What Should We Panic About?

In a pun-laden op-ed in the Wall Street Journal (examples: “Lettuce Try Not to Panic”, “Will a tragic overreaction topple Caesar and lead to the decline of the romaine empire?”) Jim Prevor argues that the CDC overreacted to the E. coli outbreak of a few weeks ago:

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention urged before Thanksgiving that “U.S. consumers not eat any romaine lettuce, and retailers and restaurants not serve or sell any” until the current E. coli outbreak is resolved. This effectively closed down the romaine industry, producing tens of millions of dollars in losses of the highly perishable crop. The advisory remains in effect for romaine from the Central Coastal growing regions of Northern and Central California.

The waste is worth it, right? It seems straightforward that no one should eat romaine when the lettuce is making people sick. But it isn’t so clear when you look at the numbers.

The way the CDC identifies a food-safety outbreak is by interviewing sick people and healthy people. If there is a big difference in their answers, the CDC zeroes in on a cause. There are 43 people known to be infected with the outbreak strain of E. coli 0157:H7. The CDC interviewed 25 of them. Eighty-eight percent of those 25 people, as opposed to 47% of the general population, said they ate romaine lettuce in the week before they got sick.

So it probably was romaine that got those people sick—16 severely enough to be hospitalized. But what rational people should do with this information is much less certain.

The U.S. population is about 326 million. If 47% of the population eats romaine each week, that’s about 153 million people. We know of 43 people who have been infected with E. coli from romaine lettuce. According to the CDC, illness start dates range from Oct. 8 to Oct. 31—a period of about three weeks. If we assume, conservatively, that each of those 153 million people eats one serving of romaine each week, then we can figure there were 459 million servings consumed during the three weeks the infection was being transmitted.

This means the odds that eating a serving of romaine will make you sick are about 1 in 11 million, and the odds it will put you in the hospital are less than 1 in 28 million. To put this in perspective, the probability of getting a royal flush in poker is dozens of times as great, at 1 in 649,740, and the probability of an amateur hitting a hole-in-one in golf is hundreds of times as great, at 1 in 12,000. If you are that risk-averse, you should stay away from dogs—the lifetime odds of getting killed by a dog attack are about 1 in 112,000. Even the odds of getting struck by lightning in a particular year are higher than 1 in a million.

To put it another way: If this outbreak were active every day, and you ate one salad a day, on average you would be hospitalized for E. coli once every 77,000 years.

I suppose I shouldn’t blame Mr. Prevor for the puns. Those are probably editorial.

I think his argument is specious. The cases weren’t distributed uniformly throughout the country—they occurred in clusters. Since we don’t keep records at a fine enough granularity (and shouldn’t) we can’t identify precisely what field produced the lettuce that carried the bacteria. We don’t know the actual incidence (it could have been hundreds of times higher but unreported). We don’t even know the actual incidence in the areas in which the cases were reported.

E. coli isn’t endemic in romaine lettuce. It was introduced from outside. Possibilities include animals, the water used in the field, or poor field sanitation conditions. One worker eliminating in a field can sicken hundreds of people. What incentives should be put in place to ensure that producers take sufficient care?

The argument Mr. Prevor is making can be levelled against most laws and most preventive measures. Every restaurant (at least every restaurant I’ve ever worked in) has prominent signs urging workers to wash their hands. Should those be removed? They were made the law due to incidents of disease being spread in restaurants a century ago. Has it all been a waste? Should we abandon all public health measures?

That’s my question for Mr. Prevor. What prevalence is enough for us to take steps in cases of preventable death?

Update

It isn’t just about reducing risk. It’s also about confidence. Do warnings like the CDC’s increase or decrease confidence? Our present system of food distribution depends on trust. What would happen to California produce growers if there were a catastrophic decrease in trust in the food supply?

5 comments

The Art of Surrender


In a sort of companion piece to Mr. Ignatius’s column, the editors of the Washington Post argue for surrender:

The question is what Mr. Trump proposes to do now that he has Beijing’s attention. One approach would be to continue condemning China’s failure to meet U.S. demands, and press ahead with higher tariffs, then settle in for what might be a protracted trade war. But the collateral damage to U.S. businesses and consumers would be severe. The wiser course, which Mr. Trump has hinted at adopting in recent days, would be a temporary truce: a further delay in additional U.S. tariffs in return for comparable Chinese concessions, to be followed by negotiations — serious negotiations — on the full range of issues between the two countries.

They are behind the curve. We will have been in a Cold War with China for 17 years come this December 11. We just haven’t been fighting back. We have experienced millions of casualties. The editors of the Washington Post are unconcerned because the casualties haven’t been their friends, families, or even people they associate with or like. They’ve been the proles.

We must demand reciprocity from the Chinese and accept no less. At the very least they should live up immediately to the commitments they made when they were admitted to the World Trade Organization or be summarily expelled. Another strategy for motivating the Chinese authorities is by using tariffs. They are part of the process of securing the concessions the editors are seeking. A one-sided concession from the U. S. would be foolish in the extreme.

What would the editors prefer? Embargo? Blockade? What other leverage do they think we have?

6 comments

The Supreme Art of War

In his latest Washington Post column David Ignatius notes that subtlety is more effective than bluster:

The calmest voices lately have been the Chinese, as they glide into the vacuum left by Trump as he embraced “America First” and abandoned leadership of the global order. China’s approach, of course, is to win wars without fighting, as enunciated 2,500 years ago by master strategist Sun Tzu. Beijing doesn’t ram boats or buzz aircraft carriers in the South China Sea; the Chinese slowly turn reefs into islands and then fortify them into air bases. By the time people see what’s happening, it’s too late. Their answer to disruption is stealth.

Commentators often argue that the United States should penalize Putin’s aggression by matching his tough tactics. “NATO should look at increasing naval patrols in the Black Sea,” argued John Herbst, a former U.S. ambassador to Ukraine, during an Atlantic Council briefing this week. But I’d tend to agree with Mark Galeotti, a British Kremlin-watcher, who tweeted: “Calls for Western naval forces to be sent into Azov [are] dangerous, impractical & illegal.”

Far better than tit-for-tat U.S. bluster and belligerence would be quiet, hard-nosed use of power. Make Russia pay a price for its aggression, but invisibly. Pressure Saudi Arabia’s crown prince to stabilize his regime and stop the fighting in Yemen, but silently.

The supreme art of war is to subdue the enemy without fighting.

Stealth is, of course, one way but there are others. Possessing overwhelming power, for example. Your enemy’s conviction that he will lose any confrontation is a great weapon. Nothing has undermined America’s power more than the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. 15 years of war not only saps your resources and your willingness to fight, it looks weak and possessing overwhelming power must be complemented by the perception that you possess overwhelming power.

Another great weapon is for your enemy or, at least, your enemy’s people to want what you want. We didn’t defeat the Soviet Union just by possessing overwhelming power and being perceived to have overwhelming power. The Russian people wanting the same things we do was a powerful supporting factor. We didn’t defeat communism simply by possessing weapons. We did it with blue jeans and canned goods.

Having a social and political system that is seen to be dysfunctional or unjust works against us. We must work to make our systems just and effective and be perceived as such.

5 comments

What Price GM?

Before I comment on Steve Rattner’s op-ed in the New York Times on GM’s decision to stop producing electric vehicles in the United States, I should probably repeat my opinion of the man himself. I think that Steve Rattner is a Democratic Party rainmaker without the knowledge, experience, or temperament to conduct serious negotiations with GM or Chrysler back in 2009 but excellent credentials to be a messenger boy between the auto industry and the Obama Administration. Occam’s Razor suggests that was indeed his role. The problem with the Obama Administration’s handling of the near-collapse of the domestic auto industry was that it had, as an old friend of mine might have put it, too many oars in the water. One of those oars was electric vehicles.

This statement from the op-ed startled me:

Moves toward electric vehicles, in particular, will vastly change the types of factories and workers that G.M. needs.

Maybe I’m naive but what moves? GM’s sales of EVs (all models) have tanked. They aren’t increasing the way sales projections have thought they would. To my eye any bumps in EV sales have been produced by Tesla. Tesla has proved that, if an automaker produces a stylish vehicle and sells it at a loss, they can sell as many as they can produce. More. Exciting news. Also, you can sell as many quarters at a nickel a piece as you care to.

Increases in worldwide sales of EVs are largely due to sales in China. China uses and produces a lot of EVs. It’s amazing what you can in a command economy. China’s motives are clear: they want to reduce oil imports, at this point their largest category of imports.

In the United States EVs are likely to remain what they have been: a niche product.

When Mr. Rattner writes this:

Mr. Trump’s responses to G.M.’s decision also miss the mark. He called on G.M. to close one of its plants in China, even though G.M. doesn’t import a meaningful number of cars from there. He said G.M. should no longer have access to incentives to stimulate electric car production, which would simply damage the government’s effort to make the industry more competitive by spurring investment in new technologies.

I suspect he doesn’t understand the big picture. IMO Trump’s not trying to curb imports of Chinese EVs. He wants China to import EVs. I don’t think that’s going to happen for reasons I’ve suggested above.

Here’s the balance of Mr. Rattner’s piece:

In addition, the American government should increase spending on education and training and finally begin that the long-delayed infrastructure initiative. We need to foster Americans’ pioneer spirit, and encourage them to move to where the jobs are.

For some Americans, it’s too late for retraining or relocation. They deserve a stronger social safety net, including programs to reduce the tendency to turn to alcohol and opioids.

or, in other words, he thinks we can educate workers to take the mid-level jobs that aren’t being produced and give the increasing numbers of unemployed and unemployable health care. At the end of this process we’ll have highly compensated educators and health care providers and millions of bored unemployed people.

It sounds to me as though he wants to manage the decline rather than produce a recovery.

14 comments

Vital?

In response to Mike Pompeo’s op-ed in the Wall Street Journal:

The kingdom is a powerful force for stability in the Middle East. Saudi Arabia is working to secure Iraq’s fragile democracy and keep Baghdad tethered to the West’s interests, not Tehran’s. Riyadh is helping manage the flood of refugees fleeing Syria’s civil war by working with host countries, cooperating closely with Egypt, and establishing stronger ties with Israel. Saudi Arabia has also contributed millions of dollars to the U.S.-led effort to fight Islamic State and other terrorist organizations. Saudi oil production and economic stability are keys to regional prosperity and global energy security.

Saudi Arabia is acting in what it perceives are its own interests and will continue to do so regardless of what we do or do not do. It is working to destabilize countries with Shi’ite majorities or minorities with power. It funds Al Qaeda. It funds Wahhabi mosques all over the world where hatred against us and our way of life is preached on a daily basis. They are not our friends. They aren’t even frenemies.

To whatever extent our relationship with KSA is vital we should take steps to change that. We shouldn’t have had “vital” relationships with Nazi Germany, the Soviet Union, or China under Mao, either. There are tolerable authoritarian governments and intolerable ones. The Saudi government has become intolerable.

14 comments

Reminder

I continue to be satisfied to let the Mueller investigation run its course. I’m impatient as I presume nearly everyone who isn’t the Red Queen or doesn’t want a guerrilla theater version of The Trial is.

4 comments

Make Your Views On Immigration Clear

Today I find myself somewhat uncomfortably in at least partial agreement with Thomas Friedman. His most recent New York Times column is about immigration policy and the factors underpinning mass immigration. Here’s the part with which I agree:

The first is a way to think about the border and the second is a way to think about all the issues beyond the border — issues that are pushing migrants our way. You cannot think seriously about the first without thinking seriously about the second, and if you don’t, this week’s scenes of Customs and Border Protection officers firing tear gas to keep out desperate migrants near Tijuana will get a lot worse.

Regarding the border, the right place for Democrats to be is for a high wall with a big gate.

I also agree with something else he implies in his column. The Democratic leadership should make their views on the border and on immigration clear. For years they’ve been engaging in strategic ambiguity, willing neither to embrace or reject open borders because they know that either position will lose votes. Their apologists are engaging in sophistry, saying in effect that if they don’t say right out in so many words that they are opposed to open borders it’s terribly unfair to suggest they are. The opposite is the case. If they don’t say they’re against open borders, won’t support enforcing our laws, and have suggested that they are at least uncomfortable with enforcing our laws, e.g. “I don’t believe in borders” or “we should abolish ICE”, deducing that they quietly support open borders is completely reasonable.

I disagree with this:

But the country won’t do as well as it can in the 21st century unless it remains committed to a very generous legal immigration policy — and a realistic pathway to citizenship for illegals already here — to attract both high-energy, low-skilled workers and high-I.Q. risk takers.

The emphasis is mine. I think that Mr. Friedman is living in the past. Wages for unskilled workers have been stagnant or declining for decades. Here in Chicago a family of four (two adults, two children) must earn at least the median income for a family four or they will be a net burden. That translates to both adults working full-time and earning at least $15/hour. Many unskilled workers, regardless of energy, will not receive that income. They are not assets. They are liabilities and drive down the wages of other unskilled workers.

In today’s American economy unskilled workers are not a necessity but a luxury. I think we should continue to admit a certain number of unskilled immigrants—those who are legitimate refugees. Those are a very small minority of the total number of unskilled workers that enter the U. S. annually. In short we need an immigration policy that much more closely resembles those of Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, other “nations of immigrants”, than they do our present policies.

He also dwells at considerable length on Venezuela and on climate change. While I think that lack of resources, inadequate capital investment, disease, and overpopulation are all significant problems for developing countries, their most serious and challenging problem is bad government. Venezuelans brought their present circumstances on themselves. Mr. Friedman can’t bring himself to draw the unavoidable and terrible conclusion. Either Venezuelans have no right of emigration (something recognized by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights) or there are limits to their sovereignty and the other countries of their region should have stepped in long ago in self-defense.

6 comments

Snarl Words

A “snarl word” is a word or phrase applied to a person, people, or belief to dismiss it in a derogatory fashion. We have all heard some of them used that way. You can find a list of snarl words here. The opposite of a snarl word is a “glittering generality”.

In my writing and in my speech I attempt to eschew agonistic forms of expression, either pro or con. I attempt to use the technically correct and apt terms. Le mot juste.

But I don’t think it’s possible any more to avoid snarl words or glittering generalities completely. If that list is any gauge anything you might say is a snarl word to somebody.

2 comments

Welcome to Dystopia

As you may know the word “utopia” was coined by Thomas More. It is from the Greek and literally means “a good place”. The opposite of utopia is dystopia and recently we’ve been treated to a rash of dystopian future both in works of fact and fiction.

In his New York Times column David Brooks paints a picture of the present and the very near future that I find dystopian in the extreme. Here’s a snippet:

Two great belief systems are clashing here. The older liberals tend to be individualistic and meritocratic. A citizen’s job is to be activist, compassionate and egalitarian. Boomers generally think they earned their success through effort and talent.

The younger militants tend to have been influenced by the cultural Marxism that is now the lingua franca in the elite academy. Group identity is what matters. Society is a clash of oppressed and oppressor groups. People who are successful usually got that way through some form of group privilege and a legacy of oppression.

The big generational clashes generally occur over definitions of professional excellence. The older liberals generally believe that the open exchange of ideas is an intrinsic good. Older liberal journalists generally believe that objectivity is an important ideal. But for many of the militants, these restraints are merely masks for the preservation of the existing power structures. They offer legitimacy to people and structures that are illegitimate.

When the generations clash, the older generation generally retreats. Nobody wants to be hated and declared a moral pariah by his or her employees. Nobody wants to seem outdated. If the war is between the left and Trumpian white nationalism, nobody wants to be seen siding with Trump.

Plus, the militants have more conviction. In the age of social media, virtue is not defined by how compassionately you act. Virtue is defined by how vehemently you react to that which you find offensive. Virtue involves the self-display of a certain indignant sensibility, and anybody who doesn’t display that sensibility is morally suspect.

He then turns to the generation gap on the right and it’s equally depressing if not more so.

Let me offer my own dystopian prediction. I think that in the coming years we’ll be seeing an increasing number of young people in Europe and North American converting to Islam. It provides the certitude and stability presently lacking in other belief systems.

Most imams in the United States are Saudis. If you like the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, you’ll love what is coming.

7 comments

Animal Dispirits

Do you believe that President Obama “saved the economy”? Quoting long-time econblogger Brad DeLong, Robert Samuelson in his Washington Post column, replies:

Not so fast, objects economist J. Bradford DeLong of the University of California at Berkeley. “Fifty years from now, historians will . . . write that President Franklin Roosevelt, Congress and the Federal Reserve provided a collective policy response that was, if not optimal, at least respectable. . . . By contrast, they will [argue] that the responses of President Barack Obama, Congress and the Federal Reserve did not come up to the standard [set by] the mid-1930s policy-makers.”

Could DeLong be correct? The answer matters, because if he’s right, the economy — despite its present strength — faces a future of long-term sluggishness.

Writing in the Milken Institute Review, an economics journal, DeLong accepts the conventional wisdom that the rapid response to the Great Recession by both the Federal Reserve and Congress — the Fed lowered short-term interest rates to near zero, and Congress passed a huge stimulus package of spending increases and tax cuts — prevented a second Great Depression. But his praise stops there.

We are now 11 years removed from the beginning of the crisis in 2007, and income per worker has risen only 7.5 percent, DeLong notes. By contrast, income per worker rose 10.5 percent in the 11 years following the 1929 stock-market crash.

What explains the gap, he argues, is a psychological hangover from the Great Recession. Consumers and businesses are more cautious, and the despondency is likely to persist. He writes:

“We are haunted by our Great Recession in a sense that our predecessors were not haunted by the Great Depression. . . . No unbiased observer projects anything other than slow growth, much slower than the years during and after World War II. Nobody is forecasting that the haunting will cease — that the shadow left from the Great Recession will lift.”

I don’t think that’s quite accurate. What I think is closer to the truth are:

  • The GWB Administration and the Federal Reserve had already taken the steps necessary to prevent a Great Depression 2 by the end of 2008.
  • While it is possible that the ARRA and the various phases of quantitative easing put in place by the Federal Reserve prevented a second dip, IMO it is more likely that they only served to improve the fortunes of certain favored constituencies and had a negligible effect on the greater economy.
  • After the ARRA the Obama Administration turned its attention beyond the economy and never really returned to it.
  • Imposing the largest tax increase on the working poor in American history as happened at the end of 2012 was unwise.

As I have said for over a year, I disagreed with the Trump Administration’s decrease in the personal income tax for the simple reason that I don’t think that slow economic growth in the U. S. has been caused by a shortfall in personal consumption but by inadequate domestic business investment over the period of the last 18 years. However, if there is one thing that should be unarguable at this point, it has been demonstrated that it is possible for the U. S. economy to grow at a rate faster than 2%, something repeatedly denied previously.

What I think what actually happened was a sort of one-two punch. The Obama Administration could not promote faster growth because of the limitations of its own ideological framework and because of the opposing policies of the Fed. What we should be doing is decentralizing, cutting business taxes, cutting payroll taxes, and streamlining federal regulations. What is likely to happen is increased business taxes (under the rubric of “paying their fair share”), increasing payroll taxes (in the name of “saving Social Security”), promoting consumer spending (mostly on goods produced in China and health care), and increasing the deadweight loss of government generally.

7 comments