I recommend you read Caroline D’Agati’s remarks about suicide at The Federalist. Here’s a sample:
In one sense, I agree with Kate and Tony: they were right to be broken-hearted. This is a broken world that neither they nor you nor I will ever be able to set right. Gunmen will continue to kill. Terrorists will bomb. Disease and poverty will ravage. And in 150 years, mourners, victims, saviors, and perpetrators alike will be equally forgotten. The abyss of time makes no distinctions between the hero and the villain.
As Kate, Anthony, Robin, and so many other entertainers show, even giving joy to others, in the end, is not enough. So in the end, why bother? How can we not be defeated when we set our eyes on the brokenness of this world?
You may disagree with her answer but her statement of the question deserves consideration.
I think our society has gone seriously astray. Somehow, somewhere the belief that life can be lived without pain has crept in. It explains both a rising suicide rate and the increasing use of narcotics. In that belief we are abetted by advertisers, pharmaceutical manufacturers, and caregivers, variously well-intentioned. Life without pain is not possible; it isn’t even desirable.
When you couple that belief with the loss of a belief in an afterlife, suicide is not only not a sign of mental illness. It is a sign of sanity. It is the ultimate numbness.
Scholars of happiness have learned something. Monotonous, repetitive, even unpleasant activities can become sources of joy when approached as games. The best and happiest workers approach their work as a game whether making the most money, building the most successful companies, creating the straightest rows, stacking the most boxes, or find the most flaws in the widgets you’re inspecting. It is the game that creates joy, not something intrinsic to the activity but part of your internal landscape.
That’s akin to what the samurai believed. They believed that all of life is a game. Suicide is forfeiting.
There’s a great line in the movie A Matter of Life and Death. Peter, an English pilot over the Channel, is plunging to his death, his aircraft completely disabled by enemy fire. To the radio operator whom he’s never met he proclaims “I love you, June. You’re life and I’m leaving you.”
Life can either be approached with love and joy or not, as you choose. When you commit suicide, you forfeit the game, leaving the rest of us players behind.