The Philosopher-Kings

In his op-ed in the Wall Street Journal Princeton economist Alan Blinder has a number of silly suggestions for improving federal economic policy but this is by far the most fatuous:

I have one final suggestion, though its scope is limited: Suppose we took some—certainly not most—economic decisions out of the hands of politicians, and put them in the hands of nonpolitical technocrats instead.

because economists are uniformly dispassionate automatons without political preferences or prejudices or ideologies of their own. Who are these philosopher-kings?

Why not put all health care policy in the hands of physicians, business policy in the hands of a committee of big business executives, and our Middle East policy in the hands of Middle East experts? If we continued in the vein we wouldn’t need legislatures or elections at all.

Let me answer Dr. Blinder explicitly. The reason we do not put economic decisions “in the hands of nonpolitical technocrats” is that there are no nonpolitical technocrats.

0 comments

What Could She Possibly Want?

Oh fiddle-dee-dee. Could Molly Roberts possibly be this stupid? In her column in the Washington Post she wonders what Stormy Daniels could possibly want by telling her story about a sexual encounter with Donald Trump twelve years ago:

The first thing Stormy Daniels wants you to know is that she’s not a liar. Second, she’s not an opportunist. And third — and she will repeat it until you understand — she is not a victim. The question is why she cares so much that you know it.

How big a stretch is it to think that a woman who has sexual relations on film for public display is an exhibitionist?

I don’t like Trump. I don’t like his character, his temperament, or his casual ignorance. I wish he were not president. I didn’t vote for him. I find it bizarre that publications that have covered up and made excuses for Bill Clinton’s sexual escapades during his presidency devote so much attention Donald Trump’s a decade before his presidency.

6 comments

Repealing the Second Amendment

The only response I can make to retired Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens’s plea in the New York Times to repeal the Second Amendment is this:

The Congress, whenever two thirds of both houses shall deem it necessary, shall propose amendments to this Constitution, or, on the application of the legislatures of two thirds of the several states, shall call a convention for proposing amendments, which, in either case, shall be valid to all intents and purposes, as part of this Constitution, when ratified by the legislatures of three fourths of the several states, or by conventions in three fourths thereof, as the one or the other mode of ratification may be proposed by the Congress; provided that no amendment which may be made prior to the year one thousand eight hundred and eight shall in any manner affect the first and fourth clauses in the ninth section of the first article; and that no state, without its consent, shall be deprived of its equal suffrage in the Senate.

I can only presume that his claim that doing so would be simple means simple to say or procedurally simple. I challenge the notion that it would be politically simple and question whether it would be politically possible. A constitutional convention would open an enormous can of worms. Chief Justice Warren Burger and Justice Antonin Scalia both cautioned against it. We could be as likely to emerge from such a convention without First Amendment rights as without Second Amendment rights. Or without protected classes of gender or race.

As to whether two-third of both houses of Congress or three-quarters of state legislatures would ratify repeal, I can only point out that half of the states presently allow open carry of firearms without a permit.

There is another downside risk to attempting repeal. Can you think of anything more likely to mobilize conservative voters?

6 comments

It’s Dead, Jim

At Project Syndicate Richard Haass pronounces the “liberal world order” dead. Here’s the slug:

America’s decision to abandon the global system it helped build, and then preserve for more than seven decades, marks a turning point, because others lack either the interest or the means to sustain it. The result will be a world that is less free, less prosperous, and less peaceful, for Americans and others alike.

I think he’s confusing “liberal world order” with “American hegemony”. There was never a liberal world order other than the one produced by overwhelming American power, both economic and military, and we can’t afford to maintain that kind of order with an economy in which just a handful of sectors are prospering while the others languish. It doesn’t help that the sectors that are prospering are those that are the most highly subsidized.

2 comments

The Roadbed

Consider the question implicitly asked by Ken Blackwell in his op-ed at The Hill. Is the reason that the U. S. infrastructure is so much worse than our wealth and power might suggest bad government?

President Trump’s plan to rebuild the nation’s crumbling infrastructure is not only needed, it opens the door for Congress to take bold steps to rollback thousands of burdensome government regulations and revamp a national permitting process now mired in bureaucracy and inefficiency.

Any effort to rebuild our country’s roads, bridges, tunnels, energy and manufacturing sectors without substantive permitting reform is like NASA announcing plans to build a space station on Mars with no astronauts, money or rockets.

Reforming a bureaucratic regulatory/permitting process is crucial for the president’s infrastructure rebuilding plan to be successful.

Roads and highways are more expensive foot for foot than any other country in the world. Americans trust their government less than the people of most other OECD countries. Americans vote in elections less than people in most other OECD countries. Maybe we’re onto something. Maybe government in America is less trustworthy than in other OECD countries.

5 comments

It’s a Crowded Field

The editors of the Wall Street Journal say that the Martin Act, a New York state law governing stock sale operations, is the “worst law in America”:

Passed in 1921 to stop “boiler-room” stock-sale operations, the Martin Act lets prosecutors call almost anything fraud, and there’s no requirement to prove evil intent in civil cases. Yet proving scienter, or the intent or knowledge of wrongdoing, has been a staple requirement of British and American law for centuries lest innocent mistakes be prosecuted as intentional frauds. The Martin Act thus gives prosecutors a huge legal advantage against defendants, though for decades it was used sparingly.

That changed in the early 2000s when then New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer wielded the Martin Act to bludgeon settlements out of big Wall Street firms without going to court. The law does particular damage because New York is America’s financial capital and nearly every company sooner or later does business there. Note how Mr. Spitzer’s equally unconstrained successor, Eric Schneiderman, is leveraging the Martin Act to investigate Exxon for purportedly misleading the public about climate change.

I’m not sure how they make that assessment other than that the Martin Act bugs them. Wouldn’t it be closer to the mark that New York has the worst prosecutors in the United States?

“Worst law” is a pretty crowded field. What about the present Massachusetts law banning women from driving automobiles unless their husbands are walking in front of the car with a red flag? Or the prohibition of long bingo games in North Carolina? How about the laws requiring occupational licensing for hair braiding in many states?

Feel free to contribute your own candidates for worst law.

2 comments

Made in the U. S. A. World

The editors of the New York Times consider a point I touched on the other day—what exactly is an import?

Foreign-badged cars aren’t the only ones that have foreign parts. The Chevrolet Bolt EV — an important vehicle for General Motors — is composed of 26 percent American/Canadian parts. The sales sheet isn’t more specific because the parts don’t care whether they’re made in Ontario or Michigan. The motor and transmission — more than half the total parts — are from South Korea, which has already been frosted by President Trump’s refrigerator tariff. The Bolt is then bolted together at G.M.’s Lake Orion, Mich., plant. In terms of origin, the Chevy Bolt is as American as a karaoke bar — a venue that has become increasingly popular in the United States. Maybe Mr. Trump should slap a tariff on bad singing.

They continue in that vein. We don’t manufacture small automobile engines here in the United States. Consequently, every small car sold in the United States is materially an imported car.

However, I can’t go along with the editors’ claim—that importing engines from here, tires from there, etc. is “how things work in a rational world”. There’s no way for us to know that. Are the present sources the most efficient sources? Or are they the most subsidized sources? It might be that under conditions of truly free trade all small automobile engines would be made in the United States rather than none. There’s really no way to tell with all of the ferocious subsidies granted to their own industries by our trading partners.

1 comment

Who Has the Stronger Hand?

Gordon Chang returns today, expressing opinions critical of China, this time at the Daily Beast and about China’s prospects for victory in a trade war:

In 2016, a stunning 68.0 percent of China’s overall merchandise trade surplus related to sales to the U.S. In 2017, that figure increased to 88.8 percent. Trade-surplus countries, as history shows, generally suffer more in trade wars.

Beijing, therefore, is generally vulnerable to being pushed around by Washington. “If trade is so unimportant to China, why has China’s trade predation lasted so long and taken so many different forms?” Alan Tonelson, an independent Washington, D.C.-based trade analyst, asked, in comments to The Daily Beast over the weekend.

Second, the American economy is far bigger than the Chinese one. Beijing claimed gross domestic product of $12.84 trillion in 2017. America’s economy, by way of contrast, clocked in at $19.39 trillion last year.

China’s GDP numbers are surely overstated because, especially during the last two years, the country’s growth was less than half that reported by the official National Bureau of Statistics. America’s larger economy is, at the moment, in fact growing at a faster clip than China’s.

It should go without saying that big economies push smaller ones around, especially when the gap is this large.

Third, the American economy, for all its faults, is stable, and China’s, by most accounts, is on the verge of a debt crisis. China’s debt-to-GDP ratio looks like it is somewhere, depending on the amount of so-called hidden debt, between 350 percent and 400 percent.

Chinese concern about the state of the economy led to extraordinary capital flight in 2015 and 2016, with net capital outflow probably reaching $2.1 trillion in the two-year period. Only the imposition of draconian capital-control measures beginning in the fall of 2016 stopped the outbound torrent of capital.

I do not know how China would weather an actual trade war. Trade war with China might be disastrous for the rest of the world or it might be benign—it could cause China to look inwards, the direction in which it must look for future economic growth. It could cause China to open its economy rather than close it further. A man’s reach must exceed his grasp, etc.

Even the most dictatorial autocrat faces political pressures and, since we know so little about China’s high level politics, we can’t assess the pressures that Xi faces. We can only speculate from the actions he’s taken lately that he faces pressures. Where those pressures may lead him we can’t possibly know.

The only other observation I can make is that a weathervane loses its usefulness when, regardless of which way the wind is blowing, it always points in the same direction. While I am anti-Chinese regime, I am not anti-China. I consider the evidence and I express my opinions but I am not ideological.

11 comments

You Don’t Know China

and most of what you think you know is wrong. That’s the message of James Palmer’s article at Foreign Policy. Here’s a sample of some of the thing you don’t know about China. You don’t know:

  • China’s GDP growth rate
  • China’s population
  • How China’s high-level politics works
  • The extent of official corruption in China
  • What the Chinese people really think about things
  • The real Chinese defense budget
  • How good (or bad) Chinese schools are
  • How much crime there is in China

and, importantly, you don’t know what you don’t know. I would add one important thing to the list: you very likely don’t know Chinese history because most of what’s taught as ancient Chinese history not only in the West but in China itself is fiction and was consciously made up by Song Dynasty scholars.

You shouldn’t feel particularly left out or ignorant. I don’t know these things. The American government doesn’t know. The Chinese people don’t know. The Chinese government doesn’t know.

1 comment

I Didn’t Take It

What happened to Thismia Americana? Check out this post at RealClearScience for a story I found fascinating—the weird saga of Thismia Americana:

In August 1912, University of Chicago graduate student Norma Pfeiffer was exploring a damp, low-lying prairie near the wetlands surrounding Chicago’s Lake Calumet when she spotted a small, glabrous, white plant with delicate streaks of blue-green ringing the mouth of the flower. It was unlike anything else in the surrounding area.

Indeed, as she soon realized after finding additional specimens over the ensuing months, the plant was unlike anything else in the entire country.

Read the whole thing.

I’d bet a shiny new dime it was a foreign invader. If there are any samples left in collections anywhere, their DNA should be analyzed.

Meanwhile, I vote that T. Americana be declared the official Chicago plant. Under the circumstances it would be appropriate.

2 comments