There another exercise in wishful thinking, this time from Jonathan Hasak at RealClearPolicy. Rather than a guaranteed job, why not guaranteed retraining, he asks:
Every administration since the Progressive Era has sought to create more jobs through the promise of tax breaks to businesses; subsidizing job opportunities; infrastructure, tax, and housing incentives; and leveraging resources from the private sector. But these incremental reforms have not fixed the broken talent marketplace that now exists in our country, nor have they corrected the mismatches in the labor market. While political constraints may prevent a large federal jobs guarantee program from becoming law anytime soon, it behooves both Democrats and Republicans — whether already in or aspiring to office — to create and champion local and state job-retraining initiatives that could be used as the foundation for a more comprehensive jobs program in the future.
He makes a significant number of weak assumptions with his proposal. First, the evidence that there is a widespread “skills mismatch” is weak. Second, how do the administrators of the proposed program decide what skills they’ll train? It will be decided politically, of course. Is there no role for aptitude or preference in his program?
But by far the greatest weakness is that as long as employers can import a workforce from abroad, they’ll do so. It gives them an edge. Workers whose jobs are dependent on not complaining, not asking for raises, and not moving away make for more docile employees. Those are the reasons that agricultural work has become increasingly dominated by Mexican and Central Americans, that meat-packing has transmogrified from a job that paid well and was mostly performed by native-born Americans to one that didn’t pay nearly so well and primarily employed immigrants, and information technology has so many South Asian, not some hypothetical “skills mismatch” or because they’re “jobs that Americans won’t do”.
Here’s my modest proposal: enforce existing labor laws, particularly those involving illegal immigrants or the use of H1-B and L-1 visas.
As usual I disagree with the assessment in Tom Friedman’s latest New York Times column. There’s no quote in it that properly summarizes his position and I won’t quote the column in full.
I’ll try to provide a synopsis. The United States or some consortium of countries can compel a change in Chinese behavior or the Chinese will voluntarily adopt the changes we want. That is nonsense. And it is even greater nonsense now that Xi Jinping is president for life.
The only country’s behavior we can change is our own and doing that’s an uphill battle. There are lots of ways we could set out on that path but increasing the prices of steel and aluminum is one small step. Our choice is whether we continue our doomed path to be a country whose economy is dependent almost entirely on consumer spending or one that achieves a better balance among personal consumption, business investment, and exports than is presently the case.
The odds are not good but I don’t see any other viable alternative.
After a bit of boilerplate about how mean the White House Correspondents Dinner was, at The Hill Lara M. Brown opines:
Every issue is a “hot button†issue. And the staged, Jerry Springer-like partisan brawls on cable news have become so normalized that this ugliness is reflected across the public discourse on social media platforms. In the name of authenticity, savagery abounds.
But what’s wilder is that partisans on both sides of the aisle believe that on the issues that matter to them, they are losing. And even worse, few Americans trust the government in Washington and “fewer than a quarter (21 percent) say it is run for the benefit of all the people.â€
As far as I’m concerned both sides losing would be a consummation devoutly to be wished but, to paraphrase the late Mayor Daley, one side or the other will win. Look at the subjects on which there is consensus between the two Congressional caucuses: that we will borrow far more than is good for us, that we will not introduce structural reforms in any entitlement, and that military intervention will remain our first recourse in foreign policy rather than our last.
She also says this:
They also know that the majority of Americans who come to Washington to make a career in politics do so for idealistic, rather than self-interested, reasons. They come, hoping to make change on the issue they care about. From enacting new protections to repealing regulations, the specific changes desired or preferred by those who work in Washington run the gamut.
which is patently wrong. No one runs for the House or Senate for reasons other than self-gratification, self-aggrandizement, or self-enrichment. By the time their first campaign for the U. S. House or Senate is over any idealistic motives have been extinguished and with each successive re-election campaign personal good is further conflated with the public good.
The news media are still a-buzz with subject in which I have little interest so let’s talk about the prospects for the midterm elections, shall we? At CNN Harry Enten sums up his analysis of the midterms:
We can also look at district-by-district ratings produced by organizations such CNN, the Cook Political Report and Inside Elections. All of these rating systems point towards Democrats picking up seats, and the average outcome would be a Democratic takeover. But there’s a wide range of possible outcomes given the predictiveness of these ratings at this point in the last few cycles. Anything from a Democratic pickup of roughly 10 to 50 seats would be in-line with these ratings.
The national environment could certainly change over the next few months. But if we’re looking at the polls and all the available evidence to us, the House is not a lost cause for Republicans at this time. Certainly not in the way described to Trump.
Anyone categorizing the House as “all but” certain to be won by Democrats in 2018 is repeating the same mistake of 2016, when polls showed a Hillary Clinton win as more likely than not but far from inevitable.
while Kyle Kondik at Sabato’s Crystal Ball concludes:
In total, we have 211 House seats rated Safe/Likely/Leaning Republican, 198 Safe/Likely/Leaning Democratic, and 26 Toss-ups. Splitting the Toss-ups evenly, 13-13, would lead to a 224-211 Republican House, a 16-seat Democratic gain from the current House, which is 240-195 Republican assuming no vacancies.
When we talk about a “floor†for Democratic gains, a gain of about 10-15 seats for the Democrats seems to be about the lowest we would expect barring a massive change in public opinion. Sometimes in elections there is a debate about expectations. For instance, one might credibly argue that Democrats would do well in the Senate if they just didn’t lose any net seats given their very challenging map this year. Such an outcome would still leave Republicans in the Senate majority, though. However, in the case of the 2018 battle for the House, there’s no need to discuss what a moral victory might look like for either side: Whichever side gets to elect the speaker next year had the better election, period. That means that even if Republicans lose, say, 20 seats, they still would have had a good election given this year’s difficult circumstances.
To my eye the great lesson of the 2016 election wasn’t that the Russians stole the election for Trump or collusion or that Americans are irredeemably sexist or even that the DNC foisted a lousy candidate on the party. It’s that money is not dispositive. The Clinton campaign spent a multiple of what the Trump campaign spent. It still didn’t ensure victory.
The conclusion is that, while money is necessary to run political campaigns, it doesn’t ensure victory. To win the House Democrats must back candidates well-suited for the districts in which they’re running regardless of their fit with the ideology that some in the caucus would like for the new Democratic majority.
Here’s the kernel of Alex Berezow’s op-ed in the Seattle Times, “After 14 years, I’ve had it. I’m leaving Seattle”:
I told my council member that Northgate, my home, had seen a noticeable increase in litter and graffiti. To my dismay, she seemed to suggest these issues were someone else’s job, not hers. So, I moved on to a bigger issue: homelessness.
When I first moved to Seattle 14 years ago, to attend the University of Washington, homelessness essentially didn’t exist at Northgate. Though I have never been a victim of or witness to a crime, some of my neighbors have been, and they believe homeless camps are the reason. Additionally, the conditions in such camps are often atrocious — not only are the homeless more likely to be victims of violent crime, they are susceptible to infectious disease, such as the hepatitis A outbreak in San Diego that sickened nearly 500 people and has killed 20.
I believe strongly that it is not compassionate to leave people who are unable or unwilling to care for themselves to suffer and die on the street. Because many (but certainly not all) homeless people struggle with mental illness or drug addiction, I suggested that Seattle find a way to make it easier to provide treatment to these troubled souls — involuntarily, if need be. It could literally save their lives.
Juarez exclaimed, “What is this? Nazi Germany?â€
Appalled — in part because my grandparents survived Nazi Germany — I got up and walked out.
I must be out of touch. It doesn’t seem to me that calling a constituent a Nazi should be an elected official’s first resort. Not even if the constituent comes into her office wearing a mustache, an armband, and shouting “Sieg Heil!”
He goes on to cite a number of other examples.
Here’s my question. Why is Seattle so angry? I can only speculate that its elected officials think that anger is working for them.
I agree with the first sentence of Bruce McConnell’s piece on U. S.-Russian relations at RealClearWorld:
The bilateral relationship between the United States and Russia is at its most dangerous point since the Cuban missile crisis.
Not only is the relationship bad, that it is so bad is almost entirely our fault. Over the last 20 years we have expanded NATO to the Russian border despite commitments not to, tried to expand NATO even farther into Georgia, supported neo-Nazis’ overthrowing of the legitimately-elected government of Ukraine to replace the pro-Russian government with a pro-U. S. one, ousted the Qaddafi government from Libya despite our assurances we would not, and supported violent radical Islamists in Syria attempting to overthrow the Assad government.
Their protestations to the contrary notwithstanding, I wouldn’t be surprised if the Russian government had engaged in hacking and disinformation campaigns during the 2016 U. S. presidential election. The U. S. has interfered with the democratic process in Russia, Congo, Chile, Guatemala, Italy, Vietnam, Philippines, Japan, Honduras, Venezuela, and who knows how many other countries, frequently in much more kinetic ways than hacking. We should remove the beam from our own collective eye before our complaints about the mote in the Russian eye can be taken very seriously.
I’m all for confidence-building with Russia. What should we do to boost their confidence?
Just a reminder. When the mostly Hondurans in the so-called “caravan” crossed into Mexico they were, at least arguably, refugees. When they crossed from Mexico into the U. S., they were economic migrants. We are under no obligation to treat them as refugees or asylum-seekers and we shouldn’t.
Today’s menu is nothingburger and there’s a lot of it. My reaction to the White House Correspondents Dinner is radical apathy. I really don’t care about it. The WHC really hate Trump and vice versa. It’s not news.
The Israelis have labored and brought forth a mouse. The known known is that prior to 2003 Iran had a nuclear weapons development program. Finding a mountain of evidence for that doesn’t make it more true. The Iranians knew they had a nuclear weapons development program, the Israelis knew it, we knew it, President Obama knew it. And nothing in the published reports I’ve seen suggests anything more than that other than that when the deal President Obama cut with the Iranians expires they’ll be able to produce a nuclear weapon on pretty short order. That, too, is not news.
The Congressional Republicans don’t care about deficits or small government. Not news.
Next you’ll be telling me that feminists don’t really care about women, that race hustlers don’t care about blacks, that there’s an investigation of the Trump campaign’s alleged collusion with the Russians going on, or that Jeff Bezos is rich.
Dave Schuler
April 30, 2018
I find this Washington Post op-ed by Michael Scherer, Greg Jaffe and Josh Dawsey very distressing:
It is unclear just how much Trump’s private conversations signal a public shift in policy or, rather, if they are just maneuvering by a famously transactional leader who often says what he needs to say to make a deal and then reverses himself. The White House declined to comment for this story, but an official confirmed the outlines of the interactions that Paul described.
Nonetheless, Trump’s talks with Paul reflect an area of growing tension between the president, whose instinct is to withdraw from overseas entanglements, and his military, whose leaders think that swift pullouts would spark dangerous instability. In Afghanistan, one indication of the military’s nervousness is its eagerness to open peace talks with the Taliban and try to negotiate an end the conflict.
The Trump-Paul conversations also point to an effort by the dovish senator and former Trump rival, long treated by his party as a foreign policy gadfly, to assert influence over a president who chafes at being managed by his advisers and the Republican foreign policy establishment.
claiming as it does that unless you’re invading and occupying other countries or have open borders with them it’s isolationist. I reject any charge of isolationism against any country with as much international trade as we do. It seems to me the authors are confusing disinterest and isolationism.
Dave Schuler
April 30, 2018
I recommend Alex Berezow’s acerbic but informative article at the American Council on Science and Health on the arguments for a nuclear energy future:
Energy models are also highly influenced by ideology and politics. How else can we explain the fact that energy models tend to minimize the implementation of nuclear power, the best energy source that mankind has exploited to date? Designing models that incorporate fantasy rather than reality is how Mark Jacobson concluded that the United States could be powered exclusively by wind, water, and solar by 2055.
He likes Integral Fast Reactors, I like small modular reactors, especially when thorium-based but the message is the same. Support for the rapid deployment of modern technology nuclear power should be much more highly emphasized than at present.