Will China Invade Taiwan?

China permabear Gordon Chang warns that China is serious in his post at National Interest:

In these days of Chinese expansionism, however, every sovereignty dispute has become a Taiwan—in other words, a do-or-die matter for the Communist Party. Tellingly, China has not been able to compromise a land border since settling with Tajikistan at the beginning of this decade. With regard to sea claims, the most it has been able to do during this period was confirm it did not claim Indonesia’s Natuna Islands (although it still, without justification, claims rights to the Exclusive Economic Zone generated by the Natunas).

Beijing’s intransigence has worked, and Chinese policymakers, taking advantage of foreign timidity, have then expanded territorial demands. The escalation of ambitions after China seized Scarborough Shoal in 2012 highlights a dangerous dynamic in the Chinese capital.

In the spring of that year, Washington brokered an agreement between Beijing and Manila for both sides to withdraw their small vessels from the strategic feature, close to the main Philippine island of Luzon. Only Manila complied with the deal, leaving China in control. The Obama administration, despite the blatant deception, did not enforce the agreement it had arranged, undoubtedly hoping to avoid confrontation with China.

By doing nothing, however, the United States handed an easy win to the worst elements in Beijing. Those elements then ramped up pressure on Second Thomas Shoal, another Philippine reef in the South China Sea, and the Senkakus, uninhabited islets under Japanese administration in the East China Sea.

Will China invade Taiwan? I don’t know but IMO it would be a tragedy for the world but especially for China. The rest of the world, particularly China’s neighbors, might not intervene but they would certainly react and their reactions would not be in a positive direction for China. It would mark the end of China’s economic expansion and a return to the bad old days before 1979.

And that doesn’t even consider how the U. S. would respond. Keep in mind who the president and his national security advisor are.

7 comments

The Trade Deficit

The graph above, illustrating the growth in the U. S. trade deficit, comes from this post at HowMuch.net:

One thing is immediately clear: imports and exports are both on an upward trajectory year over year, but imports tend to grow faster. In other words, when looking at the graph you will notice the gap between the two numbers has gotten larger and larger while the space between the two circles has also become darker and darker. In short, the trade deficit used to be relatively small, averaging less than $150B year over year in the 1990s, but then it exploded in the 2000s. The single biggest increase occurred in 2004 when it jumped from $532B to $655B—a whopping $122B in one year.

I would suggest that the graph actually understates imports because it doesn’t include intra-company transfers as imports. If GM builds 99.9% of a car in some other country, imports it into the United States, and a U. S. worker turns a screw on it, it doesn’t count as an import.

Now consider this graph:

Maybe there’s no relationship. Post hoc propter hoc and all that but it certainly bears consideration.

3 comments

Predictions

What effect will the “March for Our Lives” demonstrations and speeches have?

I think they’ll probably get their assault weapons ban. I also think it will have no measurable effect on school violence or gun homicides more generally.

8 comments

Goodbye, Catch-All Parties

In the Orange County Register Carl Cannon comments on the Illinois 3rd District primary race:

…Lipinski has close to a zero chance of losing in November. The reason? Well, that brings us to the other side of the electoral bracket, where the Republicans in Illinois’ 3rd District let a 70-year-old admirer of Adolf Hitler garner their nomination.

It’s true. Lipinski’s general election opponent is avowed racist named Arthur Joseph Jones. Yes, liberals and campus crazies hurl similar epithets at anyone to the right of Bernie Sanders these days, but Art Jones is the real article — someone who’s been a Holocaust denier all of his adult life. Jones read “Mein Kampf” in his foxhole while serving in the U.S. Army during the Vietnam War, joined the American Nazi Party, ran for mayor of Milwaukee as the candidate of the National Socialist White People’s Party, and now runs something called the America First Committee.

And he has some predictably awful ideas of what it means to put America first. Although he supported Donald Trump’s 2016 candidacy, he did so with convoluted logic. “He’s his own man,” Jones said at the time. “I like the fact that he doesn’t have to go hat-in-hand to Jewish billionaires to get money.” Later, he had second thoughts, and now calls the president “a Jew-loving fool” who “surrounds himself with hordes of Jews, including a Jew in his own family, that punk named Jared Kushner.”

To be fair, Illinois Republicans denounced Jones even before he ran, and have been doing so for a long time. Yet, in this age of thoroughly gerrymandered districts, they could recruit no one to run against Lipinski, leaving the field to this buffoon.

Let’s pause there. The Illinois Republican Party has been practically supine for the last 15 years. That’s been the case since 2004 when Jack Ryan withdrew his candidacy for one of Illinois’s senate seats under assault from his actress ex-wife, Jeri Ryan. That left the field open for his Democratic opponent, Barack Obama, then an obscure legislator, and the rest, as they say, is history.

What about Bruce Rauner (I hear somebody ask)? He became governor despite the Illinois Republican Party rather than because of it. He had never been active in party activities and financed his own campaign.

Tribune columnist John Kass believes that Illinois Republicans and Democrats have divvied the state up agreeably and don’t compete against each other.

Mr. Cannon continues:

No Labels leaders say they plan to get involved in dozens of races this year. They acknowledge that the bulk of this work must be done soon because by the time the general election rolls around it’s too late. “In nine out of 10 races,” noted Clancy, “the only elections that matter are the primaries.”

Consider the implications of that. It means that the 10-20% most highly motivated, generally also the most radical, voters decide the political fate of the country.

It may be even fewer than that. Mike Madigan has been Speaker of the Illinois House for most of the last 35 years and in the 2016 primary election fewer than 18,000 people voted for him. In other words about .3% of Illinois voters decided the fate of the state.

It’s no accident that “independent/no affiliation” is the fastest-growing political party.

0 comments

Fat, Dumb, and Happy

At the Wall Street Journal James Freeman touches on a very interesting point without developing it very much. We now know that the Iranian Revolutionary Guard conducted a major hacking exploit against U. S. universities, companies, and the U. S. government during much of President Obama’s administration and the first part of Donald Trump’s. What influence did the exploit have on U. S.-Iranian relations during the period?

Extra credit question. Are the Department of Homeland Security, the FBI, the CIA, and the U. S. military incompetent in computer security or just fat, dumb, and happy? In a sensible government some generals and heads of some of those departments would, at the very least, be imprisoned for life at hard labor or, more likely, have a much briefer life in front of a firing squad. Failing to protect us against the Iranians (the Iranians) is treason by inaction.

7 comments

Far From Hinged

In an op-ed at the Wall Street Journal Robert Kaplan lurches uncontrollably towards a point I’ve been making for some time:

Russia and China are in different situations. Russia is a rickety house that at some point may crumble. China is sturdier; nevertheless, it could slowly become a compressed pack of social dynamite with less of an outlet for its internal frustrations. It is theoretically possible for Mr. Xi, as president for life, to institute a program of dramatic economic reforms. But doing so would unleash the need and yearning for more personal freedoms, the kind that the regime is moving with its technological thought control to try to eliminate.

As Russia and China strengthen militarily, even as they maintain and intensify internal repression, they will continue to clash with the West in the near term. But as in the early days of the Cold War, policy makers have to look beyond the present to the difficulty our adversaries will have sustaining their systems over time. And if their systems come undone in the next decade or the one after, Eurasia—of which Russia and China are the geographic organizing principles—will face extreme instability. The U.S. must gird itself for this struggle, though with a certain degree of optimism. Democracy is the better long-distance runner.

but he fails to carry it over the finish line. Russia and China are not natural allies. We can force them into a temporary and tenuous marriage of convenience with unthinking aggression but they are actually natural enemies. We, on the other hand, are by nature total strangers to either or both of them. We care about very little that they do unless we force ourselves to but that’s what we’re doing. They are regional powers in the same region. Their interests will inevitably collide.

2 comments

Promoting Democracy

I agree with the thesis of David Von Drehle’s Washington Post column. I think that the U. S. should promote democracy in the world. We just differ on the means. I don’t think that bombing other countries, stationing troops in most of them, invading the countries of every Tom, Dick, and Abdul, or letting the U. S. economy dwindle to a few large banks, some technology firms, and a health care system so that most wealth is concentrated in the hands of a few ultra-rich promotes democracy.

I don’t think that Ronald Reagan’s bellicosity and building up of the American military or Maggie Thatcher’s assertiveness brought about the collapse of the Soviet Union. I think it was their optimism and building up of the American and British economies, respectively, buoyed by the prosperity of free Americans and Britons.

We can’t accomplish that by importing legions of poorly educated peasants or by bringing in low level technicians who speak incomprehensible English. That will promote both income and social inequality.

The push factors have failed to promote democracy everywhere we’ve tried them while the pull factors have been incredibly effective. Why do we keep pushing?

1 comment

The Hype

I’ve never spoken one-on-one with Sergey Brin or Elon Musk so I don’t know what they really think about autonomous vehicles. I can only give you my opinion.

My experience has been that people with technical knowledge and understanding think that autonomous vehicles are being tremendously overhyped and are something for the distant future if ever while non-technical people think they’re just around the corner or even already here. That leads me to conclude that Mssrs. Brin and Musk know that and don’t really care whether people are killed by prematurely autonomous vehicles. They just want to get in on the gold rush.

I repeat my proposal: strict liability. People who are injured by prematurely autonomous vehicles or the families of those killed by them should be able to recover from their developers regardless of intent or the ability to prove specific responsibility. All that should matter is the injury. Injured by an autonomous vehicle? You should be able to recover from Google (or Tesla or Uber).

9 comments

The Marchers

Have you noticed that the solutions to school shooting being proposed by the young people who will be marching this weekend are maximalist ones that impinge upon other people’s freedoms and force other people to change their behavior rather than more narrowly tailored changes that impinge on their own freedoms and cause them to change their own behavior?

I’m in favor of ending or even curtailing school shootings. If we really wanted to accomplish that, we’d be looking at solutions like metal detectors at school entrances, guards, and searching those who enter schools rather than disarming millions of people who are merely exercising something they consider a fundamental right and will never go into a school and shoot them up.

It seems to me that looking elsewhere for solutions rather than at ourselves is a characteristically American affliction these days. It explains all sorts of things from celebrities taking private jets to environmental conferences to the invasion of Iraq to school shootings to the tolerance of Harvey Weinstein and other predators of his ilk by the Hollywood glitterati.

2 comments

The Truth About Trump

In his most recent Washington Post column George Will echoes something I’ve been saying about Donald Trump since before he was elected:

How can the president square his convictions with Bolton’s? Let’s say this one more time: Trump. Has. No. Convictions.

Even this scatterbrain’s Swiss cheese-style tariffs are too sloppy to reflect forethought. He has sentiments, and visceral reactions to which he is attentive. But to speak of, say, a sincere sofa is to commit what philosophers call a “category mistake” — sofas are incapable of sincerity — and to speak of this president’s convictions (or plans, or policies) about this or that is a category mistake.

Something that Mr. Will doesn’t seem to understand or appreciate is that Trump is completely transactional in his approach to things. There is no long term plan. In any given situation or negotiation he just selects the path that he considers the “better deal”. What is the decision function that determines which is the better deal? Beats me. But that’s clearly what he’s doing.

I agree with Mr. Will about the danger that John Bolton poses. That he’s “intelligent, educated, principled, articulate and experienced” is dangerous because virtually his every principle is wrong and his experience has driven him to conclusions that are almost entirely false.

2 comments