What Stories are Under-Covered?

You know, you’d think that with the ravening maw of the 24 hour news cycle that the number and variety of stories covered in the news media would be vast but I find it’s almost exactly the opposite. Rather than covering the opening of an envelope as you’d think they would reporters are piling on to the same stories and I think there are significant stories that go all but completely uncovered.

Finding such stories in international affairs is almost like shooting fish in a barrel there are so many of them. For example, the wars in Yemen, Central African Republic, South Sudan, and Burma are substantial conflicts in which thousands of people have died but it’s almost as though they weren’t happening at all. The Mexican Drug War is enormous and right next door but we don’t really get much news of it here.

I’m actually somewhat sympathetic with media organizations about that. These wars are taking in places that are very hard to cover, in most cases without substantial U. S. involvement (we can’t be in every war, you know) and most U. S. news organizations have eliminated their foreign desks entirely or cut back on them severely.

IMO the continued carnage in the Austin, Garfield Park, Humboldt Park, and North Lawndale neighborhoods of Chicago is tragically undercovered and the media don’t even have the excuse that they’re hard to cover. Presumably, it’s an instantiation of Alfred Harmsworth’s observation that when a dog bites a man, that is not news, because it happens so often ut if a man bbites a dog, that is news which is even more tragic.

So, what stories, international or domestic, are presently undercovered in the U. S. media?

8 comments

It’s Just Good Old-Fashioned Pork Barrel Politics

I don’t know where to start in critiquing David Brooks’s most recent New York Times column. Here’s its kernel:

The Republicans seem to be turning themselves into an aging minority party. Moderate Democrats are no longer a force. There are only two vibrant political tendencies in America right now: Trumpian populism and Bernie Sanders/Elizabeth Warren-style progressivism. As Trumpism loses, progressivism will win.

What can we say about the coming progressive regime? First, it will be a decisive break from the moderate liberalism of Bill Clinton and even Barack Obama. Second, despite some silly recent talk, it will not be Marxist.

Let’s start here. It won’t be Marxist because it’s just barely leftist. It really is just plain old pork barrel politics, buying votes, and that’s as old as the republic.

There’s a fundamental difference between making expensive promises when federal spending is 8% of GDP and the national debt is a few billion dollars and when it’s over 20% of GDP and the debt is in the trillions, approaching 100% of GDP. The impossibility of it all is just too apparent. As Elbert Hubbard (not the Scientology guy) said more than a century ago when accused of being a socialist: when more people want to give rather than get I’ll be a socialist.

I doubt that there is an incipient let alone permanent leftist ascendancy in the United States. If there is it won’t derive from the Sanders-Warren wing of the Democratic Party.

1 comment

It’s Dead, Jim

I’ve seen quite a few articles on fact-checking recently without commenting on any of them. In my opinion fact-checking columns jumped the shark when one of them, after proclaiming something “mostly true”, subsequently declared it the “lie of the year”. They should have just closed up shop.

5 comments

The Lowest Form of Humor

I proclaim today “Bad Puns Day”.

0 comments

Keep Calm and Carry On

I should take my temperature. I’m in agreement with what Max Boot says in his most recent Washington Post column:

While evidence of Trump’s wrongdoing is copious, the case is not yet solid enough to compel impeachment. Trump has engaged in a clear pattern of obstruction of justice, beginning with his attempts to extract a loyalty oath from Comey and get him to go easy on fired national security adviser Michael Flynn. When Comey didn’t comply, he was canned. Trump then admitted on TV that he had acted to stop the investigation of the “Russia thing” (even if he now denies it). All of Trump’s attacks on the Justice Department and the FBI — and his disgraceful demands that they prosecute his political enemies — strengthen the case. So do Trump’s aborted attempts to fire special counsel Robert S. Mueller III.

There is also growing evidence of collusion between the Trump campaign and the Kremlin that the president sought to cover up — for instance, by claiming that his campaign high command was meeting with an admitted Russian “informant” to discuss “the adoption of Russian children” rather than dirt on Hillary Clinton. Trump’s flouting of ethical norms — his refusal to release his tax returns, divest himself of his business holdings, or stop doing business with partners closely linked to foreign regimes — could add additional articles of impeachment. Even greater misconduct may be uncovered via the investigation into Trump’s personal lawyer, Michael Cohen.

But it would be unwise for Democrats to proceed with impeachment unless Mueller issues a damning report. As long as the special counsel is still investigating, Democrats need to hold off, lest they play into Trump’s hands by appearing to be blatantly political. But if Mueller does find serious wrongdoing by the president, then politics should no longer matter. All members of Congress who take seriously their oaths to “support and defend the Constitution” will then be obligated to proceed with impeachment.

The emphasis is mine. However, that temporary lapse into good judgment doesn’t prevent him from going off the rails:

Rep. Waters (D-Calif.) has indeed been saying that Trump should either resign or be impeached, but that is not the message coming from Democratic Party leaders.

Maxine Waters has been calling for Trump’s impeachment practically since his inauguration and, heavens forfend, she is part of the Democratic Party leadership. She’s Minority Chief Deputy Whip, a leadership position. She’s also a former chairman of the Congressional Black Caucus. Embarrassingly, she’s not a back-bencher. She’s basically the voice of The Resistance in Congress, a proxy for the top leaders. She gives them plausible deniability.

Mr. Boot also fails to understand impeachment. It is an inherently political act. “The politics of impeachment” is a redundancy.

The dangers are far worse than Mr. Boot paints them. Should the Democrats eke out a narrow majority in the House and proceed to impeach Trump, the risk is far greater than “playing into Trump’s hands”. Trump’s supporters will not accept an impeachment on meager evidence of an underlying crime produced by 50%+1 of the House.

3 comments

Some Wars Aren’t Our Wars

The editors of the New York Times reach the correct conclusion about Saudi Arabia’s war with Yemen:

The Saudis’ brutal campaign in Yemen has created one of the world’s worst humanitarian crises, with at least eight million people on the brink of famine, one million suspected of being infected with cholera and two million displaced from their homes. Legal and human rights experts say the killing of thousands of civilians and the humanitarian aid deprivations, most blamed on Saudi Arabia, could be war crimes in which the United States would be complicit.

The war began in 2014 when Houthi rebels and forces loyal to former President Ali Abdullah Saleh took control of the capital, Sana, and much of the rest of the country. In 2015, a Saudi-led coalition, with President Barack Obama’s backing, launched blistering attacks, including thousands of airstrikes, against the Houthi-Saleh forces in support of President Abdu Rabbu Mansour Hadi.

While the war is effectively stalemated, Saudi Arabia’s rising new leader, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, seems committed to a military victory despite the horrors caused by the fighting. He has been emboldened by Mr. Trump, who has been willing to sell the kingdom almost any new military hardware it wants.

As the Houthi missiles attest, Saudi Arabia is less secure now than when it began its air campaign three years ago. Only a peace agreement is likely to bring the fighting and the killings to an end.

Although neither Prince Mohammed nor Mr. Trump seem seriously interested, the United Nations is planning to put forward a new proposal to restart peace negotiations. Congress could improve the chance of success by cutting off military aid to Saudi Arabia and voting to bar the use of American troops against the Houthis in Yemen.

without addressing some of the key issues.

  • President Obama’s drone war was enormously counter-productive. It relied too heavily on local intelligence for identifying targets which had the inevitable effect of making targets of anyone who opposed local governments. Not only was it illegal and immoral but it also had little or no effect in making us safer or punishing the perpetrators of the attacks on 9/11. It did, however, destabilize the government of Yemen.
  • The Saudis have never produced any evidence that the Iranians were supporting the Houthi rebels prior to the Saudi attack other than their vague belief that all Shi’ites are in cahoots.
  • The Saudis’ war is illegal and immoral.
  • Far from supporting them we should be condemning them in the Security Council.

Some wars just aren’t our wars. Even if the Saudis are making a hash of it we should butt out.

1 comment

Does It Matter?

While at the New York Review of Books Jay Rosen asks what is in a sense the opposite question—would it make any difference if the press were doing their jobs in a fair and even-handed manner?

There is a risk that journalists could do their job brilliantly, and it won’t really matter, because Trump supporters categorically reject it, Trump opponents already believed it, and the neither-nors aren’t paying close enough attention. In a different way, there is a risk that journalists could succeed at the production of great journalism and fail at its distribution, because the platforms created by the tech industry have so overtaken the task of organizing public attention.

There is an obvious risk that the press will lose touch with the country, fall out of contact with American culture. Newsroom diversity is supposed to prevent that, but the diversity project has itself been undermined by a longer and deeper project in mainstream journalism, which I have called the View from Nowhere, by which I mean the attempt to acquire authority by constructing an artificial impartiality, by “performing objectivity.”

At this point I don’t think that journalists are capable of reporting the news objectively and, indeed, as suggested by Mr. Rosen, they disparage it, viz. “artificial impartiality”. The journalistic fashion these days is to tell stories with a point of view and, since it’s the only point of view a reporter really knows, the point of view is inevitably the reporter’s.

No one, other than possibly the reporter’s mother, is interested in the reporter’s point of view. But it’s what’s taught in the J-schools and what’s acceptable in the newsrooms so there you have it.

I also find Mr. Rosen’s origin story of the charge of “fake news” suspect. I think you trace it back through Dan Rather’s TANG story, to the Dateline NBC ficitonalized story on the Ford Pinto through a 1981 60 Minutes report on truck accidents for which they received an Emmy, right back to the “brutally unfair”, as Claire Booth Luce put it, treatment of Barry Goldwater:

SAN FRANCISCO, July 7 (UPI) — Former Ambassador Clare Boothe Luce accused the press today of “brutally unfair” treatment of Senator Barry Goldwater. She described him as “Mr. Republican Victim of 1964.”

“The press always picks a Republican victim,” she said. Asked whether her criticism ex­tended to. Time and Life, pub­lished by her husband, Henry Luce, she replied: “I don’t think they’ve been as fair as they should have been.”

That precedes talk radio, cable news, and the 24 hour news cycle by a quarter century. I think it really traces back a century to when the foundations of modern journalism were laid and Republicans were the establishment while Democrats and unions were plucky underdog outsiders. Now Democrats, the federal bureaucracy, and public employees’ unions are as established as an establishment can get while journalists have not changed their focus.

I don’t think I can answer Mr. Rosen’s question. It’s just too fantastical. But isn’t it worth a try?

Now we rather clearly have two very distinct realities, neither of which is particularly real.

10 comments

Putting Them to the Question

At Politico Jeff Greenfield asks a provocative question—what if Trump is succeeding?

Let us assume for the moment that Donald Trump is an “idiot” and a “f—-ing moron” who hasn’t got a clue about the substance of legislation. (These judgments, if multiple news reports are accurate, come from the president’s current chief of staff, his former secretary of state and any number of Republican legislators, respectively). Let us draw from countless accounts of his conduct going back decades that the president is mendacious, graceless and a misogynist on steroids, whose character, temperament, historical cluelessness and utter incapacity for self-reflection make him by any measure the most unfit occupant of the White House ever.

Now: If you accepted these assumptions, how hard would it be to grant the president any credit for … anything? Could you embrace the old adage that “even a stopped clock is right twice a day”? Or would your wholesale revulsion at the president’s conduct simply make it impossible to accept even the possibility that he may have done something, anything, right?

I have another one. Would the New York Times, the Washington Post, and the Democratic leadership have reacted in the same way to any person other than Hillary Clinton, particularly a political outsider, who won the election in 2016?

16 comments

Be Young and White

I reject Eduardo Porter’s analysis in his New York Times report of why some “Rust Belt” cities continued to prosper while many languished. He points to location and “smart industrial zoning” while ignoring the elephant in the room. His three examples—St. Cloud, Minnesota; Grand Rapids, Michigan; and, Green Bay, Wisconsin all have some demographic features in common. Their populations are all 2/3s or more of primarily European descent and they’re younger than the national average. His contrasting examples—Decatur, Illinois and Racine, Wisconsin—are either older (Decatur) or less white (Racine).

“Be young and white” is a lousy prescription for success.

14 comments

Law, Sausages, and Lawyers

As I read Mark Penn’s list of questions for Robert Mueller at The Hill, it occurred to me that to the list of law and sausages which, as John Godfrey Saxe pointed out 150 years ago, inspire respect in inverse proportion to the scrutiny applied to them, we should add the practice of law. The practice of law may involve some distasteful chores but, since it’s the best alternative for navigating the labyrinths of the law we’ve found to date, it should elicit greater sympathy.

1 comment