It’s Not Working

The RealClearPolitics average of polls suggests that the barrage of criticism being leveled at Trump is not having the presumably desired effect. His approval rating is 43.7% but, significantly, his disapproval rating is 51.1%. That the lowest since April 2017 and the difference between the two is just 7.4 points, the smallest gap since March of 2017.

Remember my remark about the situation being like the old wisecrack about mud-wrestling with a pig? You get dirty and the pig likes it. It fits.

8 comments

Sane and Moral? Or Wishful Thinking?

I want to focus on two passages in Carl Cannon’s post at RealClearPolitics on reforming our immigration system. The first is this:

First, regarding the 11 million undocumented people already here without legal papers: It is clearly in the national interest, no matter what Trump said on the 2016 campaign trail, to incorporate these people into American life, which is what was envisioned by the 2013 Senate legislation. Perhaps this doesn’t include full citizenship rights, but it would mean they’d no longer have to live in fear and could plan for a future in their chosen country.

Is the United States their “chosen country” or are jobs in the United States their chosen jobs? I don’t think we have any means for distinguishing between the two or making that evaluation. The immigration reform of 1986 does give us a hint: only a minority of the 3.2 million eligible for U. S. citizenship under that law actually availed themselves of the opportunity.

Here’s the second passage:

As for the refugees: the government simply must adhere to U.S. law and international norms. If this means constructing huge intake centers along the border and staffing it with a massive force of trained customs agents and administrative law judges — and suitable facilities for kids — so be it. We might even want to build some of these facilities in Mexico, along that country’s southern border, which is where most of these people are coming from.

This is another example of the “roomful of money” hypothesis. We do not have a roomful of money from which we can draw at will for this or for that. Congress must appropriate money for specific purposes.

And that’s the root of the problem. Both sides of the aisle in Congress like present law just fine. They both think they’re winning and they both may be right. It’s the rest of us who are losing.

Additionally, it takes time. “Trained customs agents and administrative law judges” don’t spring forth fully grown like Athena from the brow of Zeus. It would take at least a year to implement that even if Congress had the will to do so which it doesn’t and there’s a problem now.

Also, remember that 99% figure quoted for asylum-seekers showing up at their hearings? As it turns out that that was a pilot program of just 700 families with close monitoring by individualized caseworkers. How confident can we be that generalizing that to a program several orders of magnitude larger would yield the same results?

What’s happening right now is either a deliberate Aliskyite strategy of overwhelming the system or has been impelled by some factors other than increased violence and economic distress in Central America (since that has not happened and there’s been a very large increase in the number of families from Central America presenting themselves at the border) but whatever the case it’s working. The system is overwhelmed and that calls for extraordinary measures. The extraordinary measures of family detention are better than separating families but they’re still inadequate.

3 comments

Better Science Fiction Movies

You may have noticed that I very rarely have much good to say about recent genre movies. There’s a reason for that. I don’t think they’re very good. Oh, the special effects have gotten much better over the years but otherwise most of today’s science fiction movies in particular just aren’t very good movies. The Transformers franchise and the Pacific Rim movies are basically just 1950s Godzilla movies with better special effects and that was awful. It belong under the category “Good Because It’s So Bad”.

But what I’m writing about in this post are how good movies are as science fiction rather than how good they are as movies that just happen to be science fiction and I’m pleased to say that in recent years I’ve seen a couple of movies that are actually pretty good science fiction.

So, for example, although it probably should be classed as science fantasy rather than science fiction I thought that Snowpiercer was pretty good. Arrival, too, was pretty good.

But there are two pictures I’ve seen recently that are actually darned good science fiction: Interstellar and The Martian. I actually think that The Martian could be the best science fiction movie ever made.

I realize that it’s blasphemy but the less said of the Star Wars pictures, the better. 1-3 are just awful and the original Star Wars is just an old Buster Crabbe Flash Gordon serial with better special effects, deliberately so. It sort of made me long for Charles B. Middleton.

13 comments

Credit, Blame, and Some of Both (Updated)

Every president wants to take credit for anything good that happens during his presidency and blame anything bad that happens during his presidency on his predecessors. The truth is somewhat more complicated.

Consider the Vietnam War, for example. During the 1970s protesters called it “Nixon’s War” but Truman was the first president to send troops to what was then called “French Indochina” which Eisenhower expanded to 1,000 and Kennedy expanded to 16,000. Within a few years of becoming president Johnson had increased that number to 150,000 and by the end of his presidency he had expanded that to more than 500,000.

Was this escalation a knock-on effect of Truman’s original military involvement—in other words inevitable once the original commitment had been made, did it become Nixon’s war when he became president, or should the 58,000 dead Americans be blamed on Johnson? Your answer may be a political one than a conclusion based on the facts.

Or consider the U. S. relationship with China. Nixon began the process of opening up a relationship with China which, ultimately, led to a collapse in U. S. manufacturing employment in the early Aughts. Was that an inevitable consequence of the start of more normal relations in 1971, was it George W. Bush’s fault because it happened on his watch, or were Bill Clinton’s overly optimistic granting of Most Favored Nation trading status and sponsorship of Chinese membership in the World Trade Organization have serious, deleterious knock-on effects for us?

I’ve been struggling with a way of depicting this but let’s consider some important issues of the last dozen years in the context of the last four presidents in tabular form.

Issue Clinton Bush Obama Trump  
Dot com boom Clinton had very little to do with it.       Almost entirely a consequence of capital investments in the 1980s and 1990s.
Afghanistan War   Would any president have occupied Afghanistan? Or was that a product of Bush’s insouciant optimism? The casualties resulting from his surge are on Obama’s head.   Any president sitting on 9/11/2001 would have engaged in military action against Afghanistan.
Iraq War   I’m not certain this was inevitable. This is on Bush. The rise of DAESH is mostly on Obama.    
Great Recession The repeal of Glass-Steagal was a contributing factor. Lax enforcement was a factor.     Alan Greenspan kept interest rates too low for too long.
Recovery   Just about everything that resulted in the end of the recession had been done by the end of Bush’s term. The ARRA may have contributed to preventing a “double dip”. Inaction by the Obama Administration contributed to the shallowness of the recovery. Trump policies may have contributed to an improved recovery. I’m not convinced yet that the improving pace of recovery is anything other than a continuation of trend.
Chaos in North Africa     Obama’s intervention in Libya has resulted in a lot of chaos in North Africa and is a major cause of mass migration from North Africa into Europe.    
High health care costs Clinton’s bungling of health care reform didn’t help.       High health care costs were a foreseeable consequence of the health care reforms of 1965. These were abetted by more than a decade of Congressional inattention and present Congressional cowardice.
Child migrants     Obama Administration policies resulted in an enormous increase of child migrants. Trump’s “zero tolerance” policy has certainly been terrible optics, particularly for those who already oppose Trump but, perhaps, not as much for those who support him. It’s cruel but both Bush and Obama had separated children and parents as well, just on a different scale.
Right about now it looks like an “own goal”.
 
North Korea Clinton negotiated the “Agreed Framework” with North Korea, failed to implement it, didn’t detect that North Korea had violated the agreement and obtained intel from Pakistan, and failed to respond. More than any other single president he’s responsible for letting North Korea get nuclear weapons. Bush failed to revive the Agreed Framework and took no action to prevent North Korea from obtaining nuclear weapons. North Korea detonated its first nuclear weapon on his watch. More inaction Trump has done more to engage with North Korea than any of his predecessors since Clinton. What will come of it remains to be seen. If North Korea attacks us or our allies with a nuclear weapon, it will constitute the gravest foreign policy failure in U. S. history and Clinton should but will not get the blame
Russia Clinton interfered with Russian elections and more than any president since went out of his way to antagonize Russia. A wave of NATO expansion that actually made us less secure was instigated by Clinton. And I haven’t even mentioned bombing Serbia. Bush continued the destabilizing expansion of NATO. Obama’s attack of Libya, in violation of the UNSC resolution from which both Russia and China abstained, allowing it to go forward, further poisoned relations between the U. S. and Russia. And then there’s Ukraine. If Trump “colluded” with Russia in the 2016 election, he’s a villain. If not, he’s a victim. The deterioration of U. S.-Russian relations is a bipartisan catastrophe.
Syria   Bush’s invasion of Iraq was a major factor in destabilizing Syria if, for no other reason, because of significant increase in its Sunni Arab population, a result of Iraqis fleeing the carnage in Iraq. Obama’s “red line”, the inexcusable aiding of Al Qaeda in Syria, and illegal war in Syria are among his errors in Syria. Trump appears to be continuing and expanding his predecessor’s errors in Syria.  

Not everything a president takes credit for is a result of his actions; not everything he’s blamed for is his fault. It is rare that something good that happens on a president’s watch can be completely attributed to his actions.

Every president deals with the consequences of his predecessors’ actions and failures to act as well as the new challenges that arise during his presidency. How he deals with these things is significant.

Update

I’ve added some additional issue facing us to my table.

8 comments

One-Two Punch

As I presume you’re aware the Supreme Court has rendered a decision overruling Quill Corp. v. North Dakota (1992) and National Bellas Hess Inc. v. Illinois Department of Revenue (1967), the two prior decisions that created the complex “sales nexus” rules that govern when a company engaging in interstate sales must collect sales tax. Analysis is here at SCOTUSBlog. States, hungry for revenue from decades of incompetence, mismanagement, and, in some cases, just plain corruption, will, no doubt, laud the decision.

IMO Justice Kennedy, writing the majority opinion in the 5-4 decision, was attempting to remedy his errors from 1992. That decision, along with the law exempting Internet sales from state sales tax, wrought havoc with small brick-and-mortar retailers, giving a substantial competitive advantage to mail order and online retailers. How substantial? When your margin is 2%, 10% sales tax is a big deal.

While that may have been his intention, the effect of this latest decision is to do to small online retailers what the previous one did to brick-and-mortar retailers.

The only actual remedy would have been to break up Amazon, Dell, and the other companies that have grown at the expense of small retailers. But that wasn’t the case before them.

Much is being made of the small effect this decision will have on Amazon, particularly on the part of people who don’t understand how Amazon makes its money. I believe it will have more effect than they might imagine. Amazon doesn’t make most of its money from its own retail sales. It makes considerably more by providing services to “affiliates”, many of which are the very small online retailers likely to be hurt by the decision. It could kill Shopify outright. Shopify is already in the process of becoming a captive of Amazon and Wayfair should accelerate that process. Amazon might well acquire the rest of Shopify.

When the dust has settled I think you’ll see even more consolidation in retail, a process that has been going on for some time.

8 comments

House Arrest?

At Bloomberg Tyler Cowen writes about the separation of children and parents:

It’s horrible to forcibly separate lawbreaking parents from their young children, but we do that to American citizens, too. According to one 2010 study, more than 1.1 million men and 120,000 women in U.S. jails and prisons have children under the age of 17. These separations can be traumatic, and they help perpetuate generational cycles of low achievement and criminal behavior.

These problems are especially pressing for female prisoners and their children. From 1991 to 2007, the number of children with a mother in prison more than doubled, rising 131 percent. About two-thirds of the women in state prisons are there for nonviolent offenses. Sixty percent of those women have children under the age of 18, and in one survey one-quarter of the prisoners’ children were under the age of 4. Forty-one percent of the women in state prison had more than one child.

I have a simple proposal: Let’s take one-tenth of those women and move them from prison to house arrest, combined with electronic monitoring. That would allow for proximity to their children. If the U.S. isn’t plagued by a subsequent wave of violent crime — and I don’t think it will be — let us try the same for yet another tenth. Let’s keep on doing this until it’s obviously not working. In some of these cases the court might rule that the mother — especially if she is prone to child abuse or substance abuse — will not have full custody rights to her children. Many other children, though, will benefit, and even visitation rights can help a child.

That’s an interesting proposal and one which I wish would receive more consideration.

I also think we need a greater reconsideration of our body of law. Far too many people want a civil code system in which everything is either explicitly legal or illegal. Bringing all human conduct within the law is a policy that primarily serves lawyers.

2 comments

About Those Non-Shows

I’ve seen a lot of statistics thrown around about the number of people who fail to show up at deportation hearings. I’ve already cited a New York Times article finding that the number of no-shows was between 20 and 40%. I’ve found articles from the Washington Post and Miami Herald reporting the same things. I’ll cite the Executive Summary of a study from the Center for Immigration Studies in full:

U.S. immigration enforcement and adjudication are failing. American immigration courts have the highest failure to appear rates of any courts in the country. Over the last 20 years, 37 percent of all aliens free pending trial failed to appear for their hearings. From the 2,498,375 foreign nationals outside detention during their court proceedings, 1,219,959 were ordered removed, 75 percent of them (918,098) for failing to appear. Only 25 percent of this group — some 301,861 people — actually litigated their claims. Trial courts are three times more likely to issue removal orders for failure to appear than removal orders based upon the merits of fully litigated claims. Nearly 46,000 people each year disappeared from court. Deportation orders for failure to appear are the largest group of orders issued by immigration courts outside detention facilities. From 1996 through 2015, removal orders for failure to appear numbered 918,098. Among those who absconded from court were 3,095 aliens from the 36 countries that promote terrorism. A disproportionate number — 338 altogether — came from those countries the U.S. State Department labels state sponsors of terrorism: Iran, Sudan, and Syria. As populations from countries that promote terrorism have increased since 9/11 — from naturalized citizens, immigrants,3 and refugees — plots and acts of Islam-inspired terrorism have also increased, more than twice as many under Barack Obama than under George W. Bush. Unexecuted removal orders now number 953,506 — a 58 percent increase since 2002. An average of 25,107 unexecuted orders of removal were added each year through 2015.

Practical reforms that serve America’s age-old immigration world view — to attract the talented, redeem the persecuted, and remove the offender — are needed now, perhaps more than ever in our history, as a remedy for policies that have diminished the deserving, emboldened the suspect, and rewarded the violator.

That’s a far cry from the 90% quoted by AG Jeff Sessions but it’s not negligible, either.

Some of the confusion arises from there being multiple kinds of hearings and various kinds of cases. So, for example, there are both deportation hearings and asylum hearings, two different things. And then there are the millions of unapprehended illegal immigrants who’ve never had any sort of hearing.

But I think that the 37% figure is a pretty reasonable guess for the percentage of no-noshows.

12 comments

Reversal

President Trump has signed an executive order ending the separation of migrant parents and children at the U. S. border. The alternative President Trump has chosen, maintaining his “zero tolerance” policy at the border but keeping families together, is not a legal one.

Based on present law as interpreted by the courts, there were three legal alternatives. He could release the families on their own recognizance pending their deportation or asylum hearings, essentially a continuation of the policy of the Obama Administration, a political non-starter for Trump and his supporters. He could maintain present policy and separate families and children, a cruel, inhumane policy, opposition to which appears to be rising. Or Congress could act to allow families and their children to be detained together.

I am not as comfortable with presidents who follow their consciences or move the way in which the political winds are blowing without regard for the law as many people seem to be. I also doubt that this reversal will mollify the president’s political opponents.

And the policy of “zero tolerance” at the border will produce cruelty and chaos for years to come.

12 comments

A Corporate Debt Bubble?

At Project Syndicate management consultant Susan Lund warns about a looming risk. Right along with the rise in government debt in the wake of the financial crisis of a decade ago, corporate debt has risen, too:

Over the past decade, the corporate-bond market has surged as banks have restructured and repaired their balance sheets. Since 2007, the value of corporate bonds outstanding from nonfinancial companies has nearly tripled – to $11.7 trillion – and their share of global GDP has doubled. Traditionally, the corporate-bond market was centered in the United States, but now companies from around the world have joined in.

and

Still, the biggest risks appear to be in emerging markets such as China, India, and Brazil. Already, 25-30% of bonds in these markets have been issued by companies at a higher risk of default (defined as having an interest-coverage ratio of less than 1.5). And that share could increase to 40% if interest rates were to rise by 200 basis points.

Within these emerging markets, some sectors are more vulnerable than others. In China, one-third of bonds issued by industrial companies, and 28% of those issued by real-estate companies, are at a higher risk of default. Corporate defaults are already creeping upward in China; and in Brazil, one-quarter of all corporate bonds at a higher risk of default are in the industrial sector.

It used to be said that when the U. S. economy sneezed, the rest of the world got a cold. As China, Brazil, and India have grown, the risk presented by excessive debt has spread. Not only is it not just in the United States, it may not be mainly in the United States.

2 comments

Children in Illinois DCFS

While the issue of children being separated from their parents is so much in the news and while migrant children being separated from their parents is terrible, it’s not the only terrible thing. Consider the graph above, gleaned from this Sun-Times article.

In Illinois 16,000 children have been separated from their parents, unrelated to immigration. Some of them are in wonderful situations; many are not. It’s a truly awful situation to which I don’t think there’s an easy solution.

Would they be better off with their neglectful, incompetent, or even abusive parents? Or in foster homes?

2 comments