Legal, Moral, or Political?

After six paragraphs of throat-clearing, the editors of the Washington Post finally get around to the point they’re trying to make about the “wait in Mexico” policy with respect to those seeking to enter the United States via our southern border:

What is clear is that the United States is not absolved of responsibility for migrants legitimately seeking asylum simply because they are compelled to wait elsewhere. If asylum seekers are preyed on, exploited and harmed after having been returned to Mexico, U.S. officials will not be able to shrug off their moral responsibility. The United States is bound by law and international obligations to welcome and vet migrants fleeing persecution, and to grant asylum to those who meet specific criteria. That obligation cannot be abrogated by an announcement.

In bridge “crossruffing” is a play where tricks are made by taking alternate ruffs, playing a non-trump card to be trumped by the partner, in each hand. In this paragraph the editors are attempting to crossruff legal and moral arguments. Neither is nearly as strong as they appear to believe.

The phrase “legitimately seeking asylum” is just being coy. Anyone may legitimately seek asylum. Three-quarters or more of the applications for asylum from Central Americans or Mexicans are denied because they don’t meet the requirements for asylum, something intended for religious, racial, ethnic or political persecution. In other words when you take those who don’t even bother applying into account, the actual asylum-seekers comprise a tiny fraction of those who come here.

As to the moral argument, I’ve already made my views clear. I think we are morally obligated to treat those who come here legally or illegally decently and kindly. We are not morally obligated to allow them to remain, give them jobs, or grant them citizenship. The notion that we are morally obligated to extend that level of consideration to those who haven’t actually come here is simply incredible.

Pollsters tell us that in the Americas alone 150 million people would move here from other countries if they were given the chance. We have no moral obligation to accept them and suggesting that we do goes beyond being foolhardy.

18 comments

Stopped Clocks

At New York Magazine Andrew Sullivan reacts to the reports that we will be removing our troops from Syria and (at least some) from Afghanistan:

Neoconservatism, it seems, never dies. It just mutates constantly to find new ways to intervene, to perpetuate forever wars, to send more young Americans to die in countries that don’t want them amid populations that try to kill them. If you want the most recent proof of that, look at Yemen, where the Saudi policy of mass civilian deaths in a Sunni war on Shiites is backed by American arms and U.S. It’s also backed by American troops on the ground — in a secret war conducted by Green Berets that was concealed from Congress. There is no conceivable threat to the U.S. from the Houthi rebels in Yemen; and there was no prior congressional approval. Did you even know we had ground troops deployed there?

The same for liberal internationalism, which also never seems to die, however many catastrophes it spawns. There’s always an impending “massacre” somewhere to justify intervention, which is why we have been dutifully told that withdrawing from Syria would lead to a “slaughter” of the Kurds. Remember the massacre that gave Hillary Clinton a chance to launch another Middle Eastern war in Libya? How many more innocents were slaughtered after we toppled Qaddafi than those in danger before? And all because Clinton refused to learn a single thing from Iraq. (If Clinton had actually won in 2016, we would probably have far more troops occupying Syria today, and be digging in for the long haul, and we’d probably have even more troops in yet another doomed surge in Afghanistan. That goes some way to explaining why Clinton has a massive 31/62 negative approval rating in the latest, Democrat-friendly Quinnipiac poll, much worse than even Trump.)

The claim that being opposed to invading countries with the presumed intention of imposing liberal democracy on them at the point of a gun is isolationism is a particularly vicious canard and it’s high time that we start punching people who make that accusation in the nose. At the very least. Is there some sort of strategic tar and feathers shortage?

12 comments

The Awful Truth in Illinois

At City Journal Steve Malanga recaps outgoing Rahm Emanuel’s warning to the Chicago City Council:

The more troubling that the fiscal situation in Illinois becomes, the less levelheaded local officials sound about facing up to their problems. That was evident last week, in the reaction that incoming governor Jay Pritzker and several Chicago mayoral candidates had to a speech by outgoing Chicago mayor Rahm Emanuel on the state’s deep pension problems.

Speaking before the city council, Emanuel, who will not seek reelection, warned that raising taxes alone won’t solve the city’s own pension troubles. Emanuel has run into opposition—in the courts and in Springfield—to his efforts to cut pensions costs, and he pointed out that the city has already raised taxes several times, including a huge property-tax increase in 2016, just to cover the growing pension costs. Chicago will need more new revenue as it faces sharply higher pension payments over the next two years, including $276 million in additional annual contributions just for the city’s public-safety retirement system. Emanuel urged the state to consider sweeping fixes, including changes to the state’s constitution, and he argued that the course favored by the Democratic Party’s increasingly powerful progressive wing—to solve the problem by taxing the wealthy—endangered prosperity. “You’re going to cut jobs doing that,” Emanuel said.

Those who will soon be in charge of trying to fix the mess jumped to dismiss Emanuel’s ideas. Oversimplifying the issue, state comptroller Susana Mendoza, a candidate for mayor, said, “We do not mess with people’s pensions,” adding, “End of story.” Former city hall insider Gery Chico, also running for mayor, somewhat naively suggested that one way to fix the problem is to “figure out how to do things better,” as if saving a few dollars here and there could possibly suffice. Former federal prosecutor Lori Lightfoot likened the movement to reform pensions to pulling “the rug out from under” city employees and retirees, while incoming governor Pritzker was equally simplistic in his dismissal of Emanuel’s ideas: “I believe when you’re promised something . . . you ought to get whatever you’ve been promised.”

Much as I detest him I think that Emanuel’s warning is what any honest Illinois politician would say in private and not seeking re-election. At this point the question is not whether Illinois local and state government will go bankrupt but when and what havoc they will create along the way. As long as we hold to the state constitution’s present requirements on pensions the state’s only workable option is to drive the wages of public employees down in self-defense.

That’s not going to happen so it can only end in disaster. The only remaining question is whether the disaster will take the Democratic Party along with it.

3 comments

30 Years of Foreign Policy Failure

I presume that Stephen Walt’s piece at Foreign Policy in which his thesis is that the foreign policy blunders of the Clinton, Bush, and Obama Administrations are directly responsible for the situation in which we find ourselves and, indeed, the rise of Trump:

There is no question that Trump places little value in democracy, human rights, the rule of law, or other classic liberal values, and he seems to have a particular disregard for America’s democratic partners and a soft spot for autocrats. But it is a mistake to see him as the sole—or even the most important—cause of the travails now convulsing the U.S.-led order. Indeed, the seeds of our present troubles were sown long before Trump entered the political arena, and are in good part due to foreign-policy decisions made by the administrations of former Presidents Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, and Barack Obama.

Think back a quarter century, to the beginning of the “unipolar moment.” Having triumphed over the Soviet Union, the United States could have given itself a high-five, taken a victory lap, and adopted a grand strategy better suited to a world without a superpower rival. Rejecting isolationism, Washington could nonetheless have gradually disengaged from those areas that no longer needed significant American protection and reduced its global military footprint, while remaining ready to act in a few key areas should it become absolutely necessary. These moves would have forced our wealthiest allies to take on greater responsibility for local problems while the United States addressed pressing domestic needs. Making the “American dream” more real here at home would also have shown other nations why the values of liberty, democracy, open markets, and the rule of law were worth emulating.

will be like waving a red flag in front of a bull to many but I think he’s right. Rather than restating his piece let me give four suggestions of my own for the biggest blunders of those four successive presidents (I include George H. W. Bush).

  1. We should never have placed troops in Saudi Arabia and, if we did, we should have removed them when the emergency was over.
  2. We should never have expanded NATO.
  3. We should have integrated China into the global economy much more slowly and only as a consequence of proven reforms on the part of the Chinese authorities including political reforms.
  4. We should have conformed rigorously to the rule of law including all of our international obligations. That means no bombing of Serbia, no invasion of Iraq, no torturing of prisoners, no drone war, no bombing of the Libyan government, the list is practically endless.
3 comments

Dialect, Affect, Culture, and Racism

I was delighted to see this observation from James McWhorter at Atlantic:

Many will answer with what can be summed up with the grand old mantra, “If you’re white, you’re all right, if you’re brown, stick around, but if you’re black, get back.” The idea is that animus against black Americans—as opposed to Latinos or Asians—is so profound as to stanch striving. But that line is a tad elderly now, and the success since the 1970s of so many Caribbean and African immigrants—richly familiar with racism—has shown its obsolescence. In Ivy League institutions, typically almost half of black students come from immigrant families, despite such students representing less than 15 percent of the general black population of people their age.

That is the dirty secret of racial set-asides and preferences. Rather than going to the inner city or rural American blacks for whom they were presumably intended, far too frequently the beneficiaries of those programs have been Caribbean or African blacks. White Americans have enough sins of their own ancestors for which to atone. We should not feel that we are responsible for the sins of the English, French, and Spanish as well.

This is not a new observation. Those on the front lines of integration and desegregation pointed it out 40 years ago and were frequently shouted down.

But I was mortified to see this:

Okay, first-generation Americans have, as it’s often phrased, a “pluck” one can’t expect native-born blacks to have as often. But to insist that native-born blacks require whites’ love in a way that Nigerian newcomers do not would seem to claim weakness as a birthright.

How an intelligent, well-educated American black man can write such drivel in the 21st century baffles me. Immigrant pluck as an explanation for why some Caribbean and many African blacks prosper here while American blacks, the descendants of Southern slaves, so frequently do not is BS. The reality is that that dialect, affect, and culture make a difference. There are still some knuckle-dragging whites for whom skin color alone is all that matters but many, many more white Americans find black folk with British or Jamaican or Nigerian accents charming, superior even.

It’s not merely speech. The metalinguistic features of communication—certain non-verbal signals—that accompany Standard Black English are well-known. Things like communication distance, volume, pitch, and eye contact. And they keep black folk down.

That’s why I weep when I hear people being denounced for “acting white”. I don’t ask that American blacks act white but in order to prosper they need to communicated effectively with white folk who may have visceral reactions to SBE and its metalinguistic features.

4 comments

Question

Have any of you ever submitted a letter of resignation? What was your experience?

My experience is that once a letter of resignation has been submitted that the customary two weeks’ notice is rarely required and, indeed, that your boss probably considers you disruptive and wants you to leave as quickly as possible. Getting two months to put things in order before you leave seems naive to me.

3 comments

The World Is a Foreign Country

I agree with the editors of the Washington Post that Saudi Arabia under Mohammed Bin Salman is a strategic liability to the United States:

The larger truth is that, with Mohammed bin Salman as its de facto ruler, the kingdom has become a strategic liability to the United States. The crown prince has destabilized the region with his reckless adventurism, including the abduction of the pro-American Lebanese prime minister and a boycott of neighboring Qatar, which hosts the largest U.S. air base in the Middle East. His disastrous intervention in Yemen has strengthened Iran while triggering what the United Nations calls the world’s worst humanitarian crisis. His boasts to White House counselor Jared Kushner that he would help resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict while forming an “Arab NATO” have proved empty.

When the Saudi government tried to push up oil prices this month in contravention of Mr. Trump’s public lobbying, it was a reminder that it will pursue its own interests in producing and marketing oil, not those of any U.S. president. At the same time, Mr. Trump’s vintage-1980s view of the kingdom is contradicted by the 2018 fact that the United States, as the world’s largest crude oil producer, is less dependent than ever on the Middle East for energy. Saudi Arabia has so far failed to move the oil price and cannot seriously threaten U.S. supplies.

I disagree with them in several particulars:

  1. It isn’t new. Saudi Arabia has been a strategic liability to the United States for decades. They are the home and nurturing place for Al Qaeda. Most of those who participated in the attacks on the U. S. in 2001 were Saudis. The Saudis have dispersed Islamist Saudi imams who preach hatred for liberal values on a daily basis throughout the world. They are not our friends.
  2. It isn’t just Saudi Arabia. Turkey is a strategic liability. The Gulf States are strategic liabilities.
  3. The Iranians aren’t our friends, either, but the Iranian people are much more favorably disposed to us than the Saudis are.
  4. Jamal Khashoggi wasn’t a liberal democrat, either. He was a supporter of a different faction of the Saud family than that of MBS. He was murdered as part of a dynastic struggle in Saudi Arabia with which we should have no truck.
  5. Despite how awful the Syrian and Saudi governments are there are no better alternatives at hand.
  6. Many people in the Middle East genuinely want a different sort of world than we do. They consider it a religious imperative. For them democracy doesn’t foster liberal values but provides a vehicle for them to promote their illiberal values.

Other countries really are foreign to us. I don’t know why the editors of the Washington Post think otherwise.

3 comments

Steps in Small Modular Nuclear

The Logan, Utah Herald Journal reports a major step in the development of nuclear energy:

BOISE, Idaho (AP) — The U.S. Department of Energy, a Utah-based energy cooperative and a contractor that operates an eastern Idaho nuclear research facility announced an agreement Friday involving what would be the nation’s first small modular nuclear reactors in eastern Idaho.

The Energy Department’s Office of Nuclear Energy announced the agreement with Utah Associated Municipal Power Systems and Battelle Energy Alliance, the Energy Department contractor that operates the Idaho National Laboratory.

The energy cooperative has been working for several years toward building a dozen small commercial nuclear reactors at the Energy Department’s 890-square-mile site about 50 miles west of Idaho Falls in high desert, sagebrush steppe.

At 30 megawatts of power, Logan is the city with the largest commitment in the UAMPS project, but during a Nov. 6 Municipal Council meeting, Mayor Holly Daines expressed her desire for the city to at least scale back participation. Several council members countered at the meeting that they would like to see the city continue participation.

The reactors in question are being produced by NuScale Power. 2026 is eight years away. The barriers are more regulatory and legal than technological.

Contrary to what many people seem to believe at the present state of technology solar and wind power require standby power generation using some other means, generally fossil fuels. If you genuinely want to reduce the amount of carbon being released into the atmosphere, you should support nuclear energy, particularly small module nuclear reactors.

5 comments

Who Invented Christmas?

Inspired by this post I thought I’d reflect a bit on the influences that went into making the way we celebrate Christmas. I think they can be summed up as two English queens and three 19th century New Yorkers.

What do you think of when you think of Christmas? If you’re like most Americans, you think of a largely secularized holiday, decorating houses with lights, gifts, Christmas trees, Santa Claus, and reindeer. Christmas trees are a German custom, going back at least 400 years, and introduced to Britain by George III’s German wife, Charlotte of Mecklenburg-Strelitz. In 1832 a young Victoria, soon to become Queen Victoria wrote in her journal:

After dinner… we then went into the drawing-room near the dining-room… There were two large round tables on which were placed two trees hung with lights and sugar ornaments. All the presents being placed round the trees…

The custom began to spread beyond the royal family in England after Victoria’s marriage to the German Albert and her decision to have a Christmas tree in every room of her palace in the late 1840s.

It is said that Hessian troops put up Christmas tree during the War of the American Revolution but I doubt that had much effect on the colonials. I think it far more likely that Germans emigrating to the young United States brought their customs with them and as their numbers grew the Christmas tree began to catch on. Much later I also suspect their adoption was given a boost by fashionable wealthy and upper middle class Americans aping their English cousins.

By the 1830s there were depictions of Christmas tree in the American press, long before their adoption in the United Kingdom.

Lights, whether on trees or houses, were derived from the candles traditionally hung on Christmas trees.

But in my opinoin we owe most of our Christmas iconography to three New Yorkers in the first decades of the 19th century. In 1809 Washington Irving, writing under the pseudonym of “Dietrich Knickerbocker”, published A History of New York which contained the following passage:

And the sage Oloffe dreamed a dream,‍—‌and lo, the good St. Nicholas came riding over the tops of the trees, in that self-same wagon wherein he brings his yearly presents to children, and he descended hard by where the heroes of Communipaw had made their late repast. And he lit his pipe by the fire, and sat himself down and smoked; and as he smoked, the smoke from his pipe ascended into the air and spread like a cloud overhead. And Oloffe bethought him, and he hastened and climbed up to the top of one of the tallest trees, and saw that the smoke spread over a great extent of country; and as he considered it more attentively, he fancied that the great volume of smoke assumed a variety of marvelous forms, where in dim obscurity he saw shadowed out palaces and domes and lofty spires, all of which lasted but a moment, and then faded away, until the whole rolled off, and nothing but the green woods were left. And when St. Nicholas had smoked his pipe, he twisted it in his hatband, and laying his finger beside his nose, gave the astonished Van Kortlandt a very significant look; then, mounting his wagon, he returned over the tree-tops and disappeared.

In it you can see the seeds of what was to become Santa Claus. Then in 1821 an anonymous children’s poem was published, “Old Santeclaus with Much Delight”. Here is its first stanza:

Old SANTECLAUS with much delight
His reindeer drives this frosty night,
O’r chimney tops, and tracts of snow,
To bring his yearly gifts to you.

Finally, in 1823 “A Visit from St. Nicholas”, originally published anonymously but later claimed by Clement Clarke Moore, cemented our image of Santa Claus. Note how Dutch he was. That is something that could only have been produced in Knickerbocker New York.

I think some context is in order. In colonial America the great winter holiday was New Year’s. In the years following the revolution, the generation that came to maturity were eager to establish a uniquely American iconography for the young country, distinct from the English customs that colonial America had practiced. During that federal period most immigration to the United States was from Germany rather than from the United Kingdom. Protestant America became concerned about the influx of Catholics, first Germans and then later Irish, and the papist customs they brought with them. Consequently, they sought to secularize Christmas which had been a primarily religious holiday.

So, with all respect to Charles Dickens, I do not think that A Christmas Carol or his several other portrayals of Christmas customs among his works are particularly influential in forming our Christmas customs or imagery. He’s a latecomer. Most of our customs and iconography had already been formed by the time he came around.

I do not believe that the evolution in our Christmas customs and iconography has ended. IMO it’s inevitable that we increasingly adopt Mexican customs and imagery in our practicing or Christmas. I don’t expect Santa and his reindeer to disappear but I expect them to be increasingly accompanied by making tamales, posadas, and giant nacimientos.

And I expect these customs to be adopted by the Hindu, Buddhist, and Muslim immigrants we will increasingly see here in the United States. One of the most highly decorated houses in my neighborhood at Christmas time is that of my Muslim South Asian neighbors.

0 comments

We Need to Import Less

Consider this statement from Jacquelyn Corley at RealClearHealth:

Roughly 5 billion people worldwide do not have access to timely, safe, and affordable surgical, anesthesia, and obstetric (SAO) care. Public health officials must shift more resources and attention toward treatment of NCDs, especially those that require surgery.

That is the context of a world in which the United States, the United Kingdom, France, and Germany are importing as many physicians and nurses as they can from countries in which physicians nurses are desperately needed. In many cases these health care professionals are educated on the public dime of desperately poor countries.

We need to be an exporter of care not an importer.

1 comment