Meathead Criticizes Anti-Trumpers

The Hill reports that actor and director Rob Reiner gets why celebrities should moderate the language they use in criticizing the president:

Director Rob Reiner denounced Robert De Niro and other celebrities for their remarks against President Trump, saying it only helps the president.

During an exclusive interview with The Hill’s new TV show “Rising,” which aired on Wednesday, Reiner addressed the controversy surrounding actor Robert De Niro’s “F—Trump” speech during the Tony Awards on Sunday.

De Niro called the president a “f—ing idiot” and a “f—ing fool,” which was met with a standing ovation.

“You’re helping Trump by saying ‘F— Trump,’ because he can say ‘look at these people, these elitists,’ ” Reiner told “Rising” co-hosts Krystal Ball and Buck Sexton.

Reiner said he thinks celebrities are ultimately hurting Democrats when they go on expletive-ridden rants against Trump.

“There’s a very fine line between energizing the base and energizing the other side,” Reiner said.

Whether you’re part of the Democratic leadership or not, anyone in the public eye can help or hurt the Democratic brand by his or her remarks. Rather than venting, why not be the better man?

2 comments

You Get What You Pay For

In a New York Times op-ed Harvard economist Greg Mankiw points to a paradox in today’s economy:

With unemployment at 3.8 percent, its lowest level in many years, the labor market seems healthy.

But that number hides a perplexing anomaly: The percentage of men who are neither working nor looking for work has risen substantially over the past several decades.

It can’t be explained by staying in school longer or retirements.

Yet schooling and retirement explain only part of what has occurred. Consider prime-age men, those from the ages of 25 to 54. These men are generally well past their schooling and well before their retirement. Yet this group has also been exiting the labor force.

In 1950, only 4 percent of prime-age men were not working or looking for work. Today, that figure is 11 percent.

As one might expect from a full-time academic he suggests education as a remedy:

One step in the right direction would be to expand opportunity by increasing educational attainment and skills training. Doing so would help expand opportunity, as well as address many other problems facing the economy. But that is easier said than done.

Spending more on education might help, but is a tough political sell. And improving the educational system could require not just more money, but fundamental reforms that are hotly contested by the various stakeholders.

Real per capita spending on education has more than doubled over the period of the last 25 years. Any notion that more spending alone will solve the problem borders on insanity.

Additionally, he never actually comes to terms with the reality that to succeed in college you really need an IQ that is at least at the median. What about the rest of the people? Real spending on vocational training has plummeted over the last couple of decades. We’re just writing most people off.

Over the last several decades the emphasis in automation has gone disproportionately to automating jobs filled by people with less education rather than more. Some of that is natural but some is an artifact. It is my considered belief that if the weavers’ guilds had been as well-mobilized a couple of centuries ago as members of the “learned professions” are today we’d still be wearing hand-woven underwear. Or none at all more likely.

Let me offer another suggestion. We are subsidizing health care to the tune of no less than $1.5 trillion per year and education by approximately another trillion. Both sectors, the so-called “caring professions”, attract and are predisposed to hire women. Since money is fungible, that’s $2.5 trillion that isn’t spent on building or making, sectors that tend to attract and hire men.

9 comments

The Pursuit of GDP

Read this article at USA Today:

WASHINGTON — “The economy,” Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell declared this week, “is doing very well.”

And it is. Steady hiring has shrunk unemployment to 3.8 percent — the lowest since the 1960’s. Consumers are spending. Taxes are down. Inflation is tame. Factories are busy. Demand for homes is strong. Household wealth is up.

Yet the numbers that collectively sketch a picture of a vibrant economy don’t reflect reality for a range of Americans who still feel far from financially secure even nine years into an economic expansion.

From drivers paying more for gas and families bearing heavier child care costs to workers still awaiting decent pay raises and couples struggling to afford a home, people throughout the economy are straining to succeed despite the economy’s gains.

and consider the reasons for the present state of affairs. Here’s my list:

  • The ownership of (mostly paper) assets is far too important a factor in measuring how well we’re doing as a country.
  • Higher education is a racket.
  • Educational loans are a racket.
  • Our present social arrangements are not conducive to well-being.
  • We need an economy that’s well-suited to the people we have not people who are well-suited to the economy we have.

GDP is a lousy metric for how well we’re doing as a country just as net worth is a weak metric for how well you’re doing as an individual. For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, etc.?

2 comments

Stop Me If You’ve Heard This One

Have I mentioned this before? Story idea: a retelling of Robinson Crusoe set in the middle of a major city.

I assume you’ve read Robinson Crusoe and recognize that it’s not just an adventure story but a story about how a man slowly loses his mind due to isolation. There is such a thing as technologically-based isolation, too. I sometimes wonder how much misery it’s causing?

3 comments

The Eternal Verities

It is a sign of our debased times that for some these results, reported by Brent Orrell at RealClearPolicy, are controversial or even disputed:

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services recently released an evaluation of the Administration for Children and Families’ Healthy Marriage and Responsible Fatherhood (HMRF) initiative. The findings offer hope that at least one of the tools in the federal anti-poverty toolbox is having a positive impact. HMRF gives $150 million to community-based organizations providing marriage, relationship, and fatherhood education services to thousands of low-income Americans. And the program’s positive outcomes should encourage additional investigation and continued investment.

The Parents and Children Together (PACT) evaluation, by Mathematica Policy Research, reviewed the results of the Bronx-based Supporting Healthy Relationships and the Healthy Opportunities for Marriage Enrichment Program in El Paso. The evaluation found that couples taking part in these relationship education programs were less likely to break up, with 63 percent still together at the 1-year follow-up, compared to 59 percent of the control group. Couples also reported higher levels of commitment to their spouse, improved co-parenting behaviors, and higher levels of affection. Importantly, these programs also reduced levels of destructive behavior: Reports of domestic violence were one-third lower in treatment group versus those in the control group.

Traditional marriage and families are tools for promoting human development and well-being. The social structure known as the “absolute nuclear family” has been the most effective of the many such strategies employed by human societies.

We are presently engaged in a great social experiment to see if other arrangements may be just as effective or even more so. I hope that it succeeds and that the test subject does not die in the process.

0 comments

The Fix Was In

Tribune columnist John Kass points out something the IG report has made plain:

Just chew on this apiece: How could Hillary Clinton ever be prosecuted without implicating Obama, who emailed her using a pseudonym?

Obama might have been portrayed as a victim of her use of a private server. She used that server to hide her dealings with the controversial Clinton Foundation from congressional inquiry. She should have been prosecuted.

But then, two things would have happened.

Her campaign would have fallen apart immediately, and along with it, Obama’s legacy.

The Obama White House, the senior pro-Obama bosses of the FBI and just about all the political suits thought Clinton would be our next president.

And who wants to anger the next ruler? Careers were at stake, promotions, perks, power, just as it was back in the day, in old Versailles.

You should read the report for yourself. Ignore the spin that there was no bias found at Obama’s DOJ and FBI.

It crawls with bias. Deals were cut. Then-Attorney General Loretta Lynch met on the tarmac with Bill Clinton. Hillary Clinton was shielded from a federal grand jury. Witnesses were allowed to sit with her during questioning. Comey had already decided to clear her before the investigation was complete.

and issues a warning:

But one thing should be understood here: The Clinton investigation went wrong when it was taken away from capable field agents and handed to the political suits and intriguers. Bias is their coin. Comey was their boss. His reputation has been hurt by the report.

And Trump, vulgar and boastful, was overjoyed to see Comey, a likely witness against him, take such a big public hit.

Trump is no angel. He’s famous for lies. Mueller may indeed be closing in with the Friday jailing of former Trump campaign manager Paul Manafort, who’s accused of witness tampering.

But Trump’s lies are obvious and blustery, like those told by a bad carny hustler.

Trump is no Obama.

Obama was the silky one.

And the silky ones prosper, in Washington, and as they did for a time, at Versailles.

Among the many reasons that so many people voted for Donald Trump, an obvious huckster, over President Obama’s designated successor was that not just Republicans but Democrats and, especially, independents are dissatisfied with the country’s direction and have been for some time:

After Trump’s election approval of the country’s direction spiked, briefly, to a level higher than at any time since George W. Bush was president. That wasn’t simply because of racism or bigotry or misogyny although those might have been factors and it wasn’t just because of economic conditions but because they recognize, increasingly, that those hired to serve them despise them and it’s all right there in microcosm in the investigation of Hillary Clinton’s outlaw email server.

6 comments

Social Security Needs Much More Reform

Judging by his op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, George Melloan does not understand what a Ponzi scheme is. In reference to the Social Security Trustees’ report he remarks:

Without working-age immigrants steadily expanding the American labor force, the trust funds would be going broke even faster than they are now. Yet Congress, under pressure from President Trump and other nativists in the Republican Party, is focused on curtailing rather than expanding the supply of immigrant labor.

More high-wage immigrants will increase the system’s liability somewhat while increasing its revenues quite a bit. More low-wage immigrants will increase the system’s liability by an amount much greater than the amount they will pay into the system. It’s like that old wisecrack about the guy who lost money on every sale but would make it up in volume.

The net effect of our policy of family reunification is to increase the number of low-wage immigrants. Far from healing the Social Security system, that will render its problems even less tractable.

The structural problem with the Social Security system is not that there aren’t enough people contributing to the system but that not enough income is subject to the tax. We’ve either got to raise median wages which is proving to be very difficult or we’ve got to raise the level of wages subject to the tax (FICA max) a lot. Or, as I’ve suggested, eliminate the trust funds altogether and pay SSRI out of the general fund. I believe that would by far be the easiest solution.

The picture on this post is, of course, from the shlock classic Mars Needs Women. I was inspired by the caption given to the op-ed: “Social Security System Needs Immigrants”.

4 comments

The Players

Count the editors of the New York Times among those who see the IG’s report as complete exoneration. Here’s a round-up of the NYT’s opinion page this morning:

Editorial, “No, Hillary Clinton’s Emails Will Never Go Away”
David Leonhardt, “The Report’s Real Message: Trump Is Lying”
James Comey, “This Report Says I Was Wrong. But That’s Good for the F.B.I.”

The reaction of the editors of the Washington Post is somewhat more balanced:

The valid, nonpolitical lesson arising from the inspector general’s report is that the FBI needs to be better prepared to handle politically sensitive investigations. The agency must take special care not to affect elections. It should shy from making statements about people not charged with crimes, and major announcements should be vetted carefully through the Justice Department hierarchy. As for FBI officials, they can have personal views, but they should refrain from saying careless things even in private.

While the editors of the Wall Street Journal saw the report quite differently:

The long-awaited Inspector General’s report on the FBI’s handling of the Hillary Clinton investigation makes for depressing reading for anyone who cares about American democracy. Self-government depends on public trust in its institutions, especially law enforcement. The IG’s 568-page report makes clear that the FBI under former director James Comey betrayed that public trust in a way not seen since J. Edgar Hoover.

We use the Hoover analogy advisedly, realizing that the problem in this case was not rampant illegal spying. Though IG Michael Horowitz’s conclusions are measured, his facts are damning. They show that Mr. Comey abused his authority, broke with long-established Justice Department norms, and deceived his superiors and the public.

While the IG says Mr. Comey’s decisions were not the result of “political bias,” he presided over an investigating team that included agents who clearly were biased against Donald Trump. The damage to the bureau’s reputation—and to thousands of honest agents—will take years to repair.

The issue of political bias is almost beside the point. The IG scores Mr. Comey for “ad hoc decisionmaking based on his personal views.” Like Hoover, Mr. Comey believed that he alone could protect the public trust. And like Hoover, this hubris led him to make egregious mistakes of judgment that the IG says “negatively impacted the perception of the FBI and the department as fair administrators of justice.”

I’ll quote blogospheric reactions as time allows.

13 comments

Rashomon on the Potomac

I don’t believe I have ever encountered a more Rashomon-like reaction to anything than the reaction to the Inspector General’s report on the FBI investigation of the Clinton email server and former Director James Comey’s actions in 2016. To refresh your memory Rashomon is a Kurosawa movie about a rape and murder. Over the course of the movie each character relates his or her account of the incidents and they could hardly be more divergent. The movie was remade here as The Outrage, an early feature performance by William Shatner.

The complete text of the report is here. Of the 500 some-odd pages, I have read the 12 page “Executive Summary” and a few select passages.

Some people, particularly those who are anti-Trump, see it as a complete exoneration of the FBI and the investigation. Consider these statements, from the “Conclusions” beginning on p. 497:

While we did not find documentary or testimonial evidence that improper considerations, including political bias, directly affected the specific investigative actions we reviewed in Chapter Five, the conduct by these employees cast a cloud over the entire FBI investigation and sowed doubt about the FBI’s work on, and its handling of, the Midyear investigation. It also called into question Strzok’s failure in October 2016 to follow up on the Midyear -related investigative lead discovered on the Weiner laptop. The damage caused by these employees’ actions extends far beyond the scope of the Midyear investigation and goes to the heart of the FBI’s reputation for neutral factfinding and political independence.

or this

While we did not find that these decisions were the result of political bias on Comey’s part, we nevertheless concluded that by departing so clearly and dramatically from FBI and Department norms, the decisions negatively impacted the perception of the FBI and the Department as fair administrators of justice.

While those on the other side see it as a scathing indictment of the FBI in general and Comey in particular. Consider this passage in discussion of Comey’s July remarks

A statement that the sheer volume of information classified as Secret supported an inference of gross negligence was removed and replaced with a statement that the classified information they discovered was “especially concerning because all of these emails were housed on servers not supported by full-time staff”;

this

As we describe in Chapters Two and Seven of our report, the prosecutors analyzed the legislative history of Section 793(f)(1), relevant case law, and the Department’s prior interpretation of the statute. They concluded that Section 793(f)(1) likely required a state of mind that was “so gross as to almost suggest deliberate intention,” criminally reckless, or “something that falls just short of being willful,” as well as evidence that the individuals who sent emails containing classified information “knowingly” included or transferred such information onto unclassified systems.

or this which I think is the best and most important statement I encountered in the report

Comey’s description of his choice as being between “two doors,” one labeled “speak” and one labeled “conceal,” was a false dichotomy. The two doors were actually labeled “follow policy/practice” and “depart from policy/practice.” Although we acknowledge that Comey faced a difficult situation with unattractive choices, in proceeding as he did, we concluded that Comey made a serious error of judgment.

Said another way there is plenty of room for both reactions. I honestly don’t know what to think.

How does one interpret actions that are inherently political? Where do you draw the line between actions that made certain political assumptions and political bias?

There are some important omissions and, I think, outright errors of law. For example, a commonplace method of inferring motive is that motive may be imputed from a pattern of action. That applies both to Sec. Clinton and to Mr. Comey.

The recommendations in the IG report will probably result in dismissals but IMO are unlikely to result in any criminal prosecutions. While falling short of the bill of criminal particulars that some wanted it also falls short of the complete exoneration that others wanted.

2 comments

Chicago’s Getting Boring

The Boring Company, that is. We’ve hired it. From Bloomberg:

Elon Musk’s Boring Co. is the winner in a bid to build a multibillion-dollar high-speed express train to Chicago’s O’Hare International Airport. The result gives the young company a big boost in legitimacy as it tries to get transportation projects underway in Los Angeles and Washington.

The company beat out a consortium that included Mott MacDonald, the civil engineering firm that designed a terminal at London’s Heathrow Airport, and JLC Infrastructure, an infrastructure fund backed by former basketball star Earvin “Magic” Johnson, people with knowledge of the matter said. The city is expected to announce the news as soon as Thursday, said one of the people, who asked not to be identified because they weren’t authorized to speak publicly.

I wonder what Chicago is going to do when The Boring Company goes bankrupt. Or what The Boring Company is going to do when Chicago goes bankrupt. It’s a race! A match made in heaven. Or somewhere.

4 comments