The Lesser Evil

The slug on Max Boot’s op-ed at the Washington Post on our bad options in Syria pretty much says it all:

We have lost the leverage to remove him without a massive military intervention, and in any case, it’s not clear his successors would be any better.

I would go farther. It is all but certain that his successors would be worse? Why are we supporting the greater evil? Additionally, a “massive military intervention” courts war with Russia, their interests in Syria are much greater than ours, and such a war would have no winners.

My view is that we should tread with a much lighter step in the Middle East. We have no friends there. There are no good alternatives. There are no benign outcomes. Only bad and worse.

3 comments

Bolton

It should go without saying that I don’t think much of the Trump Administration becoming even more hawkish by the addition of John Bolton as national security advisor.

What may be less obvious is that I don’t think that a hawkish Trump Administration is the gravest risk. What concerns me even more is that the use of military force has become a valence issue, i.e. the two major political parties vie over which employs force better or more frequently.

War should be the exception not the rule. The last resort rather than the first. We should only engage in war when we no longer are able to weigh profit and loss.

6 comments

Vive la différence

There’s a good article by geneticist David Reich at the New York Times on how DNA studies have changed our views on race. Simply stated, although concepts like “whiteness” are social constructs, there actually are different identifiable human populations which can be distinguished from each other by empirical means. Here’s what was for me the heart of the article:

Recent genetic studies have demonstrated differences across populations not just in the genetic determinants of simple traits such as skin color, but also in more complex traits like bodily dimensions and susceptibility to diseases. For example, we now know that genetic factors help explain why northern Europeans are taller on average than southern Europeans, why multiple sclerosis is more common in European-Americans than in African-Americans, and why the reverse is true for end-stage kidney disease.

I am worried that well-meaning people who deny the possibility of substantial biological differences among human populations are digging themselves into an indefensible position, one that will not survive the onslaught of science. I am also worried that whatever discoveries are made — and we truly have no idea yet what they will be — will be cited as “scientific proof” that racist prejudices and agendas have been correct all along, and that those well-meaning people will not understand the science well enough to push back against these claims.

This is why it is important, even urgent, that we develop a candid and scientifically up-to-date way of discussing any such differences, instead of sticking our heads in the sand and being caught unprepared when they are found.

Read the whole thing.

It can’t be emphasized often enough that you can infer nothing about differences between two individuals based on knowledge about the differences between the groups to which they belong. That fallacy is the source of much sorrow.

3 comments

What Can China Do?

Following President Trump’s signing of a memorandum authorizing tariffs against Chinese steel and aluminum to which China President Xi responded in kind as anyone who’d been paying attention knew he would, the airwaves have been full of laments about an incipient trade war. As I’ve mentioned before that’s the equivalent of complaining that the Doolittle raid was starting a war in the Pacific. China has been in a trade war with the U. S. for more than 30 years, we haven’t responded, and the war has completely transformed the American economy, greatly exacerbating income inequality.

The pretext of these tariffs is Chinese “theft” of intellectual property, something I warned about 40 years ago sitting in the Honeywell boardroom. I’m not sure what anyone would expect China to do about intellectual property theft or, frankly, any of its other violations of international trade agreements to which it is signatory. China does not have a robust system of civil law or independent courts and no tradition of either. Imagine trying to enforce intellectual property law in the United States without a system of civil law.

Here’s are a few gentle suggestions on what China could and should do to mend relations with the United States, all things completely within its power:

  • It could end state ownership of aluminum and steel-making companies or, at the very least, stop subsidizing them.
  • It could make the operations of its banks more transparent and increase foreign ownership of its banks, as it agreed to as a condition of being admitted to the WTO.
  • It could end the use of pirated software within the Chinese government.
  • It could end the theft of intellectual property by state-owned Chinese pharmaceutical companies.
  • It could end the theft of intellectual property by state-owned electronics companies, e.g. China Electronics Company.

That would be a start. Passing more laws which will never be enforced is not reform. It’s pretending to reform while conducting business as usual.

3 comments

Sweet Home Farewell, Chicago

Chicago’s population continues to decline. From WTTW:

For the third consecutive year, the Chicago metro area – which includes nine Illinois counties, four in Indiana and one in Wisconsin – saw a drop in population, according to the U.S. Census Bureau.

In 2017 there were 13,286 fewer residents in the Chicago metro area than in 2016, according to census data. (Last year’s population was 9,533,040. In 2016, the population was 9,546,326.)

Chicago demographer Rob Paral, a principal at Rob Paral and Associates, said it’s small drop. “However, what does stand out is this is not happening in our peer metro areas … New York, L.A., Houston and the Bay Area – they are all growing,” he added. Despite the drop, the Chicago area maintains its spot as the third most populous metropolitan area.

As for what’s causing the population loss, Paral says it’s a “complex stew” of factors that includes race, income and immigration.

“One way to explain the population loss is largely due, in part, to African-Americans leaving. We’ve had a dramatic departure of blacks from Illinois to southern states,” he said, adding the trend has been going on for decades. In addition, he said the Latino population is growing more slowly, while whites are growing in the city but declining in the suburbs.

In a general sort of way what’s happening is that black folk are moving out of the city and the city is gentrifying. That’s no accident. It’s the effective policy of Mayor Emanuel’s administration.

However, nearly every Illinois county has declined in population. That means that nearly every assumption made about the state’s ability to spend is wrong. Returns aren’t as high as the public employee pension funds have assumed. There are fewer Illinoisans now than there were when all of these commitments were made. A smaller tax base will need to support higher spending than anticipated.

Note that the Democratic gubernatorial candidate, J. B. Pritzker has been running on a platform of more spending and higher taxes. I wonder when Illinois’s politicians will finally look at the state’s finances realistically? My guess is just before they announce they’re retiring to Florida.

1 comment

The Party Divides

I thought you might be interested in WBEZ’s analysis of Illinois’s primary election results:

Illinois voters didn’t settle the ideological battles within the two major parties — they simply illuminated them, even with the impressive turnout among Democrats.

In the GOP governor’s primary, state Rep. Jeanne Ives hammered Rauner for his moderate stances on immigration, abortion and LGBTQ rights. That raises doubts about Rauner’s ability to build a winning coalition in a Democratic-leaning state. He gave a nod to his weaknesses on the right, saying he’s “heard” from “those of you who wanted to send me a message” and asking them to “focus on issues that unite us: reducing taxes, growing jobs and reducing corruption.”

The question is whether that approach, basically repeating his 2014 pitch as a Chamber of Commerce problem solver, can be enough without the national GOP wave that aided his initial election.

Perhaps Rauner’s best comfort is in his Democratic rival’s primary struggles. Despite his spending advantage, Pritzker couldn’t manage a majority after a primary race that featured his two closest competitors calling him a “fraud” and a “liar.” And Pritzker’s pledges to working families notwithstanding, the liberal groups and activists that have propelled the anti-Donald Trump resistance movement lined up mostly behind the second- and third-place finishers, Daniel Biss and Chris Kennedy.

Pritzker must hope that the most outspoken liberal branches of the party follow the lead of Indivisible Chicago, the local chapter of one of the leading national grassroots organizations that formed after Trump’s election to resist his agenda. The group called for party unity Tuesday, called Pritzker’s platform “progressive” and said he “represents a significant upgrade” over Rauner. Perhaps not a full-throated endorsement, but a first step toward what Pritzker needs.

Illinois’ top-billed congressional primary wasn’t in a battleground district that will determine House control in November; it was a safe Democratic seat in greater Chicago where seven-term incumbent Dan Lipinski, part of the dwindling Blue Dog caucus of moderate and conservative Democrats, nipped his more liberal challenger, political newcomer Marie Newman, by about 2 percentage points.

Lipinski, whose father held the 3rd Congressional District seat before him, had broad union support and nominal backing from national Democratic bosses including House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi. But that didn’t play with Democratic voters increasingly displeased with Lipinski’s opposition to abortion rights and same-sex marriage, his vote against the 2010 health care law, and his late-breaking support for legislation to shield certain young immigrants called “Dreamers” from deportation.

Newman was endorsed by Bernie Sanders, the Vermont senator and erstwhile presidential candidate, and liberal groups including the women’s advocacy organization Emily’s List, local Indivisible chapters and Our Revolution, the offshoot of Sanders’ 2016 campaign.

Even with Lipinski surviving, the fact that Newman battled him to a near draw will embolden liberals in other Democratic primary battles and in the larger struggle for party identity.

Not mentioned: Marie Newman fell just short of victory despite outspending Lipinski. Most of the money spent on the campaign by either side came from outside the district. When does foreigners interfering in our elections become a problem?

4 comments

More About the Unfilled Jobs

Daniel Gross has a post about the large number of unfilled jobs at strategy + business. Here’s the meat of his post:

The question cities and states should ask themselves is not how to attract entirely new companies to the area that will bring jobs, but rather how to help or convince companies that are already here to fill open positions.

He’s making an assumption of which I’m skeptical. I think that the simplest explanation is that a very large number of the jobs are bogus; they never existed. Companies fish, they advertise jobs that they’ve already filled, they post jobs in the hopes of justifying bringing in H1-B workers at lower wages.

If there were actually that many unfilled jobs wouldn’t somebody somewhere think of offering higher wages? That’s not happening so it seems most likely that the jobs don’t really exist.

7 comments

American Hypocrisy

In an article at The American Conservative titled “Gina Haspel: As If Nuremberg Never Happened”, Peter Van Buren whinges:

Nothing will say more about who we are, across three American administrations—one that demanded torture, one that covered it up, and one that seeks to promote its bloody participants—than whether Gina Haspel becomes director of the CIA.

Haspel oversaw the torture of human beings in Thailand as the chief of a CIA black site in 2002. Since then, she’s worked her way up to deputy director at the CIA. With current director Mike Pompeo slated to move to Foggy Bottom, President Donald Trump has proposed Haspel as the Agency’s new head.

The decisions of the Nuremberg trials were victor’s justice as many, especially the Germans, complained at the time. U. S. law has never accepted their findings.

My own views, repeated many times here, is that the U. S. should not torture and should prosecute it when revealed. We should also not enter into treaties to which we do not intend to adhere. It is completely unsurprising that nobody, whether friend, enemy, or frenemy, believes us.

5 comments

Remember Facebook?

There’s nothing sacred about a business model. There is no right to a business model. Novel business models are risks. It’s surprising to me that there isn’t greater recognition of that. At Bloomberg View Leonid Bershidksy warns:

I think I understand why Facebook Chief Executive Officer Mark Zuckerberg hasn’t publicly responded to the Cambridge Analytica scandal. He’s stuck in a catch-22. Any fix for Facebook’s previous big problem — fake news — would make the current big problem with data harvesting worse.

As a media company and one of Americans’ top sources of information, Facebook’s de facto anonymity and general lack of responsibility for user-generated content make it easy for propagandists to exploit. Making matters worse, it isn’t willing to impose tighter identification rules for fear of losing too many users, and it doesn’t want to be held responsible in any way for content, preferring to present itself as a neutral platform. So Zuckerberg has been trying to fix the problem by showing people more material from friends and family and by prioritizing “trusted publishers” and local news sources over purveyors of fake news.

I believe that Facebook, Google, Twitter, and any other company whose business model depends on their selling data on the online behavior of their users is doomed. They have a right to their analysis of the data but not to the data itself and there will be an increasing recognition of that.

Enjoy ’em while you can. They won’t be around for long.

5 comments

Why’s Everybody Always Picking On Me?

I think that the United States can be pardoned for thinking that the EU is picking on us with its proposed tax on technology companies. There are fewer than 50 European technology companies with annual revenues of $1 billion or more. There are 150 U. S. tech startups with revenues of $1 billion or more. That leaves out the real giants, e.g. Microsoft, Google, etc. The editors of the Wall Street Journal lament:

One difference between President Trump and the European Union is that Mr. Trump makes mistakes on his own and off the cuff, while Brussels makes mistakes by committee after careful study. So while European mandarins are kvetching about the trade war Mr. Trump risks starting with metals tariffs, Europe is now launching its own economic war with a proposal to tax U.S. tech firms.

Not that European leaders will admit the tech-tax plan they unveiled Wednesday is protectionism. The European Commission, the EU’s bureaucratic wing, is plugging for a 3% tax on revenues—no matter the profits—that large tech firms earn from sales in Europe. The companies would pay the tax to each country in which a sale occurs, rather than in the countries where their European headquarters are based, as under current rules.

For “large tech firms” you should read “American companies” since the rules are tailored to apply to the likes of Amazon, Apple, Google and Facebook . The tax proposal ensnares companies that sell digital advertising or provide a platform for online trade between third parties. This exempts such firms as brick-and-mortar department stores that sell designer handbags over their websites, no matter how digital the transactions look.

The measure would apply only to companies with at least €750 million in annual world-wide revenue and €50 million in sales within the EU. Europe wishes it had a tech company of that global heft.

The editors had best get used to this. Governments everywhere are hungry for more revenues and, when the U. S. government taxes foreign companies it’s protectionism while when European countries tax American companies it’s fair because. I’m surprised Illinois hasn’t thought of this.

2 comments