Colonialism With Chinese Characteristics

This largely pictorial article in the New York Times documents the impressive array of infrastructure projects on every continent other than Antarctica that the Chinese have tackled:

We found 112 countries where China has financed projects. While most fall under its infrastructure plan known as the Belt and Road Initiative, Beijing has pushed beyond those boundaries.

After years of honing its construction skills at home, China is now deploying them abroad, including a series of hydroelectric dams.

However, this version of foreign aid has Chinese characteristics:

China has a different view when it comes to labor and environmental strictures. To staff overseas projects, Chinese companies have flown in their own workers by the thousands, drawing complaints that they are doing little to create local jobs. Safety standards have been uneven.

And Beijing continues to export polluting technologies like coal-fired power plants, even as such projects have become unpopular in China.

Western governments and multinationals generally steer clear of politically volatile countries. The Chinese government has been less skittish, lending heavily to nations like Venezuela, Nigeria and Zimbabwe.

But China’s lending is not usually largess. Countries that run into financial trouble must renegotiate their loans, putting them deeper into debt. Sometimes projects are left in limbo.

As both the British and Americans found there’s more to building countries than roads, dams, and bridges. For one thing infrastructure in a box of the sort that the Chinese have been producing does not leave behind people with the skills to improve or maintain the structures built including the organizational skills.

The British left systems of civic infrastructure behind them that resulted in their colonies becoming more prosperous than their neighbors. The infrastructure that the Spanish left behind them retarded the development of their former colonies.

I suspect that the Chinese will find that there’s more to making friends than building dams. As Sam Clemens put it, the difference between a man and a dog is that if you feed a dog and make him prosperous, he won’t bite you. What happens when you feed the dog but don’t make him prosperous? I can only speculate that there must be much more to China’s “Belt and Road” strategy than meets the eye, domestic objectives opaque to us.

3 comments

Seize the Day

The proprietor of The Scholar’s Stage has produced a typically exquisite essay that takes a somewhat divergent position on the murder of Jamal Khashoggi. The murder, in which the Saudi Crown Prince is obviously implicated, provides an excellent opportunity for severing our relationship with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and, indeed, reducing our involvement with the Middle East more generally:

The Khashoggi incident is a gift. By refusing to extricate ourselves from the region we have put optics over interests. But Khashoggi’s death now makes the optics of withdrawal and alliance termination easy. It will still be a hard thing to do. The American defense community has strong psychological, emotional, and financial commitments to the Middle East, and to the Saudis in particular. But this is all the more reason for cutting these ties as fast as we can. The Saudi security relationship is a quicksand trap. We must be free of it. Every dollar, soldier, and diplomat that is sent to shore them up is a dollar, soldier, and diplomat who should be engaged in what will soon be be recognized as an existential conflict with the Chinese Communist Party.

The challenge in, as he puts it, “extricating ourselves from the region” are less likely to be military or economic than political. Our primary interest in the region is Israel which punches above its weight in our foreign policy thought. I wish the Israelis well but our interests are not synonymous. They need to come up with a modus vivendi with their neighbors and our aegis is merely delaying the inevitable.

2 comments

Lessons Unlearned

College prof Hilton Root has an interesting post at CapX. It purports to be about the “great lesson of economic history” that China has yet to learn but I think it’s actually about the factors that are likely to hold China’s development back. Here’s the part I found most insightful:

In today’s China, more often than not, exchanges are now conducted outside of one’s small, trusted circle. Interactions among transacting parties are rarely repeated, and local knowledge of past behaviour is not effectively monitored. The traditional use of reputation as an effective form of social control is rendered hollow by scandal after scandal involving corporate, consumer, and political bribery and fraud.

The institutional evolution of any modern economy requires more than voluntary arrangements. The central government needs to establish a framework for an independent civil society, including the enforcement of property rights and a judiciary to protect the public from fraud and malfeasance — and, at the very least, to counterbalance the consolidation of state power. Without these, uncertainty will continue to limit healthy economic risk-taking or enthusiasm for complex exchanges.

One of the things he never really addresses directly but which has been a recurring theme here is China’s lack of a robust system of civil law, something I think will be nearly impossible to cultivate without major political reform.

IMO China’s present system can persist as long as the regime’s number keeps coming up. And then a little if they’re willing to impose enough force. But to be really persistent their system will need to change.

1 comment

Thanksgiving Proclamations

At RealClearPolitics Myra Adams reminds us of the thanksgiving proclamations from George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, and Franklin Roosevelt. You can find more here.

1 comment

The Argument for Saudi Arabia

If you’re interested in a view that opposes the current prevailing wisdom about Saudi Arabia, driven by outrage over the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, this op-ed by Michael Doran and Tony Badran gives it the old college try. Here’s its conclusion:

The murder of Mr. Khashoggi was a brutal and grotesque act. The United States has registered its feelings loudly and clearly by putting sanctions on the 17 men who were directly involved in the killing. Punishing the de facto leader of Saudi Arabia will not bring justice for Mr. Khashoggi, nor will it make Saudi Arabia a more dependable ally. It will simply diminish the influence of the United States and embolden its enemies.

The biblical advice to be as “wise as serpents, and harmless as doves” offers sound counsel to anyone who seeks to see their principles influence the world. The advice of Mr. Trump’s critics is long on abstract morality but lacking in strategic wisdom.

My view is somewhat different. With or without murdering Jamal Khashoggi the Saudi regime would be heinous and our enemies. We cannot avoid their influence but we don’t need them. We shouldn’t be supplying them with weapons or furnishing other support to them.

3 comments

Things Change

In his New York Times column Nicholas Kristof writes a lovely tribute to his father and his father’s immigrant experience:

One of the things I’m grateful for this Thanksgiving is the warm welcome that America extended to a man born 100 years ago in what is now Ukraine.

Wladyslaw Krzysztofowicz was born into an Armenian family in a dangerous region; you might think of it as the Honduras of its day. During World War II, some family members were murdered by the Nazis; afterward, some survivors were killed by the Soviet “liberators.”

Wladyslaw escaped by swimming across the Danube River from Romania to Yugoslavia, was almost executed, made his way to France — and began to dream of coming to America.

My father, for that’s who he was, explored illegal options, including a fake marriage with a U.S. citizen, but in the end the First Presbyterian Church in Portland, Ore., sponsored him — even though he was Catholic, spoke no English and originated in a Communist country that was then our enemy.

There were many reasons not to take him: The sponsors had to pay his transportation to America, cover his expenses and find him a job that didn’t require English (he initially worked as a logger). They did all this with tremendous generosity; I’m still trying to pay it forward.

So in 1952, my father was on the deck of the ship Marseille as it approached New York Harbor. A white-haired Boston woman tried to chat with him, but my dad couldn’t understand her.

He’s nostalgic for that time, nearly 70 years ago. So am I.

The marginal productivity of labor was rising, had been increasing for more than a century, and would continue to increase for another 20 years. In the period following World War II the U. S. economy was the only intact industrial economy. We imported very little. Those factors meant that anyone willing to work could earn a decent living and would be able to do so for his entire working life.

Immigrants as a percentage of the population were about 5%. Now they’re about 15%. Wages for those without a command of English or saleable skills have been declining for a quarter century. We have substantial global competition now which means that with just supply and demand factors it’s unlikely that the wages of the unskilled will keep pace. We have erected an impressive edifice of social services that made assumptions about the U. S. that were correct in 1952 but are completely unrealistic for today. Total government spending at all levels as a percentage of GDP was around 17% and half of that was defense spending. Now it’s around 36%, only 5% of which is defense spending.

Times have changed. We can’t go back there again and it’s futile even to try. We would not want to make the changes that would be necessary. Rather than thinking about what immigration was in 1952 or in 1900 or in 1883 we should be crafting immigration policy suitable for 2018 and the conditions that prevail here now.

0 comments

Augustine’s Prayer

Augustine of Hippo, one of the greatest of Christian thinkers, famously wisecracked that his prayer as a youth was “God, grant me chastity and continence—but not yet.” Does anyone see echoes of that in the complaints about civility today?

I’ve been clear in my opinion. I think that if you want want moderation and civility in civic discourse you must model it in your own conduct. Others, obviously, see things differently.

1 comment

What Then?

You know, I actually agree with the proposal from the editors of the Washington Post about what to do about the “caravan” of Central Americans and others who want to come into the United States that’s making its way across Mexico:

Notwithstanding Mr. Trump’s incendiary rhetoric, the problem of migrants is real. Many cross the border with their children and apply for asylum, overwhelming existing legal mechanisms, feeding what the president calls a “catch and release” revolving door for migrants freed as they await hearings, and contributing to a backlog of about 1 million cases in immigration courts.

A rational response would be to add to the 350 or so immigration judges, who cannot handle the tens of thousands of asylum claims flooding the immigration courts annually. The administration this year hired a few dozen judges, a fraction of what is required. As the caseload has more than quadrupled since 2006, the number of judges has not even doubled, according to congressional testimony in April by Judge A. Ashley Tabaddor, president of the National Association of Immigration Judges.

Further, I would send the judges to the border to adjudicate the cases right then and there. After all justice delayed is justice denied.

But what then? If history is any gauge about 1% of those in the caravan will actually be granted asylum and refugee status. Does anyone really believe that the people in the caravan will accept the judges’ decisions?

The underlying problem is that there are millions (I’ve seen an estimate of 100 million) in Latin America alone who, given a chance, would move to the United States to trade their present problems for a different set of problems. For decades we’ve been treating our own laws with a wink and a nod. If we won’t enforce our laws, who will?

One of the things that has occurred to me is that mass immigration is the present generation’s version of the Peace Corps. Instead of going to far away places with dirt and poverty and disease and civil unrest to make the world a better place they’re bringing the world here. That way they can make the world a better place without courage or commitment or leaving their Internet connections.

4 comments

Slow Is Dead

Many people aren’t aware of it but very few news organizations these days have substantial staffs of reporters. Most of them get their news even local news from one of the big syndicates, Associated Press or UPI. If you want truly local news you must turn to social media sites which include Facebook and Youtube. AP has been around for 150 years. For most parts of the country professional local news coverage went out with disco balls and leisure suits.

Consequently, when I read this passage in David Ignatius’s lament in the Washington Post:

The virtues of a slower, less fluid Internet were outlined in an important recent article on Motherboard by Justin Kosslyn, who heads product management for the Jigsaw think tank operated by Alphabet, which also owns Google. The article’s title makes the basic, heretical argument: “The Internet Needs More Friction: Tech companies’ obsession with moving data across the internet as fast as possible has made it less safe.”

“Friction — delays and hurdles to speed and growth — can be a win-win-win for users, companies and security,” Kosslyn writes. “Highways have speed limits and drugs require prescriptions . . . yet digital information moves limitlessly.” Unfortunately, he notes, this combination of blazing speed and non-oversight “accelerates the flow of phishing, ransomware and disinformation.”

I like Kosslyn’s idea because it’s an alternative to the potential trap Facebook has entered, of hiring many thousands of human content assessors and fact-checkers to decide what ideas should be allowed on its platform. To many people, this sounds like Facebook’s version of thought police. Next, alas, come the government regulators.

Rather than create a new regulation regime for Facebook (as Congress is discussing), maybe it would be wiser to treat these social-media companies as publishers of content — and apply the same, well-established legal standards (including libel laws for reckless defamatory comments) that apply to any other publisher. This transition — from platform to publisher — should be implemented carefully, not in the heat of anti-Facebook agitation. In the meantime, slow it down.

I realized that he was engaging in yet another exercise in nostalgia. I wanted to acquaint him with a remark of Stewart Brand’s that goes back long before the Internet, just about 50 years:

Information Wants To Be Free. Information also wants to be expensive. …That tension will not go away.

Like school shootings or flying jetliners into office buildings, this is a problem of personal empowerment and it will only go away if the personal empowerment itself goes away. That would have grave implications for our society and our economy.

Just look at the major U. S. companies whose business models are built around personal empowerment. They include not only Facebook but Amazon, Apple, Google, Netflix, and Microsoft. That drives me to the conclusion that the speed that personal empowerment demands will not go away. Speed is here to stay.

0 comments

WWRD?

Adam Schuster’s op-ed in the Chicago Tribune is yet another example of wishful thinking. In it the Rauner advisor gives advice to the man who defeated Rauner’s re-election bid:

• First, ask schools and universities to shoulder the cost of their employees’ retirement. Under the status quo, local officials negotiate salary and health benefits, which form the basis for pension payments and retiree health costs, but the state pays the bill. That creates a misalignment between responsibility and accountability, reducing pressure to keep compensation affordable for taxpayers. Gov. Bruce Rauner pushed this idea in each of his budget addresses, but the proposal started with Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan.

According to data from the Governor’s Office of Management and Budget, by phasing this shift in over a number of years, Pritzker could see savings of $825 million in the first year, with further savings each year after.

• Second, Pritzker should ask state government workers to play fair at the bargaining table. Rauner suggested savings of nearly $500 million annually, accomplished by asking workers to pay for the same percentage of their health care costs as is typical in the private sector, or about 40 percent, up from just 23 percent now. Again, this concept has received bipartisan support. Former Gov. Pat Quinn also tried to right-size government worker health insurance costs.

Was Mr. Schuster AWOL during the first week of November? Rauner lost and, as been said, elections have consequences. One of those consequences is that otherwise reasonable ideas for balancing Illinois’s budget won’t happen because they won’t pass muster with Mike Madigan.

Re-imagining J. B. Pritzker as Bruce Rauner is an exercise in futility. I have no idea what Gov. Pritzker will do. My guess is that he will try, unsuccessfully, to enact a graduated income tax in Illinois (that would require a constitutional amendment). And he may try to attract more big businesses to Illinois despite Illinois’s adverse tax and regulatory environment. What will he offer them? Tax breaks? Why not offer the tax breaks to companies that are already here to induce them to stay?

2 comments