It’s a Scholarship Program!

The big question about the Miss America Pageant is not what its viewership will be the first time it’s presented after its significant new reforms. It’s what its viewership will be the time after that.

IMO beauty pageants, generally, have been anachronistic for some time. I don’t watch them, never have, but I guess I’m not the target audience.

3 comments

Whole Hall of Mirrors

There’s a very interesting interview with Seymour Hersh at the Columbia Journalism Review. It’s pretty wide-ranging so I think there’s something in it that should make just about anybody uncomfortable.

I think that Mr. Hersh is very conscientious and determined but my own lack of comfort with what he writes is that I think he relies far too much on unnamed sources which means they’re unverifiable. It isn’t too hard to find a guy with a grievance in a bar in Washington. What’s harder is determining whether the guy is telling you the truth. That and that, at least to my ear, he gives the impression of being as squirrelly as the dickens.

But it makes for entertaining reading.

1 comment

The Four Stages of Climate Change Activism

At the Wall Street Journal Steven Hayward explains the four stages of “climate change” an epitome for climate change activism:

A good indicator of why climate change as an issue is over can be found early in the text of the Paris Agreement. The “nonbinding” pact declares that climate action must include concern for “gender equality, empowerment of women, and intergenerational equity” as well as “the importance for some of the concept of ‘climate justice.’ ” Another is Sarah Myhre’s address at the most recent meeting of the American Geophysical Union, in which she proclaimed that climate change cannot fully be addressed without also grappling with the misogyny and social injustice that have perpetuated the problem for decades.

The descent of climate change into the abyss of social-justice identity politics represents the last gasp of a cause that has lost its vitality. Climate alarm is like a car alarm—a blaring noise people are tuning out.

This outcome was predictable. Political scientist Anthony Downs described the downward trajectory of many political movements in an article for the Public Interest, “Up and Down With Ecology: The ‘Issue-Attention Cycle,’ ” published in 1972, long before the climate-change campaign began. Observing the movements that had arisen to address issues like crime, poverty and even the U.S.-Soviet space race, Mr. Downs discerned a five-stage cycle through which political issues pass regularly.

The first stage involves groups of experts and activists calling attention to a public problem, which leads quickly to the second stage, wherein the alarmed media and political class discover the issue. The second stage typically includes a large amount of euphoric enthusiasm—you might call it the “dopamine” stage—as activists conceive the issue in terms of global peril and salvation. This tendency explains the fanaticism with which divinity-school dropouts Al Gore and Jerry Brown have warned of climate change.

Then comes the third stage: the hinge. As Mr. Downs explains, there soon comes “a gradually spreading realization that the cost of ‘solving’ the problem is very high indeed.” That’s where we’ve been since the United Nations’ traveling climate circus committed itself to the fanatical mission of massive near-term reductions in fossil fuel consumption, codified in unrealistic proposals like the Kyoto Protocol. This third stage, Mr. Downs continues, “becomes almost imperceptibly transformed into the fourth stage: a gradual decline in the intensity of public interest in the problem.”

While opinion surveys find that roughly half of Americans regard climate change as a problem, the issue has never achieved high salience among the public, despite the drumbeat of alarm from the climate campaign. Americans have consistently ranked climate change the 19th or 20th of 20 leading issues on the annual Pew Research Center poll, while Gallup’s yearly survey of environmental issues typically ranks climate change far behind air and water pollution.

“In the final stage,” Mr. Downs concludes, “an issue that has been replaced at the center of public concern moves into a prolonged limbo—a twilight realm of lesser attention or spasmodic recurrences of interest.” Mr. Downs predicted correctly that environmental issues would suffer this decline, because solving such issues involves painful trade-offs that committed climate activists would rather not make.

Unlike many of my readers I think that human-induced climate change is a genuine problem. I don’t know how urgent the problem is and, frankly, I’m skeptical of anybody who tells you that they do know.

I also think that the measures that have been proposed to reduce carbon emissions are horribly regressive and, sadly, ineffectual, since carbon emissions increase geometrically with income. Tax-based schemes will only affect the poorest; the rich will just pay the taxes. That’s why I think that capture and sequester are better strategies for reducing carbon emissions than carbon taxes. But that assumes that you want to reduce carbon emissions rather than increase taxes and control.

21 comments

Democratic Economic Policy

I think that Ryan Cooper is confusing the parties’ press releases with their policies. In his recent post at The Week he characterizes Republican policies:

One consistent theme of American politics over the last generation has been the increasingly strong ideological discipline of the Republican Party. What that has meant in policy terms is fairly clear: tax cuts for the rich, cuts to social insurance programs, deregulation, free trade, union-busting, and a belligerent foreign policy.

and then Democratic policies:

Certainly before 2008, one couldn’t say they had a starkly different set of policy ideas. Up through about the early 1970s, it had been a fairly straightforward working-class party, but after a generation of reform, under Bill Clinton it stood for a muddle of capitalism worship leavened with means-tested welfare programs. At bottom, it was a left-inflected version of the same neoliberalism that comprises Republican Party doctrine.

Let’s look solely at economic policy—Democrats and Republican share the same “belligerent foreign policy” and I’ll leave the comparison of the social policies of the two parties to others.

Republican economic policy is cuts in the personal and corporate income tax full stop. Look at what they do not what they say. Whenever they have control of both house of the Congress and the White House they cut personal and corporate income tax rates. They don’t cut spending, they don’t pare back “social insurance programs”, they don’t expand free trade, and they don’t break up unions. They also do not cut back on the size of government. “Party of small government” is just boilerplate for the rubes.

As to the Democrats they are not now and never have been the party of Keynesian economics. Consider this remark of Mr. Cooper’s:

The economic stimulus of 2009 — passed in a panic after Obama was inaugurated — prevented a full-blown depression, but did not restore full employment.

As 2010 progressed, it became increasingly obvious that the stimulus had been a severe undershoot. But Democrats did not pass another. The reason was ideological. The Keynesian idea that the government should spend until full employment was reached — as it did during the New Deal and the Second World War, thus fixing the Great Depression — took tentative hold in 2009, but soon afterwards the forces of neoliberalism regrouped and began loudly flipping out about deficits. Most Democrats had a vague at best understanding of the logic of stimulus, and quickly gave in.

By February 2010, Obama was “pivoting” to deficit reduction and austerity — and most of the party went along with him. It was a monumental political mistake: It meant unemployment was still nearly at 10 percent on election day in 2010, and hence absolutely crushing defeat — the loss of 63 House seats and control of the chamber, six Senate seats, and 680 state legislative seats.

First, the notion that Obama saved the country from a “full-blown depression” is arrant nonsense. Before a penny of the money that had been appropriated by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act had been spent the recovery had already begun (the recession ended in the second quarter of 2009). Is it possible that there might have been a second, deeper dip without it? Sure. Without empirical evidence that’s just post hoc propter hoc. Tiger repellent.
There’s as much empirical evidence that the ARRA prolonged the recession as prevented it from getting deeper.

But there’s a reason that the Democratic leadership leapt on the opportunity that the recession presented, why they insisted on spending too small to offset the dip in private consumption, why they spent money as they did, and why they spread it out over several years rather than concentrating the entirety of the spending where it would do the most good. The leadership didn’t believe in that Keynesian mumbo jumbo but they did believe in pork barrel spending. After a long drought they wanted to give money to favored causes, shore up favored constituencies, reward donors and bundlers, and time everything to maximize political control. And that’s what they did. In that process they were aided by useful idiots like the Panglossian Lawrence Summers, always ready to lend his intellectual authority to what the political leadership had decided on anyway.

Just for the record I do believe in that Keynesian mumbo jumbo. I believe that carefully-crafted, well-timed stimulus can restore full employment under conditions of a shortfall in aggregate demand. I just don’t believe that the Congress is capable of producing a carefully-crafted, well-timed stimulus.

There was precisely one way to implement such a stimulus that wasn’t hopelessly regressive and that was by a full-blown payroll tax holiday but that wouldn’t provide the sine qua non of stimulus packages acceptable to the Democratic leadership: political control.

There’s a word that I use occasionally here that I’ve realized you may not understand, “nomenklatura”. In the Soviet Union the nomenklatura referred to the party officials who held key administrative posts in the government and, basically, ran the country. The golden thread that runs through domestic policies favored by today’s Democratic Party is that they maximize political control, i.e. the power of the nomenklatura. That was true of the ARRA; it is true of the Affordable Care Act.

I’m indifferent to whether we need a more Keynesian Democratic Party. I don’t think they can ever time or construct a stimulus package in such a way as to effect its goals. I do think that we need a more populist Democratic Party.

1 comment

Masterpiece

While I wait for better-informed commentary than mine on Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission, I wanted to make two observations.

First, I strongly suspect it’s going to be overinterpreted, by supporters and opponents alike. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

Second, do you notice how neatly it supports the point I made last week that the idea of a 4-4 partisan/ideological split in the Court is greatly exaggerated? There’s a better argument to be made that there’s a 2-2-5 split in the Court with Thomas and Alito holding a conservative hard line and Ginsburg and Sotomayor holding a progressive hard line just as determinedly. But even that ignores that there were two other Supreme Court decisions rendered today, one 9-0 and the other 6-3.

8 comments

Compare and Contrast

For the first time in four years Illinois has managed to enact a budget on time. The Chicago Tribune reports:

Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner on Monday signed into law a $38.5 billion spending plan for state government, approving a full budget on time for the first time since he took office in 2015.

Flanked by Republican and Democratic lawmakers, Rauner touted the legislation as the product of “a great team effort, a great bipartisan effort.”

“Today we are having a small celebration,” Rauner said at a signing ceremony at the James R. Thompson Center in the Loop, adding that the budget was a compromise. “It is not perfect, but it’s a good step in the right direction.”

The budget legislation is the product of negotiations between the Democrats who control the General Assembly and Republican lawmakers allied with the governor.

Unlike in previous years, when Rauner had insisted that a budget deal come alongside approval of his broader legislative agenda, the governor this time requested only a balanced budget that required no new taxes. That meant that lawmakers were free to spend the money they’d raised through a new income tax increase that was enacted last summer over Rauner’s objections.

The plan maintains state government spending close to existing levels. It boosts funding for early childhood and K-12 education by a combined $407 million. And it projects savings of $445 million from new pension buyout options for state pensioners.

It’s amazing how elections in the fall tend to focus the mind.

On the other hand this morning roughly a dozen cancellations of RFBs from the State of Illinois have crossed my desk, all cancelled because there were no bidders. That’s the sort of thing that happens when you don’t pay your bills.

1 comment

Just the Facts, Ma’am

I encourage you to read Jack F. Matlock’s piece at The Nation on the facts as we know them in the “Russia-gate” affair. I think his enumeration of the facts is fair. The piece is relatively brief so go on over and read it.

I remain content to let the Mueller investigation do its work and I won’t speculate on what its outcome will be. It should also be noted that the facts as Mr. Matlock lists them are based on what has been made public. Maybe there’s more that hasn’t been made public yet. Maybe there isn’t.

9 comments

Sun-Times vs. Tribune

The two major Chicago newspapers are on opposite sides of the fence when it comes to whether President Trump should commute the sentence of Rod Blagojevich, convicted on multiple charges of corruption.

Sun-Times

Whatever Trump’s motivations are, commuting Blagojevich’s sentence would be no travesty of justice at this point. We have long argued that the 14-year sentence he began serving in 2012 is too severe and that it should have been in line with the 6½-year sentence imposed on former Gov. George Ryan. A commutation now would achieve that.

Although he was not convicted of personally enriching himself, Blagojevich tried to sell a vacant Senate seat and extort big campaign donations from a hospital and racetrack owner. Trump, as usual, was paltering with the facts when he said Blagojevich was convicted for “being stupid, saying things that every other politician, you know, that many other politicians say.” Yet, as we have said, Blagojevich was more of a fumbling goof than a master criminal.

The power of the presidential pardon should be used to correct flaws in the criminal justice system. Trump is using it as a weapon against what he cynically portrays as a “deep state” conspiracy against him, and unfair justice department treatment of him and his allies.

If Trump goes ahead with his plans, it actually would be a fair shake for Blagojevich, whose lawyer, Leonard Goodman, is an investor in our newspaper.

Tribune

The president certainly is vulnerable to the last thing he saw or read, be it the lobbying of Blagojevich’s wife, Patti, on Fox News, or the prisoner’s nonsensical Wall Street Journal op-ed claiming he was prosecuted for aggressive campaign fundraising, a claim Trump seems to accept. “Plenty of other politicians have said a lot worse,” Trump told reporters on Air Force One. “And it doesn’t, he shouldn’t have been put in jail.” Come to think of it, maybe Trump, more than a year into the Robert Mueller investigation, feels sorry for a fellow blowhard.

But in Illinois, where law-abiding citizens have seen four of their last 10 governors frog-marched to federal prison, the next crooked pols surely are thrilled to hear Trump bloviate. They’d love to go back to the long era of gentlemen’s sentences for the unfortunates who get caught wallowing in the Illinois culture of political sleaze.

We’ve never found joy in watching Blagojevich’s family — the people he victimized most — plead for mercy. We have, though, concluded that the sentence he earned not only is fair. It’s fair warning to other criminal pols here in Illinois, the State of Corruption.

I don’t think that the Sun-Times makes a good case for second-guessing the jury in Blagojevich’s case. I might feel differently if the former governor had shown any signs of remorse but he’s still insisting that he did nothing wrong. As long as that’s the case, I think that the jury’s decision should stand.

1 comment

Functional Illiteracy

Is it my imagination or is there a tremendous amount of functional illiteracy around these days? “Illiteracy” means you can’t read. “Functional illiteracy” means that, although you can read the words, you have difficulty understanding the meaning of the text.

Is it functional illiteracy, not having the time to read, wanting to talk so much you can’t be bothered to read, or just not giving a damn?

12 comments

The Drought

Some of the many bad aspects of the continuous state of outrage that Donald Trump has—I’m at a loss of finding the right word—enjoyed is that the media appear to be running out of other subjects and we’re in grave danger of outrage fatigue. None of the problems that existed in 2015 when Trump was primarily known for hosting his own reality show have gone away. They just no longer receive the same attention.

The slant of far too many opinion pieces is “how can it be used to bash Trump?” And all too often Trump obliges with a tweet.

But there’s a terrible drought of articles about anything else. I can’t make bricks without straw, you know.

7 comments