Our Biggest Policy Error

If you’re looking for the history of the greatest policy error that the U. S. has made in the last 40 years (it’s a crowded field), check out Reihan Salam’s article at Atlantic.

3 comments

We’re #1!

According to 24/7 Wall Street of the American cities losing population Chicago has lost more residents than any other—nearly 300,000 since 2010:

The 50 cities where the most people are moving to can primarily be found in the Sun Belt, particularly in states like Florida, Texas, and Arizona. Among the fastest growing cities are places like Dallas, Miami, and Phoenix.

William Frey, demographer at the Brookings Institution, a nonprofit public policy research group, explained that these cities adding several hundred thousand new residents due to migration are part of the long-term trend of movement from the Northeast and the Midwest to warmer climates, a trend that has increased in recent years.

but that’s an oversimplification. Los Angeles is #2 on the list of “cities Americans are abandoning”. Unless you redefine “Sun Belt” and “warmer” pretty radically, those just aren’t that predictive. A number of California cities—Bakersfield, Fresno, Visalia—are among those Americans are leaving and there’s an obvious profile. The white working class is leaving Los Angeles and Bakersfield for Dallas, Miami, and Phoenix.

I don’t think that people are just looking for warm weather. I think they’re looking for a place they can afford to live. I think they’re looking for hope.

Update

After reviewing the entire lists of cities that Americans are leaving and those they’re “flocking to”, it’s obvious that tax policy has an enormous amount to do with it. Taxes, jobs, affordability, weather, probably in that order.

1 comment

GDP and Truck Tonnage

Ed Yardeni’s analysis of U. S. GDP growth as measured by the “coincident indicator” of truck tonnage is pretty interesting:

Could it be that all the chatter about the shortage of truck drivers is misguided? How else to explain the record high in truck tonnage? There is a good correlation between the ATA index and payroll employment of truckers. Friday’s employment report showed that payroll employment in the truck transportation industry has been stuck just below 1.5 million for the past six months, but it is at a record high and up 24,200 y/y.

Starting at the end of last year, a new federal rule requires all interstate truck drivers to install an electronic logging device, or ELD, that logs their hours. Truck drivers are required to reduce their overtime hours because fatigued ones have been involved in major crashes on the highways. That could exacerbate the perceived shortage of workers. The y/y growth rate in the average hourly earnings of truckers is very volatile, but April’s increase of 2.5% was relatively subdued and belies the shortage-of-truckers chatter.

Then what is the explanation for the “chatter”? Is it coming from employers or truckers or both? If it’s employers they may be envisioning future shortages rather than present ones which would seem consistent with high level of present tonnage.

3 comments

What Should the Consequences Be?

Consider this article at the Washington Free Beacon which quotes an Iranian official as claiming that Iran facilitated the movements of the 9/11 terrorists:

Mohammad-Javad Larijani, an international affairs assistant in the Iran’s judiciary, disclosed in Farsi-language remarks broadcast on Iran’s state-controlled television that Iranian intelligence officials secretly helped provide the al Qaeda attackers with passage and gave them refuge in the Islamic Republic, according to an English translation published by Al Arabiya.

“Our government agreed not to stamp the passports of some of them because they were on transit flights for two hours, and they were resuming their flights without having their passports stamped. However their movements were under the complete supervision of the Iranian intelligence,” Larijani was quoted as saying.

The remarks represent the first time senior Iranian officials have publicly admitted to aiding al Qaeda and playing a direct role in facilitating the 9/11 attacks.

What should the consequences be?

  1. It’s impossible. Shi’ites will never cooperate with Sunnis.
  2. It’s not news. The U. S. government has maintained that all along. There have been consequences in the form of sanctions, etc. At least up until the “Iran deal”.
  3. This is part of a Gulf Arab-inspired propaganda and disinformation campaign.
  4. 17 years is a long time. We shouldn’t do anything.
  5. We should immediately invade Iran.
  6. Bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb Iran.
  7. There should be consequences but not necessarily anything as direct or open as invasion or bombing.
3 comments

Two Movies

The Dilbert cartoonist Scott Adams, a Trump supporter, has said that Republicans and Democrats are playing two different movies in their minds. This op-ed by Republican and Trump supporter Christopher Buskirk in the New York Times is one of the clearest examples of that I’ve ever seen. Many Democrats will disagree vehemently with the positive interpretations he puts on Mr. Trump’s remarks and, indeed, see them as big negatives. Where he sees inclusion, they will hear racist dogwhistles. Where he sees a path forward, they will hear reaction.

So, when, for example Mr. Buskirk writes:

Republicans have long criticized Democrats for dividing the country into competing grievance groups. Some now realize that the Republican analogue has been to divide the country into radically autonomous individuals based on a cartoonish misreading of libertarianism that replaces the free markets and free minds of Friedrich Hayek with the greed and hubris of Gordon Gekko. But that is changing quickly. There is a renewed emphasis on addressing America and Americans as a community characterized by fraternal bonds and mutual responsibility — what Lincoln called the “mystic chords of memory.”

If anything he’s tempering the position of the Ayn Rand objectivist wing of the Republican Party typified by Ron and Rand Paul. I think that what many Democrats will be playing in their minds is:

But Trump is a crook and a con man.

Or this:

The three-legged stool of the new Republican majority is a pro-citizen immigration policy, a pro-worker economic policy and a foreign policy that rejects moral imperialism and its concomitant foreign wars. John Adams described just such a foreign policy when he wrote that America is “the well-wisher to the freedom and independence of all” but “the champion and vindicator only of her own.”

but I think that many Democrats will hear:

How is an immigration policy that separates parents and children at the border “pro-citizen”. Isn’t that just racism gussied up in patriotic diction? How is an economic policy that gives tax cuts to the rich “pro-worker”? Not only is Trump continuing all of the foreign wars of his predecessors, he’s adding and/or threatening new ones of his own.

BTW, that was John Quincy Adams not John Adams.

When Trump says “we”, “us”, or “ours”, they don’t think he means “all Americans”. They think he means white, Christian Americans, Trump supporters.

Two movies.

12 comments

Defense Ain’t the Only Thing

You pretty frequently encounter the observation that the U. S. spends more on its military than any other country in the world. What you don’t see mentioned very often is that the United States spends more on health care than all other countries combined and that it spend more on housing than all other countries combined.

Indeed, in the United States government at all levels spends more on health care than the United Kingdom, France, and Germany combined.

2 comments

The Triumph of Progressivism

You might be tempted to think from reading Chuck DeVore’s column at Forbes that the only thing necessary for the ultimate triumph of conservatism is the triumph of progressivism:

Government programs and regulations and welfare policies that act to discourage employment and job creation, family cohesion, and voluntary associations and religious charity, all play a role in the damaged fabric of American life.

Progressive political “solutions” to these longstanding frailties of human nature are usually the creation of complex organizations replete with esoteric formulae and dense pages of regulations. They have the advantage of being at the same time indecipherable, unaccountable, and conferring the appearance of having “done something” on their proponents.

Political conservatives, in contrast, simply ask to dismantle failed programs, trusting in people to do better by their family and neighbors than a bureaucrat with a rule book.

His column start with a litany of the horrors wrought by Seattle’s City Council.

I think he’s ignoring some things. First, in a “natural economy driven by market forces” Boeing, Microsoft, and Amazon wouldn’t exist. Seattle would be a much smaller city and its primary industries would be related to geography, e.g. fishing, shipbuilding. Smaller population—reduced housing problem.

Second, there are some ideas that however badly they fail every time they’re tried will always find adherents. Finally, the urge to power will always result in people trying to control other people. That’s not a left-right thing. That’s a human nature thing.

In my view all of the pat solutions to problems are wrong. There is no magic bullet, no alternative to prudent stewardship and maintaining prudent stewardship is very difficult, like liberty it’s price is eternal vigilance.

4 comments

Bad Leaders

At last. I’ve finally found someone who sees our political situation more as I do. At RealClearPolicy Philip A. Wallach and James Wallner are skeptical about the narrative of Congressional dysfunction due to polarization:

It turns out that the conventional wisdom on polarization does not explain legislative behavior particularly well. That may be because polarization, properly understood, characterizes the appearance of politics, not its reality.

Today’s divergence between Democrats and Republicans in Congress does not indicate that members share no common beliefs or values. Instead, it reveals a political environment in which legislative leaders are extremely skilled at agenda-control and issue-suppression — at avoiding certain kinds of votes, for instance.

All of the measures of extreme polarization in the Congress are actually measures of the effectiveness of Congressional leaders in controlling the agenda.

More specifically, leaders work hard to keep divisive issues off the agenda for as long as possible. When that is no longer an option, they resort to crafting must-pass legislation behind closed doors with little or no input from the rank-and-file. Leaders then wait until the last minute to unveil the legislation in order to confront members with a fait accompli, thus increasing the chances that the bill will pass while minimizing the exposure of partisan divisions.

What to do about it? The implications of that hypothesis are that we need better leaders with different motivations and that implies a different process for selecting Congressional leaders. Or, alternatively, we could just content ourselves with the same lousy results we’ve been getting.

The practical problem is that Congress won’t change that of its own accord—present rules preclude it. And the present Congressional leadership won’t change it because they’re the primary beneficiaries of Things As They Are.

Update

No Labels has some related suggestions—letting all of the members of the House vote on who should be Speaker and getting rid of the “motion to vacate”.

5 comments

When Medicare Is Insolvent

Medicare began dipping into its “trust fund” this year. The Medicare system’s actuaries have warned that the system will be insolvent, i.e. the funds paid in the form of Medicare taxes over the years that have exceed the amount spent in Medicare reimbursements, will be completely depleted in 2026 somewhat earlier than had been anticipated. What happens then?

One thing that could happen is that payments to providers could be delayed, even greatly delayed. Presently for every “clean” claim filed an 835 remittance response is received in about two weeks and the 835 and actual payment are, at least in theory, concurrent. Increased delays could be disastrous for providers since they depend on them so highly.

I think it’s pretty likely that the federal government will continue to pay claims even after the notional trust fund is depleted. SSRI is more problematic. If Medicare claims continue to be paid, the federal government’s issuance of credit to itself will skyrocket. We don’t really know what the implications of that might be. Nothing might happen or it might be catastrophic.

2 comments

The Process

Eugene Robinson’s Washington Post column today is a very good one. In it he explains why a summit between President Trump and Kim Jong Un is a good idea. I interpret this as his contribution to the complaint that’s been emerging lately that Democrats are overly negative about this meeting:

President Trump’s on-again, off-again summit with Kim has been hastily slapped together. The necessary groundwork has not been laid. The Trump administration’s stated goal — full denuclearization by North Korea — is unrealistic. Kim is said to know the intricacies of his country’s nuclear program, including its technical aspects, in great detail; Trump, by contrast, said Thursday that “I don’t think I have to prepare very much. It’s about the attitude.” Critics say the meeting itself is an enormous concession to the North Koreans, for which the United States has received exactly zero in return.

Nonetheless, I have been and remain strongly in favor of the summit. I believe there is reason to believe it will do no harm — and reason to hope it might do some good.

Put it into context. The rhetoric coming from both sides had been heating up rapidly, something that has been mitigated somewhat just by the announcement of a meeting.

North Korea, like most politically-charge situations, presents a “wicked problem”. Wicked problems have no solutions in the sense that mathematical or engineering problems do. The most that can be accomplished is that a process for addressing them can be begun. That’s what I think the proposed meeting may be.

There is one particular in which I’d quibble with Mr. Robinson. There is a way in which the meeting could do actual harm and that’s if for President Trump the meeting is a way of proving that he had exerted every effort to avoid war. Let’s think good thoughts and hope that at the very least the meeting dials down the rhetoric a bit.

1 comment