Dissociation

James Montier of GMO delivers a sobering assessment of the stock market:

In order to believe that U.S. equities are going to generate a “normal” return from these levels, you have to believe some quite extraordinary things. Perhaps you believe that P/Es are going to soar to levels not even seen at the height of the TMT bubble; or perhaps you believe that profitability is going to rise (from already extended levels) so that every firm in the U.S. looks like a FAANG stock; or perhaps you believe that growth is simply going to reach unprecedented levels. We, however, are not so prone to flights of fancy that require multi standard deviation outcomes. Unless you believe one of these extreme scenarios, you should be skeptical about the ability of the U.S. market to continue its outstanding performance. Ask yourself how much exposure you have to the U.S. stock market. Then ask yourself what is the minimum amount you could own. We at GMO own essentially zero in our unconstrained portfolios, but then again we are used to career risk and would rather run it than allocate to such an expensive and risky asset.

It’s full of interesting and thought-provoking insights, not the least of which is that over the years there has been a dramatic transition from institutions being the primary purchasers of equities to households (including mutual funds) to the present situation in which non-financial companies are the primary purchasers of stocks.

That’s an example of what I’ve have complained about from time to time around here. Who’s minding the store? I understand the motives behind large companies transforming themselves into stock-trading companies. But it’s no foundation for an economy.

2 comments

1-2-3 What Are We Fighting For?

Read this article at the Washington Post by Aaron David Miller and Richard Sokolsky:

But it should have been clear by now to Graham, Rubio and anyone else that Moscow and Tehran had long ago won the strategic fight for Syria. Russian military intervention in 2015 saved Assad and secured long-term military basing rights for the Russian military. As Steven Cook observed in July, Syria is “the centerpiece and pivot of Russia’s strategy to reassert itself as a global power.” Iran, in its long-term effort to gain regional power and further its proxy war against, among others, rival Saudi Arabia, has lent Assad the assistance of the Iranian military and Iran-backed Shiite militias. Though a predominantly Sunni country like Saudi Arabia, Turkey shares Shiite-dominated Iran’s goal of thwarting anything that bolsters Kurdish autonomy, including close military cooperation between the U.S. military and Kurdish forces in Syria and Iraq.

To achieve their ends, Russia and Iran have been more willing to devote resources toward keeping Assad afloat than the U.S. has been prepared to either remove him from power or stand behind the assorted elements in Syria who’ve tried and so far failed to overthrow him. There are valid reasons for U.S. reticence, but Americans should let go of the idea that we were ever trying very hard to win.

and explain to me why we should be building up our forces in Syria let alone keeping them there.

12 comments

Views of Inequality

There is also an interesting article at New Scientist, from which the graph above was sampled, on inequality:

The dislike of economic inequality supposedly runs deep in human psychology. The trait we call “inequality aversion” emerges early in development and is found across many cultures, from city dwellers in the US to villagers in Peru and Uganda.

Laboratory studies confirm that inequality aversion is a strong motivator of behaviour. For example, when people are asked to divide money among themselves and fellow subjects in experiments, they have a clear preference for equal distribution. This desire for equality is so powerful that people often choose to receive smaller but more equal rewards over larger but more unequal ones, and in other cases prefer surplus resources to be thrown away rather than distributed unequally.

There is, however, a paradox. A separate body of research finds something quite different. When people are asked about the ideal distribution of wealth in their country rather than among a small group of individuals in the lab, they are actually quite relaxed about inequality.

What I think people are forgetting is that the considerable inequality of today is something that hasn’t been seen within living memory. When I was a kid things were much more like those “what they’d like to see” bars than they are like what they thinks things are or what they really are.

Here’s a significant observation:

In 1960, a chief executive in the US typically earned 20 times as much as an average worker. Today it is more like 354 times.

I refuse to believe that is due to the workings of the market or justified by productivity. I have no problem with the boss making 20 times as much as I do but I refuse to believe that he’s 15 times as productive as the bosses of 60 years ago.

I think that competition, barriers to entry, and subsidies mark the difference not any great superiority of today’s managers compared to those of long ago.

15 comments

CLOs Call

I found Carmen Reinhardt’s most recent piece in Project Syndicate thought-provoking. In it she makes a number of interesting points. First, that the spread between yields in the emerging market asset class and high-yield U. S. corporate debt is the highest in history:

Historically, there has been a tight positive relationship between high-yield US corporate debt instruments and high-yield EM sovereigns. In effect, high-yield US corporate debt is the emerging market that exists within the US economy (let’s call it USEM debt). In the course of this year, however, their paths have diverged (see Figure 1). Notably, US corporate yields have failed to rise in tandem with their EM counterparts.

What’s driving this divergence? Are financial markets overestimating the risks in EM fixed income (EM yields are “too high”)? Or are they underestimating risks in lower-grade US corporates (USEM yields are too low)?

Taking together the current trends and cycles in global factors (US interest rates, the US dollar’s strength, and world commodity prices) plus a variety of adverse country-specific economic and political developments that have recently plagued some of the larger EMs, I am inclined to the second interpretation.

The second is that a considerable volume of these U. S. corporate instruments are collateralized loan obligations:

In what is still a low-interest-rate environment globally, the perpetual search for yield has found a comparatively new and attractive source in the guise of collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) within the USEM world. According to the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, new issues of “conventional” high-yield corporate bonds peaked in 2017 and are off significantly this year (about 35% through November). New issuance activity has shifted to the CLO market, where the amounts outstanding have soared, hitting new peaks almost daily. The S&P/LSTA US Leveraged Loan 100 Index shows an increase of about 70% in early December from its 2012 lows (see Figure 2), with issuance hitting record highs in 2018. In the language of emerging markets, the USEM is attracting large capital inflows.

It should be needless to say that this is terrible news for emerging economies and what is terrible news for emerging economies has a way of provoking real world events. It may not be pretty to see.

I have made no secret of the fact that I am suspicious of, as she puts it, a world economy “geared toward increasing the supply of financial assets” without also expanding real production or even at its expense. I have explained why previously. Such an economy presents no problems as long as it does not impinge on the real world but it inevitably does.

1 comment

More on Those Nodules

At Atlantic James Hamblin touches and expands on the question I asked yesterday:

A nodule is, by definition, fewer than 3 centimeters (around an inch) in diameter. These two nodules are now gone, and there are apparently no others remaining.

But the word that makes the statement more complicated and concerning is two.

Pulmonary nodules are indeed extremely common, and most are benign. To find two malignant nodules in a person who smokes would not be especially surprising. However, if you have two separate malignant nodules in your lung and you do not smoke, doctors worry that this means they represent metastatic disease from a cancer somewhere else.

This is especially true if the patient has a history of cancer, as Ginsburg does. She had early-stage colon and pancreatic cancers removed in 1999 and 2009, respectively.

Lung nodules are generally removed when they are deemed suspicious for malignancy, meaning they either showed signs of growth or were not seen on prior oncologic screening. “Growing pulmonary nodules can be primary lung cancers, and synchronous ones do appear,” says Howard Forman, a radiologist and professor at Yale. “But in a patient with two primary known malignancies, we would need to know the pathology of the nodules before believing she is cured.”

The pathology report can tell us if the malignant cells are lung cancer—meaning a rare case of two simultaneous new lung cancers in a nonsmoker—or if they represent a recurrence of metastatic colon or pancreatic cancer, or if they are of some other origin. If this is the case, it would raise concern that although current scans showed no evidence of metastatic disease elsewhere, there could be yet-undetectable cancer cells already seeded in Ginsburg’s body.

The fact that the statement says the nodules are indeed malignant means that at least a preliminary pathology report has been done, but this crucial detail—what type of malignancy?—was either unclear or withheld from the statement. It reads only: “According to the thoracic surgeon, Valerie W. Rusch, MD, FACS, both nodules removed during surgery were found to be malignant on initial pathology evaluation.” (I emailed Rusch, who told me, “We have no additional information on the pathology at the present time.”)

Read the whole thing. This story is ongoing and will be for some time to come.

Why am I dwelling on this? If Justice Ginsburg were to die or become incapacitated, it could occasion the toughest, meanest, most divisive political battle of my lifetime. Think the last two years have been disruptive and violated norms? You ain’t heard nothin’ yet.

5 comments

Tulsi Gabbard for SecDef!

I agree with Pat Lang. Tulsi Gabbard would make a solid replacement for Gen. James Mattis as Secretary of Defense.

If for no other reason that to watch the heads spin.

Intersectionality, baby.

3 comments

When Is It Metastatic?

Yesterday I heard that Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg had undergone surgery to have two malignant growths removed from her lung and that she is doing well after surgery with no other signs of cancer. I wish Justice Ginsburg well.

Not to be a crepe hanger but that did bring up several questions for me. I’m not a doctor. I am unaware of a reliable blood enzyme test for pancreatic cancer. How do they know that her lung growths are not metastatic cancer? I know that metastatic cancer is when a cancer spreads to other organs beyond its original point of origin and is, presumably, diagnosed by the presence of certain blood enzymes. I also know that when you have had cancer once there is a slightly elevated risk for getting another, not just of the same type but of a different type.

Justice Ginsburg has now had cancer at least two and possibly three times. What is her present risk of getting cancer again?

2 comments

Mattis’s Resignation

I suppose I should comment on Gen. James Mattis’s resignation as Secretary of Defense. I thought that during his tenure as SecDef he was a welcome tonic to the often mercurial president. It was a thankless job and I’m surprised he stuck it out as long as he did. The editors of the New York Times declaimed:

Jim Mattis is stepping down as defense secretary, a day after President Trump overruled him and other top national security advisers by ordering the rapid withdrawal of all 2,000 American ground troops from Syria. Mr. Mattis, a retired four-star general, said in his letter of resignation that his views on a number of foreign policy and defense matters were fundamentally at odds with those of the president.

while the editors of the Wall Street Journal report:

On Thursday, Mr. Trump tweeted that “Getting out of Syria was no surprise” because he campaigned on it. But the abruptness of the announcement did catch his own advisers and the world by surprise. The Chairman of the Joint Chiefs, General Joseph Dunford, is widely reported to have not been consulted.

Withdrawing those 2,000 American troops from the Middle East is a significant act for which allies in the region and elsewhere needed a decent interval to prepare. Mr. Trump gave them none. The decision, which emerged after Mr. Trump’s phone call with Turkish dictator Recep Tayyip Erdogan, did earn public praise from one big beneficiary—Russia’s Vladimir Putin.

Then on Thursday Mr. Trump tweeted that Defense Secretary Jim Mattis, one of his strongest appointees, “will be retiring” in February. This landed shortly after the Journal reported that Mr. Trump may withdraw most U.S. troops from Afghanistan within weeks. Mr. Mattis’s resignation letter makes clear he is leaving because he disagrees with Mr. Trump’s treatment of allies and his impulsive decision making.

This may come as a shock to the editors but “civilian” control” means that those are the president’s decisions to make. Not the Secretary of Defense’s. Not the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. The president’s.

My advice: carpe diem. Donald Trump may be the only president with the temerity to withdraw our troops from Afghanistan or, indeed, Syria. We aren’t making progress in Afghanistan any more and it’s unclear to me whether we’re making progress in Syria or not. In Syria a “political solution” that does not include leaving the Alawite regime in place is either wishful thinking or antithetical to our interests. The Kurds know that and are highly likely to make common cause with Syria.

As Lord Palmerston put it more than a century and a half ago, we have no permanent allies, only permanent interests. Turkey has not been our ally for at least 20 years. Can any Islamist country be a reliable NATO member? I have my doubts.

4 comments

Context and Conclusion

For context, read this piece at Lawfare on the judge’s outrageous conduct during Michael Flynn’s sentencing hearing.

Conclusion:

Under statute the Supreme Court has an affirmative responsibility to discipline judges for ethics violations and bias among other things and any American has the right to bring such abuses to their attention. The rule of law and the rule of lawyers are not the same thing. You have a right to bring instances of abuse of power to the attention of the members of the Supreme Court and they have a responsibility to deal with them. At the very least judges who abuse their power should be disciplined as should Supreme Court justices who refuse to do their jobs even unpalatable parts of their jobs.

2 comments

Citizenship Is Not a Universal Human Right

Here is the peroration of Michelle Alexander’s New York Times op-ed about the terrible immorality of birthright citizenship:

It’s tempting to imagine that our position as gatekeepers is morally sound — since we’re frequently reminded that “all nations have a right to defend their borders” — but our relationship to those who are fleeing poverty and violence is morally complex. Not only does birthright citizenship bestow upon us a privileged status that we haven’t earned; our nation’s unparalleled wealth and power, as well as our actual borders, lack a sturdy moral foundation. But for slavery, genocide and colonization, we would not be the wealthiest, most powerful nation in the world — in fact, our nation would not even exist. This is not hyperbole; it’s history. There’s good reason some Mexicans say: “We didn’t cross the border. The border crossed us.” That is, in fact, what happened.

It is terribly difficult to debate someone at a distance, especially when you have so little common agreement with them about morality, law, or even language.

Let’s start with language. Here is the second definition of “earn” as thoughtfully provided by Merriam-Webster:

2a : to come to be duly worthy of or entitled or suited to
she earned a promotion
b : to make worthy of or obtain for
the suggestion earned him a promotion

Those of us born in the United States have earned citizenship in that sense by virtue of U. S. law. Those whom she cites who have entered the United States in contravention of U. S. law have not. They have committed crimes in doing so. Their guilt from those crimes may be mitigated by virtue of their motives but they are not eliminated by them. We are legally entitled to punish them for those crimes as long as we do so justly.

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which had its 70th anniversary the other day, a most expansive document, does not recognize a right of immigration. Emigration but not immigration. It also does not recognize a universal right of U. S. citizenship. Prudently, it recognizes that it is up to the governments of individual countries to determine who is a citizen and who is not. Just as Mexico may determine who is a Mexican citizen the United States may determine who is a U. S. citizen. It is not up to Americans to determine who is a Mexican citizen any more than it is up to Mexicans to determine who is an American citizen.

Two hundred years ago Mexico had acquired its territory at the time in the same way that every present country has: by seizing it by force of arms from its previous owners. The status of territory 200 years ago has no legal or moral relevance today.

Morally, we are required to treat people decently, kindly, and justly. We are not required to give them jobs or citizenship. If we are Christians, we are required to treat them in a caring way. We are not required to make them citizens or even grant them legal residency. “Render unto Caesar, etc.” We should feed them, clothe them, and care for their wounds.

Finally, neither Emma Lazarus nor Margaret Mead have any political, legal, or moral standing. Margaret Mead may have some authority in cultural anthropology but even that is a matter of some doubt. Just about everything she ever wrote has been challenged by later anthropologists.

6 comments