Who’s the Audience?

David Brooks’s column today in the New York Times is about “wokeness”:

The modern right has its own trigger words (diversity, dialogue, social justice, community organizer), its own safe spaces (Fox News) and its own wokeness. Michael Anton’s essay “The Flight 93 Election” is only one example of the common apocalyptic view: Modern liberals are hate-filled nihilists who will destroy the nation if given power. Anybody who doesn’t understand this reality is not conservatively woke.

The problem with wokeness is that it doesn’t inspire action; it freezes it. To be woke is first and foremost to put yourself on display. To make a problem seem massively intractable is to inspire separation — building a wall between you and the problem — not a solution.

There’s a debate on precisely this point now surrounding the writer Ta-Nehisi Coates. Coates is, of course, well known for seeing the problem of racism in maximalist terms. The entire American story was and continues to be based on “plunder,” the violent crushing of minority bodies. Even today, “Gentrification is white supremacy.”

Coates is very honest about his pessimism and his hopeless view of the situation. But a number of writers have criticized his stance. Cornel West has argued that it’s all words; it doesn’t lead to collective action. In The New York Review of Books, Darryl Pinckney argues, “Afro-pessimism threatens no one, and white audiences confuse having been chastised with learning.”

I’d add that it’s a blunt fact that most great social reforms have happened in moments of optimism, not moments of pessimism, in moments of encouraging progress, not in moments of perceived threat.

In his account the entire matter is an attention-getting device rather than a call to action.

What I wonder about is who his intended audience is? He already has very little audience on the right and the column won’t make him any friends on the left. The center doesn’t exist (just ask anybody) and is just a bunch of phonies anyway. Is it an audience of one?

2 comments

Futile Breast-Beating


Today we have our annual exercise in futile breast-beating following the release of the Social Security and Medicare actuaries’ report. The editors of the Washington Post declaim:

The sensible approach to this long-term challenge would be to close the gap between federal revenue and federal spending commitments. The way to do that is to legislate modest reforms to the entitlement programs along with higher taxes (including Social Security payroll taxes) for those most able to afford them. Unfortunately, Mr. Trump’s addition to Republican ideology was to commit the party to never doing either of those things.

while in the same publication Mitch Daniels pronounces:

So another congressional session is half over and, we’re told, is likely to go by without a mention of the moose on the American table, our preposterously out-of-control federal debt. It’s not as though the stakes are high: just our standard of living, national security, all the discretionary activities of government, and literally our future as an autonomous, self-governing people. Every honest observer knows what will cause the coming crunch, so aptly termed by Erskine Bowles as “the most predictable crisis in history”: the runaway autopilot programs we call “entitlements.” Without changes there, no combination of other measures can come close to preventing the reckoning.

Both the Social Security retirement program and Medicare have structural problems which can be delayed but not corrected by tinkering around the edges as both the editors and Sen. Daniels propose.

Social Security’s structural problem is not just that it is a “pay as you go” program, as pointed out by nearly everybody. It is that its assumptions are bad. It assumed that revenue and population would increase proportionally. That hasn’t happen. It’s a victim of income inequality. The only practical way to fix it is to stop paying it from its notional trust fund at all and pay it from general revenues. Any other solution is just kicking the can down the road.

To understand Medicare’s problems consider the graph above. Spending per recipient more than tripled from 1991 to 2010 and continues to increase. That’s about twice the general rate of inflation and an even greater multiple of non-healthcare inflation. That’s not a problem that can be solved by any solutions other than abolishing the program entirely or ending the present rate of increase. Shorter: there’s no painless way to solve Medicare’s problem so it won’t be done at all.

1 comment

“I Don’t Know How It Works!”

You may recall that a year or so ago when the Navy experienced a number of collisions or close calls with its ships that I posted several times on the subject. Per Defense News the Navy has done its evaluation and decided that 85% of junior officers were deficient in their ability to use the systems under their command or handle their vessels decisively and properly under conditions in which a collision might occur:

WASHINGTON — A three-month internal review conducted by senior U.S. surface fleet leaders found some or significant concerns with the ship handling skills of nearly 85 percent of its junior officers, and that many struggled to react decisively to extricate their ship from danger when there was an immediate risk of collision, according to an internal message obtained by Defense News.

Led by the Surface Warfare Officer School, officer of the deck competency checks were conducted on a random selection of OOD-qualified first-tour division officers (the newest officers in the fleet) in underway bridge navigation simulators fleet-wide between January and March. Of the 164 officers who were evaluated, only 27 passed with “no concerns.” Another 108 completed with “some concerns,” and 29 had “significant concerns,” according to the message, which was released by the Navy’s top surface warfare officer Vice Adm. Richard Brown.

Brown, who leads Naval Surface Force Pacific, termed the results “sobering.”

They’re revising the training accordingly. Frankly, 85% is pretty terrible. I would think that you could achieve 85% deficient for a lot less money than we’re actually spending. More of those evaluated presented “significant concerns” than passed with no concerns. If that’s the case, there’s a problem with a lot more than junior officers.

2 comments

Call It the “Schultz Put”

At Bloomberg View Joe Nocera muses:

I hope Schultz doesn’t run for president. As I said in a recent column, I don’t think he would have the stomach for it, especially once the mud-slinging begins. He is guileless, and he wears his sincerity on his sleeve. These qualities may make him a decent human being and a charismatic CEO, but he’ll be ripped to shreds if he goes into politics.

Schultz wants to stay in the public arena once his post-Starbucks life begins at the end of this month. “One of the things I want to do in my next chapter is to figure out if there is a role I can play in giving back,” he told Sorkin.

With a lot of ex-CEOs, “giving back” is little more than a platitude. I don’t think that will be the case with Schultz. Whatever he does next will be done with the same sense of purpose, the same guilelessness, and the same sincerity, as his efforts at Starbucks. And who knows? It might even make a difference.

I don’t think he needs to worry about that. I think that Mr. Schultz has decided to sell his Starbucks stock at the highest value it will see for a while and he can’t very well do that as company CEO, can he? Call it the “Schultz Put”. I think he’s betting that recent events will cause Starbucks’s stock to decline for the foreseeable future.

1 comment

On the Map

Check out this map of the world’s coal-fired power plants at Carbon Brief. The graphic above is a snapshot; the one at the link is interactive and tells much more about each plant.

They say that one picture is worth 1,000 words. China is still bringing new coal-fired power plants online domestically albeit at a slower pace than previously and is building another 200 for other countries.

0 comments

There’s One Born Every Minute

At Motley Fool Maxx Chatsko explains China’s actual energy plans:

China is investing tens of billions of dollars every year into renewable energy deployment and supply chains. Its motivations are simple: The country wants to improve its environmental footprint and air quality, develop a leadership position in global markets, and increase national security and energy independence (you don’t have to import renewable energy).

These plans are also longer-term than many headlines would lead investors to believe. For instance, China isn’t using renewable energy to immediately replace coal-fired power plants, which supplied 72% of the country’s electricity in 2015 — more than double the share of coal in the electric grids of the United States.

That’s because renewable energy is one of the least efficient ways to go about replacing coal consumption in a short period of time. Instead, China is hurriedly building natural gas and liquefied natural gas (LNG) import infrastructure to replace coal in the near-term. In fact, the country is single-handedly shifting global markets, having imported 58% more LNG in the first four months of 2018 than in the year-ago period, with American supply playing a central role. Energy investors shouldn’t overlook the opportunities this creates.

but I don’t think he quite appreciates what’s really going on. China wants to dominate and control the market for products used in producing solar and wind power. They’re happy to accept the subsidies that Western governments are paying to implement those technologies.

For their own use they’re deploying natural gas. There’s a clear economic case. Will they go to “renewables” in the future? It could happen. When there’s a clear economic case for it.

1 comment

Imaginary History

There is a fun article at the Times Literary Supplement on a biography of Vercingetorix:

Don’t despair! Are you aiming to write a “serious” 300-page biography of someone about whom we basically know nothing – Wat Tyler, Nefertiti, or Pontius Pilate? Easy: it is all just a matter of careful manipulation of narrative past tenses. When you have genuine evidence for something, you can use the passé simple (and a footnote): “After his defeat at Alesia, Vercingetorix threw his arms down at Caesar’s feet (Caesar, Gallic Wars VII 89.4)”. When the evidence gives out, but there is space for legitimate speculation and analogy, you can use the passé spéculatif: “Caesar may well have required Vercingetorix to pass beneath a yoke of spears, the standard Roman military ritual for humiliating defeated enemies”.

If anything the author of the article overstates the historicity of Vercingetorix. The only primary sources testifying to his existence are Gallic Wars and a few coins. It is even possible that the author of Gallic Wars only knowledge of Vercingetorix was through the coins. The earliest extant manuscript of Caesar’s Gallic Wars is from the 9th century, nearly a millennium after the events it allegedly describes. My own opinion is that the text we have was what it has always been, a text for schoolboys learning to read Latin.

But it doesn’t stop there. The evidence that Jesus of Nazareth lived is an order of magnitude better than the evidence that Julius Caesar lived. Choosing to believe in Julius Caesar but disbelieve in Jesus of Nazareth is a religious choice not an historical one. So much more so for believing in Vercingetorix. It is part of the civil religion of the French. Any biography would necessarily be in an eccentric style.

10 comments

Tech Consolidation

EconMatters has distinctly bearish remarks about Microsoft’s acquisition of GitHub:

The reason Microsoft doesn`t mind overpaying for GitHub by 4.5 Billion is because they know their stock is way overvalued by historical standards in a non bubble market. In fact they remember the last time their company’s stock was this overvalued back in 2000, and what happened after the tech bubble popped in 2000? Artificially high paper stock price valuations plunged and were as worthless as toilet paper in many cases. Microsoft realizes their stock isn`t worth $102 a share, it will be less than $50 in the next three years conservatively. So this is basically a free roll for them, paper stock values means you haven’t lost anything by buying a company with future worthless stock at these valuation levels.

Hint for GitHub be smart like Mark Cuban in the last tech bubble, cash out your Microsoft shares ASAP because these shares will be losing value every month that goes by. Mark Cuban was smart enough to cash out those worthless Yahoo Shares they paid for his bogus company, and now he still has money, you better do the same if you want to keep the winnings of your recent lottery luckbox.

In fact, every technology company should buy anyone they want to acquire right now because all their shares are going to be dropping precipitously over the next three years as the technology 2.0 market crash begins. Artificially high paper gains never last and high P/E Ratios for declining revenue growth companies like Microsoft, Apple, Intel, Cisco and the like all revert back to historical norms. Your stock prices are all artificially high due to the Central Bank Liquidity Punchbowl Bonanza so overpaying for companies with future worthless stock is a good idea, and essentially a freeroll.

I don’t honestly know whether there’s a tech bubble. It may be that stocks like Microsoft are seen as safe havens and will attract money if for no other reason that there’s no better alternative around. That will be easy enough to test. Just watch the stock prices of “declining revenue growth” tech companies.

As to the fate of GitHub itself, I know of no case in which a tech company acquired a competitor and both products survived. In general the purchaser’s product survives, possibly incorporating some worthwhile technology from the acquired company sometimes not. There are good political reasons for that; the acquiring company’s own products already have an internal constituency.

Microsoft already has a product competitive with GitHub—it’s part of Team. So expect GitHub to bite the dust and its paying users brought into the Team fold. Microsoft is an old hand at this game. They’ve been doing it for 30 years.

1 comment

Globalization and Mass Immigration Add Up to Racism

I urge you to read Noah Smith’s discussion of the television series Atlanta at Bloomberg View. In it he touches on points I’ve been making for some time. Here’s his peroration:

In other words, “Atlanta” is a microcosm of all the problems of poverty and instability in America that writers like Barbara Ehrenreich, economists like Sendhil Mullainathan, and sociologists like Sudhir Venkatesh have been sounding the alarm about for many years. A toxic combination of deindustrialization, poor urban planning, racial segregation, discrimination and the insanity of the war on drugs wastes the talent and potential of much of the country’s working class — especially the black working class. Even as cities like Atlanta grab headlines for their wealth, exciting nightlife and ample job opportunities for educated workers, millions of Americans are being left behind. They’re trying hard, and doing the best they can, but the system is failing them.

Take a look at the graph illustrating the decline of manufacturing jobs in the U. S. There’s an obvious relationship between that collapse and China’s admission to the WTO. If you combine that toxic kind of globalization with considerably more competition for jobs at the low end of the income ladder, the burden falls very heavily on black folk. That’s not going to be made up by increased education.

3 comments

Fatigue

It’s official! According to Pew Research three-quarters of Republicans and three-fifths of Democrats are just plain fatigued by the amount of news they’re being bombarded with:

If you feel like there is too much news and you can’t keep up, you are not alone. A sizable portion of Americans are feeling overwhelmed by the amount of news there is, though the sentiment is more common on the right side of the political spectrum, according to a Pew Research Center survey conducted from Feb. 22 to March 4, 2018.

Almost seven-in-ten Americans (68%) feel worn out by the amount of news there is these days, compared with only three-in-ten who say they like the amount of news they get. The portion expressing feelings of information overload is in line with how Americans felt during the 2016 presidential election, when a majority expressed feelings of exhaustion from election coverage.

A majority of Americans in every age, gender, racial or ethnic group are just plain tired of the news. I guess I’m not alone. We need fewer, better journalists.

4 comments