After the ritualized complaints about Trump, the editors of the Washington Post get down to brass tacks about the “opioid epidemic”:
Data show wide geographic discrepancies in rates of opioid prescribing (poor, rural counties have higher rates than urban ones), which suggests that objective medical considerations are not the only reason for heavy usage where it occurs. Indeed, the latest research shows that opioids are not the most effective treatment for common forms of non-cancer pain. Quite often, they have been dispensed precisely because more effective alternatives — physical therapy, for example — were not available.
Even after recent reductions, doctors in the United States still prescribe legal opioids at three times the 1999 rate. If doctors met the goal Mr. Trump set in his speech — a one-third reduction in opioid prescriptions by 2021 — they would still be prescribing at double the 1999 rate. And the United States would still be administering legal opioids far more frequently than its peer nations in the industrialized world. This country prescribes opioid pain medicines twice as frequently as Germany does, but as bitter experience has taught, that doesn’t make us twice as good at treating pain.
Ignoring the possibility that Americans actually have more pain than Germans do or that Americans are just whingers, what explains the change? I think it can only be explained by incentives—all of physicians’ incentives point to prescribing more painkillers, especially the desire to do something. However, I’m open to other explanations. Why do American physicians prescribe opioids pain medications at such a high rate?






