Singing a Different Tune

I broadly support the measures that Ben Rhodes and Jake Sullivan are encouraging the new Democratic House to put in place in their op-ed in the New York Times. For example:

Second, Democrats should challenge the president on his approach to the “forever war.” Despite running on a pledge to withdraw from military conflicts, Mr. Trump has escalated every conflict he inherited — largely behind a cloak of secrecy and without a clear strategy. Congress can insist on greater transparency around American military deployments, forcing the administration to specify which terrorist organizations the United States is at war with and the military objectives. Democrats should also push for a plan that removes our troops from harm’s way in Afghanistan, while insisting that a war against Iran cannot take place without congressional authorization. As Mr. Trump faces political setbacks at home, Democrats must be vigilant in checking military adventurism abroad.

and

Congress can also work to end United States support for the Saudi-led war in Yemen, which has precipitated the world’s worst humanitarian catastrophe. Rather than fuel the war, we should be driving the parties toward a diplomatic solution and increasing assistance to stem the spread of famine. This is even more pressing in the aftermath of Mr. Trump’s shameful statement on Saudi Arabia last week that signaled that American foreign policy is for sale and that Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman can act with impunity.

I wish those causes had a better messenger. I notice that Mr. Rhodes fails to mention from whom President Trump inherited the “forever war” in Afghanistan. Where was this zeal for peace when President Obama was escalating the war in Afghanistan, a move which has had little measurable effect other than spending billions and the deaths of American soldiers? And I seem to recall Mr. Rhodes’s zeal for President Obama’s drone war. Somehow he fails to mention that the drone war was one of the factors that contributed to Saudi Arabia’s war in Yemen.

I have opposed the war in Afghanistan under three presidents, one Democrat and two Republicans. I opposed the drone war as not being a just war. I oppose U. S. support for Saudi Arabia in its war against Yemen. At least that’s consistent. When you support something when it’s done by a Democrat and oppose it when done by a Republican it sounds more like partisanship than high-minded statesmanship.

5 comments

Illinois’s Scandalous Public Payroll

It is a frequent source of amazement to me that Illinoisans refuse to do anything about the abuses of their state and local governments but choose to vote with their feet. At RealClearPolitics Steve Cortes cites some examples:

Recently, Fox affiliate Channel 32 and Open the Books detailed the exorbitant pay package for part-time interim school Superintendent Joyce Carmine. She retired in 2017 making $398,000 annually, the highest-paid superintendent in Illinois, in a community where the median household income is $44,000. She will receive, courtesy of taxpayers, a pension of just under $300,000 for the rest of her life. Adding insult to injury, the school district hired this retiree back as a consultant at the rate of $1,200 per day for a total of 100 days, bringing her pay this year to $419,000 total for part-time work. Given the modest $75,000 median home price in Park Forest, her salary equates to 5.5 home purchases…per year.

Is Carmine somehow producing educational miracles to justify such munificence? The answer is no — testing reveals that only 26 percent of her district’s elementary school students meet state standards for their grade level, and a paltry 2 percent exceed those standards. By the time those students matriculate to the local Rich East public high school, only 16 percent meet expectations and a truly shocking 0 percent exceed them.

I wish that this Park Forest absurdity could be chalked up as exceptional profligacy. But here’s the reality: While Carmine’s pay package and benefits are particularly offensive, especially compared to the modest economic means of those she serves, similar stories abound. For example, in nearby impoverished Ford Heights, school Superintendent Gregory Jackson earned $340,000 for leading a tiny district of only 437 total students, 97 percent of whom live in low-income households.

That should help to explain what I’m complaining about.

3 comments

A More Egalitarian Federal Tax System

Contrary to the editors of the Washington Post, if I were going to make the federal tax system more egalitarian, I wouldn’t expand the Earned Income Tax Credit to cover 80% of taxpayers:

Understandably, given that hypocritical recent history, Democrats are starting to roll out big, budget-unconstrained policy plans of their own in preparation for the 2020 presidential campaign. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) has his Medicare-for-all proposal, and Sen. Kamala D. Harris (D-Calif.) has her Livable Incomes for Families Today (LIFT) tax plan. Basically, the LIFT plan would provide cash tax credits of $3,000 per year (delivered in monthly installments) to working individuals earning up to $30,000, and $6,000 for married couples earning up to $60,000. Thereafter, it would phase out at different rates depending on household status, such that none with incomes exceeding $100,000 would benefit. If this sounds familiar, it’s because it resembles the existing earned-income tax credit; the main differences are that Ms. Harris’s plan (which would add to, not replace, the EITC) would pay people higher in the income scale, and regardless of the number of children they have.

The net effect of that would be to encourage consumer spending (something not presently needed) and make the federal budget more dependent on the revenue from payroll taxes than it already is. IMO preferred ways of making federal taxes more egalitarian would be either by reducing payroll taxes or increasing FICA max to at least $250,000 from where it presently is at $128,400. How about making 100% of every Congressman’s wages from serving as a Congressman subject to FICA?

3 comments

Nota Bene

I think this statement from economist Brian Domitrovic in an op-ed at Forbes:

As I have argued for years, taking a cue from Nobel economist and Wanniski companion Robert A. Mundell, a major nation shorn of all forms of taxation can get all the revenue, in effect, it needs by issuing currency. The demand for the dollar, from international and domestic sources alike, would be unthinkably large if we eliminated all forms of taxation. The United States could buy anything it wanted on the open market by issuing currency into this demand. It could also, in such an environment, easily make the dollar convertible in gold, in that currency would be in tremendous differential demand against gold in business conditions that were fantastic.

should warm the hearts of all proponents of Modern Monetary Theory.

To the larger questions of the evils of both tariffs and taxes addressed in the op-ed I would very much like to see an explanation from advocates of free trades, low (or no) taxes, and expansive immigration policies, how they plan to accomplish decent lifestyles for most Americans under their plan. They should show their work, i.e. put real, practical, foreseeable numbers behind their plans.

7 comments

Why Do We Subsidize Higher Education?

At RealClearPolitics Peter Berkowitz laments the sorry state of higher education and its lamentable impact on today’s society and politics:

No antidote to the poison that higher education has been pumping into our politics for three generations can succeed without reforming higher education. But prospects are poor for effecting the necessary changes from within. The progressive grip on higher education shows no signs of weakening. Faculty and administrators exhibit little appetite for self-criticism or external accountability. The implementation of inherently desirable practices inside the university such as a core curriculum are likely to be hijacked to serve illiberal ends.

That leaves a variety of alternatives outside of the university. Home schooling and charter schools that nurture the acquisition of knowledge and spirit of free inquiry before college are important options. Another is the expanding network of initiatives, generally supported by conservative philanthropists, that provide undergraduates and recent graduates the liberal education neglected or abused by our colleges and universities. The focus should be on an education for liberty, beginning with literacy and numeracy and proceeding through study of America and the West to the exploration of other civilizations. Successful experiments in education in the private sector might have a salutary influence on public education.

Neither Donald Trump’s antics nor his achievements should be allowed to obscure the urgency of educational reform. Without a basic familiarity with, and an education that is governed by, the norms of free and democratic societies, how will we be able to evaluate properly our current president, or any other one?

I don’t think that reform of higher education is possible without returning to first principles. Presently, 84% of the spending on education by government at all levels is for higher education. Over the last 60 years it has tripled in real terms. Why?

The conventional answer is that the path to a secure, prosperous future for Americans runs through higher education. Considered uncritically, that leaves out half of the American people for whom higher education is a path to failure and debt rather than to security and prosperity.

But is it actually true?

It is no accident that so many millennials emerge from college with $50,000 in student debt. At present starting wages that is debt they will be in their 30s before they discharge if ever. That is a drastic shift in prospects compared to previous age cohorts and affects every sector of our economy and every aspect of our society.

But I’m skeptical that the ROI on higher education is actually what it is advertised to be. What are the differences in lifetime earning prospects for those with college education compared to those without when you discount the very high incomes of a relative handful of college grads, e.g. physicians, graduates of top law schools, graduates of top business schools, and a few others? Factor in the opportunity costs of education, etc. does higher education really pay? Or for most is it a luxury and, for the average American, a luxury they can’t afford?

4 comments

The Greatest Threat to Journalism

I’m glad to see that longterm journalist John Solomon agrees with me:

We journalists have more freedom, more reach, and more ability to inform today than ever before. But with those advantages comes an even greater responsibility to the public, one I fear is being denigrated by journalists who substitute opinion for facts and emotion for dispassion.

Beyond the killings, the threats, and the vitriol, what most threatens journalism today is the behavior of its own practitioners.

We have become too full of our own opinions, too enthralled with our own celebrity, too emotionally offended by warranted and unwarranted criticism, and too astray from the neutral, factual voice our teachers in journalism school insisted we practice.

Read the whole thing.

He correctly lays the blame on “point of view” journalism. Facts are now relatively unimportant. What is important is having a point of view and expressing it vehemently. I suspect that is one result of the move towards visualcy in our consumption of information, something I have written about frequently. That itself leads to more agonistic modes of expression.

4 comments

Discrimination or Perceived Discrimination?

I do not know whether women are being systematically discriminated against in FBI training as is alleged in this New York Times article or whether the trainees quoted in the piece merely perceive that they are being discriminated against as this quotation reflects:

“Female trainees are singled out in group tactical exercises because they are perceived as being weak and prone to failure,” they wrote in the complaint. “Male trainees are provided multiple avenues for success, in spite of their errors. Male trainees are often permitted to retake tactical exams when female trainees are denied the opportunity to do so.”

I do know that only 25% of police officers, 15% of active duty military, and 7% of firefighters are women despite decades of energetic recruitment. I think that some of the discrepancy is due to discrimination but I also think that some is due to preference on the part of women while some is also because these are tough, physically demanding jobs whose requirements ought not to be relaxed to make it easier for women or weaker men to join.

1 comment

Fighting the Lies of Those You Hate Isn’t Enough

I think that Nicholas Kristof is asking the wrong questions in his New York Times column about how journalists can “fight, not spread fear and lies”. For example this:

Solutions are complicated, for there may well be a public interest in seeing purloined material; if Trump’s tax returns showed up in my mailbox, I would report on them even if I thought that China had stolen them and was using me to undermine the White House. Likewise, we do have to cover what a president says, even if it’s false, bigoted or demagogic — but I think we can try harder to make crystal clear the efforts at manipulating the public.

I don’t believe that one journalist in 1,000 would be reluctant to publish damaging information about Trump whatever its provenance. The more relevant hypothetical is if information about Obama that would have destroyed his presidency showed up in his mailbox would he have published it? Or would he have found scruples about its provenance that overrode the public’s right to know?

The reason that the public’s esteem for journalists and journalism has plummeted to near-Congressional levels of distrust over the period of the last 40 years isn’t because of Trump or, more precisely, isn’t just because of Trump. It’s because it has become obvious that journalists aren’t pursuing the truth regardless of where it takes them but turning their sights on oppo research against people of whom they disapprove.

It isn’t new. Journalists covered for Franklin Roosevelt for decades despite knowing of his marital infidelities and other weaknesses, going so far as to de-emphasize the hiding in plain sight reality that he was ridden to a wheelchair. They had hated Nixon for decades before he became president and once he became president the unfavorable media coverage he received was torrential. Were they against him because he was a bad guy or did he become a bad guy because of their hatred? Probably some of both.

Since then it has become increasingly the case that it’s open season, not just on presidents which would be fine, but on Republican presidents which is merely political activism. The net outcome of decades of partisan political activism by the press has been a concurrent decline in public esteem on the part of the press and giving a pass to someone possessed of as many qualities that in the past would have been disqualifying as Trump.

Not only is fairness good journalistic ethics; it means people are more likely to believe you.

In conclusion the way for journalists to regain public confidence is not merely by being willing to fight the lies of those you hate. That isn’t nearly enough. You’ve got to be willing to fight the lies of those you like as well.

8 comments

A Quiet Thanksgiving

My wife and I had a very quiet Thanksgiving yesterday. I spent some of the time working. The rest of the day I spent cooking. We only had a single guest—a dear old friend without family in town.

The only excitement came at the end of the evning during cleanup. A horrible sound came from the garbage disposal. After turning if off my wife found that the problem was a pie weight that had somehow fallen into the disposal. She ingeniously removed the pie weight without sticking her hand into the disposal by wrapping duct tape (I think that makes 1,007 uses) around a chopstick and fishing the weight out with it.

I made my standard menu: smoked turkey, a variant on my wife’s family’s dressing, mashed potatoes with gravy, brussels sprouts, cranberry mold and cranberry relish, pumpkin chiffon pie. The pie was probably our all-time best effort.

3 comments

Is Syria an Exception or a Roadmap?

I found this post at Lawfare thought-provoking. In the post Daniel Byman argues that in terms of radical Islamism Syria was an exception:

For counterterrorism officials, one of the most difficult counterterrorism challenges is identifying the next global struggle that, like the Syrian civil war, will energize the world’s Muslims and lead tens of thousands of foreigners to join the fray. However, as a Danish proverb (not Yogi Berra) warns, “It’s tough to make predictions, especially about the future.” But while counterterrorism officials must be on alert for the next cause that, like in Syria, produces a surge of foreign fighters and terrorism, they should not assume past is prologue. Indeed, there are many reasons to believe that the emergence of the Islamic State in Syria and the massive flow of foreigners to fight was due to unusual (though not unique) circumstances.

He does make (at least) one interesting point: perhaps the greatest casualty of the war against DAESH was the idea the social media are benign:

Technology companies also stepped up their efforts. Although they have a long way to go, they are vigorously taking down content linked to jihadist terrorist groups, streamlining coordination, hiring more staff, and otherwise improving their game. It is possible that the next group might use different emerging technologies and again catch Silicon Valley flat-footed, but thanks in part to its exploitation by extremist groups and foreign intelligence organizations, the blithe confidence in the internet’s inherent goodness is now gone for good, and it is likely that both governments and technology companies will be more vigilant.

Quite to the contrary I think that Syria provides a roadmap for how future jihadis may operate. First, let me repeat a point I have made in the past (including to those much more knowledgeable about Islam than I who have generally agreed with this claim). Violent movements like Al Qaeda or DAESH will be endemic in any universal, proselytizing sola scriptura religion without a magisterium. Let me de-jargonize that a bit. “Universal proselytizing” means it accepts converts and adherents believe that everyone should belong to the religion. “Sola scriptura” means completely based on scripture, e.g. the Bible or, in the case of Islam, the Qur’an. There are sola scriptura Christian denominations but not all Christian denominations are sola scriptura. All Muslims are sola scriptura. “Magisterium” means an authoritarive teaching authority. Catholics have a magisterium, i.e. the organizational church and, ultimately, the pope. Not all Christian denominations have a magisterium. Again in Islam there is no magisterium. Interpretation of the scripture is left to the individual believer. Consequently, the translation of the sentence above is that DAESH will return or another organization like it will.

Here are some of the markers along the highway. First, choose an objective that has an authoritarian government, particularly an authoritarian government run by an ethnic or religious minority. It is not difficult to find such targets in the Muslim world. Second, false flag operations to encourage Western countries to help you or, at least, not help the regime. Third, neighbors with axes to grind are a plus. Again, not difficult to find. I could go on.

Because DAESH or movements that think the same way are endemic in Islam, expect more to follow this pattern.

4 comments