Who Knows Best?

This piece by Daniel DiMartino at RealClearPolicy sounds a number of themes near and dear to my heart:

In the wake of a recent Congressional Budget Office (CBO) report that revealed that federal highway spending could face a 30 percent cut after 2021, Democrats and Republicans are rallying together around infrastructure. Many members of Congress now agree on raising the gas tax or indebting the nation to pay for increased infrastructure spending. Meanwhile, President Trump has endorsed a gas tax increase to pay for his $200 billion infrastructure plan. But Congress should not pass some massive spending bill to try and solve America’s infrastructure problem — it should empower states to fix it themselves, and drastically reduce the federal role in highway funding.

Just to enumerate a few…

  1. The federal government has a legitimate role in genuinely interstate travel, e.g. bridges across rivers that border states. It does not have a legitimate role in commuter roads or transport.
  2. People are more likely to make prudent judgments when they foot the bill themselves.
  3. Lower federal taxes could create more “head room” for increased state and local taxes.
  4. The experience in some states, e.g. Missouri, clearly demonstrates that people are willing to tax themselves to pay for things that they want.
  5. Centralizing decision-making infantilizes state and local governments.
  6. The Mass Transit Account is just one of the thousands of ways in which suburban and rural Americans subsidize citydwellers.

As me auld mither used to say we can afford anything we want but we can’t afford everything we want.

8 comments

The Incredible Shrinking State

The editors of the Chicago Tribune are alarmed that Illinois continues to shrink:

When he takes office in January, Gov.-elect J.B. Pritzker will have fewer constituents than he might have expected. Unfortunately he’ll also have fewer constituents working and paying taxes to support Illinois’ state and local governments. Every time a worker departs, the tax burden on those of us who remain grows.

The release on Wednesday of new census data about Illinois was alarming: Not only has the flight of citizens continued for a fifth straight year, but the population loss is intensifying. This year’s estimated net reduction of 45,116 residents is the worst of these five losing years.

and

Why are so many people departing? Certainly some leave because they don’t like winter weather, or summer humidity, we suppose. But the trail out West or to down South is well worn. There’s nothing new about Sun Belt migration, and indeed, the story in Illinois is that for decades a steady, fairly predictable number of Illinois residents left for other places. Over the past few decades, about 65,000 more people voluntarily left the state each year than arrived. It was neither shocking nor worrisome.

The change came in 2014. That year, with the Great Recession well over, the domestic migration shortfall jumped from 68,204 to 93,704. The negative number jumped again in 2015 (106,544) and again in 2016 (109,941). In 2017, more exodus: 114,779. And now in 2018, Illinois lost another 114,154 people. If you’ve read our editorials about what we call the “Illinois Exodus,” you’ve met many of these people and absorbed their families’ stories. They include young people who will build their futures elsewhere, far from the families who raised them and hoped to keep them close.

Many of them left because they believed Illinois is headed in the wrong direction. Because Illinois politicians have raised taxes, milked employers and created enormous public indebtedness that the pols want to address with … still more taxation.

Consider, too, the implications for a diminished Illinois in Congress. When Madigan was born 76 years ago, Illinois boasted 27 seats in the U.S. House. Yet in recent decades as the growth-squelching, hostile-to-employers agenda of Springfield has driven people to economically friendlier states, that number has plummeted to 18. In the next reapportionment, after the 2020 census, that number surely will drop to 17. Wednesday’s news of continuing population decline here increases the chance the Illinois’ U.S. House delegation instead will shrink to 16.

Left unmentioned: the median income of those departing is higher than the median income of those remaining.

The weather in Illinois didn’t suddenly become worse in 2014 and I’ve been to Texas. It does not have better weather than Illinois. Illinois isn’t losing population to Texas because of Texas’s benign climate other than its business and tax climates.

Illinois cannot tax and borrow its way to prosperity. The reason is simple mathematics: the debt must be serviced by fewer, poorer people than those by whom it was incurred.

J. B. Pritzker was elected on a platform of increased spending and the probably elusive goal of creating a graduated income tax here, something that would require that the state’s constitution be amended.

6 comments

All the President’s Neocons

All of the interventionists, neocons, and anyone else promoting the advancement of American interests through war over the period of the last 30 years have been condemning the announcement that the U. S. would be withdrawing its small force from Syria. The editors of the Washington Post are pretty typical of the lot:

PRESIDENT TRUMP’S sudden move to yank U.S. troops out of Syria undermined at a stroke several foreign policy goals he has championed. The president promised to finish the job of destroying the Islamic State, but the withdrawal will leave thousands of its fighters still in place. He vowed to roll back Iran’s aggression across the Middle East, but his decision will allow its forces to entrench in the country that is the keystone of Tehran’s ambitions. He promised to protect Israel, but that nation will now be left to face alone the buildup by Iran and its proxies along its northern border.

as are the editors of the Wall Street Journal:

Mr. Trump inherited a mess in Syria, and by the time he took office it was far more difficult to enforce a no-fly zone to protect opponents of the Bashar Assad regime. But the U.S. presence in northeastern Syria amounted to a de facto no-fly zone that allowed the Kurdish and Arab Syrian Democratic Forces to clear out as many ISIS cells as possible. Keeping 2,500 forces in northeast Syria to continue this work is hardly an exorbitant commitment. It is not nation-building.

The stakes are also larger than ISIS. Mr. Trump made his withdrawal decision soon after a phone call with Turkey’s Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, who has been threatening to attack the Kurds in Syria. Trump officials insist they aren’t abandoning our allies, but the SDF will now have to make its own survival calculations in striking deals with Mr. Erdoğan, Mr. Assad and his Russian and Iranian backers.

Withdrawing U.S. troops greatly reduces U.S. influence on a diplomatic solution to the Syrian civil war. The U.S. can complain at the United Nations, and it can block money for rebuilding the country, but facts on the ground count for far more. That’s especially true for Iran, which is turning southern Syria into a forward operating base against Israel.

while those who are more skeptical of spreading democracy at the point of a gun are holding their peace. Those who have argued we have a grave moral obligation to remove a criminal like Assad have a better case but I note, perhaps pettily, that their sense of obligation does not extend to taking up arms themselves or foregoing other goals they desire in the interest of that obligation. My own view is that however criminal Assad and the Alawite regime he represents, every other real alternative is worse. If your interest is the people of Syria, you should want the conflict there to end as quickly as possible which means either aiding the Russians and Iranians or simply standing aside to let them complete their task.

Those concerned for the Kurds in our absence should recognize that the Turks are not our friends and have not been our friends for 15 years. No Islamist government should be considered a NATO member and how anyone could think anything else astonishes me.

6 comments

Who Cares?

At Ricochet James Pethokoukis warns us to prepare for an America with an economy growing faster than we might expect:

What might things be like in, say, 2040? The expert consensus predicts the same old, same old economic growth, about the same pace as we’ve seen throughout the 2000s. A (maybe, nearly, hopefully) 2 percent economy. Real GDP will likely grow at about half the pace of what it did in the last half of the 20th century.

And there are good reasons for this forecast, a combo of demographics (an aging society with lower birthrates) and weak productivity growth. On that latter point, the Robert Gordon argument laid out in “The Rise and Fall of American Growth” represents the baseline in mainstream thinking. All the low-hanging fruit of innovation has been picked. New inventions like the iPhone and even autonomous vehicles pale against the old such as electrification and the combustion engine. Sorry, Millennials.

But what if the future is already here, just not widely distributed? What if artificial intelligence and advanced robotics spread throughout the economy and improve, boosting worker productivity and economic growth and incomes? How about a 1990s-style tech boom that keeps on booming? That’s just the optimistic prediction of the consultancy Capital Economics, as outlined in its first long-term forecast.

My answer to that is who cares? Let’s do a little thought experiment.

Imagine that just one person, say Bill Gates, in the United States’s income rises by a trillion dollars over the next 20 years and everybody else’s stayed the same. Most of the money stays in the financial system, a lot is spent on good works outside the U. S., and a little leaks into the U. S. economy.

Good for him but it doesn’t mean much to me one way or another. That’s the extreme case.

Now look at the graph at the top of this post. That’s the Gini index, a measure of income inequality, in the U. S. over time. It has been going up—meaning incomes are becoming less equal over time. When I was a kid it resembled that of most Western European countries. Now it’s more like Saudi Arabia’s.

My answer to Mr. Pethokoukis is that a growing economy is great but not nearly enough. We need a society in which the income is spread around a little more evenly and there’s no obvious way to get there.

My point is that there is a perceptual component to economic growth and my advice to the top .1% of income earners to whom most of the incremental income is accruing is that it’s in your interest for other people to feel that they have a greater stake in economic growth.

8 comments

What I Was Complaining About

A week or so ago I complained about the increasing level of crime in my neighborhood. Here’s an example of what I was talking about from ABC 7 Chicago:

SKOKIE, Ill. (WLS) — A pair of carjackings this week in Chicago’s suburbs have police on alert.

The latest incident occurred Tuesday. Police are still looking for five suspects at the center of a crime spree that began with a stolen car in west suburban Elmhurst and then a retail theft at Old Orchard Mall in north suburban Skokie.

It was there were the suspects stole another car at gunpoint from a 13-year-old student and her mother in the Niles North High School parking lot, fled, then crashed the second vehicle and set it on fire.

Police said just before 1 p.m. they were alerted to a retail theft at the Nordstrom in Old Orchard Center. Witnesses told police they saw five males running out of the store carrying purses.

Police said those suspects got into a stolen silver Audi and tried to flee, but crashed into another vehicle on the west side of the mall.

Elmhurst police said the silver Audi had been stolen from the 800-block of North Addison Street. Police said the keys had been left in the ignition, and the owner left a loaded .380 caliber handgun in the car.

Police said the suspects abandoned the Audi and at least one ran to the parking lot of Niles North High School where they stole a Jeep at gunpoint.

“I just thought, is this real? Is this actually happening? Why did this happen to us?” said the 13-year-old girl inside the car. ABC7 Eyewitness News is protecting her identity.

The girl spoke to ABC7 with her parents about the encounter that left her shaken.

“He came up to my mom and started pulling her out of the car, telling her to get out and leave everything. He was pointing a gun at her head,” the girl said.

The girl and her mother had just left a meeting when they were met by the gunman.

“I was yelling at the guy to don’t hurt her,” she said. “I thought, is he going to kill her? Is he going to kill me?”

Police described that suspect as a black male, over 6 feet tall, with a thin build and who was bald and wearing a black coat. Police did not release descriptions of any of the other suspects.

The stolen Jeep then picked up the rest of the suspects before fleeing southbound on Interstate 94. Police found the car in a parking lot near Cicero Avenue and Peterson Avenue in Chicago, abandoned and apparently set on fire.

Destroyed in the backseat were the girl’s book bag full of school supplies and the computer she uses for class.

“He took everything that we had and just burned it all,” she said. “The only good thing is that he let me go and didn’t just kill me right there.”

The burning car was abandoned a block and a half from my house. The culprits are still at large.

That same parking lot was the scene of a carjacking a week or so ago. There had been a previous carjacking two blocks north of me. There have been several armed robberies and an increasing number of burglaries.

We pay the highest property taxes in Chicago while the values of our houses haven’t increased in 20 years.

I’ve already told you about the mismanaged road repairs in our neighborhood. I’m beginning to think that Chicago doesn’t want us. It isn’t just the taxes. It’s not receiving value for what we’re paying.

4 comments

Why Are French Farmers Unhappy?

In his latest New York Times column Tom Friedman worries about the fate of the European Union:

On Nov. 24, The Guardian published an illuminating collection of voices from Yellow Vest protesters in Paris that told their stories. There was Florence, 55, who worked for an airfreight company outside Paris, who said of Macron, “When he appears on television we have the impression he is uncomfortable with normal people, that there is a certain contempt for us.”

There was Bruno Binelli, 66, a retired carpenter from Lyon, reacting to Macron’s raising the taxes on diesel to combat climate change, leading to fuel costs that hit people in the countryside particularly hard because they have only cars to get around: “I have a little diesel van and I don’t have the money to buy a new one, especially as I’m about to retire. We have the feeling those from the countryside are forgotten.”

And there was Marie Lemoine, 62, a schoolteacher from Provins, who said she was neither “right or left,” explaining: “ I’m here for my children and grandchildren and all those people left crying by the 15th of the month because they’ve gone into the red. … Macron is our Louis XVI, and we know what happened to him. He ended up at the guillotine.”

It is going to take extraordinary leadership for the U.S., Britain and the E.U. to come up with a strategy for these grievances.

It has to balance the need for economic growth and redistribution, the need to take care of those who have been left behind without burdening future generations, the need for free-flowing borders to attract new talent and ideas, and the need to prevent people from feeling like strangers in their own homes.

But that leadership is not present. I get why a slim majority of U.K. citizens voted for Brexit — as it was sold to them. They were told they could curb all the stuff they didn’t like — such as a flood of 2.2 million foreign E.U. workers — and still keep all the stuff they liked — mainly Britain’s free access to the E.U. market — and give up nothing. But it was all a lie.

Let me fill in a little background. Through what’s called the Common Agricultural Policy French and other farmers receive a subsidy from the EU. Indeed, the entire pretext for the Eu has always been to subsidize French farmers and give German manufacturers larger markets. That’s how the cats were herded.

The graph at the top of the page illustrates the subsidies minus taxes by country. The CAP subsidizes have been flat for decades. The recent increases in taxes in France in particular were the difference between continuing to receive a net subsidy and no effective subsidy. Add that expansion into Eastern Europe left France with a lot more competition from within the EU. For years I’ve been saying that I didn’t understand how French farmers were going to survive admitting Romania to the EU. Nearly 30% of the Romanian labor force are farmers and Romanian exports have been growing sharply.

Mr. Friedman is right to worry. Unless the Germans are willing to increase the subsidies, and let’s face it, the German tail is wagging the European dog, the rural French population will be increasingly unhappy with the present arrangement. The entire thing was a house of cards but it’s been that way from the beginning.

2 comments

Is There An Immigration Compromise on the Horizon?

The observations in Jason L. Riley’s Wall Street Journal column approximate my own views on border security and immigration:

A wall would have some deterrent effect but probably not much, and critics are correct when they argue that there are better ways to spend border-enforcement dollars. Today, the majority of people who settle in the U.S. without authorization arrive legally and then overstay their visas. According to a Center for Migration Studies report last year, these “overstays” have outnumbered illegal entries every year for the past decade—a problem more fencing doesn’t address. Still, Bismarck was right: Politics is “the art of possible, the attainable,” and a wall may be what is necessary to advance immigration reform while Donald Trump is president, or even after he’s left office.

A national Bipartisan Policy Center survey on immigration released in July concluded that the “consensus set of immigration policies that Americans support is more to the right than many realize.” “Most Americans believe that the current system is broken, out of control, and antiquated,” reads the summary. “They don’t feel that anyone is controlling the process or supervising who enters the country legally, and they think that insecure borders make it easier for people to come to the United States illegally.”

Moreover, a larger percentage of survey respondents approved of a wall (48%) than disapproved (41%), which is consistent with other recent polling on the enforcement of immigration laws. A Quinnipiac University poll from April asked, “Do you think that undocumented immigrants illegally crossing the border with Mexico is an important problem, or not?” Seventy-one percent of respondents said yes.

Note that this was before the country witnessed mobs of Central American migrants rushing the border trying to force their way in. The bottom line is that a majority of voters have views on border security that are much closer to Mr. Trump’s than many liberals want to admit. The Democrats ignore these concerns at their own peril. Ask Mrs. Clinton.

It also precedes the recent deaths of children taken into custody by ICE. I don’t know whether opinion has shifted or will shift.

Where I disagree with Mr. Riley is that there is any compromise to be had on immigration and border security. I think that the Democrats, particularly the House Democrats, will reject any plan that doesn’t include something that is effectively amnesty for people already in the country illegally and Republicans will reject any plan that could be characterized as amnesty. It’s an impasse. It has been an impasse for decades. It will remain an impasse.

The immigration reform that was enacted in 1986 amounted to legalization now, enforcement later. Events have demonstrated that we can reasonably conclude that was ineffective. It ran afoul of moral hazard and employers were able to escape punishment for hiring workers without legal status because all that was required of them was plausible deniability.

Our present policy such as it is is gravely immoral. The continuing, reasonably dependable supply of new workers who will work for minimum wage or less keeps wages low for native-born Americans, particularly blacks, and previous cohorts of immigrants. It also enables business models depending on these continuing low wages. It’s one of the reasons for increasing income inequality. Our present inability to arrive at any compromise is a tragedy.

1 comment

Doomed From the Start

In his Wall Street Journal column Walter Russell Mead muses over the decline of “human rights diplomacy”:

Think back to 2011, when President Obama knew where the arc of history was headed and planned to steer American policy accordingly. As the Arab Spring toppled Hosni Mubarak, Ben Rhodes told reporters the administration believed “there is not going to be a return to the way things were in Egypt.” The people had spoken, tyranny was broken, and Egyptian democracy was here to stay.

Those were heady times. Recep Tayyip Erdogan was creating an “Islamist democracy” in Turkey. Aung San Suu Kyi was being compared to Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela for her reformist advocacy in Burma.

Also in 2011, the “international community” proposed a new concept to change the way the world worked: the “responsibility to protect.” The U.S. intervention in Libya, we were told, established a new principle in international law that dictators could no longer massacre their people with impunity.

This sunny worldview couldn’t long withstand the cold realities of geopolitics. After Libya, Mr. Obama’s appetite for human-rights interventions diminished abruptly. Here he was reflecting public sentiment. Americans still believed in human rights and democracy, but they had lost confidence in the ability of policy experts to advance these principles effectively on the world stage.

Let me answer Dr. Mead. The effort was doomed from the start. Here in the United States, increasingly ruled by Hamiltonians, we have Wilsonians who, unlike the progressive interventionists of the first part of the 20th century which rose from the missionary tradition, urge promoting American values at the points of guns wielded by someone else while actually profiting from it, the guns are actually being wielded by Jacksonians who deeply resent the constraints being placed on them by the Wilsonians and Hamiltonians, in a country that would promote its putative values more effectively with a Jeffersonian strategy of practicing them at home while wishing the promoters of liberal democracy outside our borders well without insisting on being their vindicators.

It is much harder to practice one thing while preaching another than it used to be. People in far away countries have videocameras in their mitts, too, and what happens a world away will be shown on the Internet in all its horror before you can mount a propaganda campaign. And we have plenty of enemies who will rejoice in the opportunity of bringing our flaws into the light of day.

1 comment

Everything Old

In an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal Michael Mukasey points out an unexpected intersection between present day feminism and the foundations of 20th century Islamist radicalism:

In the 1940s, an Egyptian writer and Education Ministry employee harshly criticized the government under King Farouk as insufficiently Islamic. That writer, Sayyid Qutb, was rewarded with a traveling fellowship, apparently to get him out of the country.

Qutb arrived at Colorado State College of Education in Greeley in 1948. He didn’t much like it. “I stayed there six months and never did I see a person or a family actually enjoying themselves,” he wrote. Even gardening drew his contempt: “There is nothing behind this activity in the way of beauty or artistic taste. It is the machinery of organization and arrangement, devoid of spirituality and aesthetic enjoyment.”

But contempt curdled into revulsion when Qutb dropped in on a church dance that followed a service—a shocking juxtaposition in itself: “The dance hall convulsed to the tunes on the gramophone and was full of bounding feet and seductive legs. . . . Arms circled waists, lips met lips, chests met chests, and the atmosphere was full of passion.”

The song that was playing: “Baby, It’s Cold Outside.” For Qutb, it epitomized the West’s moral degradation. He condemned the “animal-like mixing of the sexes,” concluded that Americans were “numb to faith in art, faith in religion, and faith in spiritual values altogether,” and determined that Islam would have to be perpetually at war with such a society.

He went back to Egypt, quit the civil service, joined the Muslim Brotherhood, and eventually became the organization’s spiritual leader.

I don’t have a lot to add to that. I mostly just wanted to point it out.

“Baby, It’s Cold Outside” began as a novelty number, written by Frank Loesser,creator of the Broadway Guys and Dolls, The Most Happy Fella, and How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying, as something that he and his wife, Lynn Garland, would perform together at parties. It caught on. It bears a resemblance to earlier vaudeville numbers. My grandfather’s vaudeville act included a similar song which I still have committed to memory. The very slightly naughty quality has been popular during all but the most puritanical periods.

I guess we’re entering one of those now although with all of the sex and nudity in popular entertainment that’s hard to believe.

5 comments

The Factors Unspoken

I’m surprised that Robert Samuelson doesn’t mention two reasons for the Federal Reserve to continue bringing interest rates closer to normal in his column in the Washington Post on how the Fed should react to recent developments:

The current job expansion is an important venture in social policy. People who were tossed out of the labor market are returning, along with many who were never in the market. This may have long-term benefits. If the Fed is too aggressive in fighting weak inflation and mild speculation, it might kill the recovery and sacrifice these gains.

On the other hand, the Fed could become too concerned with a recovery. Throughout history, the Fed has been prone to overstay episodes of easy money and loose credit. By the time this is obvious, the damage has already occurred. Inflation has accelerated, or speculation has become widespread. The economy then enters a long stretch of poor performance.

The first unstated reason is that with the present continuing low interest rates the Fed doesn’t give the Fed much leeway in the case of an economic downturn. This is all the more astounding since econpundits have been harping on it for most of the last decade. Apparently, it’s suddenly become uninteresting.

But second persistent low interest rates have generally injured savers, particularly elder savers who are necessarily risk averse. I would hope that interest rates held under 2% for a decade would disabuse critics of the notion that most people actually able to save for their own retirements. Only those in the two decile of income earners have that luxury and not all of those.

5 comments