We Need Better Congressmen

At The Hill Tom Daschle and Trent Lott, two names all but certain to roil partisans of either party, hold forth on their opinions for getting the Congress off their duffs:

First, Congress should codify its recent tendency toward approving biennial budgets, including two-year budget resolutions and appropriations bills. The traditional annual budgeting process leaves the bulk of members out of decision-making, is disconnected from the authorization process, and produces short-sighted policymaking. Additionally, moving to a two-year cycle would provide more time for the Appropriations committees to conduct vital oversight of programs within their jurisdictions.

Second, the Senate filibuster has been the subject of much debate and maligning over the years. We support maintaining the current 60-vote threshold for legislation to preserve the Senate’s unique, invaluable role as the body that protects the rights of the minority. At the same time, CPR recommended eliminating the ability to filibuster motions to move to consideration of legislation. The joint committee should apply this principle to the appropriations process.

Third, in exchange for limiting debate on the motion to proceed, we urged that each side of the aisle be accorded a minimum number of amendments to each piece of legislation. Both the House and Senate should adopt this provision for appropriations.

Their first suggestion is probably unconstitutional and would definitely require the repeal of the Budget and Accounting Act of 1921. Something depends on whether you can split the budget from appropriations. Appropriations are constitutionally required to be annual. I believe that’s why we have the byzantine fund accounting for programs like Social Security and Medicare.

The use and misuse of the filibuster is a sign of the grave difference of opinion in the Congress. It’s not the cause of it.

And according a minimum number of amendments to each party is a) fantasizing and b) would make our laws even more opaque than they already are.

Try again. Keep in mind that elections are not IQ tests nor are they indicators of an understanding of present law.

While we’re fantasizing my suggestions would be to select the Speaker of the House by lot from the membership of the House of both parties, limit the power of the Congressional leadership, or, preferably, both.

5 comments

Why Do We Have Courts?

I want to ask a serious question. Why do we have courts? There is clearly a difference of opinion. I think that we have courts to interpret the law without regard to personages. It is quite clear that many Americans think that we have courts to do justice.

So, why do we have courts? And what should the relative importance of interpreting the law as opposed to doing justice be?

1 comment

Trump v. Hawaii

The Supreme Court has upheld President Trump’s so-called “Muslim ban” on a 5-4 vote. From Amy Howe at SCOTUSBlog:

Under the Supreme Court’s cases, Roberts suggested, the justices would normally only look at whether the order is neutral on its face – that is, whether it applies to all religions equally. But even if they look beyond the text of the September 2017 order at other evidence of the president’s intent, Roberts continued, the order still survives because it is directly based on a legitimate purpose: “preventing entry of nationals who cannot be adequately vetted and inducing other nations to improve their practices.” Roberts acknowledged that five of the seven countries currently covered by the order have Muslim-majority populations. But “that fact alone,” he suggested, “does not support an inference of religious hostility, given that the policy covers just 8% of the world’s Muslim population and is limited to countries that were previously designated by Congress or prior administrations as posing national security risks.” Roberts dismissed the state’s contention that the September 2017 order applies too broadly and “does little to serve national security interests,” responding that courts should not substitute their own judgment for that of the executive branch on national-security matters, which he characterized as “delicate,” “complex,” and involving “large elements of prophecy.”

Roberts cited three specific features of the September 2017 order that, in his view, further buttress the government’s claim that the order was intended to serve genuine national-security interests. First, he emphasized, three Muslim-majority countries covered by the president’s January 2017 order – Iraq, Sudan and Chad – are no longer covered by the restrictions, and the September 2017 order contains exceptions that would allow some nationals from almost all of the countries covered by the order to come to the United States. What’s more, Roberts added, the September 2017 order also contains a waiver provision that allows nationals from covered countries to travel to the United States in certain circumstances, such as to obtain urgent medical care. When all of these circumstances are considered together, Roberts concluded, the government has demonstrated “a sufficient national security justification” for the September 2017 order to survive. The district court’s injunction that temporarily blocked the government from enforcing the order is now reversed, and the case will go back to the lower courts, Roberts indicated, “for such further proceedings as may be appropriate.”

IMO this was a clear case of usurpation on the part of the lower courts, an issue touched on by Justice Clarence Thomas in his concurring opinion, and I wish they had been rebuked more soundly. They were called on to rule on the law, not on whether they approved of Trump, and their rulings should have been limited to the law.

My own view was that the “Muslim ban”, in reality a ban on immigration of citizens of just five countries with majority Muslim populations (Iran, Iraq, Libya, Syria, Somalia, Sudan and Yemen)—all conflict areas was ill-considered but within the president’s powers and that’s what the court found, too. “Muslim ban” is good marketing but factually incorrect. Those aren’t even the largest countries with Muslim majorities (Indonesia, Pakistan, and Egypt were not included) and it extended to all citizens of those countries, not just Muslims. And there are more Muslims in India than there are in all of the banned countries put together. So, hardly a “Muslim ban”.

Update

From Jonathan Turley at The Hill:

The Supreme Court ruling in Trump v. Hawaii today was more than a predictable reversal of the 9th Circuit appeals court in its dubious ruling that the travel ban was unconstitutional. As some of us noted from the outset of this litigation, the precedent heavily favored President Trump.

What was unprecedented was the degree to which courts relied on campaign statements and tweets by Trump to rule that the entry limits were based on religious animus. The ruling properly returns the courts, and others, to basic principles of legal process. Call it “The Red Hen moment” for the courts, where judges, appalled by Trump’s inflammatory and reckless comments against Muslims, refused to extend him the same deference shown to predecessors like former President Obama. The response from judges, however, seemed more visceral than analytical in ignoring the nondiscriminatory rationales cited by agencies for the policy.

Exactly.

If you’re going to rule based not on the law but on the campaign statements of the president who signed the law, you’ve raised the stakes on getting control of the courts too far. Simply that you think the president is a bad guy does not mean that everything he does is illegal.

13 comments

It’s Not Working, Part 3

IMO the video of protesters harassing Elaine Chao, Mitch McConnell’s wife, will be played over and over again during the upcoming elections. The video is easy enough to find.

Those protesters are awfully male and awfully pale. Whatever the merits, it’s not particularly good optics for The Resistance for a bunch of white boys to be seen harassing an Asian woman.

4 comments

No Strategic Shortage

The one objection that I have to this post at Global Macro Monitor is that I don’t believe we have a strategic shortage of murderous psychopaths. We have plenty of our very own, native-born murderous psychopaths, thank you.

But it does highlight a grave misconception about violent crime. It’s not a commodity like potatoes. It doesn’t rise and fall like the supply of raspberries. The crime rate among illegal immigrants is irrelevant. Every single violent crime perpetrated by an illegal immigrant would not have taken place if that illegal immigrant were not in the United States. At least it wouldn’t have taken place here.

The Gospel admonishes us to forgive those who harm us. It does not advise us to coddle them or encourage them. Controlling our borders is a right. Denying individuals with gang tattoos, for example, entry into the United States is completely within our rights. We are not morally obligated to admit every career criminal in the world into the United States but to control their entry we need to control the border and enforce our laws. And some innocents will be injured in the process.

21 comments

Advice on Immigration

Niall Ferguson has good advice on immigration at the Boston Globe:

To those of you contentedly living in the country where you were born, I address a plea for empathy and also realism. A world without cross-border migration would be a poorer world in multiple ways. The question is not whether to stop migration but how to manage it. But from those of you who regard any regulation of immigration as somehow unjust — who want illegal immigrants to be treated the same as those who follow the rules — I plead for rationality. Wholly open borders are not a sane option for any country. And comparing today’s US government with the Nazis — who systematically persecuted native-born German Jews by depriving them of their citizenship, then their rights, then their property, and finally their lives — is preposterous.

and

The last time the issue surfaced, in 2014, the Obama administration threw in the towel. Just 3 percent of the tens of thousands of children from Central America who entered the United States that year were ultimately deported. The Trump administration didn’t want to be such a pushover. It was nevertheless pushed over — not by the asylum seekers, but by the media.

The German leader Trump more closely resembles is not Adolf Hitler but Angela Merkel. She too was forced to cave by the media, in 2015, when her statement to a sobbing Palestinian girl that Germany “could not manage” to accommodate refugees from the Middle East triggered a storm of emotion. You may recall what happened in the months after Merkel’s U-turn. European and American leaders confront essentially the same problem. I just wish the media would express the same outrage about the camps in Turkey and North Africa where Europeans are now trying to confine their would-be immigrants.

This is not an American problem. It is a global problem. According to a Gallup survey published a year ago, more than 700 million adults around the world would like to move permanently to another country. Of that vast number, more than one-fifth (21 percent) say that their first choice would be to move to the United States. The proportion who name a European Union country as their dream destination is higher: 23 percent.

Those calling for more empathy need to recognize that a) there is no right of immigration; b) the claims of most of those seeking asylum are ultimately rejected—they’re actually economic migrants gaming the system; c) the citizens of the United States (as well as Germany) have the right to determine who becomes a resident of the United States not those seeking residence; and d) enforcing the law is harsh by its nature.

Those calling for more realism need to understand that in a contest between emotion and reason emotion will always win. They’ve got to do more than recite the facts. They’ve got to tell a compelling story as well. Immigration has victims, too, and most of them are your fellow citizens. Tell their stories and pit emotion against emotion.

4 comments

It’s Not Working, Part 2


If you think that the strategy that has been employed by Democrats to gain control of the House (and Senate!) is working, consider the graph above. A 6 point advantage in the generic Congressional ballot is not enough for Democrats to gain control of the House let alone the Senate. Back in December Democrats had a 13 point advantage. Since then they’ve lost that and, well, there is not trend—no actual movement one way or another. Despite demonstrations, Marcusist guerrilla theater, and the incessant press onslaught, there’s been little change since February.

The editors of the Wall Street Journal declaim:

Hillary Clinton lost the Presidency in 2016 for many reasons but one was surely because she called people who disagreed with her a “basket of deplorables.” Millions of Americans knew who she meant, and nearly 63 million voted for Donald J. Trump.

The political left is now repeating that mistake as its cultural and political vanguard sends a message of condescension, hostility and now ostracism to anyone who voted for Mr. Trump or has worked with or for him for the good of the country. Their relentless contempt might end up re-electing him.

On that score don’t underestimate how the refusal by a restaurant in Lexington, Virginia, to serve White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders will resonate politically. Ms. Sanders had taken a seat at the Red Hen with several others on Friday when owner Stephanie Wilkinson asked her to leave. Ms. Wilkinson told the press, which is turning her into Rosa Parks, that her restaurant “has certain standards that I feel it has to uphold, such as honesty, and compassion, and cooperation.”

Except toward people who don’t share Ms. Wilkinson’s views. Rest assured every Trump supporter in America will be reminded of this episode from here to November. The message: Now you’re so deplorable they won’t serve you in their restaurants.

Meanwhile, hecklers ran Secretary of Homeland Security Kirstjen Nielsen out of a Mexican restaurant in Washington, D.C. last week. Protesters are also harassing Ms. Nielsen at home, blaring audio of crying children detained at the border and shouting “no justice, no sleep.”

Then there’s actor Seth Rogen, who bragged on TV that he recently refused to take a picture with Paul Ryan and the House Speaker’s sons. He delivered a lecture instead. Apparently rudeness to children is now a badge of courage.

No doubt some on the right behave as badly—though when they do they don’t become media heroes. But the irony is that the main beneficiary of all this is Donald Trump.

Republicans know that Mr. Trump often acts deplorably, and many also dislike his immigration policies, especially his recent separation of parents from children. The resulting political uproar, not least from Republicans, has caused the White House to change policy and keep immigrant families together.

But Republicans and other voters also know when they are being sneered at and marginalized. They don’t think it’s un-American to ask if maybe immigrant parents shouldn’t take their toddlers on a dangerous illegal trip across the border. They may not like Mr. Trump personally, but they do like that he stands up to the cultural arbiters who hate them. Mr. Rogen and his fellow political censors won’t admit it, but they are playing into Donald Trump’s hands.

Yeah, that’s definitely the way to win converts.

5 comments

Why I’m Not Worried

As I’ve said before I’m not particularly worried about mass migration from Latin America and the graph above illustrates why. The reality is that conditions aren’t what they were thirty or more years ago. Immigration is impelled both by push pressures and by pull pressures.

Thirty years ago the most important pull pressure was the U. S. economy. The U. S. at least promised to give anyone a job that wanted one. That’s no longer the case. Wages for those without high school educations have been falling here for years. We don’t really need more workers who can’t speak, read, or write English and without greater skills. And Mexicans, at least, are aware of that. Better enforcement hasn’t slowed immigration from Mexico. That job prospects in Mexico have improved while job prospects in the U. S. have worsened have done the trick.

The greatest push pressure impelling immigration has been the large numbers of young people in Mexico, Central America, and the other countries of Latin America. As the graph above illustrates that’s no longer the case, either. Our fears are overblown—most of whatever we had to fear about mass immigration has already happened. The countries of Latin America need their young people and they need to reform their societies to keep them.

3 comments

The Central American Migrants

I agree 100% with the editors of the Washington Post’s take on the proper response to the influx of Central American migrants into the United States:

The right way to respond to the influx of migrants is, first, for Congress to enact legislation requiring that families be released under supervision or, if they must be detained, detained together and briefly. Second, it’s to help alleviate Central America’s misery at its source, through economic and law enforcement aid. Third, the United States should bolster the judicial machinery to cope with the problem. So far, Mr. Trump has thrown his weight behind none of the above.

to which I would add that Mexico is a good part of the problem. Mexico is a signatory to both the 1951 and 1967 conventions on refugees while the U. S. is a signatory only to the 1951 convention. That means its responsibility is greater than ours but they’re reacting as though they have no responsibilities at all while condemning us for our reaction.

1 comment

First, Fire the Econometricians

At Marketwatch Peter Morici has observed that the Phillips Curve has fallen and it can’t get up:

Heads must be exploding at the Federal Reserve — unemployment keeps sinking below the level that economists and policy makers think should instigate significantly much higher inflation — because econometric models that estimate that threshold are estimated, as they must be, with historical statistics. Those cannot accommodate the consequences of the technological and institutional changes that are redefining U.S. labor, commodity and product markets.

Perhaps the most striking example is the disappearance of the Phillips curve—the hypothesized inverse relationship between inflation and unemployment. In plain English, at 3.8% unemployment we should be seeing a lot more wage and price jumps than we are experiencing.

I continue to think that there’s a relationship but they’re calculating unemployment the wrong way. Unfortunately, these metrics become increasingly politicized over time. Economic behavior is unimpressed by such machinations.

8 comments