Gordon Chang returns today, expressing opinions critical of China, this time at the Daily Beast and about China’s prospects for victory in a trade war:
In 2016, a stunning 68.0 percent of China’s overall merchandise trade surplus related to sales to the U.S. In 2017, that figure increased to 88.8 percent. Trade-surplus countries, as history shows, generally suffer more in trade wars.
Beijing, therefore, is generally vulnerable to being pushed around by Washington. “If trade is so unimportant to China, why has China’s trade predation lasted so long and taken so many different forms?†Alan Tonelson, an independent Washington, D.C.-based trade analyst, asked, in comments to The Daily Beast over the weekend.
Second, the American economy is far bigger than the Chinese one. Beijing claimed gross domestic product of $12.84 trillion in 2017. America’s economy, by way of contrast, clocked in at $19.39 trillion last year.
China’s GDP numbers are surely overstated because, especially during the last two years, the country’s growth was less than half that reported by the official National Bureau of Statistics. America’s larger economy is, at the moment, in fact growing at a faster clip than China’s.
It should go without saying that big economies push smaller ones around, especially when the gap is this large.
Third, the American economy, for all its faults, is stable, and China’s, by most accounts, is on the verge of a debt crisis. China’s debt-to-GDP ratio looks like it is somewhere, depending on the amount of so-called hidden debt, between 350 percent and 400 percent.
Chinese concern about the state of the economy led to extraordinary capital flight in 2015 and 2016, with net capital outflow probably reaching $2.1 trillion in the two-year period. Only the imposition of draconian capital-control measures beginning in the fall of 2016 stopped the outbound torrent of capital.
I do not know how China would weather an actual trade war. Trade war with China might be disastrous for the rest of the world or it might be benign—it could cause China to look inwards, the direction in which it must look for future economic growth. It could cause China to open its economy rather than close it further. A man’s reach must exceed his grasp, etc.
Even the most dictatorial autocrat faces political pressures and, since we know so little about China’s high level politics, we can’t assess the pressures that Xi faces. We can only speculate from the actions he’s taken lately that he faces pressures. Where those pressures may lead him we can’t possibly know.
The only other observation I can make is that a weathervane loses its usefulness when, regardless of which way the wind is blowing, it always points in the same direction. While I am anti-Chinese regime, I am not anti-China. I consider the evidence and I express my opinions but I am not ideological.