Will Congress Be Better, Worse, or the Same?

According to Brookings the incoming Congressional freshmen will be the most educated:


and the least experienced:

in Congressional history.

Here’s my question. Is that good, bad, or will it make no difference? My vote is that it will make no difference for a simple reason. The performance of the Congress is based less on the rank and file and even less on incoming freshmen than it is on the Congressional leadership and the incoming Congressional leadership will have concentrated the most power in its hands than in any Congress in recent memory. It’s also the oldest leadership. Most of the leaders of the incoming Congress can remember when Truman was president.

5 comments

The Biggest Loser

In his Wall Street Journal column this morning Walter Russell Mead says that the biggest losers this year have been China’s Belt and Road Initiative:

After Beijing forced Sri Lanka to hand over control of its Hambantota port facilities for 99 years to satisfy its debt late in 2017, this year saw China’s most important BRI targets cancel existing agreements (Malaysia), demand better terms (Pakistan) and scale back projects (Myanmar). Chinese ties to South Africa’s Gupta family (widely blamed for facilitating the corruption of former president Jacob Zuma) and other corrupt figures have contributed to a more skeptical view of Beijing’s intentions across Asia and Africa. The pushback has only begun. China’s debt-trap diplomacy will face more obstacles in 2019.

the United Kingdom:

The United Kingdom slowly twisted in the wind in 2018, unable to negotiate an acceptable European Union exit package or to make up its mind what to do next. At year’s end the future of Brexit is as uncertain as it was 12 months ago. None of the available options—accept the EU’s offer, crash out of the EU in a “no deal” Brexit, hold a second referendum, or give up and remain in the EU—command a parliamentary majority. Within living memory Britain was one of the world’s leading powers and its parliamentary system lauded as the most successful model of democratic governance. At the start of 2019, British prestige and power are touching new lows.

Emmanuel Macron, president of France:

The French president, whose 2017 election animated hopes of a “new political center” in the West, had a horrible year in 2018. His problem wasn’t merely that his poll numbers plummeted or that “yellow jacket” protests forced him to make an embarrassing public apology and roll back some of his agenda. The theory of his presidency failed in 2018.

and Mohammed Bin Salman:

The crown prince of Saudi Arabia managed to keep his job in 2018, but otherwise the year was a nightmare for him and his country. Staging the brutal murder in Istanbul of columnist Jamal Khashoggi, an ally of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, may have been intended to deliver a message to the Turkish leader, a Saudi rival. Instead the Turks outplayed the Saudis and dripped out one damaging revelation after another as the Saudi public-relations machine struggled to contain the fallout. Saudi prestige bled further as the kingdom’s war in Yemen wrought havoc on civilians.

but the biggest loser was the liberal international order:

The biggest loser of 2018 was the post-Cold War system that the U.S. and its closest allies hoped would shape global politics. The idea was that liberal democracy, market-based economic systems and the rule of law would spread from the West into the postcommunist East as well as into the Global South. International institutions would increasingly replace the anarchic competition of states by developing rules-based approaches to issues from trade to climate change.

Great powers like Russia and China never liked this approach, seeing it as a thinly disguised form of U.S. hegemony and a threat to their illiberal political systems. The aspiration for a liberal world system has faced growing headwinds for many years; in 2018 it buckled further under stress.

Even Japan, long a zealous upholder of the rules-based order, exited the International Whaling Commission; Russia solidified its hold on southeastern Ukraine; China fortified its artificial islands in the South China Sea; the U.S. flouted WTO procedures in pursuit of what the Trump administration calls “fair trade”; and one country after another failed to comply with its commitments under the Paris climate agreement. A modern Voltaire might quip that the old system was neither liberal nor international nor an order, but its absence will be felt if it disintegrates.

I think that Britain’s problems are less a result of Brexit than of the British authorities’ undemocratic recalcitrance in following the will of the people. Indeed, that’s a common theme in the political stories of 2018. Liberal democracy is highly desireable unless, of course, it results in freedom or democracy in which case never mind.

It’s too early to tell whether MBS was a winner or loser this year. We just don’t know enough about the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s internal politics to make an assessment. He may well have been a tremendous winner and the assassination of Jamal Khashoggi may have been instrumental in that victory. Or he may be a loser. We just can’t tell.

And the post-Cold War system being a loser is old news. That has been obvious for at least 25 years. It was obvious that it had failed in 1999 when NATO planes bombed Yugoslavia without Security Council authorization but I could point to any number of other events including German reunification, the adoption of the euro, China’s failure to live up to the commitments it made to join the WTO, and any number of others as evidence of the failure. The liberal international order’s acme was marked by the Gulf War and it’s been going downhill ever since.

Picking the biggest winners is harder. Nancy Pelosi is an obvious candidate as is Chinese President Xi Jinping. Who or what else?

4 comments

Colonialism With Chinese Characteristics

From The Star Claire Munde reports that Kenyan President Uhuru Kenyatta is reassuring Kenyans that China will not take over the Port Of Mombasa:

Propaganda. That is how President Uhuru Kenyatta has described reports that the Port of Mombasa could be taken over by China if Kenya defaults on paying its loan for the SGR.

“The issue of the take over of Mombasa Port by China is pure propaganda. We are ahead of our payment schedule for the SGR loan and there is no cause for alarm,” Uhuru said.

The President spoke on Friday during a round table discussion with journalists.

The president said though there has been public outrage and concerns about Chinese lending, his government will continue to borrow.

“We must appreciate where we are. All these issues are just a chicken in the egg. We are borrowing to handle the huge infrastructure deficit. It is not about incurring debt but how we use it,” he said.

Two observations:

  1. I’m sure that’s what the authorities in Sri Lanka were saying, too.
  2. Never believe anything until it’s been officially denied.
1 comment

The Other Side of the Argument

At Commentary Abe Greenwald presents the argument for leaving significant numbers of American soldiers in Syria and Afghanstian, presumably forever:

Our troops don’t go to war for the parades. They fight to protect their country. And a serious country understands that messy wars with elusive victories still have to be fought. In this light, our military efforts in Iraq, Syria, and Afghanistan have been vital. What have we gotten in return for all the pain and sacrifice? Only a peaceful homeland—a strangely under-appreciated miracle in the 21st century. Like the growth and prosperity that comes from free trade, peace is taken for granted. But it’s the direct result of American success in the wars we love to hate.

He goes on to characterize opposing views:

The counter-arguments are too familiar: It’s no business of ours what happens in places like Iraq, Syria, and Afghanistan. Small improvements in the security conditions of lawless countries aren’t worth the cost in American blood and treasure.

Consider this graph:

Was Afghanistan safer in 2017, the last year for which we have statistics, than in 2008 before President Obama began his “Afghan surge”? Perhaps I’m asking too much but it seems to me that an adult policy would recognize when no progress were being made.

2 comments

Commanding the Waves to Recede

At RealClearPolicy Andy Smarick proposes an approach to solving the United States’s work problems:

One of the hardest things for policymakers to do is admit there is a major domestic challenge but then concede there is not a direct government fix. Most policy leaders, understandably, think in terms of policy. They see it as their job to use policy to improve lives. So non-technical challenges — those not readily responding to a shift in this tax rate or that appropriation — can rattle or even debilitate public officials.

that I think is the equivalent of trying to command the waves to recede. Bureaucrats and politicians will inevitably prefer to do nothing than to do things that fail and built into his proposal is the fact that there is no master stroke which will solve our problems and many of the programs that will be tried will fail.

And that’s why most of my suggestions are for government to do less, also an impossibly tall order. The pressure to do something is impossibly hard to resist.

Over time government programs take on lives of their own. Not only do they make up the livelihoods of those who benefit by them but they are the livelihoods of those who administer them. Illinois’s system of toll roads are an object lesson. It was obvious 30 years ago that they had transformed from a system for paying for road maintenance to a system for generating funds to pay the pensions of retired tollway authority workers and paying current tollway authority workers (who would become the retired tollway authority workers of the future). That cozy system was upset by open road tolling. Do you know who the most outspoken opponents of open road tolling were? Tollway authority workers.

There are any number of examples of programs that have no only outlived their usefulness but that produced graver problems. Aid to Families with Dependent Children originated benignly enough as a way of supporting widows and orphans. By the time it was shut down during the Clinton Administration it was primarily subsidizing single motherhood.

Today we have government programs that have outlived their original purposes by a century or more but still keep struggling on.

We don’t just need housecleaning. We need a systematic way of evaluating the performance of programs and killing off those that aren’t working. Among the programs that aren’t working are our whole immigration system, the hundreds of job training programs, and our system of trade.

I’ll leave you with this observation from the cited piece:

For decades, scholars and observers on the left and right have noted with regret that America’s “mediating institutions” have deteriorated. These voluntary associations, like community-based groups, local philanthropies, faith-based organizations, and unions, help individuals and bind communities together in numerous ways. A big part of the reason they’ve atrophied is because larger and larger entities, from the federal government to multinational corporations, have taken away or been given the work of these smaller, local bodies. If we want vigorous local associations to return, we have to catalyze their development and enable them to add value to the lives of citizens, families, and neighborhoods.

I don’t know what it’s like outside the Chicago area but I know that here many NGOs survive on the basis of government grants, receive little oversight, and, routinely become organizations primarily devoted to political organization in order to, unsurprisingly, generate more grants.

2 comments

Death in the Embassy

At Atlantic Graeme Wood outlines some questions in the murder of Jamal Khashoggi that make it a mystery. Here are the bullet points:

  • Why kill him in the consulate—the one place in Istanbul where Saudi culpability would be undeniable?
  • Why kill him with sedatives?
  • Why deploy a team of more than a dozen easily recognized Saudi operatives?
  • Why bring in a Jamal Khashoggi look-alike?
  • Why was Saudi Arabia so ill-prepared for Khashoggi’s death?

to which I’d add why are the editors of the WaPo so intent on papering over the truth about the situation? To those bullet points I’d add a few observations:

  • Saudi Arabia isn’t a Western liberal democracy. It isn’t even a Western authoritarian country.
  • Saudi Arabia is a country where people are stoned to death for things that aren’t even crimes in Europe or the United States.
  • There have been multiple reports that Jamal Khashoggi was a Qatari operative.
  • He was certainly a supporter of a Saudi faction opposed to Mohammed Bin Salman.
  • Lèse-majesté is a serious crime in many places, not just in Saudi Arabia. In traditional European monarchies it was considered a form of blasphemy.
8 comments

Population Loss

The editors of the Wall Street Journal point out the truth of the situation that Illinois and other states are in:

Illinois’s population has declined by 157,000 over the past five years, which is equivalent to the mid-sized city of Rockford. According to research outfit Wirepoints, more than 114,000 residents left the state on net in 2018 and nearly 1.5 million people since 2000. Cold weather? While Illinois’s population has declined by 0.8% since 2010, Indiana’s has grown 3.1% and Wisconsin’s by 2.2%.

These population shifts mean that several states including New York, Illinois and Minnesota are likely to lose House seats after the 2020 reapportionment. States that have been rapidly adding population like Arizona, Florida and Texas are likely to increase their representation. It’d be nice to think this would finally prompt Democratic politicians to rethink their anti-growth policies. But with state political cultures dominated by public unions and welfare spending, they probably require a much deeper crisis to face reality.

Incoming Illinois governor J. B. Pritzker is already backing off from the platform on which he ran. Apparently, he isn’t really a guy who believes that Illinois can tax and spend its way to prosperity. He just plays one on TV.

2 comments

Posing

Here’s Mamie posing with the Christmas tree. She’s getting to be a very grown-up girl.

9 comments

Leaving Syria

Robert Ford, U. S. ambassador to Syria under President Obama, in an op-ed in the Washington Post, gives his opinion about President Trump’s decision to withdraw our troops from Syria:

Stability, not a deeply embattled Syrian Kurdish autonomous zone, is the vital long-term U.S. interest in northeastern Syria. Turkey can accept with conditions the return of Syrian government forces into the area, as Russia and Iran want. Ankara dislikes the Assad government, but it dislikes more the prospect of an autonomous Kurdish region along its border.

That is so obviously correct that it sparks the inevitable question: why are so many people complaining so bitterly about the announcement? Let’s consider a few reasons.

  • If Trump is for it, they’re against it.
  • They disagree and think that a Syrian Kurdish autonomous zone is in the U. S. interest. Why?
  • They think that the U. S. has short-term interests which temporarily over-rule our long-term interest. What?
  • They’re focused on something other than U. S. interests. What?
  • They haven’t thought it through.

Have I missed anything? This is genuinely puzzling to me.

14 comments

Christmas, 2018


As usual we had a lovely Christmas. The tree we had this year was one our prettiest. We followed our usual pattern—Christmas in the morning, birthday at night.

I gave my wife a Dremel Versa, a copy of Ruth Gordon’s autobiography,a copy of John Fante’s novel, Ask the Dust (I thought she might like it because it’s been called one of the best novels about Los Angeles), and a new, leather band for her Fitbit.

She gave me several new shirts and a new raincoat (presumably she was tired of my old, ragged one), and a bottle of good Bourbon.

For Christmas dinner I had ordered a country ham and prepared sweet potatoes and green beans.

We made a birthday cake which was without doubt the best we have ever made—gingerbread layer cake with ermine frosting. The gingerbread was definitely for adult tastes, not as sweet as most cakes and seasoned with free ginger, ground ginger, pepper, and cayenne pepper. The frosting was the perfect accompaniment. These were so good I have to share them. I’ll post the recipes later.

For me this was probably the saddest Christmas since my dad died, sadder even than the Christmas that my mom died. It is a difficult time to be a Catholic. I will remain a Catholic until I die but I find it nearly impossible to be an observant Catholic. I don’t think it is any longer possible to doubt the complicity of the whole body of the clergy in the crimes that have been perpetrated for so many years.

I’m not a Donatist so I do not require perfection of the clergy but I don’t demand perfection, just sincere contrition, penance, and commitment to change as our tradition requires but I don’t even see that in evidence. I don’t trust myself to exchange a simple “Hello” with my parish priest without punching him in the nose.

8 comments