Party Affiliation

Neither political party has anything resembling a majority of voters affiliated with them.

Gallup: Democrats 28%/Republicans 28%

Pew: Democrats 44%/Republicans 37%

If you add “leaners”, independents who lean more towards Democrats or lean more towards Republicans, both Gallup and Pew get just about the same results: Democrats 48%/Republicans 44%.

28% is not a majority. Neither is 48%. Americans are pretty darned dissatisfied with both political parties.

2 comments

How Many Geese Make a Gaggle?

Despite the title of this post, in it I’m asking a serious question. There have been a number of news stories in recent months about the suppression of freedom of speech on college campuses. University of Missouri, Evergreen State, Yale, Oberlin, Middlebury College, Berkeley, the list goes on.

I think I can identify three distinct positions on whether this constitutes a problem or not. The first position is that it’s a tempest in a teapot, just a handful of instances so, consequently, not a problem. In the “not a problem” camp, there is also a Marcusist strain that not only says that it’s not a problem but such suppression happens, it’s widespread, and it’s good. I’m discounting that view.

The second position is that the issue is present on most if not all college campuses these days and, consequently, is a grave problem because it flies in the face of the very purpose of higher education.

The third is that there’s just not enough data to tell.

Which if any of these positions is correct? If it’s the third, how many colleges, how many incidents would be required for the claim to achieve critical mass and, in particular, before the burden of proof transfers from those who claim it’s a problem to those who say it isn’t or that they don’t know?

The word “gaggle” is a collective noun, a medieval hunting term. There is no authoritative answer to how many geese make a gaggle but it’s at least three. Three or more geese flocking on the ground is a gaggle; three or more geese flocking in the air are a skein.

18 comments

Special Pleading

Special pleading is the logical fallacy in which on cites something as an exception to a general rule or principle without justifying the exception.

Here’s my question. How do you distinguish between “a poor choice of words” and actual bigotry, as Geoffrey Stone and Eric Seagall do in their defense in the New York Times of Dianne Feinstein’s apparent indictment of Catholics in her questioning of judicial nominee Amy Barrett? Isn’t using the wrong words whatever one’s intent now being proclaimed as wrong? Aren’t they making an exception in the case of Sen. Feinstein? Or Catholics?

2 comments

More Cold Equations

The scales have fallen from John Judis’s eyes, as his essay at the New Republic illustrates:

If you take the percentage of Americans that the U.S. census defines as “minorities” and project their past voting habits into the next decade and beyond, you’ll come up with a very sunny version of the Democrats’ prospects. There are only two problems with this line of thinking, but they’re pretty big ones. For starters, the census prediction of a “majority-minority” America—slated to arrive in 2044—is deeply flawed. And so is the notion that ethnic minorities will always and forever continue to back Democrats in Obama-like numbers.

The U.S. census makes a critical assumption that undermines its predictions of a majority-nonwhite country. It projects that the same percentage of people who currently identify themselves as “Latino” or “Asian” will continue to claim those identities in future generations. In reality, that’s highly unlikely. History shows that as ethnic groups assimilate into American culture, they increasingly identify themselves as “white.”

which is precisely the point I made back in 2002 when his book first came out.

The thesis is so flawed it’s hard to know where to start. “Whiteness” is malleable. In 1840 my Irish ancestors were not seen as white. Now they would be. As recently as 1920 my wife’s Italian ancestors along with the Jews and many others who had come here were not seen as white. Now they are except by the .02% of the population who will never see anyone who is not a white Anglo-Saxon Protestant as white.

Today the majority of Mexican-Americans are in fact Mexican citizens. Under the Mexican nationality law people born in Mexico or the foreign-born children of Mexican citizens born in Mexico are Mexican citizens. In 50 years (maybe sooner) the majority of Mexican-Americans won’t be Mexican citizens.

But the notion that blacks, Hispanics, and Asians have more interests in common with each other than they do with the balance of the population is itself fundamentally flawed, a product of ignorance. Tell it to the young black man whose main job competition comes from Hispanics. Or the Asian shopkeeper who’s just had a brick thrown through his window by a black or Hispanic neighborhood kid.

The actual consequences as opposed to the imagined consequences of the racial spoils system sort of identity politics is that various racial minorities will squabble over the scraps that fall from the table while the white elite remains firmly in control of the table. If you don’t believe that’s the case, look at the number and roles of blacks and Hispanics in the Congressional Democratic caucus.

He continues to overestimate the proportion of the population who are progressives but that’s another question. IMO it’s more like 15% of the population than 51% but if you torture the definition of “progressive” long enough it will submit. Jacksonians, white, black, or other are the most hidebound of conservatives but they see nothing in conflict between that and taking a government handout.

5 comments

The Cold Equations

Something else you might find entertaining comes from James Freeman of the Wall Street Journal:

In August, 36% of respondents said they had a somewhat or very positive view of Mr. Trump, compared to 52% with a somewhat or very negative view. These numbers look terrible, until you see Mrs. Clinton’s. Just 30% of respondents said they had a somewhat or very positive view of her, compared to 53% with a somewhat or very negative view—23 percentage points underwater. This is not quite the worst polling she’s ever had in this survey. Mrs. Clinton did manage to sink to 24 points underwater in April of last year—right after the email scandal broke.

and that’s what happened. Americans have become like the Bourbons, who “learned nothing and forgot nothing”, as Talleyrand put it. More bourbons, less Bourbons!

0 comments

Reducing People to a Number

I think that Amar Bhidé is whistling past a graveyard in his op-ed in the Wall Street Journal. In it he blames the rise of Equifax and other credit-scoring companies on fair lending laws:

Outrage that Equifax exposed more than 143 million credit records to identity thieves misses the point. We really should worry about what makes impersonation so easy—why do lenders know so little about the people to whom they issue credit?

Because laws meant to ensure fair lending also reduce individuals to anonymous credit scores. Regulators enforcing the 1968 Fair Housing Act and the 1974 Equal Credit Opportunity Act look askance at lenders who rely on judgment instead of scores to screen loan applications.

Even broadly relying on statistical scores doesn’t get lenders off the hook. Regulators also frown on “discretionary overrides,” especially if lenders allow frontline staff to overrule scores instead of having someone at headquarters do it. A branch-based banker in direct contact with customers may be better positioned to determine whether an applicant’s score reflects true creditworthiness. But regulators worry that giving branch staffers this authority may invite discrimination, so it’s a no-no.

Federal fairness examiners also worry about “customized” scoring models that can include variables excluded from credit-bureau records, such as education. It isn’t entirely forbidden, but regulators worry those variables could correlate with factors like race, ethnicity and sex. Lenders often resort to using a “generic” bureau score, popularly called a FICO score, to mitigate regulatory risk.

Everything in our civilization is pushing towards reducing people to numbers. Whether you can buy a house or a car, whether you get that job, whether you get into that school, and, consequently, how much you earn and where and how you live are all governed by numbers. It won’t be reversed.

The drawing at the top of this post is the minor Peanuts character 555 95472. Welcome, fellow numbers!

2 comments

Who Works Harder?

You might be entertained by this table, courtesy of the OECD, of the average number of hours worked per year by workers in various countries. It tells us, for example, that on average Americans work about two weeks more per year than Canadians, that New Zealanders work about as many hours per year as Americans do, and that the people of France, Germany, and the Netherlands work a lot less than Americans, months less on average in a year.

It also tells us that Greeks work much, much longer on average than Germans do. That’s another way of saying, as I’ve claimed for years, that Greece’s problem isn’t that the Greeks are lazy but that Greece is undercapitalized.

1 comment

“Trickle Down” Lives!

Or maybe this post should have been titled “The Return of the Laffer Curve”. The editors of the Wall Street Journal, predictably, argue that the Republicans should just ignore balancing the budget in favor of a revenue-decreasing tax cut:

The problem is that under the arcane rules of “reconciliation,” legislation cannot raise the deficit beyond the budget “window” that is usually 10 years. Tax writers thus feel obliged to “pay for” any tax cut based on estimates from the Joint Committee on Taxation and Congressional Budget Office, though such estimates are notoriously unreliable predictors of growth and tax receipts.

The GOP might trap itself inside this budget box. House Speaker Paul Ryan has already conceded publicly that cutting the corporate tax rate to 15% from 35% is unrealistic and the rate might have to be in “the mid-to-low 20s.” House Republicans have already abandoned a cut in the top individual tax rate, and death-tax repeal could also be on the chopping block.

The risk is that Congress ends up passing a tax cut that is a damp squib for economic growth—amid an expansion that is already long by historical standards and needs a capital investment boost.

Congress can increase its pro-growth running room by eliminating tax loopholes, and we hope they do. But some of the biggest money savers are politically difficult—even among Republicans. Repealing the state and local tax deduction gins up more than $1 trillion over 10 years, but will the GOP delegations in high-tax California and New York buy that? Deductions for charitable giving and mortgage interest have been declared untouchable.

The Joint Tax Committee is also supposed to offer a dynamic “score,” or an estimate that considers how a reform would influence behavior and growth. But Joint Tax makes highly debatable assumptions: One is that deficits increase borrowing costs for Treasury and “crowd out” private investment, as the Tax Foundation has detailed. That argument should have been repudiated in the 1980s when deficits rose but interest rates fell and growth soared. But Joint Tax persists, and the effect is to mute its growth estimates and thus any revenue gains from reform.

The best way to escape the budget trap is to have the courage of GOP tax convictions and assume reform will restore the economy to faster growth. CBO predicts average GDP growth over the next decade of a mere 1.9% a year—far below the historical norm. It assumes this will yield some $43 trillion in revenue. But if growth merely averaged 3% a year, that would add some $2.5 trillion more in government revenue over a decade.

There is good reason to believe that our corporate income tax, the highest in the OECD, is driving companies away and creating an environment in which its worth it for companies to spend billions avoiding the tax. There is also good reason to believe that our rising level of public debt is impeding economic growth. There is no equally good reason to believe that a cut in the marginal tax rates of the rich, who pay most of the taxes, will result in a spurt of business investment or even personal consumption that will boost economic growth.

The only big ticket items in the federal budget are defense, Social Security, and health care. If the Congress can’t or won’t trim any of those and it refuses to suspend FICA, the taxes paid by the poor and, in fact, the majority of Americans, in the interests of fund accounting, its only alternatives are either increasing the deficit or trading a decrease in the corporate income tax for an increase in the taxes paid by those in the dizzying heights of the economy. It should do the latter even if it makes the editors of the Wall Street Journal unhappy.

0 comments

The Slippery Slope

In his op-ed at the Washington Post Alex Yablon reflects on the factors that unite mass murders with little else in common:

The Trace launched just 48 hours after the 2015 Charleston church massacre. Since then, my colleagues and I have covered similar shootings perpetrated by failed business owners, wayward veterans, troubled teenagers, jihadist dabblers, disgruntled employees, antiabortionists, estranged spouses, Black Lives Matter supporters, sovereign citizens and many others. It’s usually difficult to decide just which label best describes the perpetrator: Often, several seem to apply, or none at all. The difficulty of interpreting motivations is compounded by the fact that at the end of these rampages, the shooter is typically among the dead.

What is clear, however, is that regardless of ideological motivation, or even in the complete absence of any such drive, these kinds of attacks are usually presaged by some clear warning signs.

As Duke University psychiatrist Dr. Jeffrey Swanson told me in the wake of the 2016 Pulse Nightclub shooting in Orlando, “Most people who commit serious crimes, that’s not where they began. They didn’t just start committing gun homicides.”

Is it possible that plea deals and general failure to enforce the law contribute to an escalating pattern that may lead with mass murder? That the broken window strategy of law enforcement is actually correct and undermined by prosecutors more interested in clearing their dockets than enforcing the law?

3 comments

Ever Hopeful

Ever hopeful, the editors of the Washington Post are actually pleased that the repeal of the overbroad and superannuated Authorization to Use Military Force failed to attract enough votes in the Senate to pass:

The Senate must now do the hard work of following through — particularly the Foreign Relations Committee, which Mr. Kaine has asked to take up the debate. Mr. Kaine and Mr. Flake’s draft AUMF provides a place from which the committee can begin its work. Now that the vote on Mr. Paul’s amendment has opened the door for a bipartisan effort to reform the authorization, there is no excuse not to walk through it.

What puzzles me is why they don’t think the matter is closed? The Senate has seen fit to delegate unconstitutional power to presidents to fight wars wherever and whenever they want for sixteen years now. Doesn’t past experience suggest that they’re more likely to stick with their core competency and do nothing?

2 comments