Two million people represent about a third of one percent of China’s workforce.

I agree with a lot of what’s in the article but China is so large and the economic numbers we receive are so cooked I have no idea how we can discern what’s actually happening at this great distance. I doubt that we could tell that China had collapsed until it had already happened. Maybe not even then.

5 comments

Why Hasn’t Pump-Priming Worked?

In his latest essay at RealClearMarkets Jeffrey Snider asks a very simple question: why hasn’t stimulus, pump-priming worked? As is the case with all of his essays I’ve read so far, it’s unexcerptable. I’m not even sure I can really recommend that you read the whole thing. Here’s a taste:

Keynes coalmine parable is incomplete. The Treasury Department can print and bury a whole lot of banknotes in the ground, have private businesses extract them from under the town refuse, and then watch as they are hoarded, too, along with money and cash already in and then out of circulation. The addition of new money is pointless unless it addresses the reason or reasons existing money has failed in the first place.

He has one answer and I have another. My answer is that the Great Recession followed the collapse of a bubble and bubbles are different. As a bubble inflates the increasing capacity is imaginary. It doesn’t really exist. When it collapses, it’s a return to reality. You can’t reinflate the bubble. There’s nothing to reinflate.

The implication of my theory is that our economy has been growing very, very slowly for a very long time. It’s not enough to revert back to 2006 or to 1999. You’ve got to go back much farther back than that (at least to 1993) and remediate the harm that all of the wrong choices that have been made over the intervening period has wrought.

5 comments

What’s the Objective of Corporate Income Taxes?

At Forbes Nathan Lewis has a good post about the conundrum facing the United States. We have the highest corporate income tax rates among OECD countries but realize less revenue from corporate income taxes than other OECD countries do:

One of the harder economic concepts to embrace is that tax revenues, as a percentage of GDP, are often lower when rates are higher, and higher when rates are lower. Huh? The reason is that high rates have a multitude of effects, among them: people do not engage in highly-taxed activities; and there is inevitably intense pressure upon the political system to create all sorts of exemptions and exclusions, so that more activity is taxed at a lower rate, or untaxed.

That is why the U.S., with a 38.91% combined tax rate (according to the OECD), has total corporate tax revenue of a meager 2.06% of GDP, while Britain, with a 19.00% combined rate, has revenue of 2.58% of GDP (average over five years 2011-2015).

That’s not a “trickle-down” or “Laffer Curve” argument. It is a statement of fact based on observable behavior.

What are the objectives of corporate income taxes? If they are to ensure that corporations “pay their fair share”, they’re obviously not accomplishing that. If they’re to realize more revenue, they’re not accomplishing that, either.

Are they intended to provide big companies a competitive advantage over small companies? If so, that objective is neither legitimate nor desireable. New companies start small and they hire. Big companies have trimmed payrolls for decades.

Are they intended to show voters that politicians’ hearts are in the right place, that they’re on the side of the little guy? That’s not a legitimate reason, either, and it’s reducing the effectiveness of legitimate objectives of corporate income taxes.

How does 3.5% of a higher GDP realized from the corporate income tax sound?

Probably, the best thing would be to implement a full “flat tax” reform – the corporate half of the “flat tax” proposals that have already been worked out in detail. Personally, I like Steve Forbes’ version, described in The Flat Tax Revolution (2005). This would eliminate huge counterproductive swathes of the tax code, and probably produce much more revenue – perhaps as much as 3.5% of GDP, as demonstrated by Hong Kong, with its 16.5% rate.

Establish priorities. Do what is required to accomplish the priorities. Stop letting politicians campaign at the nation’s expense.

4 comments

Giving the Easy Answers

Catherine Rampell devotes her Washington Post column to arguing that Sen. Sanders’s health care reform plan is an exercise in signalling how virtuous he and anyone who supports his plan are:

Given Americans’ allergy to higher taxes, it’s not enough to dismiss fiscal concerns by assuming Americans will gladly give Uncle Sam the money they currently earmark for a private health insurance system.

On this and other major questions, the Sanders plan punts. Anyone who asks such questions, or raises an eyebrow at the lowball estimates cooked up by the Sanders camp, gets branded a wet blanket, a heartless technocrat, a corporate shill or worse.

The goal should be universal health care, however we get there. And we’re much likelier to get there if we start from a baseline of reality than if both parties hand-wave away inconvenient truths. There is no courage in saying everyone should have health care. The courage is in staking out a plan to pay for it.

One way of beginning that process is by defining what is meant by “universal health care”. What is “universal”? Everyone? Every citizen? Everyone in the country legally? If your answer is “citizens”, you’ve already discounted nearly 15% of the people in California, the most populous state in the Union and, consequently, the most influential.

What is meant by “health care”? Everything that patients may want? Everything they need? Who decides what they need?
Some market basket of defined care? Who decides what goes into the basket?

These are hard questions. Handwaving is ever so much easier than answering them.

5 comments

It’s Complicated

In his latest New York Times column David Brooks speculates that maybe the U. S. economy is working as you would expect it to:

In 2015, median household incomes rose by 5.2 percent. That was the fastest surge in percentage terms since the Census Bureau began keeping records in the 1960s. Women living alone saw their incomes rise by 8.7 percent. Median incomes for Hispanics rose by 6.1 percent. Immigrants’ incomes, excluding naturalized citizens, jumped by over 10 percent.

The news was especially good for the poor. The share of overall income that went to the poorest fifth increased by 3 percent, while the share that went to the affluent groups did not change. In that year, the poverty rate fell by 1.2 percentage points, the steepest decline since 1999.

The numbers for 2016 have just been released by the Census Bureau, and the trends are pretty much the same. Median household income rose another 3.2 percent, after inflation, to its highest level ever. The poverty rate fell some more. The share of national income going to labor is now rising, while the share going to capital is falling.

However, this passage jumped out at me:

In a well-functioning economy, workers are rewarded for their productivity. As output, jobs and hours worked rise, so does income. Over the past two years, that seems to be exactly what’s happening.

That’s simply not true. Workers are rewarded based on the productivity of other workers whom they resemble superficially, not on the basis of their own personal productivity. The most productive mail carrier in the U. S. is paid the same as other mail carriers with the same job title and seniority. That’s the way the government and most private sector companies work. Maybe that’s not a “well-functioning economy” but it’s the one we have and we shouldn’t expect anything else to materialize in the foreseeable future.

He continues:

The problem of the middle-class squeeze, in short, may not be with how the fruits of productivity are distributed, but the fact that there isn’t much productivity growth at all. It’s not that a rising tide doesn’t lift all boats; it’s that the tide is not rising fast enough.

That’s why I perseverate on deadweight loss. Total government spending is around 36% of GDP. That’s a lot of space for deadweight loss (the difference between the economic activity that would have been realized and the economic activity that was actually realized in the light of government spending) and it wouldn’t take much to boost GDP.

Then Mr. Brooks lurches uncontrollably on to the truth:

If productivity itself is the problem, not distribution, radically different politics is demanded than we’re seeing today. If productivity is the problem, we need more dynamism, not less, more openness, not less, more growth-oriented policies, not more dirigiste and redistributive ones.

Simply discarding the programs that aren’t accomplishing their goals would be a step in the right direction.

1 comment

What If These Ship Collisions Are the Results of Cyberattacks?

At Foreign Policy Elias Groll reports that the Navy is investigating whether the McCain’s collision was the result of a cyberattack:

The military is examining whether compromised computer systems were responsible for one of two U.S. Navy destroyer collisions with merchant vessels that occurred in recent months, Vice Admiral Jan Tighe, the deputy chief of naval operations for information warfare, said on Thursday.

Naval investigators are scrambling to determine the causes of the mishaps, including whether hackers infiltrated the computer systems of the USS John S. McCain ahead of the collision on Aug. 21, Tighe said during an appearance at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington.

Investigators are not, however, considering the possibility that the USS Fitzgerald collision, which took place on June 17, was the result of hacking.

“With the McCain incident happening so close to the Fitzgerald,” questions immediately arose about whether computer manipulation could have been the cause of the crash, Tighe said. The Navy has no indication that a cyberattack was behind either of the incidents, but is dispatching investigators to the McCain to put those questions to rest, she said.

That they’re investigating it doesn’t mean that’s what happened. It just means they’re considering the possibility, for this event and prospective future events. Our military considers all sorts of counter-factuals.

But what if it was a cyberattack? I don’t know that it’s even possible to operate these enormous machines without their computer systems and retrofitting them so that they can be sounds like an expensive and maybe impossible task. Security capable of definitely denying success to cyberattacks has proven elusive to our military, our government, and private sector companies alike. It requires patterns of thought presently foreign to them, completely counter-intuitive, and which limit their freedom of action in ways they presently find intolerable.

4 comments

Health Care Reform Means Cutting Costs

At Reason Peter Suderman has unearthed a video clip from 30 years ago of the younger Bernie Sanders telling what is the simple truth: Medicaid for all would bankrupt the United States. Go on over there for the clip.

Note that real per capita health care spending is significantly higher today than it was 30 years ago. Mr. Suderman observes:

Medicaid, notably, is far less generous than Medicare, the health program for seniors that Sanders wants to expand.

Medicaid’s provider networks are narrower, and its benefits are generally more limited. It pays doctors quite a bit less than Medicare, on average, and it costs substantially less per capita. Relative to Medicare, it’s the bargain option.

This is a short clip, and the full version may reveal additional relevant context. But what Sanders is describing in the segment above is the comparatively high cost of health care services in the United States relative to countries like Canada. As the clip ends, Dr. Milton Terris begins to discuss the ways in which other countries limit extra charges and use the power of government monopoly to force down prices.

Forcing health care spending down to the levels seen in other countries would radically upset the system, pushing doctors out of business and likely leaving many hospitals with little choice but to close down or eliminate services. It would, at minimum, be incredibly difficult politically, since it would require decreasing funding to hospitals and other large medical facilities, which would in turn require eliminating jobs or drastically reducing compensation. At the end of every health care spending cut is an individual with a job and a paycheck.

That’s the conclusion I came to as well. How should health care be reformed? Start making the hard choices now rather than handwaving them away, assuming they’ll be made later, or will be unnecessary. Adopt the mindset of using “the power of government monopoly to force down prices”. Government already pays for more than half of all health care. It has influence which it does not presently choose to use.

Stop subsidizing the wealthy and the well-to-do. Help the genuinely needy. Those are the reforms we need.

3 comments