Treating Pain

After the ritualized complaints about Trump, the editors of the Washington Post get down to brass tacks about the “opioid epidemic”:

Data show wide geographic discrepancies in rates of opioid prescribing (poor, rural counties have higher rates than urban ones), which suggests that objective medical considerations are not the only reason for heavy usage where it occurs. Indeed, the latest research shows that opioids are not the most effective treatment for common forms of non-cancer pain. Quite often, they have been dispensed precisely because more effective alternatives — physical therapy, for example — were not available.

Even after recent reductions, doctors in the United States still prescribe legal opioids at three times the 1999 rate. If doctors met the goal Mr. Trump set in his speech — a one-third reduction in opioid prescriptions by 2021 — they would still be prescribing at double the 1999 rate. And the United States would still be administering legal opioids far more frequently than its peer nations in the industrialized world. This country prescribes opioid pain medicines twice as frequently as Germany does, but as bitter experience has taught, that doesn’t make us twice as good at treating pain.

Ignoring the possibility that Americans actually have more pain than Germans do or that Americans are just whingers, what explains the change? I think it can only be explained by incentives—all of physicians’ incentives point to prescribing more painkillers, especially the desire to do something. However, I’m open to other explanations. Why do American physicians prescribe opioids pain medications at such a high rate?

9 comments

Better to Reign in Hell

Thomas Edsall has a good column in the New York Times concerning a basic decision that the Democratic Party needs to make. Should centrist Democratic candidates be encouraged or not? Here’s the conclusion of his column:

To nominate candidates who, like Lamb, are equipped to win working and middle class swing districts in the general election will require Democratic primary voters to cast strategic rather than ideological ballots — focusing on who can prevail in November, in 2018 but also in 2020. And, perhaps more to the point, Democratic donors will have to decide whether they can back candidates who agree with them 80 percent but not 99 percent of the time.

At a moment when Trump has exacerbated polarization, persuading leaders and voters on the left flank of the Democratic Party to think tactically about the 2020 presidential primaries is crucial but problematic. Insofar as Democrats place a higher priority on purity than viability, they may be risking an indeterminate extension of the Trump era.

Coastal Democrats need to come to terms with the reality that being a Democrat doesn’t mean the same thing in Des Moines that it does in San Jose. People who believe as they do constitute a relatively small proportion of the American electorate despite the fact that everybody they know believes as they do.

The situations of the two major political parties are not symmetrical.

1 comment

Dershowitz: Put Up or Shut Up

At The Hill Allen Dershowitz calls for a non-partisan commission to determine whether any crimes were committed in connection with Russia’s meddling in our elections in 2016 and, if not, for the Mueller investigation to be permanently suspended:

The vice of a special counsel is that he is supposed to find crimes, and if he comes up empty-handed, after spending lots of taxpayer money, then he is deemed a failure. If he can’t charge the designated target — in this case, the president — he must at least charge some of those close to the target, even if it is for crimes unrelated to the special counsel’s core mandate. By indicting these low-hanging fruits, he shows that he is trying. Maybe those lesser defendants will flip and sing against higher-ups, but the problem is that the pressure to sing may cause certain defendants to “compose,” meaning make up or enhance evidence in order to get a better deal for themselves.

In this case, the appointment of a special counsel has done more harm than good. It has politicized our justice system beyond repair. The FBI deputy director has been fired for leaking and lying. His testimony appears to be in conflict with that of the former FBI director as to whether the leaks were authorized. Messages by high-ranking FBI agents suggest strong bias against Trump. A tweet by the former CIA director reveals equally strong negative views of the president. Perhaps these revelations prove nothing more than that law enforcement and national security officials are human and hold political views like everyone else.

That’s what I called for at the time and, frankly, I think it’s too late for that now. IMO a deadline should be imposed on the Mueller investigation to find and reveal the evidence of an underlying crime. The present situation is Kafka-esque.

Meanwhile I’ve seen columns in major media outlets by purportedly responsible journalists saying that it doesn’t really matter whether there was an underlying crime or not since the objective of the investigation is to disrupt and discredit the Trump Administration. Our system just isn’t supposed to work that way and I doubt that anyone will care much for these new rules.

8 comments

The Political Parties and Their Supporters

Pew Research finds a growing gap between Democrats and Republicans in terms of gender and educational attainment:

As the 2018 midterm elections approach, women and especially college graduates have moved toward the Democratic Party. By contrast, the Republican Party’s advantage in leaned party identification among white voters without a college degree has never been greater, dating back more than two decades.

While partisanship among voters usually does not change much on a yearly basis, some differences have widened over time, especially by educational attainment, gender and age. And these gaps are even larger when categories are combined, such as education, race and gender.

A new analysis of party identification, based on more than 10,000 interviews of registered voters conducted by Pew Research Center in 2017, finds that 37% of registered voters identify as independents, 33% are Democrats and 26% are Republicans.

but no in terms of race the gap is actually narrowing a trifle. Fewer blacks are reliably Democrats than was the case years ago.

The party identification growing the fastest is independent. However it’s spun the percentage of people who are 100% solidly Democratic or 100% solidly Republican is decreasing.

There’s been quite a bit of scholarship about party identification over the years, much of it controversial. What seems to be the case is that life experiences and circumstances influence party identification, i.e. it is not true that once you’re a Democrat you’re always a Democrat. For Democrats getting the youth vote is a good thing. But just as it is true that the young won’t always be young it’s also true that they won’t always be Democrats and that’s truer today than at any time since the Great Depression.

3 comments

Illinois’s Primaries, Part 2

There were relatively few surprises in Illinois’s primary elections yesterday. In general incumbents prevailed, a bleak sign for a state where change is sorely needed. In races without incumbents money talked. Democratic gubernatorial candidate J. B. Pritzker spent nearly $70 million, mostly from his own billionaire’s pockets, dwarfing the spending of his Democratic opponents 30:1.

Here are the sound bites from the Chicago Tribune’s Clout Street which handily sum up the results:

*Fall governor race look-ahead: Rauner-Pritzker campaign expected to be expensive, brutal and long.

*Republican governor primary: Rauner claims narrow victory over Ives.

*Democratic governor primary: Pritzker cruises to win after $70 million campaign.

*Attorney general: Raoul emerges victorious, ending Quinn’s comeback attempt. GOP’s Harold easily wins.

*Cook County assessor: Embattled Berrios concedes to challenger Kaegi.

*Cook County board president: Preckwinkle skates despite pop tax backlash. In commissioner races, Fritchey loses.

*IL-3: Lipinski with slim lead over challenger Newman.

*IL-4: "Chuy" Garcia headed toward a promotion to Congress.

*General Assembly roundup: Silverstein loses after sexual harassment allegations; Ald. Burke’s brother loses to Garcia-backed challenger.

*House GOP leader Durkin leads Burr Ridge mayor in rare primary challenge.

*Turnout: "Disappointing," city election official said.

*Election results can be found here.

*DuPage County has vote counting problems.

In the much-watched Illinois 3rd Congressional District incumbent Dan Lipinski edged out challenger Marie Newman, despite Newman’s outspending Lipinski. Lots of money was spent by both campaigns, mostly from sources outside the district. As I have suggested repeatedly the 3rd is still a relatively conservative district. I don’t know whether there are lessons to be learned here by the DCC or not.

Don’t breathe a sigh of relief yet. These were just the primaries. I expect that the general election for governor starts today with two billionaires facing off: a self-made billionaire in Rauner’s case vs. inherited wealth in Pritzker’s. I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if this weren’t the most expensive governor’s race in history. I predict that if Rauner is re-elected it will be another term in which his every move is blocked by the state legislature and if Pritzker is elected he’ll underwrite every move by the state legislature. Mike Madigan will continue to be the King of Illinois.

3 comments

Best Time Ever?

In his Wall Street Journal column James Freeman says it’s the best time ever to be looking for a job:

The press corps has been so focused on the Friday firing of an FBI official for his alleged lack of candor under oath that it’s easy to miss all the hiring. It turns out that former FBI deputy director Andrew McCabe is hitting the job market at a nearly perfect time.

On Friday the Labor Department released its latest Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, better known as the “Jolts” report. The feds reported a remarkable finding about the historic eagerness of businesses to hire. “On the last business day of January, the job openings level increased to a series high of 6.3 million,” noted the government.

Man, I really don’t see it. I’ve been looking for a new job for some time. I’m really desperate to get away from my present employer. From my perspective pickings are pretty slim.

Two factors may be promoting an illusion. First, February always looks a lot rosier than it should because the BLS dumps its errors into February and the birth/death ratio, a fudge factor, supplies a ridiculous proportion of the supposed jobs. Second, I wonder how many of those hiring notices are just pro forma?

10 comments

Gina Haspel

If torture was carried out there during Gina Haspel’s tenure as chief of a CIA “black site”, she should not be confirmed as head of the CIA. And, yes, waterboarding is torture.

Whether torture is effective or not is moot. The end does not justify the means and we are signatory to international accords prohibiting torture.

6 comments

Two Words

I only have two words to say about the death of a pedestrian, killed by an autonomous vehicle: strict liability.

1 comment

Another Day Another Bomb

So, what do you make of these bombs going off in Austin?

6 comments

End Support for the War in Yemen

I agree with the editors of the New York Times. Congress should end U. S. support for Saudi Arabia’s war against Yemen:

The Pentagon has argued its military aid is noncombat assistance, like advising the Saudi Air Force on how to drop bombs so they kill fewer civilians. But while the Saudis pledged in 2017 to reduce civilian deaths, Human Rights Watch said six attacks since then killed 55 civilians.

Meanwhile, Gen. Joseph Votel, head of Central Command, told Congress, “We’re not parties to this conflict.” That isn’t credible. The Saudi-led coalition would have a hard time continuing the onslaught without American assistance, which has included air-to-air refueling, arms, intelligence assessments and other military advice.

Apart from the humanitarian disaster, members of Congress who have supported the resolution are concerned about the legal basis for American involvement. The United States initially deployed forces to combat Al Qaeda in Yemen under post-Sept. 11 congressional authorization measures. But Congress never specifically approved military involvement in the Saudi-Houthi war even though the Constitution and the 1973 War Powers Act give lawmakers a role.

It’s long past time we end our military support for Saudi Arabia and its war in Yemen and it’s long past time that Congress reasserted its constitutional warmaking powers.

I do disagree with the editors in one particular:

It has been wracked by civil war since 2014, when Houthi rebels allied with Iran, and forces loyal to former President Ali Abdullah Saleh, took control of the capital, Sana, and much of the rest of the country.

I would have pushed the causes of the civil war back slightly further to President Obama’s drone war which inevitably transitioned from fighting Al Qaeda to fighting the enemies of the governments of the various countries everywhere in which it was prosecuted. They’re just promoting the Saudi party line.

Here’s a little food for thought. The U. S.’s greatest geopolitical foe isn’t Russia or China. It’s Saudi Arabia. Keep that in mind during Mohammed bin Salman’s visit to Washington this week.

2 comments