Evidence

There’s at least a little evidence supporting my hypothesis that command and discipline problems in the Western Pacific area of operations are contributing factors to the ship collisions that have occurred there recently. Reuters reports:

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Navy dismissed two senior officers on Monday after a series of collisions involving Seventh Fleet warships in Asia, citing a loss of confidence in their ability to command.

Rear Admiral Charles Williams, commander of Task Force 70, and Captain Jeffrey Bennett, commander of Destroyer Squadron 15, were fired by Seventh Fleet commander Vice Admiral Phil Sawyer, the Navy said. In August, Sawyer replaced fleet commander Vice Admiral Joseph Aucoin, who was fired after the accidents.

“Both reliefs were due to a loss of confidence in their ability to command,” the Navy statement said.

Various actions have been taken with respect to other officers as well.

1 comment

Health Care System Face-Off

At the New York Times several contributors engage in a tournament-style face-off of the health care systems of the following countries: Canada, Britain, Singapore, Germany, Switzerland, France, Australia and the U.S. Although the U. S. health care system makes it into the semi-finals, it loses there to France.

The country whose system ultimately prevails is Switzerland:

AARON: Switzerland. This is a tough call. Switzerland does a good job of combining conservative and progressive beliefs about health care systems into a workable model providing top-notch access and quality at a reasonable cost. It doesn’t hurt that it does so through private (although heavily regulated) insurance.

CRAIG: France. Its system has more competition among providers than Switzerland’s does.

AUSTIN: Switzerland. The Swiss system is so close to the A.C.A.’s structure (which, to date, has survived all manner of political attacks) that something like it could work in the U.S.

ASHISH: Switzerland Both of these countries spend a lot on health care, outpacing the average among high-income countries, and both perform comparably on measures of access to care. However, in general, the Swiss health care system delivers a higher quality of care across a range of measures and invests more in innovation that fuels new knowledge and, ultimately, better treatments that we all benefit from.

UWE: France. It is cheaper, its financing is more equitable, and its system is simpler.

Not coincidentally, I believe, Switzerland’s per capita spending is second only to that in the United States.

The differences between Switzerland and the United States could hardly be more stark. Switzerland is small, compact, and has a high degree of national consensus and social cohesion. Nearly every matter of significance is subject to a popular vote. Per capita income is higher there than here. It is landlocked. It does not share a 1,500 mile land border with a country where the per capita income is a third of theirs with even worse income inequality. The list is practically endless.

The “tournament” is entertaining and informative but ultimately meaningless. The United States is an outlier and for a health care system to be workable here it will necessarily be an outlier, too.

3 comments

No Preventive War

At RealClearDefense Bonnie Kristian makes an argument that’s music to my ears. The United States must eschew preventive war:

Preventive war has not been the political or ethical norm for the great bulk of U.S. history, and it is a grave mistake to make it an option for responding to North Korea’s admittedly serious provocations.

First, an aside for definitions is in order, for confusion abounds (and is too often misused by modern Washington) over the nature of “preventive” war and its near-homophone, “preemptive” war. Preventive war is an attack launched to prevent the materialization of a potential future threat; preemptive war is a response to an imminent threat.

To attack North Korea right now because it has a nuclear arsenal would be preventive war. The threat is not imminent (and it is entirely possible, though the probability is debatable, that Kim would never use his weapons, but merely maintain his arsenal to deter regime change efforts).

Read the whole thing. Preventive war is immoral and, because of international accords to which the United States is signatory, illegal. It would not make us safer. It would be courting disaster;

2 comments

Ukraine’s Problem

At Globalist Kenneth Courtis explains that Ukraine’s biggest problem is Ukraine:

Ukraine’s President, 51-year old Petro Poroshenko – or Porky, as he is known to all Ukrainians – is at single digits in the polls. With elections scheduled for 2019 that cannot sit well with the oligarch-turned-president.

But in their assessment of him, Ukrainians are simply echoing the disdain that, all smooth-talking rhetoric aside, he has shown them. Remember that he promised to divest himself of certain assets – presumably acquired “legally” once he was elected.

What has happened is the opposite. His group has acquired more state assets at below rock-bottom prices. His firms are already lined up at the trough to gobble up all kinds of stuff in the coming wave of privatizations that the IMF has instructed the county to carry out.

Porky is pretty much the chocolate king of Eastern Europe and the CIS. People on the ground tell me that his three most profitable chocolate factories are in, yes, Russia…

All that sweet stuff can’t obscure the harsh realities. Real wages of workers have been chopped by more than half over the last three years. The emerging middle classes have been crushed.

Read the whole thing. It isn’t long.

What eludes me is why we should support the present kleptocratic government which overthrew the previous kleptocratic government which succeeded the kleptocratic government before that.

3 comments

Drawing the Battle Lines on Equifax

I have so many quibbles with this Bloomberg editorial on the Equifax data breach that it’s hard to know where to start. Let’s start at the beginning:

The three big U.S. credit reporting companies — Equifax, Experian and TransUnion — have an unusual combination of power and lack of accountability. They dominate the business of collecting information on consumers, influencing everything from who gets jobs to how much interest people pay on mortgages. But they’re not answerable to those consumers; they primarily serve the banks and other customers that buy their products. As a result, they lack strong incentives to invest in keeping sensitive data secure, or to fix mistakes that can ruin people’s lives.

The parallels how an old boss of mine characterized the perfect job: maximum impact, minimum accountability. But Equifax’s problems go beyond weak incentives. Weak incentives didn’t cause Equifax’s management to hold on to the news about the breach until after they’d sold their stock, for example. And it doesn’t absolve them from their responsibilities under Sarbanes-Oxley, which requires them to know what the heck is going on in their own companies.

They continue:

Granted, keeping data secure is difficult, and Equifax is hardly the first company to let people down in this fashion. Also, it’s too soon to know how the breach happened, whether the company was negligent, and what kinds of additional defenses could have made a difference.

Let’s stop right there. By definition if you’re robbed the controls you have in place were inadequate to prevent the robbery. You were negligent. What the editors of Bloomberg are talking about is criminal negligence.

That’s why I’ve been arguing for strict liability. Equifax should be held responsible for the consequences of their actions and inactions whatever its managers’ intent and whether or not they were reckless. It also explains the math I’ve been citing: if every individual whose data has been exposed due to Equifax’s heedlessness is compensated for a single hour of remedial action and/or worry about it, that alone would be enough to break the company.

The editors continue by arguing for the need for clarity:

Ideally, Congress would respond with new legislation to give the CFPB clearer authority to police the companies. It could even opt for a more utility-like approach, allowing the CFPB to cap profits until they meet benchmarks for accuracy and privacy. But the companies spend heavily on lobbying, and it would be unwise to rely on Congress: On the day Equifax announced the breach, the House Financial Services Committee was considering legislation to reduce their legal liability.

That, unfortunately, ignores the Congress’s core competency which is doing nothing and the editors recognize that:

Rather than waiting for new legislation, the regulators should do more with the powers they already have. Under FCRA, the CFPB can penalize companies for failing to make “reasonable” efforts to keep sensitive information out of the wrong hands. The bureau should thoroughly investigate whether such efforts were made in this case, and demand strong remedies for any transgressions. If it takes the lead in this, the CFPB can set a new standard for the firms’ protection of financial data.

IMO there are already plenty of laws on the books to deal with this situation. What is missing is the will to enforce them.

2 comments

The Nature of the Problem

Looking at a brightening picture for most Americans, in his latest Washington Post column Robert Samuelson points out the storm clouds:

There’s no table with this figure; but it reflects simple arithmetic. Let’s do it. From 1990 to 2016, the number of people living below the government’s poverty line rose from 33.6 million to 40.6 million, a gain of 7 million. Over the same years, the Hispanics in poverty increased from 6 million to 11.1 million, a gain of 5.1 million and 73 percent of the total 7 million boost.

or, in other words, we don’t have a poverty problem in the United States. We have an immigration problem. Let me put it yet another way. If you can think of any way that we can admit unlimited numbers of poor people who don’t speak English and don’t have skills that will yield them any but a meager income without their being poor, I’m all ears.

My own view is that our bad immigration policies exacerbate most of our other problems, including our poverty and racial equity problems. As I’ve noted previously real black median income hasn’t changed in a generation.

1 comment

Coping With the Worldwide Shortage of Physicians

It’s estimated that within the next ten years there may be a substantial shortfall in the total number of physicians worldwide. In the United States alone it is expected that we will have about 20% fewer physicians than we need.

Such projections are hardly new. In 1960 there was a similar prediction and despite recent increases in the number of medical graduates and a great increase in the number of internationally-trained medical professionals, we still have fewer physicians per 100,000 population than we did in 1960. (We have fewer physicians per 100K population than we did in 1900 but that’s a story I’ve told before.) The practice of importing ITMPs by the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, France, and Germany from Asia, Latin America, and Africa actually exacerbates the shortage in those places.

A startup has devised an innovative approach to medical education with an eye on addressing the problem. Tech Crunch reports:

Lenihan’s thesis is twofold. The first is that medical schools are looking at the wrong signals to determine who they accept. And once accepted, university resources are misallocated by focusing on having professors lecturing to students instead of providing more interactive and practical examples of lessons in the classroom.

Lenihan first began changing admissions guidelines and teaching practices at Touro. He expanded the number of students admitted to the medical school and told teachers to start recording their lectures and distributing them before class.

In the classroom students were quizzed and assessed on their ability to understand and retain the material. It allowed teachers to identify areas where students were falling behind and begin tailoring the lessons to meet individual students’ needs. This new teaching paradigm also let educators determine who would be best pursuing a different path in their studies of medicine. Underperforming students could be referred to nursing school or technical fields where they could still become health care professionals (even if working as a doctor was beyond their ability).

With the success these education innovations had at Touro (admissions were up, students were being accepted into top residency programs, and in-class performance was up across the board), Lenihan began looking for a way to expand on his innovations.

It will be interesting to see how the medical profession and establishment react to their methods, flying in the face, as it does, of the strategy that has been used in medical education in this country for well over a century. Since 1910 the guiding vision has been “fewer better doctors” with “better” defined as more selective and better equipt to be medical researchers.

On the one hand physicians presently practicing are understandably committed to the old strategies and may be concerned about threats to their livelihoods. On the other hand the younger cohorts may well be more amenable not only to new strategies for selecting and training physicians but to telemedicine and other strategies for putting medical resources where they’re most needed.

9 comments

Give Me the Bottom Line

In her article at Greentech Media Emma Foehringer Merchant tells the inconvenient truth:

The pieces of a renewable-forward future are falling into place. Wind, solar, and storage are accelerating. Plummeting costs and greater security in investment mean countries are increasingly looking to renewable technologies as a safe bet. And prices for offshore wind and battery storage are dropping faster than expected.

One hitch, though: That renewable future still won’t mean the globe reaches its climate goals.

which anyone with any mathematical or engineering insight could have told you for the last twenty years. Even if fully implemented the measures being proposed won’t accomplish the objectives that supporters say are necessary for the survival of the human species.

Don’t tell me the cost of the first step or the next step. Give me the bottom line. Tell me what will solve the problem.

Doing anything else really makes one think that these advocates have some other agenda in mind.

I continue to think, as I have thought for many years, that we should be building more nuclear power stations and devoting more attention to capture methods than is presently the case.

23 comments

Some Math Required

In a Wall Street Journal article analyzing Volswagen’s full bore commitment to electric vehicles I found this quote from VW CEO Matthias Müller telling:

Mr. Müller said Volkswagen had to have its feet planted firmly on both sides of the field. It had to keep developing the combustion engine until the market for new technology takes off. “That’s why I say the technologies will have to coexist,” he said. “One day, electric vehicles will make up 25% of our sales.”

The emphasis is mine.

Let’s do a quick reality check. EVs presently constitute less than 2% of VW’s sales. If the second largest auto company in the world presently sells fewer than 2% EVs and sees that topping out at 25% “one day” (the largest car company, Toyota, doesn’t produce an EV; hybrids constitute about 25% of its sales), how long will it be before all of the vehicles on the road are electrics?

IMO VW would do better by spending its money rebuilding the trust it’s lost by committing fraud about the emissions produce by its diesels.

3 comments

An Unseen Subsidy

At RealClearEnergy Josh T. Smith points out something that hadn’t occurred to me. Fossil fuel producers receive substantial subsidies in the form of the very structure of the energy grid:

According to a report by Management Information Services, Inc., a DC consulting firm, the oil and gas industry has received 54 percent of all energy incentives since 1950. Federal energy incentives and favoritism only recently flipped to favor renewables––and flipped big. From 2011 to 2016, renewable energy got more than three times what oil, natural gas, coal, and nuclear received combined.

A huge form of support for the fossil fuel industry is harder to quantify, however. The electrical grid is built with fossil fuel producers in mind. The system is designed to move power in one direction, from producers to consumers. With the emergence of distributed energy sources,, however, electricity now moves from consumers to be used by others–as well as from large power plants. Many current energy policy debates are artifacts of the grid’s design and represent a conflict between the old model and what may eventually become a new way of powering our lives.

My preferred strategy would be, taking a day forward approach, to start eliminating all subsidies for energy and fuel producers, whether fossil fuels, ethanol, solar, wind, or other. These competing technologies should succeed or fail on their own merits.

The single exception to that would be the grid. If we want a resilient, durable power grid suitable for today’s needs it will need to be built by governments, just as roads are built by governments.

4 comments