What Divides Us

At Atlantic Conor Friedersdorf expounds on the same subject touched on in the paper to which I linked over the weekend, party and ideological differences:

When a New York Review of Books reviewer sees “fascist mysticism” in Jordan Peterson, or the Southern Poverty Law Center misallocates scarce resources warning its audience about Christina Hoff Sommers, I despair at how much work is needed to bridge gaps far narrower than some factions on the left imagine. And when Noah Smith, a very smart guy whose sincerity I never doubt, stakes out a series of claims about the right that strike me as clearly contradicted by lots of available evidence—well, I figure one of us is very wrong, and that I’d better put forth my thinking and hear his so we can figure out who that is.

He concludes his Twitter essay, “The age of Trump is one of racial and gender animus. Trump’s divisiveness and hate have infected every corner of our intellectual landscape, poisoned every discussion.” With his last sentence I concur: “American intellectual life is just one more thing that won’t be healthy again until Trump is gone.”

I think they’re all making one common, grave error. We need to distinguish between ordinary people on the one hand and public intellectuals and political leadership on the other. I don’t think there’s an ounce of sincerity in our political leadership, Democratic or Republican. And I think that public intellectuals largely follow the leads of the political leadership.

For example is it true that

“On the left, the drive to purge racism, sexism, etc. from American society is very strong,” he tweeted, “and most discourse concerns this drive––either decrying examples of racism/sexism, discussing institutions that maintain these -isms, or discussing how to effect change.”

How, then, can you explain why there has been no substantial racial progress in Illinois, where Democrats have complete control of the state government? I think it’s obvious. Racial equity sounds good on the stump but they don’t really give a damn. What they do give a damn about is beating down their political opponents and calling Republicans Nazis and Klansmen is a darned good way of doing that.

I think what most divides us is our political leadership, our would-be ruling class.

6 comments

Price Controls for Health Care?

In his latest Washington Post column Robert Samuelson makes a provocative suggestion. If, indeed, it’s the prices, stupid as the late Uwe Reinhardt claimed was the reason for high health care costs in the U. S., why not impose price controls?

If higher American health spending reflects the growing market power of providers, then why not curb that power with some form of price controls? This is what most affluent societies do, notes Laugesen.

Writing in the liberal Washington Monthly magazine, Paul Hewitt and Phillip Longman recommend just that. Under their proposal, Congress would adopt the Medicare fee and reimbursement system for the entire country. If this were done, employer-paid premiums would drop sharply, and some savings — maybe all — would be passed along to workers. (Hewitt and Longman call their proposal the “single-price system,” as opposed to the “single-payer system,” which is universal coverage.)

Of course, this wouldn’t be done instantly. The sudden loss of so much income would doubtlessly bankrupt scores of hospitals and doctors’ practices, whose costs are tied to present premiums. But phased in over, say, a decade, some sort of new system might achieve significant savings without destroying the health-care infrastructure.

I see a number of risks in such a plan. The most obvious is that it might not decrease the number of bankruptcies in the health care sector as it would just spread them out. It might even increase their number.

Another possible risk is price controls in health care would have the same results as in any other sector: they would create a black market. I can see all sorts of ways that could happen.

The third is that it might not result in any savings at all. Medicare prices are determined by a committee and private insurance prices are usually determined, effectively, as a markup above Medicare prices. Our pricing problem is the entire system not merely the price differential between Medicare and private.

Also, isn’t it inevitable that the sort of price controls being proposed would result in private insurers leaving the market? That is, the only remaining forms of health insurance would be Medicare, Medicaid, and other public plans?

What do you think? Are price controls the solution to our high health care costs?

15 comments

Lying to Congress

Lying to Congress under oath should have serious consequences. When perjury is treated with a wink and a nod while lying to the FBI when not under oath is treated as a serious crime it is itself abuse of power. We need to decide under what conditions lying is an offense and adhere to those standards. Otherwise perjury becomes merely a political offense.

0 comments

What Happened in Syria?

Yesterday several Syrian government military facilities were struck by what appear to have been missiles. The BBC reports:

The Syrian military said facilities in Hama and Aleppo provinces were struck.

It did not immediately report any casualties. But a UK-based monitoring group said 26 pro-government fighters were killed, most of them Iranians.

It is not known who was behind the attacks. Western nations and Israel have previously hit sites in Syria.

Earlier this month, the US, UK and France bombed three facilities they said were associated with the Syrian government’s alleged chemical weapons programme.

Israel is meanwhile alleged to have hit an airbase in Homs province reportedly serving as an Iranian drone command centre and containing an advanced Iranian air defence system.

Seven Iranian soldiers were among 14 military personnel killed in that attack.

It is widely suspected that Israel is behind the strikes. Should Israel become more actively involved in the campaign against the Syrian government the consequences could be quite serious.

0 comments

Mystery Tree

Do you have a Franklinia growing in your backyard? Consider the history of this mysterious tree as recounted in JSTOR Daily:

Along the Altamaha River near Georgia’s Fort Barrington, the Franklinia alatamaha was witnessed for the first and last times. The tree was initially recorded by botanists John and William Bartram, a father-son team from Philadelphia, in October 1765. The Bartrams were out exploring because earlier that year, King George III appointed John his Royal Botanist for North America. William would return several times, collecting the tree’s seeds in the 1770s and bringing them back to Philadelphia. It wasn’t until 1781, years after his father’s death, that a cultivated tree finally bloomed its snowy camellia-like flowers. William decided to name the tree in honor of one of his late father’s friend, a fellow botany aficionado who through John had introduced rhubarb to North America: Benjamin Franklin.

An elegant watercolor of Franklinia, attributed to William Bartram, is now at the Natural History Museum in London. One white flower faces the viewer, its five petals surrounded by a burst of deep green leaves. In the fall, those leaves turn a radiant red, sometimes while the flowers with their orange-like fragrance are still in bloom. That contrast and its dainty form—growing to about 25 feet tall—made this member of the tea tree family ready for popular gardening, and, as botanist Peter Del Tredici wrote in Arnoldia, nurseries in Philadelphia started cultivating Franklinia in the nineteenth century. One early propagator was Thomas Meehan, a British immigrant who had worked at Bartram’s Garden, and would later partner with Charles Sprague Sargent, the first director of Harvard University’s Arnold Arboretum, to protect Bartram’s house and garden as part of the Philadelphia park system. He also donated a Franklinia to the Arboretum, which now has the two largest specimens in the world.

If so, you might want to contact Bartram’s Garden or Gayther L. Plummer.

2 comments

Political Science

Read this article at RealClearScience by Ross Pomeroy on a Chinese medical study and you’ll have a better understanding of my skepticism about the science being practiced in China.

If you liked Lysenkoism, you’ll love Chinese science.

0 comments

The Most Vetted Immigrants in History

This, as reported in Stars and Stripes, is an injustice:

Thousands of Afghans and Iraqis and their families have entered the U.S. since Congress enacted The Afghan Allies Protection Act in 2009 and a similar program for Iraq a year earlier. The laws provided for special immigrant visas for these applicants, threatened because of their work with the United States.

But the numbers of Afghans requesting the visas have surpassed the numbers allocated. At the end of September, government data showed that more than 9,000 Afghan applicants and nearly 13,000 of their family members were caught somewhere in the lengthy application process. Congress had initially allocated 1,500 Afghan SIVs for fiscal 2017, but midway through the year, a bipartisan coalition of lawmakers introduced legislation to provide 2,500 more visas for Afghans – still far short of what was needed.

The Iraq SIV program stopped accepting new applications in September 2014, and U.S.-affiliated Iraqis must now go through the U.S. Refugee Admissions Program for resettlement.

The Afghans and Iraqis who worked with us and helped us are deserving of our assistance, need our assistance, and are among the most vetted immigrants in history. We should be admitting more of them not fewer.

5 comments

Three Questions

Rather than analyzing Steven Metz’s article at World Politics Review, “How Russia Crafted a Three-Dimensional Strategy to Regain Global Influence”, I have three questions for Mr. Metz.

How many countries has Russia attacked or invaded over the period of the last 30 years?

In how many countries’ internal politics has the U. S. intervened over the period of the last 30 years?

What country sells the most armaments to other countries?

I do not think the Russians are our friends. I think that criticism of Russia is completely legitimate. However, it’s a lot harder to fault them for doing what we ourselves are doing on a much greater scale.

I’d like for the U. S. to be in a position to criticize Russia’s bad behavior. It would take a complete transformation of our foreign policy.

0 comments

Dragnet

As I’ve mentioned before I’ve been listening to old radio programs as I drive around in the car. For the last couple of months I’ve been listening to what I have no doubt is the second-best radio drama series ever made: Dragnet. In 1949 after his short run in the highly-rated Pat Novak for Hire Jack Webb had Dragnet greenlighted and the rest, to coin a cliché, is history.

If you only know Dragnet from its late 60s television revival, check out the radio series. Everything that’s campy in the TV series works on radio.

They tackled subjects which strike me as very frank and realistic for the time. Something like 5-10% of the cases are drug-dealing in one form or another. I’ve heard one case involving prostitution. They dealt with homicide, theft, fraud, and just about every other crime subject in a very low-key, factual, realistic fashion.

In 1951 Barton Yarborough, the radio staple who had played Joe Friday’s partner Ben Romero since the series’s inception, died suddenly of a heart attack. On December 27, 1951, in an episode titled “The Big Sorrow” dedicated to Yarborough’s memory, Joe Friday receives the news that Ben had died of a heart attack. Very affecting. For the first four years of the series they repeated the Christmas episode, “A .22 for Christmas”, in which a youngster who’d received a .22 rifle for Christmas accidentally kills a playmate with it. Also very affecting.

0 comments

City of the Smokes

As you may recall I went to New York City on business for the first time in years a month or so ago. One of the things I failed to mention about my visit that jumped out at me was a) how young the people in the city were and b) how many of them were smoking. Very different from Chicago where, other than standing on the sidewalk in front of buildings, you rarely see anyone smoking.

I’m not sure what I can attribute that to. Maybe I’m mistaken. Or maybe the very large percentage of foreign-born population (over 40%) has something to do with it.

0 comments