Hagiography

For those of you who aren’t familiar with the word “hagiography” it refers to narratives of the lives of the saints. I hope that the exaggerated hagiographies of Robert Kennedy, presumably in recognition of the 50th anniversary of his assassination, to which we’re being treated don’t go on for too long. I realize that he’s seen as a lost opportunity by Baby Boomers but IMO that just illustrates how little they were actually aware of real events, even the real events of their youths.

By the time RFK was assassinated Hubert Humphrey already had the Democratic nomination sewed up. If RFK hadn’t been assassinated, I doubt it would have changed much about the 1968 election. What state carried by Nixon would have gone for RFK? Kennedy would in all likelihood have replaced McGovern in 1972 and would have lost just as badly as McGovern did for the same reasons. The main difference if he had not been assassinated is that his children would have grown up with even less respect for him than they did when he was a symbol of something that was lost.

But let’s play along and fantasize that Robert Kennedy was the Democratic nominee for the presidency in 1968. IMO he would have been beaten by Nixon worse than Humphrey was because he wouldn’t have carried Texas.

He wasn’t a good guy. He was a bigot. He’d been thrown out of high school for cheating, a very bad habit of the Kennedys. He was just another entitled rich guy with a Hyannis Port accent.

3 comments

Astonishing

It is astonishing to me that I should be taken to task for speaking in favor of the Golden Rule, something that’s been advocated by every school of wisdom from Christianity to Confucianism to modern secularism over the period of the last 5,000 years. I think it shows what a bad place we’re in.

39 comments

Poor Little China

I don’t think that there’s going to be a meeting of minds between China and the U. S. over the South China Sea if Ankit Panda’s op-ed at South China Morning Post is any gauge of how analysts are thinking about the situation. In it he paints a picture of the U. S. as aggressor against poor little China, e.g. “freedom of navigation” exercises, multiple ships, disinviting China from naval exercises, renaming USPACOM to the “United States Indo-Pacific Command” (the horror!).

The op-ed makes some serious omissions. For example, that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands are mostly made up or, more precisely, if the U. S. used the same standard the Chinese are all of the world’s waters would be U. S. territorial waters because there probably isn’t an inch of ocean that hasn’t been fished by American fishermen at one time or another and American seamen have washed up all over the place. By the end of the 19th century there were 3,000 fishing trawlers commissioned in the United Kingdom alone. British, American, and Portuguese fishmen fished all over the world.

The Philippines, Japan, Malaysia, and Vietnam have all expressed concerns about Chinese expansionism and in general they’ve been more worried about Washington being too passive than too aggressive.

China’s problem is that time is not on its side. Vietnam, Malaysia, and Philippines are growing, not declining not to mention India and China’s own demographics are against it. What should happen to defuse tensions in the region? China should recognize that, although it will be a regional superpower, it’s not the only country in the region and the other countries have interests, too. What will happen? Beats the heck out of me.

3 comments

Leave Him in Prison

The editors of the Chicago Tribune explain why President Trump should leave Rod Blagojevich in prison:

President Donald Trump has got this thing and it’s golden. He has the power to commute the sentence of U.S. Bureau of Prisons inmate 40892-424. Never mind that Rod Blagojevich tried to sell a U.S. Senate seat that belonged to the 12 million-plus people of Illinois. Never mind that honest people and companies got cheated out of government careers and state contracts because, under Blagojevich, the fix was in. Never mind that a commutation would reassure other crooked pols that if they fuss long enough and whine loud enough, they’ll win the Get Out of Jail Free card they think they deserve.

Blagojevich was corrupt when he took his oath of office and corrupt when he was arrested. He is proximally responsible for the fiscal disaster that Illinois has become, using teachers’ pensions to expand state services rather than raising taxes to do what he wanted, effectively buying votes. He has never acknowledged that he did wrong. He should remain in jail as long as the law allows.

9 comments

Child Migrants

Can someone provide a proposal for handling child migrants at our border with Mexico that is just, merciful, keeps families together, and doesn’t implement open borders? I’m at my wit’s end.

The appeals to emotion seem to ignore that there’s an underlying crime and the crime is being perpetrated by adult migrants (or those who send children across the border alone). Crimes have victims and sometimes the victims are children. I don’t think I’ve ever seen another case in which children are being exploited to excuse crimes.

10 comments

Is Satire Dead?

It’s sad but nobody seems to know about L’il Abner or Pogo any more. Increasingly, I find myself needing to explain what Doonesbury was. They were all political satire. L’il Abner goes back to the 1930s and Pogo to the late 1940s.

Blondie started as social satire in 1930 before transmogrifying into the comic strip equivalent of a family sitcom.

Is it the comic strip that’s moribund or satire? I guess it’s arguable that all humor is satire these days but to me it’s almost entirely blue, mean-spirited, and unfunny. Basically, Lenny Bruce without insight or timing.

3 comments

Social Security or Abortion?

I’m not going to link to Paul Krugman’s column today but I do want to consider a question inspired by it. In it he analogizes the Affordable Care Act to Social Security implying that over time it will gain near-universal support. Is he right? Or is will its fate be more like abortion—a battle that never ends?

2 comments

Voting Systems and Representation—Illinois’s Experience

In his New York Times column David Brooks is in despair about the current Congress:

Now the two-party system has rigidified and ossified. The two parties no longer bend to the center. They push to the extremes, where the donor bases and their media propaganda arms are. More and more people feel politically homeless, alienated from both parties and without any say in how the country is run.

Moreover, the whole way of practicing politics has been transformed. Each party imagines that it is one wave election from destroying the other side and gaining total power. Therefore, as Drutman notes, there’s no interest in compromise, just winning and losing, gloating and seething.

Partisans’ chief interest is in proving that the other party is despicable — in ramping up fear, hatred and the negative polarization that is the central feature of contemporary American politics.

The result is that people, especially the young, lose faith in democratic norms altogether. There are over 6,000 breweries in America, but when it comes to our politics, we get to choose between Soviet Refrigerator Factory A and Soviet Refrigerator Factory B.

and proposes an alternative system of voting to “save” America:

The way to do that is through multimember districts and ranked-choice voting. In populous states, the congressional districts would be bigger, with around three to five members per district. Voters would rank the candidates on the ballot. If no candidate had a majority of first-place votes, then the candidate with the fewest first-place votes would be eliminated. Voters who preferred that candidate would have their second-choice vote counted instead. The process would be repeated until you get your winners.

As it turns out for 110 years Illinois had a voting system for its House and Senate that approximated such a system so, consequently, Illinois’s experience is relevant. The system was called “cumulative voting” and, like the system proposed by Mr. Brooks, it was an ordinal voting system.

Under cumulative voting each voter had three votes and could cast the three votes for a candidate once, twice, or three times. The candidate who got the most votes won. Without getting too much into the weeds, the intention of the system was to approximate proportional representation with geographic districts and the multiple studies of the system have tended to find that it was successful. Over time it had a defect: it tended to provide an edge to incumbents.

Mr. Brooks’s system is likely to have the same problem, especially in the presence of party primary elections. Since our present problem is not that it’s just too darned hard for incumbents to get re-elected, giving an edge to incumbents is hardly what we need. BTW, the system that Mr. Brooks is advocating has a name: single transferable vote.

The arguments against Illinois’s system of cumulative voting apply equally to Mr. Brooks’s system. In particular that it’s complicated, too complicated for the voters to understand.

If I had to pick just one reform to “save” our political system at the national level, it would be to cap the number of persons who could be represented by a representative in a single geographical district at something like 150,000 and let the number of House districts grow over time accordingly.

There’s actually a simpler way to accomplish what Mr. Brooks wants to do: ban political parties altogether.

I should add that voting systems don’t have just one objective they have several. People tend to focus on whether the outcome is proportional that is to say does it have legitimacy when they should also be considering the quality of the representatives being elected. IMO that’s our greater problem. We have lousy representation. That won’t be improved just by a system that is more proportional.

1 comment

Why?

Why is the adult employment rate in the United Kingdom at around 74% so much higher than it is here in the United States (75%)? I’m serious. Why?

3 comments

Pro-Growth

It should be obvious that I’m quite reluctant to say anything which could be construed as supportive of President Trump but I wanted to point out something that may be missed in the din of Trump criticism. Economic activity can be summarized as arising from five factors: personal consumption, business investment, government spending, imports (inversely correlated), and exports. The Trump Administration has put in place or is putting in place measures in all five areas with the objective of increasing growth.

The tax cut was a measure to increase personal consumption as well as business investment. “The Wall” and President Trump’s infrastructure spending proposal are measures to increase government spending. The tariffs that have gone into place are intended to reduce imports as is the support for domestic oil production. The negotiations with China to increase Chinese purchases of U. S. goods will increase exports.

In other words Trump isn’t nearly as scatter-brained as the media might lead you to believe. A tremendous number of his administration’s policies are targeted at increasing economic growth.

5 comments